A Discourse on the Cinnamon , Cassia , or Canella .
By Taylor White , Esquire , F. R. S. THE Cinnamon , Cassia , or Canella , are shrubs of no great height : they grow in Ceylon , Malabar , Java , Sumatra , and other places in the East Indies ; as I think , in the island of St. Thomas , and on the coast of Coromandel .
They are described by Mr. Ray , in his History of Plants , vol. ii .
f. 1559 .
under the title de Arboribus Pruniferis .
Read Dec. 21 , 1758 .
Philos. Trans. Vol. L. TAB. XXXVI .
p. 860 .
III .
F. IX .
F.V. F.XII .
Fig. I. F.X. F.IV .
F.~ F.XI .
~ F.VI .
F. VII .
Linnaeus , in his Species Plantarum , places them under the title Enneandria Monogynia , by the name Laurus .
The leaf , flower , and fruit , of this plant , are particularly described by Mr. Ray .
The leaf is smooth and shining ; has one large vein running thro ' the midst , and a remarkable one on each side ; the middle one generally running near the length of the leaf .
The leaves differ in shape , some being more acute , others more oval or obtuse .
The flowers grow in an umbel , somewhat like the Laurus Tinus ; but they are small , consisting of one petal , of a tubular form at the bottom , and divided at the top into six segments in the form of a star .
The flowers are succeeded by berries growing out of a capsula , like acorns in shape ; which berries contain a shining seed .
The description of Mr. Ray of the flower , in his description of the Cinnamon of Malabar , is extremely accurate ; as is also the figure in the Hortus Malabaricus , No. 54 .
and the description , fol. 107 .
under the name Carua .
I shall therefore refer to those .
I shall not trouble you with the question debated by Mr. Ray , whether the Cinnamon and Cassia of the ancients were , or were not , the same with those so called by the moderns ?
whether the Cinnamon of the ancients was the twigs of the tree bearing cloves , or any plant now unknown to us ?
Mr. Ray has largely treated on this subject ; and to him I refer such as are curious to be informed on this subject .
But as the Cinnamon and Cassia of the ancients are said to have been used as perfumes , and to make perfumed ointments , I think they must have differed from ours , whose smell is not very fragrant , nor is emitted to any great distance .
The matter of the present inquiry is , whether the Cinnamon of Ceylon is the same sort of plant with that growing in Malabar , Sumatra , &amp;c. differing only by the soil or climate , in which it grows , which is the opinion of Garcias ; or from the culture or manner of curing the plant , as I am inclined to believe ; or whether it is really a different genus or species of plant , as many people believe , and some botanical writers seem to indicate .
I shall endeavour to explain this matter by producing , 1st , The descriptions of the most celebrated authors : 2dly , By producing the most accurate figures of the plants of Sumatra and Ceylon : [ See Tab. xxxvi .
] 3dly , By showing the specimen of the leaves and branches brought from Sumatra .
I have no specimen from Ceylon ; but have carefully examined the specimens kept in the British Museum , with the assistance of Dr. Maty and Mr. Empson , and compared them with the specimens I have from Sumatra ; from whence I traced exactly the figures brought herewith : which specimens are undoubtedly brought from Ceylon , and were the collections of Boerhaave , Courteen , Plukenet , and Petiver .
But , previous to this inquiry , I would premise , that the writers , who give the description of the Cinnamon of Ceylon , were probably not acquainted with that of Malabar at the time of their publishing their works .
Mr. Ray also , who so accurately describes the flower of the Cinnamon of Malabar , seems not so well acquainted with its fruit ; and probably had then never seen the specimens of the Cinnamon from Ceylon ; for his description is plainly borrowed from others , and not his own .
Tho ' I have reason to think he afterwards saw the specimens of Mr. Courteen , and was convinced , that the plants were the same .
In his description of the Cinnamon of Ceylon , he supposes differences in the manner of veining the leaf , which are not found in the leaves themselves .
He supposes , that the Cinnamon of Ceylon differs from that of Malabar by its berries growing in cups like acorns ; which is apparently the same in both , as may be seen in its figure in the Hortus Malabaricus .
The other differences taken notice of by the botanic writers are as follow : In the Flora Zeylanica , p. 545 .
and in the Materia Medica , 190 .
the Cinnamon of Ceylon is called Laurus foliis trinerviis ovato-oblongis nervis unientibus : which description is adhered to in the Hortus Cliffordiensis , p. 154 .
under the name Laurus foliis oblongo-ovatis nitidis planis .
And Burman , in his Flora Zeylanica , 62 .
