LXXIII .
Of the best Form of Geographical Maps .
By the Rev. Patrick Murdoch , M. A. F. R. S. I. WHEN any portion of the earth 's surface is projected on a plane , or transferred to it by whatever method of description , the real dimensions , and very often the figure and position of countries , are much altered and misrepresented .
In the common projection of the two hemispheres , the meridians and parallels of latitude do indeed intersect at right angles , as on the globe ; but the linear distances are every where diminished , excepting only at the extremity of the projection : at the center they are but half their just quantity , and thence the superficial dimensions but one-fourth part : and in less general maps this inconvenience will always , in some degree , attend the stereographic projection .
Read Feb. 9 , 1758 .
The orthographic , by parallel lines , would be still less exact , those lines falling altogether oblique on the extreme parts of the hemisphere .
It is useful , however , in describing the circum-polar regions : and the rules of both projections , for their elegance , as well as for their uses in astronomy , ought to be retained , and carefully studied .
As to Wright 's , or Mercator 's , nautical chart , it does not here fall under our consideration : it is perfect in its kind ; and will always be reckoned among the chief inventions of the last age .
If it has been misunderstood , or misapplied , by geographers , they only are to blame .
II .
The particular methods of description proposed or used by geographers are so various , that we might , on that very account , suspect them to be faulty ; but in most of their works we actually find these two blemishes , the linear distances visibly false , and the intersections of the circles oblique : so that a quadrilateral rectangular space shall often be represented by an oblique-angled rhomboid figure , whose diagonals are very far from equal ; and yet , by a strange contradiction , you shall see a fixed scale of distances inserted in such a map .
III .
The only maps I remember to have seen , in which the last of these blemishes is removed , and the other lessened , are some of P. Schenk 's of Amsterdam , a map of the Russian empire , the Germania Critica of the famous Professor Meyer , and a few more ~ .
In these the meridians are straight lines converging to a point ; from which , as a center , the parallels of latitude are described : and a rule has been published for the drawing of such maps * .
But as that rule appears to be only an easy and convenient approximation , it remains still to be inquired , What is the construction of a particular map , that shall exhibit the superficial and linear measures in their truest proportions ?
In order to which , IV .
Let E lL P , in this figure ( See TAB. XXI .
) be the quadrant of a meridian of a given sphere , whose center is C , and its pole P ; E L , El , the latitudes of two places in that meridian , EM their ~ Senex drew several of that form .
* See the Preface to the small Berlin Atlas .
T Philos. Trans. Vol. L. TAB. XXI .
p. 554 .
t I Q no P~~ se RK~ ~ LNW sw 20 V so 60 10 M x 50 360 H 350 y 40 340 ~l 30 330 n 320 G 20 310 EFC 300 280 290 middle latitude .
Draw L N , l n , cosines of the latitudes , the sine of the middle latitude M F , and its cotangent M T. Then writing unity for the radius , if in CM we take Cx=N n/ Ll ~ MF ~ MT , and thro ' x we draw x R , x r , equal each to half the arc Ll , and perpendicular to C M ; the conical surface generated by the line R r , while the figure revolves on the axis of the sphere , will be equal to the surface of the zone that is to be described in the same time by the arc L l ; as will easily appear by comparing that conical surface with the zone , as measured by Archimedes .
And , lastly , If from the point t , in which rR produced meets the axis , we take the angle CtV in proportion to the longitude of the proposed map , as MF the sine of the middle latitude is to radius , and draw the parallels and meridians as in the figure , the whole space SOQV will be the proposed part of the conical surface expanded into a plane ; in which the places may now be inserted according to their known longitudes and latitudes .
EXAMPL E. V. Let Ll , the breadth of the zone , be 50~ , lying between 10~ and 60~ north latitude ; its longitude 110~ , from 20~ east of the Canaries to the center of the western hemisphere ; comprehending the western parts of Europe and Africa , the more known parts of North America , and the ocean that separates it from the old continent .
And because Cx=N n/ Ll ~ MF ~ MT , add these three logarithms .
Log. 0.8726650 ( = 50~ to radius 1 ) 1.9408476 Log. MF ( sin. 35~ ) ... ... .
1.7585913 Log. MT ( tang .
55~ ) ... ... .
0.1547732 Take the sum ... ... .
1.8542121 from log .
Nn ( =.6923772 ) ... .
1.8403427 the remainder ... ... .
