LXXXI .
An Account of an extraordinary Case of the Efficacy of the Bark in the Delirium of a Fever .
By Nic~ .
Munckley , M. D. Physician to Guy's-Hospital , and F. R. S. AS the following case contains some circumstances , which are curious in themselves , and which may be of service to be known , I have thought it proper to be laid before the Society .
Read April 6 .
1758 .
this charge between anno Christi 309 , when Constantine began to reign , and 320 .
If he was then of a great age , he might have composed the treatise , out of which this authority is produced , and which was one of the earliest of his works , that are extant ( Vid. Sparkii praef .
ad Lactant .
) , 40 years before , viz. about anno Christi 280 ; which brings us up to 200 years after the overthrow of Herculaneum , as above .
On Sunday the 5th of March I was sent for to a gentleman , of about 30 years of age , who had been for some days ill of a fever .
I found him with a degree of heat considerably above what was natural , and with a pulse rather low , but quick , and beating , as measured by a stop-watch , about a hundred strokes in a minute .
In this situation he continued , without any remarkable alteration , for the two following days ; and , from the appearance of this disease , I imagined , that it would not be speedily terminated .
On Wednesday , the third day of my seeing him , I found him however much better ; his heat being considerably abated , and his pulse being more than twenty strokes in a minute flower than it had been the day before .
On this alteration , so much in his favour , it might have been thought he was growing well , had it not been , that there was no appearance either by sweat or urine , or on the skin , by which it could be imagined the disease was perfectly judged .
On this account no alteration was made in his treatment that day : but finding , the next morning , that he had slept well the preceding night , and that his pulse continued quiet , being no more than 74 strokes in a minute , he was allowed to get up in the evening , to have his bed made ; and I should have thought him well , had not every appearance of a critical separation been still wanting .
On this account , I thought him to be very liable to a return of his fever ; and therefore , when early the next morning I was informed , that he had been without any sleep , and quite delirious , the whole night , I was not greatly alarmed , as thinking he had a feverish paroxysm , to which the bark would probably put an end .
When I saw him that morning , I found him very delirious ; but , to my great surprise , quite free from all kind of fever whatever ; his pulse being then as calm as it had been the preceding day .
In this condition he remained all that day , and the following night ; nothing , that was attempted to relieve him , having done him the least service : on the contrary , his delirium increased so much , as to make it very difficult for the attendants to keep him in bed .
The next morning he was much as he had been the day before ; his imagination continuing greatly disturbed , and he at times laughing , and playing antic tricks , and using gestures the most opposite to his common demeanour when well ; and which , tho ' the pulse had not been so perfectly quiet , had more the appearance of a mania , than of the delirium of a fever .
In this unhappy situation , there was but one thing , which seemed likely to bring the affair to a speedy determination : this it was proper to attempt , tho ' the indications for it were very obscure , and the event perfectly uncertain .
On recollecting the time of this delirium 's coming on , which was about 36 hours after the pulse had grown quiet ; and perceiving , that one glass of the water , which had been made in the night , was thick , and seemed disposed to drop a sediment ; there was some reason to suspect , and indeed to hope , that tho ' the pulse had been perfectly calm during the whole time of the delirium , there was something of the fever still at the bottom of this complaint .
From these indications , obscure as they were , it was judged proper to make a trial of the bark ; which was accordingly ordered to be taken immediately , and to be repeated every two hours .
This method succeeded beyond what could have been imagined ; insomuch that it was observable , even by the attendants on this gentleman , that his mind came evidently more and more to itself after every dose : and in the evening , after he had taken six drachms , his urine grew thick , and dropped a lateritious sediment ; and , excepting the weakness naturally consequent on such violent emotions as he had undergone , both of mind and body , he was as well as ever he had been in his life .
He hath repeated the bark at proper intervals , as is usual after intermittent fevers , and continues to this day perfectly well .
The use of the bark , in the most irregular intermittent disorders , is very happily so well known in this island , that it might perhaps have been thought needless to have recited any case merely in confirmation of this practice : and I am too well aware of the insufficiency of every thing , but a number of facts on which to found any philosophical truth , to presume to rest any thing on one single instance only .
But the case above related is of so very extraordinary a kind , as to make it worthy of being mentioned , both on its own account , and for that analogy , which being found by experience to subsist between diseases , affords the surest method of reasoning on practical subjects .
The two remarkable circumstances of this case are , the delirium 's coming on , and continuing , without any exacerbation of the pulse ; and the bark 's proving so speedy and effectual a remedy , tho ' given at a time , when there was no appearance of any remission of the symptom , which it was intended to remove .
It hath been thought , that a quick pulse is so essential to the definition of a fever , as to be a pathognomonic symptom of it .
But experience is against this notion : perhaps the present case is a proof of the contrary ; however this be , there have not been wanting instances , in which , towards the end of a fever , the pulse has grown quiet , without the abatement of any other symptom , and the patient hath generally lain comatose , and with the appearance of one , who hath taken a large quantity of opium .
Galen , in the third book of the Presages of the Pulse , mentions this symptom , and pronounces it to be almost a fatal sign : and the same thing hath happened in more instances than one , which have come to my knowlege .
May not then the aboverecited case lead to this useful inquiry , Whether in fevers of every kind , when the pulse is quiet , the bark is not proper to be given , and likely to prove a remedy ?
In this case it proved absolutely such : and that it is at least a safe medicine in all such cases , in which any practitioner of experience or judgment would ever think of giving it , is now certainly known .
For my own part , I can safely declare , that in near ten years experience of it in Guy's-Hospital , during which time I find I have given it , on different occasions , to above five hundred patients in that house only , I never , from the most accurate observation I could make , saw it do any harm , or bring on any bad symptom , even in cases where it did not succeed according to the intention for which it was ordered ; and ( which I have thought worth remarking ) in chronical cases , even in those , where the bark hath been by many thought the most prejudicial , when , on the coming on of an intermittent fever , the bark hath hath been necessary to cure this secondary disease , the original distemper hath gone on , according to the best judgment I could form of it , exactly in the same manner , as it would have done had the bark never been given .

