A Letter to the Right Honourable the Earl of Macclesfield , President of the Royal Society , from the Rev. William Brakenridge , D.D. F.R.S. containing an Answer to the Account of the Numbers and Increase of the People of England , by the Rev. Mr. Forster .
My Lord , AS I endeavoured , at a former meeting of the Society , to answer extempore some objections offered by a Gentleman in the country , to what I have wrote concerning the number of people in England ; I now presume to send you what I said then in writing , with some farther reflections .
And this subject I never intended to VOL. 50 .
Ooo have Read Mar. 16 , have meddled with any more ; but as I seem to be called upon , to defend what I have formerly wrote , I hope I shall be excused if I briefly attempt it .
Your Lordship , I know , and our illustrious Body only desire a fair representation of facts , which is the ground of all philosophical inquiries ; and therefore I shall endeavour to do this , as far as I can , without regarding any hypothesis .
My design , when I first entered on this subject , was to discover whether our people were in an increasing or decreasing state , with regard to their numbers ; which I thought of great importance to be known , because of its influence on the affairs of Government , in determining our strength , in settling of taxes , and directing us in the oeconomy and employment of our people .
Now , in order to proceed in this inquiry , it was evident to me , that if the number of houses were exactly known , the number of people would be nearly ascertained .
And therefore I attended to this , to find out the number of houses , as the only thing that could with any certainty help us to judge of this matter .
And accordingly , being resolved to depend only upon the most sure , and general observations , I applied to a public office , where I thought I might possibly get at their number .
And I there found , that from the last survey that was made , since the year 1750 , there were 690,700 houses in England and Wales that paid the window-tax , and the two-shilling duty on houses ; besides cottages that paid nothing .
By cottages are understood those who neither pay to church or poor , and are , by act of parliament in 1747 , in consideration of the poverty of the people , declared to be exempted both from the tax and the two-shillings duty ; and they only remain not accurately known , to ascertain the whole number of houses .
However , they are so far known , that from all the accounts that are hitherto given in , they do not appear to be so many as 300,000 ; and from what I myself have seen , in the books of that office , I should think they were not much above 200,000 ; for in some places , that I was perfectly acquainted with , I found many of the day labourers rated to the two-shillings duty , and there did not appear to be one house in ten omitted .
And therefore , if there are not 300,000 cottages , as seems plain to me , there cannot be a million of houses in the whole in England and Wales ; and the rated houses are to the cottages more than two to one ; of both which , according to the returns made , there is now about one in seventeen or 58,800 empty throughout the kingdom .
But if we were to allow , that there are a million of houses in the whole ; which is more than the Gentlemen in the above mentioned office believe , and then deduct those that are empty , there could not be above 941,200 inhabited houses ; and consequently supposing six to a house , about 5,647,200 people , or near about five millions and an half ; which at the utmost , is what I insist on to be the real number .
But now the Gentleman , who objects to my calculations , thinks , that I have made the number of houses too few , and that in the whole there are above 1,400,000 houses , of which he imagines there are more than 700,000 cottages ; for he supposes them to be more than the rated houses ; and from thence he infers , that there are about seven millions and an half of people , in England and Wales ; which I wish , with all my heart , was the true number : But I am so far from thinking that I have under-rated them , that I suspect I have rather made them more than they are .
However , this controversy will soon be determined , there being now orders given , as I am informed , to all the Officers concerned in the window-tax , to make an exact return of all the cottages , as well as the rated houses , in each of their several districts .
In the mean time , the Gentleman and I differ in this , that he supposes above 400,000 cottages more than I can possibly imagine .
Let us now see upon what grounds , and by what method of reasoning he determines his numbers .
He makes a division of the 690,000 taxed houses into three classes , placing 200,000 of them in the open country and villages , and 200,000 in the market and inferior towns , and the next , viz. 290,000 , in the the cities and great towns ; for which division he has nothing to direct him ; no proof , nor even probability .
And as it is a mere arbitrary supposition , all reasoning and calculations founded upon it are nothing to the purpose , and the number of houses or people comptued from thence must be false or uncertain .
But yet , upon this supposition , as if it was absolutely certain , he goes on to compute the houses and people in each division .
As to the first , he says he has counted all the houses in nine contiguous parishes in Berkshire , in which he has found the whole number to be 588 , and those charged to the duty to be only 177 ; and therefore the cottages are to the rated houses as 411 to 177 , or above two to one .
