LVI .
An Answer to the preceding Remarks .
By Mr. John Ellis , F. R. S. MY letter to Mr. Webb , which is printed in the second part of the xlixth volume of the Philosophical Transactions * , was intended to show this Honourable Society , that Mr. Miller , in his reply to the Abbe Mazeas 's letter , had brought no proofs to lessen the discovery , which he tells us the Abbe Savages had made , in attempting to improve the art of painting or staining linens and cottons of a fine durable black colour , by making use of the juice of the Carolina pennated Toxicodendron , instead of the common method of staining black with gauls and a preparation of iron ; which , he says , always turns to a rusty colour when washed .
Read Jan. 19 , 1758 .
Mr. Miller , instead of producing the proper proofs , to show that this method of staining cottons and linens of a black colour was known before , or quoteing the authors in which he says it is mentioned , contents himself with telling the Society , that this American Toxicodendron is the same plant with the true varnish-tree of Japan ; and that callicuts are painted with the juice of this shrub .
In my letter to Mr. Webb , I have endeavoured to show , that notwithstanding the authority of Dr. Dillenius , and the authors that have followed him , it does not appear , from Dr. Kaempfer 's description of this Japan plant , that it can be the same with our American one .
* Page 806 .
The design , then , of this paper , is to lay before this Society some further reasons , why these plants cannot be the same ; and that even if they were the same , Mr. Miller has produced no authority to show , that this juice was ever made use of for this purpose abroad ; with some remarks on his reply to my letter , in which he obliges me to be more particular than I intended , in explaining some errors , which I find he has run into .
In my letter to Mr. Webb , I have pointed out the exact description , which Kaempfer has given us of the leaves of this plant , showing how much they differ from our American one : but now I shall mention some observations that escaped me before , and which , I think , will give us a clearer proof of this matter .
Kaempfer , then , informs us , that this Japan varnish-tree , or Sitz-dsju , is a tree , not a shrub : and this author ( it is well known ) is remarkably exact in the description of his Japan plants , making the necessary distinctions between a shrub , an arborescent shrub , and a tree .
He then goes on to explain the manner of its growth ; and tells us , that it grows with long sappy shoots , very luxuriantly , to the height of a sallow or willow-tree , which we may reasonably allow to be from 20 to 30 feet : whereas this Carolina pennated Toxicodendron , as Mr. Miller tells us in his Dictionary , 6th edit .
in folio , is a shrub , and seldom rises above five feet high with us : and many people , who have been in North America , agree , that it is but a slow grower there , and is one of the shrubby underwoods of that country : so that , allowing it to grow even double the height it does here , it is still but a shrub , in comparison with the other .
Further , while Dr. Dillenius was warm with this supposed discovery , of our having got the true Japan varnish-tree in America , attempts were made there , by intelligent persons under his direction , to procure this varnish after the manner of Kaempfer ; but without success , as I am assured by persons of that country now here , with whom the Doctor corresponded .
Let us now consult the growth of the Carolina and Virginia Sumachs , or Rhus 's , in our nurserygardens , and compare them with this little shrubby Toxicodendron , and we shall find , that even in this cold climate nature keeps her regular proportionable pace in the growth of vegetables of the same country .
Let us observe the growth of some of these Rhus 's , and we shall find that great luxuriancy of the shoots , which Kaempfer so justly describes in his varnish-tree .
One of these American ones even seems to promise the same height as the Japan Rhus ; whereas this little shrubby Toxicodendron still preserves the same dwarfish slow-growing habit , that it has in its native country .
This leads me , in the next place , to show , that these two plants must be of different genus 's ; the one a Rhus , and the other a Toxicodendron : and if so , according to Mr. Miller , they ought to be properly distinguished , and not ranked together , as Dr. Linnaeus has done .
In order to prove this , let us then examine Kaempfer 's description of the parts of the flower , and see whether it does not answer exactly to the genus of Rhus ; and whether the flowers are not male and female in themselves , that is , hermaphrodites , on the same tree .
