XCVIII .
An Account of some Experiments concerning the different Refrangibility of Light .
By Mr. John Dollond .
With a Letter from James Short , M.A. F.R.S. Acad. Reg. Suec. Soc. To the Rev. Dr. Birch , Secret .
R. S. Dear Sir , I Have received the enclosed paper from Mr. Dollond , which he desires may be laid before the Royal Society .
It contains the theory of correcting the errors arising from the different refrangibility of the rays of light in the object-glasses of refracting telescopes ; and I have found , upon examination , that telescopes made according to this theory are entirely free from colours , and are as distinct as reflecting telescopes .
I am , Read June 8 , 1758 .
Surrey-street , 8th June , 1758 .
Dear Sir , Your most obedient humble Servant , Ja .
Short .
IT is well known , that a ray of light , refracted by passing thro ' mediums of different densities , is at the same time proportionally divided or spread into a number of parts , commonly called homogeneal rays , each of a different colour ; and that these , after refraction , proceed diverging : a proof , that they are differently refracted , and that light consists of parts that differ in degrees of refrangibility .
Every ray of light passing from a rarer into a denser medium , is refracted towards the perpendicular ; but from a denser into a rarer one , from the perpendicular ; and the sines of the angles of incidence and refraction are in a given ratio .
But light consisting of parts , which are differently refrangible , each part of an original or compound ray has a ratio peculiar to itself ; and therefore the more a heterogene ray is refracted , the more will the colours diverge , since the ratios of the sines of the homogene rays are constant ; and equal refractions produce equal divergencies .
That this is the case when light is refracted by one given medium only , as suppose any particular sort of glass , is out of all dispute , being indeed selfevident ; but that the divergency of the colours will be the same under equal refractions , whatsoever mediums the light may be refracted by , tho ' generally supposed , does not appear quite so clearly .
However , as no medium is known , which will refract light without diverging the colours , and as difference of refrangibility seems thence to be a property inherent in light itself , Opticians have , upon that consideration , concluded , that equal refractions must produce equal divergencies in every sort of medium : whence it should also follow , that equal and contrary refractions must not only destroy each other , but that the divergency of the colours from one refraction would likewise be corrected by the other ; and there could be no possibility of producing any such thing as refraction , which would not be affected by the different refrangibilty of light ; or , in other words , that however a ray of light might be refracted backwards and forwards by different mediums , as water , glass , &amp;c. provided it was so done , that the emergent ray should be parallel to the incident one , it would ever after be white ; and , conversely , if it should come out inclined to the incident , it would diverge , and ever after be coloured .
From which it was natural to infer , that all spherical object-glasses of telescopes must be equally affected by the different refrangibility of light , in proportion to their apertures , whatever material they may be formed of .
But it seems worthy of consideration , that notwithstanding this notion has been generally adopted as an incontestable truth , yet it does not seem to have been hitherto so confirmed by evident experiment , as the nature of so important a matter justly demands ; and this it was that determined me to attempt putting the thing to issue by the following experiment .
I cemented together two plates of parallel glass at their edges , so as to form a prismatic or wedge-like vessel , when stopped at the ends or bases ; and its edge being turned downwards , I placed therein a glass prism with one of its edges upwards , and filled up the vacancy with clear water : thus the refraction of the prism was contrived to be contrary to that of the water , so that a ray of light transmitted thro ' both these refracting mediums would be refracted by the difference only between the two refractions .
Wherefore , as I found the water to refract more or less than the glass prism , I diminished or or increased the angle between the glass plates , till I found the two contrary refractions to be equal ; which I discovered by viewing an object thro ' this double prism ; which , when it appeared neither raised nor depressed , I was satisfied , that the refractions were equal , and that the emergent rays were parallel to the incident .
Now , according to the prevailing opinion , the object should have appeared thro ' this double prism quite of its natural colour ; for if the difference of refrangibility had been equal in the two equal refractions , they would have rectified each other : but the experiment fully proved the fallacy of this received opinion , by showing the divergency of the light by the prism to be almost double of that by the water ; for the object , tho ' not at all refracted , was yet as much infected with prismatic colours , as if it had been seen thro ' a glass wedge only , whose refracting angle was near 30 degrees .