And from this he assumes , that the whole number of houses thro ' the villages and open country in England will be to the cottages nearly in the same proportion .
But here I am surprised , that he should reason in so loose and an inaccurate a manner .
For , as there may be 7000 parishes in the villages and open country , to infer from the numbers in nine of them that are contiguous , and that all of them together do not make a very large parish , many being much larger as to the number of houses , and where there may be particular circumstances ; I say , to infer from them what the proportion will be in all parishes , in the villages and open country , is the same way of reasoning as to say , because the poor in one parish are in such a proportion , therefore they are so in 1000 parishes , or thro ' four or five counties : whereas it is plain , that the proportion differs almost in every parish , and in every county ; and the sum of all must be added together , before we can know what the real proportion is .
And nothing can be inferred from the circumstances of a few parishes , or even of a County , what the proportion will be in the whole .
And yet , from such precarious and vague reasoning he presumes to compute , that there are above 460,000 cottages in the villages and open country ; having assumed , without any hesitation , that there are 200,000 rated houses in that extent .
Such reasoning is unusual in philosophcal inquiries .
In like manner the Gentleman reasons very inaccurately about his second division , containing the lesser market and country towns , having supposed in them 200,000 taxed houses : For from one instance of the market town of Langborne , having found the whole number of houses to be to the cottages as 445 to 229 , or the rated houses to the cottages as 216 to 229 , he supposes the like proportion in all the market~ ket towns .
That is , tho ' there be perhaps above 300 market towns in England , he supposes each of them has the same proportion of the poor in it as the single town of Langborne ; which is unreasonable to imagine .
For every one of them may have a different proportion , according to the various circumstances of their trade and situation .
But yet from this strange and uncertain way of reasoning , without any induction , and from one instance among 300 cases at least , he concludes by proportion , that there are 388,646 houses in the country market towns , of which there are 188,646 cottages , besides those in the cities and great towns .
In the next place , as to his third class , the cities and great towns , he allows , that my proportion may be among them , viz. that the rated houses are to the cottages as 690,000 to 200,000 , or 69 to 20 : For he thinks , that it cannot be any-where but in the most flourishing places .
And therefore , as he has arbitrarily placed 260,000 taxed houses in them , he computes that they must contain 84,058 cottages .
But he has given no proof , that my proportion is only in the most flourishing places , besides these few instances that he has produced ; which are nothing to form any general conclusion upon .
For if we were to be directed by a few cases , we might think that there were much fewer cottages than I have allowed .
There are some parishes , in which there are none at all .
In the great parishes of St. James 's and St George 's Westminster , in which there are about 7000 houses , there are none : in the country parish of Chiselherst in Kent , where there are above 100 houses , there are but three : and in many parishes there is not one in 20 .
So that from particular instances , there is nothing to be concluded .
But in all Middlesex , London , Westminster , and Southwark included , in which the poor are as numerous as in most places in the kingdom , because of the numbers of labouring people that flock hither for employment , there is nearly the same proportion that I have assigned .
For from a late survey in that district , as I am informed , there are 87,614 houses in the whole , and of these 19,324 cottages , and 4810 empty .
Which indeed shows , that we are not so populous , in and near the metropolis , as is commonly supposed , and much less than I had calculated in my first letter : For from this account , if it be true , there are not above 530,000 people in that compass ; of which , within the bills of mortality , there die about 25,000 yearly ; that is , not less than one in 20 .
As to what the Gentleman mentions concerning the militia , he seems to be much mistaken .
For if the proportion be as he says , that one in 45 is levied , this directly proves the number of people in England and Wales to be about five millions and an half , according to my calculation ; because the electors or balloters are the fencible men , or those able to carry arms .
And if the whole levy be 32,000 , then 45 multiplied by 32,000 will give 1,440,000 for all the fencible men in England .
But Dr. Halley has clearly shown , that the fencible men are one quarter of the whole people , children included ; and therefore , four times 1,440,000 , or 5,760,000 , will be the whole number of the people ; which is nearly what I have made them .
And thus , having seen how he has established his numbers in opposition to me , let us now , in the next place , consider what he has said with regard to the increase of our people .
He says , whether the kingdom is really in a declining or increasing state , is a problem not to be solved by calculation : And yet he himself can guess by appearances , that it has greatly increased within these 40 years .
But , by his good leave I must tell him , that it is a problem in political arithmetic to be solved from some data , as well as others .
