LXIX .
A Discourse on the Usefulness of Inoculation of the horned Cattle to prevent the contagious Distemper among them .
In a Letter to the Right Hon. George Earl of Macclesfield , P. R. S. from Daniel Peter Layard , M. D. F. R. S. My Lord , THE honour you have done me , in condescending to peruse my Essay on the contagious Distemper among the horned Cattle , claims my most respectful thanks ; and I am no less obliged to your Lordship for the just remark you made , ` ` That before inoculation could be practised on the horned Cattle , it is necessary to bring proofs , that this disease is not susceptible more than once ; and also assurances , that a recovery from the distemper by inoculation guards the beast from a second infection .
' ' Read Feb. 2 .
1758 .
An entire conviction of the analogy between this disease and the small-pox would not permit me to omit mentioning the great advantages , which must arise from inoculation ; and therefore , my Lord , I recommend its use : nor do I find any reason to alter my opinion , after having carefully read over what has been published , and made the strictest inquiry I was able in several parts of Great Britain .
I shall , in the concisest manner possible , submit the following particulars to your Lordship 's consideration , and the learned Society , over which you so deservedly preside .
The Marquis de Courtivron , in two memoirs read before the Royal Academy of Sciences in the year 1748 , and published by that learned body , relates the observations he , together with Monsieur Pelversier de Gombeau , formerly surgeon to the regiment de la Sarre , made on the rise , progress , and fatality , of the contagious distemper at Issurtille , a town in Burgundy ; to which are added experiments they made , by application , digestion , and inoculation , towards communicating the disease ; and concludes from the failure of these attempts , that the distemper can only be communicated from one beast to another .
Besides , notwithstanding the Marquis observes ( 1 ) the regularity of the illness , the critical days , on the seventh and ninth , and particularly that all such as recovered had more or fewer pustules broke out in different parts of the body ; yet ( 2 ) he will not allow of Rammazzini 's opinion , of the analogy between this distemper and the smallpox , nor that it is an eruptive fever ; but ranks it as a plague .
But the Marquis goes still farther .
He positively say , ( 3 ) ` ` That in the preceding years , in the provinces of Bresse , Maconnois , and Bugey , some private persons had suffered by buying cattle recovered from the distemper , which had , at that time , the pustules remaining on them : which cattle had the distemper afterwards .
' ' Nay , he adds that even after recovering twice , a third infection has seized and killed many .
' ' ( 1 ) Memoires de l'Acad .
des Sciences , anno 1748 .
p. 326 .
( 2 ) Ibid. p. 338 .
( 3 ) Ibid. p. 337 .
No wonder , my Lord , that such positive assertions should stagger , and cause the practice of inoculation not to be received , till the nature of the disease be absolutely determined , and facts prove the contrary of what has been asserted .
In a matter of so great importance to every nation , it were to be wished , that the Marquis de Courtivron had produced attested observations of these second and third infections : for tho ' a nobleman of his rank , character , and great abilities , would not willingly impose upon the world ; yet it may happen , that he may have received wrong informations .
As to the nature , rise , progress , and fatality , of this distemper at Issurtille , it appears to be the same disease as raged in these kingdoms .
All the symptoms agree , as described by Rammazzini , Lancisi , the Marquis , and in my Essay .
A distempered beast gave rise to the three infections .
The illness was every-where the same in Italy , France , and Britain ; and either terminated fatally on the fourth or fifth day , when a scouring prevented the salutary eruptions , or in some cases by abortion ; and on the seventh or ninth favourably , when the pustules had regularly taken their course .
Tho ' the Marquis did not observe , that any particular medicines were of use , he says , that in general acids were beneficial , especially poor thin wines somewhat sour ; and that the distempered beasts were all fond of these acids ( 4 ) .
The fatality was likewise the same , as will appear from the Marquis 's tables .
Of 192 head of cattle , 176 died .
The mortality was chiefly among the fat ( 4 ) See my Essay on the contagious Distemper , p. 70 .
cattle , cows with calf , and young sucking or yearling calves ; and of the surviving sixteen , only two calves out of seventy-seven lived , and these two , with seven other beasts of the sixteen , escaped the infection , tho ' constantly among the diseased : so that it is plain , Of 192 beasts , 176 died 7 recovered 9 escaped the infection .
192 The mortality was as considerable in these kingdoms .
Whoever will compare the appearances , progress , and fatality , of the small-pox , with what is remarked by authors of authority , as Rammazzini and Lancisi , and other observers , relative to the contagious distemper among the horned cattle , will not be at a loss one moment to determine , whether this disease be an eruptive fever , like unto the small-pox , or not .