N. B. This experiment will be readily perceived to be the same as that which Sir Isaac Newton mentions * ; but how it comes to differ so very remarkably in the result , I shall not take upon me to account for ; but will only add , that I used all possible precaution and care in the process , and that I keep the apparatus by me to evince the truth of what I write , whenever I may be properly required so to do .
I plainly saw then , that if the refracting angle of the water-vessel could have admitted of a sufficient * Book I. Part ii .
Prop. 3 .
Experiment 8 .
of his Optics .
increase , the divergency of the coloured rays would have been greatly diminished , or entirely rectified ; and there would have been a very great refraction without colour , as now I had a great discolouring without refraction : but the inconveniency of so large an angle , as that of the vessel must have been , to bring the light to an equal divergency with that of the glass prism , whose angle was about 60 degrees , made it necessary to try some experiments of the same kind , by smaller angles .
I ground a wedge of common plate glass to an angle of somewhat less than 9 degrees , which refracted the mean rays about 5 degrees .
I then made a wedge-like vessel , as in the former experiment , and filling it with water , managed it so , that it refracted equally with the glass wedge ; or , in other words , the difference of their refractions was nothing , and objects viewed thro ' them appeared neither raised nor depressed .
This was done with an intent to observe the same thing over again in these small angles , which I had seen in the prism : and it appeared indeed the same in proportion , or as near as I could judge ; for notwithstanding the refractions were here also equal , yet the divergency of the colours by the glass was vastly greater than that by the water ; for objects seen by these two refractions were very much discoloured .
Now this was a demonstration , that the divergency of the light , by the different refrangibility , was far from being equal in these two refractions .
I also saw , from the position of the colours , that the excess of divergency was in the glass ; so that I increased the angle of the waterwedge , by different trials , till the divergency of the light by the water was equal to that by the glass , that is , till the object , tho ' considerably refracted , by the excess of the refraction of the water , appeared nevertheless quite free from any colours proceeding from the different refrangibility of light ; and , as near as I could then measure , the refraction by the water was about 5/ 4 of that by the glass .
Indeed I was not very exact in taking the measures , because my business was not at that time about the proportions , so much as to show , that the divergency of the colours , by different substances , was by no means in proportion to the refractions ; and that there was a possibility of refraction without any divergency of the light at all .
Having , about the beginning of the year 1757 , tried these experiments , I soon after set about grinding telescopic object-glasses upon the new principles of refractions , which I had gathered from them ; which object-glasses were compounded of two spherical glasses with water between them .
These glasses I had the satisfaction to find , as I had expected , free from the errors arising from the different refrangibility of light : for the refractions , by which the rays were brought to a focus , were every-where the differences between two contrary refractions , in the same manner , and in the same proportions , as in the experiment with the wedges .
However , the images formed at the foci of these object-glasses were still very far from being so distinct as might have been expected from the removal of so great a disturbance ; and yet it was not very difficult to guess at the reason , when I considered , that the radii of the spherical surfaces of those glasses were required to be so short , in order to make the refractions in the required proportions , that they must produce aberrations , or errors , in the image , as great , or greater , than those from the different refrangibility of light .
And therefore , seeing no method of getting over that difficulty , I gave up all hopes of succeeding in that way .
And yet , as these experiments clearly proved , that different substances diverged the light very differently , in proportion to the refraction ; I began to suspect , that such variety might possibly be found in different sorts of glass , especially as experience had already shown , that some made much better object-glasses , in the usual way , than others : and as no satisfactory cause had as yet been assigned for such difference , there was great reason to presume , that it might be owing to the different divergency of the light by their refractions .
Wherefore , the next business to be undertaken , was to grind wedges of different kinds of glass , and apply them together , so that the refractions might be made in contrary directions , in order to discover , as in the foregoing experiments , whether the refraction and divergency of the colours would vanish together .
But a considerable time elapsed before I could set about that work ; for tho ' I was determined to try it at my leisure , for satisfying my own curiosity , yet I did not expect to meet with a difference sufficient to give room for any great improvement of telescopes ; so that it was not till the latter end of the year that I undertook it , when my first trials convinced me , that this business really deserved my utmost attention and application .