If the number of people be nearly found , and the general proportion of births to burials , at an average , thro ' the kingdom be known , with the annual losses of our fencible men , at a moderate computation ; from these data , I say , any one , who understands numbers , will easily determine whether we are increasing or decreasing .
And accordingly , I have shown , that the annual increment of our fencible men is not much above 8000 , which number is consumed by our annual losses ; and therefore we are not in an increasing state .
For the whole number of people must always be in proportion to the fencible men ; so that , if there is no increase of them , there can be none upon the whole .
It is true , I am the first who ventured upon a solution of this question ; but when I consider what I have done , I cannot see but that the principles upon which I reasoned are right .
The data are , I think , exact enough to discover our state .
And Dr. Halley 's rule to compute the fencible men , where our losses are to be reckoned , is undoubtedly true .
So that if there is any difficulty , it is in fixing the general proportion between births and burials , thro ' the kingdom , viz. 112 to 100 ; which I have taken from Dr. Derham , who had collected many observations ; being a greater proportion than Sir William Petty allowed .
And which if it is thought too small , it is to be considered , that within the bills of mortality the births are much under the burials as 4 to 5 ; and in some of the great towns there are fewer births than burials , and in others they are nearly equal ; so that these reduce the proportion that arises from the villages and open country .
But if we were to make a calculation from the births and burials , only in the villages and open country ; which Dr. Derham has found to be at an average as 117 to 100 , or nearly as 7 to 6 ; and suppose this to obtain all over Britain and Ireland , in the towns as well as the country , which is surely more than the truth ; we shall then find , that the annual increment cannot be more than 9000 fencible men ; which corroborates my former estimate .
For , to compute it by the principles I have formerly endeavoured to establish ; let the number of our people in Britain and Ireland be eight millions and an half , that is , five and an half in England and three millions in Scotland and Ireland ; because some Irish Gentlemen have assured me , from some facts , that there is half a million more in their country than I formerly allowed ; for I did not pretend to calculate them ; and then the annual number of the dead , in Britain and Ireland , being one in 40~ will be about 212,500 ; which will be to the births as , 100 to 117 : And therefore the births must be 248,625 , and the increase 36,125 ; of which the fourth part is about 9000 for the fencible men , which I am persuaded is more than the real number .
Now let any one compute our losses in the moderate way that I have done , and he will easily see , that they cannot be less than this number ; and consequently we are far from increasing .
And indeed it is evident from the number of empty houses thro ' the kingdom , mentioned above , viz. one in seventeen , or 58,000 , and one in twelve of those that are taxed within the bills of mortality .
For it is impossible , if we were increasing , that there could be so many empty ; And therefore the appearance of so much building is only the effect of our luxury , requiring larger , more convenient , and more elegant houses , and not caused by our increase .
However , the Gentleman objects to all this , and says , that he has examined the Registers of some neighbouring parishes , and particularly of three that are perfect ; and he finds , that the burials are to the baptisms as 83 to 149 ; which may possibly be the case , as I myself have known it in one parish in the Isle of Wight , where the place is healthy , and people generally marry .
But does he imagine that this proportion is general all over England ?
If so , we should increase in a rapid manner indeed !
for then we should double our people in 35 years , if it were not for our losses ; which no reasonable man will venture to say .
He does not reflect , that in many country places , from their bad situation , there is very little increase , and in some towns none at all , and in others a decrease , continually supplied from the neighbouring country .
Within the bills of mortality there are annually 5000 burials more than the births ; and consequently , to maintain our numbers here , there must be a yearly supply of 5000 ; which destroys the whole increase of six or seven counties .
And Dr. Derham found , from the accounts he had of country parishes , that in general among them the proportion of births to burials was not greater than 117 to 100 , as we mentioned above ; so that nothing can be concluded from particular healthy places .
The question is , what is the result upon the whole thro ' the kingdom ?
what is the general proportion of the births to burials , from which the increase is to be estimated ?
and which Sir William Petty says is 111 to 100 , and Dr. Derham as 112 to 100 .
See if he can disprove these numbers by putting together all the different accounts from every corner , among the towns as well as the country ; and if he cannot , to argue only from a few instances is nothing to the purpose ; for where there there is a multitude of different cases , they must all be considered , to arrive at the general truth .
But even in the particulars he mentions , he has not completed his argument ; for , to make it conclusive , he should have shown , that , within these last forty years , the time , he thinks , of our great increase , in those parishes the number of houses or people were increased , in proportion almost as the births were above the burials , as 149 to 83 : and if that cannot be made to appear , it is plain , that , for all he has said , the annual increase may be constantly consumed by our losses .