T. 27 .
calls it Cinamomum foliis latis ovatis .
Whereas the Cassia of Sumatra is distinguished by these writers : that in Flora Zeyl .
146 .
and in Materia Medica , 191 .
is called Laurus foliis trinerviis lanceolatis nervis supra basin unitis : and Burman , Zeylan .
63 .
T. 28 .
calls it Cinamomum perpetuo florens folio tenuiore acuto .
The distinction therefore , which these writers would make us believe there is between these plants , consists in the leaves of the one being oval , the other sharppointed ; and that the nerves are limited at the bottom in the Cinnamon , but not so in the Cassia : for as to the semper florens , mentioned by Burman , that must undoubtedly be common to both .
Now as to the different shape of the leaves , we know how often this happens by seminal varieties , and from the age of plants , as in the leaves of holly and ivy ; and that even the shapes of leaves vary greatly on the very same plant , and sometimes on the same branch ; as in the ash , and many other plants , the leaves of the young shoots are more oval than those on the old boughs , which are generally more pointed .
But this variety is much more frequent in the plants of warm countries .
In the sassafras , part of the leaves generally near the bottom of the plant are plain , whilst the other leaves are divided into three lobes or segments .
I have observed great difference also in the leaves of almost every one of the American oaks .
In the Virginian cedar , the berries of the same plant produce some plants with juniper leaves , and others with leaves like the savin ; and some plants with both leaves growing on the same plant .
I must observe , that Burman has , in his figures of the two plants before mentioned , made them extremely different .
In that of Ceylon he has made all the leaves oval ; and , to make the difference greater , has drawn the rudiments of the berries ; to which he has added the flower , or part of it , at the top of the style or rudiment of the fruit : and in that of Malabar he has drawn the flower growing in the umbel .
On these drawings I must observe , that his drawing of the Cinnamon of Ceylon agrees with no one specimen in the British Museum ; and scarcely is one leaf to be found of the shape , which he gives .
The first figure , which I shall produce , is a drawing , which I procured from the ingenious Mr. Ehret in the year 1754 : which , as I am informed by Mr. Empson , was from a specimen , given to Mr. Ehret by him in that year , of the Cinnamon of Ceylon .
See Fig. 1 .
This agrees in every thing with the drawing of the Cinnamon of Malabar in the Hort. Malab. fig. 54 .
fol. 107 .
and there called Carua ; except that it wants the fruit : but that defect is supplied by Mr. Ray 's description of the Cinnamon of Ceylon above mentioned .
See fig. of the fruit , Fig. 2 .
In the figure in the Hort. Malabar .
it may be observed , that the nerves do not go quite to the bottom of the leaf .
But this is merely accidental , as will appear by the leaves of the same plant brought from Sumatra , which I shall produce ; in which , part of the leaves have veins going quite to the bottom , and united there , and the others not so .
See Fig. 3 .
The next drawing I shall produce contains that of the leaves of the Cinnamon plant , from specimens in the British Museum .
Fig. 4 .
A specimen , with the flower , from the collection of Mr. Courteen , who lived long in Ceylon .
These leaves were more pointed , but were broke at the end .
Fig. 5 .
A whole leaf , with its point , in the same collection , growing on a branch , on which are the rudiments of the fruit .
Fig. 6 .
A leaf in Plukenet 's specimens .
Fig. 7 .
Another leaf of the same collection , and of the same plant .
Fig. 8 .
A leaf of a large specimen from Boerhaave 's collection .
Fig. 9 .
Another leaf on the same branch .
Fig. 10 .
A specimen from Petiver 's collection .
The points of the leaves are broken off .
Fig. 11 .
The flower of the first specimen .
Fig. 12 .
In the rudiment of the seed before formed , in the state given in Burman 's first drawing .
Note , It is to be observed also , that the specimens of the Cinnamon of Ceylon are probably of cultivated plants .
From all these specimens it plainly appears , that the distinction of foliis ovatis &amp; lanceolatis does not appear well founded .
But were it otherwise , and that the leaves of the plants differed , it would by no means be a proof of any material difference in the nature or quality of the plants ; as is well known to persons conversant in natural history .
Before I leave this subject of the description of the plant , it may be proper to mention , that Bauhin calls the one of these plants Cinnamomum or Canella Malabarica &amp; Javanensis , and the other Cinnamomum Canella Zeylanica , Bauhin .
pinax 408 and 409 ; but neither from these names , nor from his description , can any conclusive argument be formed : and that Herman , in his Hort. Lugd. Batav .
129 .
t. 1655 .
calls this Cinnamon of Ceylon Cassia Cinnamonia .