1.9861306 is the logarithm of Cx .
And because 1 : Cx : : MT : xt , to this adding the log .
MT 0.1547732 The sum ... ... . .
0.1409038 is the log .
of xt= 1.383260 ; and xR ( = xr= 1/ 2 L l ) being.4363325 , Rt will be 0.9469275 , rt = 1.8195925 .
Whence having fixed upon any convenient size for our map , the center t is easily found .
As , allowing an inch to a degree of a great circle , or 50 inches to the line Rr , Rt the semidiameter of the least parallel will be 54.255 inches , and that of the greatest parallel 104.255 inches .
Again , making as radius to MF so the longitude 110~ to the angle St V , that angle will be 63~ 5~3/ 5 .
Divide the meridians and parallels , and finish the map as usual .
Note , The log .
MT being repeated in this computation with a contrary sign , we may find xt immediately by subtracting the sum of the logarithms of Ll and MF from the log .
of N n. VI .
A map drawn by this rule will have the following properties : 1 .
The intersections of the meridians and parallels will be rectangular .
2 .
The distances north and south will be exact ; and any meridian will serve as a scale .
3 .
The parallels thro ' z and y , where the line Rr cuts the arc Ll , or any small distances of places that lie in those parallels , will be of their just quantity .
At the extreme latitudes they will exceed , and in mean latitudes , from x towards z or y , they will fall short of it .
But unless the zone is very broad , neither the excess nor the defect will be any-where considerable .
4 .
The latitudes and the superficies of the map being exact , by the construction , it follows , that the excesses and defects of distance , now mentioned , compensate each other ; and are , in general , of the least quantity they can have in the map designed .
5 .
If a thread is extended on a plane , and fixed to it at its two extremities , and afterwards the plane is formed into a pyramidal or conical surface , it may be easily shown , that the thread will pass thro ' the same points of the surface as before ; and that , conversely , the shortest distance between two points in a conical surface is the right line which joins them , when that surface is expanded into a plane .
Now , in the present case , the shortest distances on the conical surface will be , if not equal , always nearly equal , to the correspondent distances on the sphere : and therefore , all rectilinear distances on the map , applied to the meridian as a scale , will , nearly at least , show the true distances of the places represented .
6 .
In maps , whose breadth exceeds not 10~ or 15~ , the rectilinear distances may be taken for sufficiently exact .
But we have chosen our example of a greater breadth than can often be required , on purpose pose to show how high the errors can ever arise ; and how they may , if it is thought needful , be nearly estimated and corrected .
Write down , in a vacant space at the bottom of the map , a table of the errors of equidistant parallels , as from five degrees to five degrees of the whole latitude ; and having taken the mean errors , and diminished them in the ratio of radius to the sine of the mean inclination of the line of distance to the meridian , you shall find the correction required ; remembering only to distinguish the distance into its parts that lie within and without the sphere , and taking the difference of the correspondent errors , in defect and in excess .
But it was thought needless to add any examples ; as , from what has been said , the intelligent reader will readily see the use of such a table ; and chiefly as , whenever exactness is required , it will be more proper , and indeed more expeditious , to compute the distances of places by the following canon .
Multiply the product of the cosines of the two given latitudes by the square of the sine of half the difference of longitude ; and to this product add the square of the sine of half the difference of the latitudes ; the square root of the sum shall be the sine of half the arc of a great circle between the two places given .
Thus , if we are to find the true distance from one angle of our map to the opposite , that is , from S to Q , the operation will be as follows : L. sin. L. sin. 30~= 1.6989700 L. sin. 80~= 1.9933515 2 L. sin. 55~= 1.8267290 1.5190505 = log .
of 0.330408 and 2 L. sin. 25~= 1.2518966 = log .
of 0.178606 Log. of the sum ... 0 509014 is 1.7067297 Whose half is 1.8533648 the L. sin. of 45~ 31~ , the double of which is 91~ 2~ , or 5462 geographical miles .
And seeing the lines TS , TQ , reduced to minutes of a degree , are 6255 .
189 and 3255 .
189 respectively .
and the angle STV is 63~ 5~ 3/ 5 , the right line SQ on the map will be 5594~ , exceeding its just value by 132~ or 1/ 42 of the whole .
7 .
The errors on the parallels increasing fast towards the north , and the line SQ having , at last , nearly the same direction , it is not to be wondered that the errors in our example should amount to 1/ 42 .