And now the worthy Gentleman having endeavoured to show , from the case of a few parishes in the country , that we are in an increasing state , he proceeds to give me his serious advice in two particulars : First , That I would reconsider a proposition advanced by me , That all reasonable ways of increasing our people , even to the naturalising of foreigners , would be for the public welfare .
In answer to which kind admonition I must say , that I have often considerd the thing , as far as I can ; and I think this may be easily shown against any political writer , That it is the interest of a government , when they have powerful and dangerous neighbours , to increase their people by all reasonable means , even to the inviting of foreigners , so far as the natural produce of the country can sustain them ; and that it is the fault or weakness of an administration not to be able to employ them .
And in Britain , where they can have the assistance of the produce of so many large and fruitful countries of their own in America , I will venture to say , that it is an error in their policy , not to endeavour to increase their people ; by which they might be more formidable , and perhaps stronger than their grand Enemy .
The present King of Prussia has shown the utility of this within his dominions ; by which he has been enabled to make such a figure in Europe .
The second thing he admonishes me to reconsider is , That I have supposed our commerce to be one cause of the loss of our sensible men .
And who in the world doubts of it , but himself !
Do shipwrecks , the disasters and inclemency of the sea , the scurvy , &amp;c. beget people ?
But he will say , without these we could not have trade , which employs great numbers of our people ; and therefore , what we lose , we may gain another way .
And just so he may say of our wars , that occasion the destruction of so many of our people , that they are no loss to us ; for we gain by them in their consequences , in securing of our liberties and property , and by which our trade is preserved and promoted .
But notwithstanding this , can it be said , that war does not diminish our fencible men !
The truth is , trade increases riches , and gives more of the conveniences of life , and brings luxury along with it ; but it does not necessarily breed people : For we see in those countries where they have little trade , the people increase much faster than they do with us , as appears from the Bills of mortality in Prussia ; where the general proportion of the births to the burials is greater than it is here , viz. 4 to 3 ; and by which the people might double in 84 years , if it were not for their losses .
( Vid. Phil. Trans. vol. xxxvi .
) Which great increase , by the way , easily accounts for those vast swarms of people that came from thence and the adjacent countries in former ages , and over run all Europe .
And therefore it is not so terrible a paradox , as he imagines , that possibly where there is much less trade the people may increase faster ; for luxury and other vices , that come with trade , do not promote an increase .
And now , as he has been so good as to give me his advice , I will return the favour , and desire him to reconsider the method of reasoning by induction ; which may possibly help him to escape some paralogisms , in arguing upon these subjects .
And I would likewise recommend it to him to inquire diligently , whether the number of our houses in England be increased these last sixty years ; which , according to his reasoning , ought at least to be doubled : For if there is no increase of the houses , there can be none of the people .
To conclude : He adds , that my doctrine , from beginning to end , to say the best of it , is ill-timed , when we are contending with our hereditary enemy , pro aris &amp; focis .
But here his zeal hurries him on , that he does not look to the dates of my Letters .
For the first three were read before the Society , and ordered to be printed , long before the war was proclaimed ; and as for the last , it is only a supplement to the rest ; in which I have shown , that France , by the bad oeconomy of her people , is not in an increasing state ; which , I think , is a comfortable hearing .
But supposing they had been all printed during the war : What then ?
Is a fact to be concealed that , if discovered , may be useful to prevent errors in government , and rectify our notions of the oeconomy of our people ?
What advantage can our enemies make of such a discovery ?
Will it encourage them to imagine that we shall be easier subdued , when they know , by the most moderate computation , we have at least two millions of fencible men in our British islands .
Enough , surely , to resist them in all their attempts !
But I doubt we are not so deficient in our numbers as in public virtue , without which the greatest multitude may be easily overcome .
And thus , my Lord , I have endeavoured to answer what this Gentleman has wrote in his second Letter ; for I pass over the first , as it does not seem to contain any more in opposition to me , than what I have here considered .
And upon the whole I cannot see , that he has said any thing to invalidate what I have formerly advanced .
If I could discover it , I should be very ready to acknowledge my error .
I am sensible I have made this reply too long ; but I trust your usual benevolence to all our worthy Members will excuse me , who shall always esteem it an honour to be , Sion-College , March 16 .
1758 .
My Lord , Your Lordship 's Most obedient and faithful Servant , Wm. Brakenridge .
END of PART I. VO L. L.