If any conjecture can arise from hence , it may be , that the Cinnamon of Ceylon was formerly , as well as that of Sumatra and Malabar , called Cassia ; but that the Dutch writers , being acquainted with the excellent qualities , which the ancients ascribed to their Cinnamon , chose to add the name Cinnamon to that of Cassia : and in process of time they have found the name of Cinnamon more profitable than that of Cassia , by which we chuse to call our Canella , to our national loss of many thousands a year .
Having now given an account of the figure of these plants , and in what respect they are said herein to differ ; I shall proceed to consider the pretended differences in the Canella itself ; which are supposed not to be in form only , but substantial and material ; and are generally understood to be so by persons supposed to be acquainted with the subject .
Mr. Ray states this matter fully in his Hist. Plant .
vol. ii .
p. 1560 .
in these words : Officinae nostrae Cassiam ligneam a Cinnamomo seu Canella distinctam faciunt , Cassiam Cinnamomo crassiorem plerumque esse , colore rubicundiorem , substantia duriorem , solidiorem &amp; compactiorem , gustu magis glutinoso , odore quidem &amp; sapore Cinnamomum aptius refer , tamen Cinnamomo imbecilliorum &amp; minus vegetam esse , ex accurata observatione Tho. Johnson .
From these reasons Mr. Ray draws a conclusion ( I must own not very instructive ) , that the Cinnamon of Ceylon is Cinnamon ; and the Cinnamon of Malabar , &amp;c. is the Cassia of the shops .
From the specimens I shall now produce , it will most plainly appear , that these differences are merely accidents arising from the age of the Canella , the part of the tree from whence it is gathered , and from the manner of cultivating and curing it .
In the Philosoph. Transact. No. 278 .
p. 1099 .
in Mr. Strachan 's account of Ceylon , which is abridged by Eames and Martyn , vol. ii .
p. 183 .
he says , that there are two sorts of Cinnamon-trees , of which the tree , which is esteemed the best , has a leaf much larger and thicker than the other ; but otherwise no difference is to be perceived .
Note , Here is no mention of the folio ovato .
I remember , in an account given some years ago to the Royal Society , three or four sorts were mentioned ; and it was said the best sort was cut every three or four years .
This superiority I then guessed ( as well as the difference of leaves mentioned by Mr. Strachan ) to arise from the cutting the tree down every three or four years ; which occasioned it to produce strong and vigorous shoots , thicker and larger leaves , as well as greater quantity of bark , and of a superior quality .
A large shoot or sucker of this plant was produced in the year 1750 .
or 51 .
by my worthy friend Dr. William Watson , together with an account of the Cinnamon-tree ; which is published in the Philosoph. Transact. vol. xlvii .
p. 301 .
This shoot was a plain proof to me , that the Cinnamon was frequently cut down , and that this shoot arose from the root of a plant so cut ; for it was of the size of a walkingcane ; and no shrub could have produced such a shoot , unless a strong plant cut down .
This method of treating this plant accounts for the mistake of Garcias , mentioned by Mr. Ray ; viz. Quae Garcias habet de duplice hujus arboris cortice ad modum suberis , nobis suspecta sunt , quaeque de deliberatione liberatione semel triennio facta ; non enim puto renascitur cortex semel detractus .
This shows , that the bark was gathered every three years : but Mr. Ray was not acquainted , that the plant was cut down , in order to take off the bark , once in three years .
In the account above mentioned to be given to the Society by Dr. Watson , no descriptions are given either of the plants of Ceylon , or Malabar ; but he quotes Burman , who says , that he had nine different sorts of Cinnamon from Ceylon , of which that , which is the best , is brought to us , and called by the name Rasse Coronde .
What the differences between these sorts were , does not appear ; whether in leaf or bark , or manner of culture .
And I must observe , that in all the specimens in the British Museum I could observe no difference of species .
But this is to be understood , that every sort coming from Ceylon is , by the Dutch and by the shops , called Cinnamon ; and that of our own growth is by them always called Cassia .
The reason is obvious .
The specimens , which I now produce , of the Canella or bark of the Cinnamon of Sumatra , I procured in the year 1755 .
from Mr. Tho. Combs , a gentleman then in the service of the East India Company in Sumatra , by means of a friend .
I was then attempting to form a society for the carrying on a General Natural History , to try proper experiments , and to employ proper painters and engravers suitable to the importance of the subject ; and therefore attempted to establish a correspondence in those parts , whose productions are as yet little known to the public .
