LXXVI .
A remarkable Instance of Four rough Stones , that were discovered in an human urinary Bladder , contrary to the received Opinion ; and successfully extracted by the lateral Method of Cutting for the Stone .
By Mr. Joseph Warner , F. R. S. and Surgeon to Guy's-Hospital .
THE favourable reception those few papers have met with from the Royal Society , which I have done myself the honour of addressing to them , encourages me to take the liberty of offering the following account to their consideration : and I am the more immediately induced to submit this paper to their perusal , as the fact hereafter related may possibly be not esteemed a matter of mere curiosity ; since it is probable , that the inferences deduced from the history of the subsequent case , when attended to , may prove of the greatest consequence to the future ease and welfare of the patient , as well as be a means of preventing the operator from falling into such errors , as cannot fail of drawing an imputation upon his character , in the practice of one of the most capital and difficult undertakings in his profession .
Read Feb. 23 .
1758 .
It is a maxim laid down by the most judicious and best received writers upon operations in surgery , that when the surface of a stone , which has been extracted from the bladder , appears to be totally rough , it amounts to a proof of its having been there alone .
But notwithstanding I admit it is from experience found , that the observation is in general well grounded , it may nevertheless appear , from the following case , that this rule is not unexceptionable : for which reason perhaps it may be thought right , that we should not be determined from circumstances only ; but , on the contrary , that it is necessary for every surgeon to take such methods during the operation , as will enable him to judge with that degree of certainty , without which he cannot be enabled to do so .
The methods I would recommend are these : That after the extraction of a stone from the bladder , tho ' the whole of its surface be rough , the operator should nevertheless introduce the foresinger of his left or right hand thro ' the wound into the cavity of the bladder ; by which means , if the subject be under twelve years of age , he will be enabled to come in contact with every internal part of the bladder with his finger : but if the subject be an adult , and of a corpulent habit of body , the finger , under these circumstances , not being found to be sufficiently long sor the purpose , he must have recourse to a female catheter , or some other instrument that is nearly strait , quite smooth and polished , and of about nine or ten inches long ; which will serve the purpose equally well , if of a proper form and thickness .
This is the method I have made use of upon the like occasions of late years , without giving any great degree of pain to the patient , or considerably retarding the operation .
Since I have had the opportunity of making the following observation , as well as a prior observation tion something similar to this , where two rough stones were extracted by me a few years ago from a young man 's bladder of 15 years of age , I cannot help suspecting , that there may have been instances of one or more stones being left behind in the bladder at the time of operating , merely from the operator 's putting too great a confidence in this general rule .
Which suspicion I am led into from having known people , who have undergone the operation of cutting for the stone , relapse into the like disorder in a short time after the healing of their wounds , attended with such symptoms , as have obliged them to submit to a second operation ; when the stone , upon being extracted , has appeared of so considerable a size , as to make it suspicious , that this stone must probably have been of a much longer growth , than the short time betwixt the two operations could admit of .
The maxim laid down to us by authors , of a smooth and polished stone in the bladder being never there alone , but always accompanied with one or more stones of the same kind , I know no exception to .
But if this phenomenon should ever occur , the strict observance of that rule ( delivered to us by judicious writers in surgery ) of always searching the bladder under the like appearances , on presumption of one or more stones being left behind , cannot be attended with any future mischief to the patient , when carefully executed by the methods recommended above , and undoubtedly should always be strictly attended to .
The smooth and polished appearances of the surfaces of human calculi are universally supposed to arise from their rubbing one against the other ; which may with reason be supposed posed to be the case : but I confess this inference is not satisfactory to me ; since it is probable , if this was the sole cause of their smoothness , the same effect would probably be always produced , when attended with the same degree of friction .
But as this may be considered as a matter of mere speculation , I refer the decision of this point to those of superior abilities .
CAS E. Mr. William Woodhams , a gentleman farmer , of a corpulent habit of body , in the 46th year of his age , now living in the parish of Udimore , within three miles of Rye in Sussex , was attacked about eight years ago with severe complaints in his loins , accompanied with an incapacity of voiding his urine without the assistance of proper medicines , which were administered to him by a neighbouring apothecary for that purpose .
These medicines had the desired effect : they promoted a secretion , and an evacuation of urine ; which appeared to be loaded with a considerable quantity of gravelly particles mixed with a mucus of a whitish colour .
In the space of three weeks he had perfectly recovered from this attack , and continued well for near five years afterwards , without any return of his complaint , except when he rode hard on horseback , or drank more freely of strong liquors than usual .
At the expiration of five years he was seized with an acute fever , of which he recovered in a few weeks .
Very soon after his recovery from this illness , he began to complain of excessive pain in voiding his urine , or upon going to stool ; which symptoms were so greatly increased for many months before hesubmitted to the operation , as to quite disable him from riding , from walking , or from using any kind of exercise .
His urine , of late , was continually and involuntarily flowing from him in small quantities .
He complained of great pain and soreness in his fundament , attended with a tenesmus .
This account he delivered to me on the second day after the operation ; and at the same time he very feelingly told me , that he had enjoyed but very few and short intervals of ease for the three last years , till since the operation .
On the 30th of January 1758 , I cut him , at his own house in Sussex , having first prepared him for the operation in the manner , that is usual upon the like occasion .
In the operation , I extracted the four stones , which I now have the honour of laying before the Royal Society .
The whole surfaces of these stones appear to be rough , not having the least marks of ever having rubbed against each other during their confinement in the bladder : but yet I conjecture this must frequently have been the case , as there was no difficulty in embracing these calculi with the forceps : for had they been contained in different cells or pouches in the bladder , which sometimes have been observed from dissections , this circumstance would , in all probability , have rendered it impracticable for me to have so immediately got at them , if at all .
The forceps was introduced only three times into the bladder for effecting the extraction of the three first stones , and only twice for the extraction of the fourth stone .
Besides these four stones , which I have presented to the Society for their inspection , I thought it not improper to produce , at the same time , some other human calculi , for their further satisfaction , each of which was found single in the urinary bladders of different subjects .
The surfaces of these stones may be observed to be much smoother than the surface of either of the four stones , that were extracted from Mr. Woodhams 's bladder in the operation I have just now recited ; and therefore it was more reasonable to expect to find each of these stones accompanied with one or more stones in the same bladder ( according to the received opinion ) , than it was to find more stones than one in the case of Mr. Woodhams 's , which has given rise to these observations .
But as the fact before us does of itself show the impropriety and danger of determining from the surfaces of such extraneous bodies , perhaps it may be thought needless to enlarge upon this subject , to strengthen those precautions so reasonable to be observed in this operation .
However , as I have already taken notice of the smooth and polished appearances of the surfaces of such stones , as are probably never found single in the bladder ; I have produced two stones of this kind , that were extracted from the same bladder , to show , that these stones do no more resemble those stones of Mr. Woodhams 's , than a piece of polished marble can be said to resemble a rough block of the same species .
P. S. I am informed , by a letter from Sussex , dated the 18th instant , that Mr. Woodhams is perfectly well in health ; that the whole of his urine had passed through the urethra for the Philos. Trans. Vol. L. TAB XXII.(a ) p. 584 .
This Plate is an exact representation of the sizes and external appearances of the four rough stones described in the preceeding paper last five or six days ; and that his wound will , in all probability , be soon healed .
Hatton-Garden , February 22 .
1758 .
Joseph Warner .