The original of Kaempfer is as follows , p. 791 of his Amaenitates : ` ` Flosculos continent pumilos , et citra coriandri seminis magnitudinem radiantes , in luteum herbaceos , pentapetalos , petalis carnosis nonnihil oblongis et repandis , staminibus ad petalorum interstitia singulis , apicatis , brevissimis , stylo perbrevi tricipite , floris turbini insidente ; fructus flosculum excipit gibbosus utcunque in rhomboids figuram compressus .
' ' Whereas Dr. Dillenius , and the authors that have copied after him , say , that his Toxicodendron has the male blossoms on one plant , and the female on the other ; from whence it must evidently be another genus .
It appears , however , that Dr. Dillenius was not altogether ignorant of this difference of genus in these two plants ; but , rather than his Toxicodendron , which he had made agree exactly in the leaves , should not agree in the fructification , he makes the accurate Kaempfer guilty of an unpardonable oversight , in not taking notice of the difference of the sexes of this varnish-tree in different plants : whereas we have just now shown , that nothing can be more minutely and judiciously described , than he has done both the male and female parts of the blossom , which change into the fruit on the same plant .
The original of Dr. Dillenius 's remarks on Dr. Kaempfer 's specimen runs thus : ` ` Planta sicca , quae in Japonia lecta , servatur in phytophylacio Sherardino , nostrae huic specie examussim quadrat , id tantum sexus nempe differentia praetervisa fuit auctori .
' ' Hence we find how this error came to spread , and this false synonym to be adopted by the botanic writers , who copied after Dillenius .
This shows us what little dependence we can have upon the result of that meeting , which Mr. Miller mentions he had with his botanic friends ; where , from the similitude of leaves only , without the parts of fructification , they determined these two plants , so different in their growth , to be one and the same plant .
Mr. Miller remarks very justly , that the leaves of the same tree often vary much in shape , such as those of the poplar , sallow , &amp;c. But in answer to this , we may reasonably suppose , that Dr. Kaempfer , who was on the spot , would not choose for his specimens leaves of the most uncommon sorts that were on the tree , and neglect the most common .
This would be carrying the supposition farther than can be allowed , unless we suppose this author had not the understanding even of a common gardener ; for otherwise , I am persuaded , Sir Hans Sloane would not have thought his specimens worth purchasing .
For another synonym to the true Japan varnishtree , as also to Dillenius 's pennated Toxicodendron with rhomboidal fruit , Mr. Miller brings in ( in his answer to the Abbe Mazeas 's letter ) the Bahama Toxicodendron foliis alatis fructu purpureo pyriformi sparso of Catesby 's Not .
Hist. vol. i. p. 40 .
so that he would have all these three different plants one and the same : and , in his reply to my letter , he still insists on it , that these two Toxicodendrons are the same .
But here I must beg the favour of this Honourable Society , when they come more attentively to consider this matter , to compare his answer to the Abbe Mazeas 's letter , and his reply to me , in this particular part .
I shall only at present take notice , that Catesby says , this Toxicodendron , with the pear-shaped fruit , grows usually on rocks in Providence , Ilathera , and other of the Bahama islands ; and does not mention , that he ever saw it in Carolina .
I cannot find it described by any author as growing in Carolina , or in any other part of the continent of North America : nor do I believe that there is a plant of it now growing in England , or that it is even the same genus with Dillenius 's rhomboidal-fruited one , from the different structure both of its leaves as well as fruit .
In looking over Dr. Linnaeus 's Hortus Cliffortianus , I find he gives this Bahama Toxicodendron of Catesby as a synonym to his Elemifera foliis pinnatis , p. 486 .
I now come to that part of Mr. Miller 's reply , relating to the China varnish-tree , that was raised from seeds sent to the Royal Society by Father D'Incarville ; where he still insists on it , that this is the same with the spurious varnish-tree of Kaempfer .
His reasons are , that notwithstanding the indentation and roundness of the bottom of the lobe-leaves of the China varnish-tree , and tho ' the lobe-leaves of the spurious Japan varnish-tree come to a point at the base , and are no-way indented , but quite even on the edges ; yet he says , because they have an equal number of pinnae , or lobe-leaves , on the whole leaf of each tree , they must be the same .