I discovered a difference , far beyond my hopes , in the refractive qualities of different kinds of glass , with respect to their divergency of colours .
The yellow or straw-coloured foreign sort , commonly called Venice glass , and the English crown glass , are very near alike in that respect , tho ' in general the crown glass seems to diverge the light rather the least of the two .
The common plate glass made in England diverges more ; and the white crystal or flint English glass , as it is called , most of all .
It was not now my business to examine into the particular qualities of every kind of glass that I could come at , much less to amuse myself with conjectures about the cause , but to fix upon such two sorts as their difference was the greatest ; which I soon found to be the crown , and the white flint or crystal .
I therefore ground a wedge of white flint of about 25 degrees , and another of crown of about 29 degrees , which refracted nearly alike ; but their divergency of the colours was very different .
I then ground several others of crown to different angles , till I got one , which was equal , with respect to the divergency of the light , to that in the white slint : for when they were put together , so as to refract in contrary directions , the refracted light was entirely free from colour .
Then measuring the refractions of each wedge , I found that of the white glass to be to that of the crown nearly as 2 to 3 ; and this proportion would hold very nearly in all small angles .
Wherefore any two wedges made in this proportion , and applied together , so as to refract in a contrary direction , would refract the light without any difference of refrangibility .
To make therefore two spherical glasses , that shall refract the light in contrary directions , it is easy to understand , that one must be concave , and the other convex ; and as the rays are to converge to a real focus , the excess of refraction must evidently be in the convex ; and as the convex is to refract most , it appears from the experiment , that it must be made with crown glass , and the concave with white flint glass .
And further , as the refractions of spherical glasses are in an inverse ratio of their focal distances ; it follows , that the focal distances of the two glasses should be inversely as the ratio 's of the fractions of the wedges : for being thus proportioned , every ray of light , that passes thro ' this combined glass , at whatever distance it may pass from its axe , will constantly be refracted , by the difference between two contrary refractions , in the proportion required ; and therefore the different refrangibility of the light will be entirely removed .
Having thus got rid of the principal cause of the imperfection of refracting telelescopes , there seemed to be nothing more to do , but to go to work upon this principle : but I had not made many attempts , before I found , that the removal of one impediment had introduced another equally detrimental ( the same as I had before found in two glasses with water between them ) : for the two glasses , that were to be combined together , were the segments of very deep spheres ; and therefore the aberrations from the spherical surfaces became very considerable , and greatly disturbed the distinctness of the image .
Tho ' this appeared at first a very great difficulty , yet I was not long without hopes of a remedy : for considering , the surfaces of spherical glasses admit of great variations , tho ' the focal distance be limited , and that by these variations their aberrations may be made more or less , almost at pleasure ; I plainly saw the possibility of making the aberrations of any two glasses equal ; and as in this case the refractions of the two glasses were contrary to each other , their aberrations , being equal , would entirely vanish .
And thus , at last , I obtained a perfect theory for making object-glasses , to the apertures of which I could scarce conceive any limits : for if the practice could come up to the theory , they must certainly admit of very extensive ones , and of course bear very great magnifying powers .
But the difficulties attending the practice are very considerable .
In the first place , the focal distances , as well as the particular surfaces , must be very nicely proportioned to the densities or refracting powers of the glasses ; which are very apt to vary in the same sort of glass made at different times .
Secondly , the centres of the two glasses must be placed truly on the common axis of the telescope , otherwise the desired effect will be in a great measure destroyed .
Add to these , that there are four surfaces to be wrought perfectly spherical ; and any person , but moderately practised in optical operations , will allow , that there must be the greatest accuracy throughout the whole work .
Notwithstanding so many difficulties , as I have enumerated , I have , after numerous trials , and a resolute perseverance , brought the matter at last to such an issue , that I can construct refracting telescopes , scopes , with such apertures and magnifying powers , under limited lengths , as , in the opinion of the best and undeniable judges , who have experienced them , far exceed any thing that has been hitherto produced , as representing objects with great distinctness , and in their true colours .
John Dollond .