Now if , as the Marquis has granted in both his memoirs ( 5 ) , it be a general observation , that an eruption of pustules on some parts of the body , regularly thrown out , digested , and dried , is the means used by nature to effect the cure ; and that in general the morbid matter does not affect the parotid , inguinal , or other glands , nor produce large carbuncles and abscesses , as the plague does : Nay more , since it is observed by the Marquis , that the difference between the contagious distemper of 1745 and 1746 , and of 1747 and 1748 , was , that in the former the ( 5 ) Page .
143 .
and 338 .
salutary eruptions appeared , but in the latter were , as he justly apprehends , checked by the excessive cold weather ; and should it appear , that by inoculation the same regular eruptive fever has been produced , with every stage , and the same symptoms as arise in the small-pox ; the nature of this distemper will then be ascertained .
I shall now proceed , my Lord , to lay before your Lordship and the Society the accounts I have received relating to the infection and inoculation of the cattle , and make some observations on the experiments made at Issurtille .
So long , my Lord , as the distemper has raged in Great Britain , not one attested proof has been brought of any beast having this disease regularly more than once .
I make no doubt but these creatures may be liable to eruptions of different kinds ; but as all sorts of eruptions , says Dr. Mead ( 6 ) , are not the smallpox , nor measles , so every pustule is not a sign of the plague .
Thro ' ignorance , or fraud , persons may have been deceived in purchasing cattle , and have lost them , as well in England as in the provinces of France mentioned by the Marquis ; but until a second infection be proved , the general opinion must prevail in this case , as in the small-pox : for tho ' many have insisted on the same thing with regard to the small-pox , yet a single instance , properly vouched and attested , has never been produced , either after recovery from the natural way , or from inoculation ; unless what is frequently the case with nurses and others attending the small-pox , that is , pustules ( 6 ) Essay on the Plague .
breaking out in their arms and face , be allowed as the signs of a second infection .
The farmers and graziers in Huntingdonshire , Cambridgeshire , Lincolnshire , Kent , and Yorkshire , from whence I have written testimonies , all agree , that they never knew of a beast having the contagious distemper more than once .
In this county particularly , Mr. J. Mehew , the farmer mentioned in my Essay , has now among his stock at Godmanchester eight cows , which had the contagious distemper the first time it appeared in Godmanchester in 1746 .
It returned in 1749 , 1755 , and 1756 ; the two last not so generally over the town as the two former years .
All these four times Mr. Mehew suffered by the loss of his cattle ; yet those eight cows , which recovered in 1746 , remained all the while the distemper was in the farm the three years it raged , were in the midst of the sick cattle , lay with them in the same barns , eat of the same fodder , nay of such as the distempered beasts had left and slobbered upon , drank after them , and constantly received their breath and steams , without ever being in the least affected .
Is not this a convincing proof ?
If in general the cattle be susceptible of a second infection , how comes it , that not one of these eight cows were affected ?
In the years abovementioned the distemper spared no beast , but such as had recovered from that disease : and this is confirmed to me by Mr. Mehew 's father and brother , all the chief farmers of Godmanchester , and is the opinion of all the farmers and graziers in Huntingdonshire , who are so thoroughly convinced of there being no second infection , that they are always ready to give an advanced price for such cattle as have recovered from the contagious distemper .
The Rev. Mr. Scaife , assistant to the Rev. Dr. Greene , Dean of Salisbury , in his parish of Cottenham , Cambridgeshire , acquaints me , that the farmers in that neighbourhood lost , in 1746 and 1747 , twelve hundred head of cattle , in 1751 four hundred and seventy ; and tells me , that Mr. Ivett , Sayers , Moor , Dent , Lawson , chief farmers at Cottenham , Mr. Taylor , Sumpter , and Matthews , of his own parish of Histon , and the farmers of Wivelingham alias Willingham , unanimously declare , they never had one instance of a beast having the distemper twice .
Mr. Thorpe , a farmer and grazier near Gainsborough in Lincolnshire , has had beasts recovered from the distemper , which have herded with cattle fallen ill afterwards , and never met with a single instance of a second infection .
Mr. Lofty , an eminent surgeon at Canterbury , has inquired for me of the farmers and graziers in that part of Kent , and about Romney-Marsh ; and from whence no belief of a second infection can be had .
The Rev. Dr. Fountain , Dean of York , writes me word , that no beast has been known , in his neighbourhood , to have had the distemper twice .
And several persons from that county , and others , have told me the same thing .
If the above testimony of persons of character and veracity , together with the concurrent persuasion of farmers in general , be allowed of , it must be determined , that there is no instance of a second infection .