I mention this design , because it would not be possible else to explain what Mr. Combs means by the word Society , which he so often mentions in his letter ; of which I shall produce an extract , so far as it relates to the present inquiry .
It seemed to me very improbable ( as the same plants are generally found in the same latitude and soil ) , that the spices now in the possession of the Dutch should grow only in that small tract of land , which is in their possession .
And I had many credible informations , that , whatever they may pretend to the contrary , this is only a pretence .
I therefore desired to obtain the best information of the nature and culture of the plants producing spices , as well as of many other things , which are foreign from this inquiry .
I desired to know , how the spices were dried and cured ; and that different specimens might be sent me of the plants , their seed , flower , leaf , and bark , and properly cured and prepared .
This produced the answer I lay before you herewith , together with the specimens now produced .
You see hereby , that the Dutch dry their Cinnamon in sand ; probably to take away that viscosity , which is complained of in the Cassia .
And you will observe also , that the specimen produced dried and cured is also as free from any viscosity , as the Cinnamon of Ceylon : That it agrees also with the Cinnamon in every other quality , and in colour ; and that none of the distinctions mentioned by Mr. Ray can be found herein ; but that they may arise from the part of the tree , from whence the bark was taken ; the inner bark of the large wood being red , as you see by the other specimen produced .
And the common Cassia taken from the larger branches , and not cured , has the viscosity complained of in some degree , tho ' much less than it had four years since , when I received it .
Mr. Ray says , that one is weaker in taste , as he supposes , than the other .
That may be so from its manner of drying , or keeping of it .
Dried in large quantities , and by a stronger heat , it will probably be stronger , than if it is dried in a lesser quantity , and slower .
As for the viscosity , the glutinous part is found in every plant in some degree , as well as in every animal .
It preserves the parts from moisture ; but will be consumed by heat or time ; and it will be a preservative to the plant , till it is destroyed ; which was the reason , as I suppose , that Mr. Ray mentions Cassia to have kept good thirty years , the viscosity not having been destroyed by drying .
I suppose the reason , which the Dutch have to dry it , is to make it sooner fit for the market , and possibly fitter for distillation .
You will see from Mr. Combes 's letters and specimens , that he thinks there may be two sorts of Cassia or Cinnamon in Sumatra : possibly there may be the same difference in Ceylon ; but , if so , I suspect them both to be only seminal varieties , and that their virtues are the same .
Mr. Barlow , some time since a Surgeon in the service of the India company , made a considerable quantity of oil of the Cassia of Sumatra , which was very little , if any thing , inferior to that drawn from Cinnamon ; and it was sold to great profit .
If these plants are really the same , or if they are of equal goodness , supposing there was a small difference ference in the form of the leaf , it might be well worth the attention of the East India company to try to cultivate these plants in the manner they do in Ceylon ; that is , to make plantations in a proper soil ; and to have regard to the proper distance from the sea of the place , where they try the experiment : for some plants require to be near the sea , and others far from it , in Sumatra ; which is the case of the Mango , and Mangosteen ; the one of which must be near the sea , the other at a distance from it .
I think the plants should be suffered to grow strong , to be six or seven years old , and then cut every three years , the bark peeled off and dried in hot sand , and packed close , and kept dry .
This I take to be all necessary to be done , to try , if our Cinnamon will not produce as good a price as that of the Dutch .
Perhaps the plants need not stand so long before cut ; for the vegetation of plants in hot countries is very great .
There are many other most valuable vegetables in Sumatra , which might be made staple commodities , as sago , camphire , several sorts of ginger , rice , and many other , which are foreign to the present inquiry .
But it may not be amiss to recommend it to the traders to Sumatra to bring some quantity of the twig-bark of the true Cassia , well cured ; and also to the company , to have a chemist at Sumatra , to extract carefully the oil of Cassia ; which is best , and in greatest quantities , produced from the bark of the body , and of the larger branches of the tree : and also that the company would procure an exemption of all customs or duties on Cassia , or on the oil of Cassia , for some time : and also that the college of physicians in their dispensatory would direct Cassia or Cinnamon of Malabar or Sumatra to be used , instead of the Cinnamon of Ceylon ; and that the same should be used by apothecaries and distillers , and in all simple and compound waters , in which Cinnamon is used .
Extract of a Letter from Mr. THOMASCOMBE S , dated Fort Marlborough , 5 Jan. 1755 .
IN regard to the first article of your paper , now before me , which is the inquiry desired to be made concerning the spices , I am of opinion , that the true Cinnamon grows no-where but on the island of Ceylon , unless Cassia be allowed to be the same tree , which I am inclined to think .