Greater still would happen , if we measured the distance from O to Q by a straight line joining those points : for that line , on the conic surface , lying every-where at a greater distance from the sphere than the points O and Q , must plainly be a very improper measure of the distance of their correspondent points on the sphere .
And therefore , to prevent all errors of that kind , and confine the other errors in this part of our map to narrower bounds , it will be best to terminate it towards the pole by a straight line KI touching the parallel OQ in the middle point K , and on the east and west by lines , as H I , parallel to the meridian thro ' K , and meeting the tangent at the middle point of the parallel SV in H. By this means too we shall gain more space than we lose , while the map takes the usual rectangular form , and the spaces GHV remain for the title , and other inscriptions .
VII .
Another , and not the least considerable , property of our map is , that it may , without sensible error , be used as a sea-chart ; the rumb-lines on it being logarithmic spirals to their common pole t , as is partly represented in the figure : and the arithmetical solutions thence derived will be found as accurate as is necessary in the art of sailing .
Thus if it were required to find the course a ship is to steer between two ports , whose longitudes and latitudes are known , we may use the following RUL E. To the logarithm of the number of minutes in the difference of longitude add the constant logarithm * 4.1015105 , and to their sum the logarithm sine of the mean latitude , and let this last sum be S. The cotangent of the mean latitude being T , and an arithmetical mean between half the difference of latitude and its tangent being called m , from the logarithm of T+m take the logarithm of T m , and let the logarithm of their difference be D ; then shall SD be nearly the logarithm tangent of the angle , in which the ship 's course cuts the meridians .
Note , We ought , in strictness , to use the ratio of tx+xR to txxR instead of T+m to T m ; but we substitute this last as more easily computed , and very little different .
* This constant logarithm contains the reduction of the diff. of longitude to parts of radius unity , and to Briggs 's Modulus .
EXAMPLE I. Let the latitudes , on the same side of the equator , be 10~ and 60~ ; then the middle latitude and its complement are 35~ and 55~ , and half the difference of the latitudes is 25~ : and the difference of longitude being 110~ , the operation will stand as below .
Log. 6600~ ( in 110~). .
3.8195439 Constant log ... .
4.1015105 -1.9210544 Log. sin. 35~ ... 1.7585913 S = ... .
1.6796457 Again T= 1.4281480 m =.4513202 Log. T+ m(= 1.8794682 ) 0.2740350 Log. T m(= 0.9768278 ) 1.9898180 Log. 0.2842170=D= -1.4536500 SD ( = log .
tangent 59~ 16~ ) ... .
= 0.2259957 agreeing to a minute with the solution by a table of meridional parts .
EXAMPLE 2 .
The rest remaining , let the difference of longitude be only 40~ ; then Log. 2400~ ( in 40~). .
3.3802112 Constant log ... .
4.1015105 1.4817217 Log. sin. 35~ ... 1.7585913 S = ... .
1.2403130 D ( as before ) = 1.4536500 SD ( = log .
tang .
31~ 27~ ~/ ~ ) ... 1.7866630 EXAMPLE 3 .
Let the difference of longitude be 40~ ; but the latitudes 56~ and 80~ ; And log .
2400~ = 1.4817217 + log .
constant Log. sin. 68~ ... = 1.9671659 S = ... .
1.4488876 T ( tang .
22~ ) =.4040262 m = ... ... 2109980 Log. T+m ( =.6150242 ) 1.7888921 Log. Tm ( =.1830282 ) 1.2625181 Log ... 0.5263740 =D= 1.7212944 SD ( = log .
tangent 28~ 6~ ) ... ... .
= 1.7275932 wanting of the true answer no more than 1~ 4~ .
And in all cases that can occur , the error of this rule will be inconsiderable .
It is not meant , however , that it ought to take place of the easier and better computation by a table of meridional parts : but it was thought proper to show , by some examples , how safely the map itself may be depended on in the longest voyages ; provided it is sufficiently large , and the necessary rumb-lines are exactly drawn * .
* See Cotesii Logometr .
prop. 6 .
last age .
If it has been misunderstood or misapplied by geographers , they only are to blame.''And again , at the end of his nautical examples , he concludes thus , viz. ` ` It is not meant , however , that it ought to take place of the easier and better computation by a table of meridional parts .
' ' I have the honour to be , with the greatest respect , SIR , The ROYALSOCIET Y'S , and Your most obedient Servant ,