Supposing now it should appear , that this distemper is regularly , as in the natural way , tho ' in a milder manner , produced by inoculation , and that inoculation secures a beast also from a second infection ; then undoubtedly inoculation will be recommendable .
The very few trials made in England , and those not with the greatest exactness or propriety , will yet serve to put this matter out of all doubt .
The Rev. Dean of York had five beasts inoculated , by means of a skein of cotton dipped in the matter , and passed thro ' a hole , like a seaton , in the dew-lap .
Of these five , one cow near the time of calving died : the other four , after going thro ' the several stages of this contagious disease , recovered ; two of which , being cows young with calf , did not slip their calves .
All four have herded with distempered cattle a long while , and never had the least symptom of a second infection .
Mr. Bewley , a surgeon of reputation in Lincolnshire , inoculated three beasts two years old , for Mr. Wigglesworth of Manton , in the dew-lap , and with mucus from the nostrils .
All three had the regular symptoms of the contagious distemper in a mild manner , recovered , and tho ' they herded a twelvemonth after with five or six distempered beasts , they never were the least affected .
Mr. Bewley also declared to Mr. Thorpe , that there never was one instance produced , that he knew of , of a second infection .
Since it is plain , that notwithstanding neither welldigested pus was made use of , nor incisions made in the properest places , and it may be supposed few medicines were given ; yet inoculation succeeded so as to bring on the distemper in a regular and mild manner , as appears by the cows with calf not slipping their calves .
One may fairly conclude , that in this contagious distemper , like unto the small-pox , the practice of inoculation is not only warrantable , but much to be recommended .
But how comes it then , that neither by application , digestion , nor inoculation , the distemper was not communicated in France ?
The Marquis says , that this distemper is not communicated but from one beast to another immediately .
I must beg leave to say , that to my knowlege the distemper in February 1756 was carried from the farm-yard , where I visited some distempered cattle , to two other farm-yards , each at a considerable distance , without any communication of the cattle with each other , and merely by the means of servants going to and fro , or of dogs .
The experiments made on four beasts , by tying over their heads part of distempered hides , or pieces of linen and woollen cloth or silk , which had received the breath and steams of dying cattle , serve to show , by the bullock 's forcing off the cloth tied about him , that the putrid stench was disagreeable to him ; but that neither his blood , nor that of the other three beasts , was then in a state to receive the infection .
With regard to the pustules , which the Marquis relates were mixed with oats and bran , or dissolved in white wine ; the distempered bile , which was mixed with milk ; milk taken from diseased cows ; water , in which part of a distempered hide had been steeped ; and the precaution taken to force these mixtures into the paunch of calves , by means of a funnel , whose end was covered with a piece of raw distempered skin , that the beast might both swallow and suck in the disease .
All these experiments could have no other effect than what followed ; which was , that the acrimony of the distempered bile created first a nausea , and then produced a violent scouring , which killed the beast , leaving marks of its irritation on the intestines .
The practice of inoculation is but lately followed , and even now but little known , in the provinces of France .
Its advantages have not long since been strangely disputed at Paris .
In the case of inoculating cattle , instead of a slip of raw hide taken from a beast just dead , or putting a pustule into the neck , they should either have passed in the dewlap cotton or silk dipped in well-digested pus , or have inserted in proper incisions cotton-thread or silk soaked with pus either on the shoulders or buttocks ; the true way of inoculating in the English manner .
Some persons have indeed thought , that to inoculate with the blood of the infected would answer the intention ; but most of the modern practitioners chuse to depend on digested matter .
Several constitutions will not receive infection , let them be inoculated ever so judiciously .
A Ranby , a Hawkins , a Middleton , and other inoculators , will tell us , that the incisions have sometimes suppurated so much , and pustules have appeared round the edges of the wound , without any other particular marks of the disease ; and yet the patient has never had the small-pox afterwards .
The Marquis mentions an instance somewhat of the same kind in his first Memoir , p. 147 .
The examination of these very important and interesting particulars has , I observe , drawn me into a prolixity , which I fear may prove tedious to your Lordship : but should I have removed all doubts , and brought convincing proofs of the absurdity of fearing a second infection ; should I have shown inoculation to be a necessary practice , and that the contagious distemper may be communicated more ways than one ; I hope your Lordship will excuse the length of this letter .
I shall only add my earnest wishes , that the legislature may , by effectual means , prevent the importation of distempered cattle and hides into these kingdoms ; the only means of naturalising and perpetuating a dreadful distemper , now , thank God !
much decreased among us .
I am , with the greatest respect , Huntingdon , 26 Nov. 1757 .
My Lord , Your Lordship 's Most humble and most obedient Servant , Daniel Peter Layard .