No. 9 .
contains seeds of the Cassia or wild Cinnamon-tree .
As for the seeds of the true Cinnamontree , I believe they are very difficult to be got ; for as the Dutch are the sole masters of this spice , and get a good deal of money by it , I fancy , according to their usual custom , they have very well guarded against the transplantation of it .
I hope however , that these seeds will not be unacceptable to the society , as Cassia itself is of some value ; and as I am very doubtful , whether this tree is not the same with the true Cinnamon , being of opinion , that the difference observed in them arises from the different method of curing their barks , or from the taking the bark from different parts of the tree , or at different seasons , or of different ages , or perhaps all these .
I have made inquiry concerning this from some very intelligent persons , and found them to be of opinion , that the Cassia and Cinnamon-tree were of the same genus .
I have inquired further concerning the method of curing it at Ceylon ; but as this is done by the natives , the Dutch are not very well acquainted with it ; nor could I obtain any good account of it , different people giving me different relations .
Some said , it was the inner bark , some the middle , and some the outer ; tho ' of the young branches , they seemed in general to agree , that it was gathered at a certain season of the year , and that one part of the cure was burying it in sand for some time .
This may be tried with Cassia , and may perhaps take away that viscosity or glutinous quality observed by chewing it , and which is the principal mark for distinguishing it from Cinnamon .
As to their chemical oils , I have heard many people say , that they are not distinguishable otherwise , than that from Cinnamon is generally better , or , as it may be called , stronger , than that from Cassia ; and accordingly bears a better price .
But the Dutch company 's chemist at Batavia , if I may give him this title , informed me , that they are essentially different , and plainly distinguishable .
But I must confess myself very doubtful of the knowlege or veracity of this chemist , and strongly suspect , that they are no otherwise different than in goodness , as many other oils drawn from the same subject are .
I observe the price of Cassia is greatly risen in England within these two or three years ; but whether this be owing to an increase in the consumption , or a decrease in the importation of this commodity , I cannot say .
The Dutch government of Batavia has this year , in some new regulations of their trade , prohibited to all persons the dealing in any of the fine quilled sort of Cassia , and declared the same to be contraband , and reserved for their company only ; and put it upon the same footing as their Cinnamon .
What reasons induced them to this , I am yet a stranger to ; but it makes me suspect , that the rise of this commodity in Europe is owing to some other cause than a deficiency in the importation thereof .
Perhaps some discovery has been made rendering Cassia equal to Cinnamon .
In Persia , I think , they make not so great a difference between them as elsewhere ; and I myself , for want of Cinnamon here for some months past , made use of the fine quilled Cassia ; and the difference I observe between them I imagine to arise rather from the greenness and want of dryness in the Cassia , than any thing else , or perhaps from the method of curing it : for if there happens to be a little too much Cassia put into my chocolate ( and other things I use in it ) , a little bitterish taste arises , something like what we meet with in most barks ; tho ' I do not remember to have observed this of Cinnamon : but as to its boiling to a jelly , as Quincy mentions , I find no such thing , and think it bears boiling as well as Cinnamon .
Nor do I think its distilled water more subject to an empyreuma than that of Cinnamon .
I have inquired of the country people here , who bring it us , and they tell me the finest sort is the inner bark of the small branches ; and indeed that it is the inner bark , I think , is evident in Cinnamon as well as Cassia ; no outer bark of the youngest branches of any tree having , in my opinion , that smooth surface observable in both these barks .
I once thought , that it was better to take the bark from the body of the tree than from the branches , imagining that the bark from the trunk or body of all trees must in general be stronger , let its natural taste be what it will , than from its branches .
This I find to be so in Cassia ; and I have been informed , that the large ligneous pieces of Cassia have afforded rather more oil in distillation than the fine quilled sort , their weight being equal ; but upon trial I could not make the bark from the trunk curl or roll up , as it ought to do , owing , as I suppose , to my unskilfulness , or to rigidity , or the natural position of its fibres ; for the bark of the younger branches curled of itself , wanting hardly any other assistance than the sun .
I have already observed , that Cassia is found in chewing to have a viscidness , which Cinnamon has not .
I have endeavoured to remove this in a little I send you , marked B : pray let me know , if it answers ; and be assured , it was taken from the younger branches of the tree , of which I send you the seeds .
I send you also , marked C , some of the bark taken from the same tree ; as also some of the leaves , marked D. I have sent you also a little of the bark of the trunk of a tree , which , tho ' called Cassia , seems not to be so , marked E ; and also the leaves of the same tree , marked F. END of the FIFTIETH VOLUME .