Rhus sinense foliis alatis foliolis oblongis ~~ ad basin ~ ct dentatis .
J. Mind delin et Sc. Ex. Horto Botanico Philippi Carter .
' In answer to this , I say their lobe-leaves are not equal ; for I have examined both the specimens and drawings of Dr. Kaempfer 's spurious varnish-tree , and I do n't find that the number of the pinnae exceed seven on a side : whereas I have a small specimen of a leaf by me , that was taken from the top of one of D'Incarville 's China varnish-trees , which is above eight feet high , and stands in an open exposure ; and this leaf , tho ' but a foot long , has 12 lobe-leaves on a side , and each lobe indented at the base * .
At the same time I observed , that the leaves of the young shoots of another tree were a yard long , as they were this summer at the garden of the British Museum .
Another thing is remarkable in the leaves of this China varnish-tree ; and that is , the lobes of the leaves , as they approach to the end , grow smaller and smaller ; whereas in the spurious Japan varnish-tree they are rather , if there is any difference , larger towards the end .
I shall make this further remark , that tho ' these indentations on the lobe-leaves may vary in number in this China varnish-tree ; yet , as I observed before , since they are continued on even in the smaller leaves at the top of the branches of a tree eight feet high in the open ground , it appears to me , that this specific character , besides the form and insertion of the ' lobe-leaves , will ever distinguish it as a different species from the Fasi-no-ki , or spurious varnish-tree of Kaempfer .
Mr. Miller now goes on to tell us , he is confirmed in his belief of their being the same , by making some observations on the seeds of this China varnish* See TAB. XVII .
where this specimen is exactly delineated .
tree ; and therefore asserts , that they are the same .
It is natural to suppose he compared them with the accurate drawings of the seeds of Kaempfer 's Fasi-noki , p. 794 .
that being the only place where the seeds of it are described .
In the very next paragraph Mr. Miller seems to forget , that from his own observations on the seeds of the China varnish-tree , he has asserted it to be the Fasi-no-ki of Kaempfer ; but now he finds , in his memorandums , that those seeds were wedgeshaped , and like the seeds of the beech-tree ; and that all the three seeds he received seemed to be enclosed in one capsule : so that now he is at a loss what to call it ; and at the same time says I have been to hasty in calling it a Rhus .
Mr. Miller goes on , and allows this China varnishtree changes to a purple in the autumn ; but not so deep as the true varnish-tree .
I suppose he means , by this true varnish-tree , the Carolina pennated Toxicodendron ; for Kaempfer has not told us what colour the true varnish-tree of Japan changes to in autumn .
But this is no certain proof on either side of the question , only a corroborating circumstance of the species of a tree : nor should I have mentioned it , but for the manner in which Kaempfer , with an imagination truly poetical , describes the autumnal beauty of his Fasi-no-ki , or spurious varnish-tree .
Rubore suo autumnati qua viridantes sylvas suaviter interpolat , intuentium oculos e longinquo in se convertit .
' ' Even this description would make one suspect it is not the same with the China varnishtree , which , I am informed , did not turn purplish in the garden of the British Museum till the first frost came on : whereas it is well known , that some of the Rhus 's and Toxicodendrons , particularly the Carolina pennated one , change to a fine scarlet colour in the beginning of a dry autumn , even before any frost appears .
Mr. Miller seems surprised , how I should think , that the Carolina pennated Toxicodendron , or poisonash is like the Fasi-no-ki of Kaempfer .
I must here acknowledge , at this time , not having seen Doctor Kaempfer 's specimen , I imagined , from the shape of the lobe-leaves ( as he has described them ) and from the remarkable scarlet colour of both these trees in autumn , that Mr. Miller might be right in what he has advanced ; for it was from his authority I took it , depending on the information he gives us in his Dictionary , fol. edit .
6 .
under the article Toxicodendron , where he takes some pains to assure us , that they are the very same plants .
In the next paragraph I find Mr. Miller has entirely mistaken the meaning of one part of my letter to Mr. Webb ; which I must recommend to him to read again , and he will find it exactly agees with his own sentiments .
There he will find my opinion is , that notwithstanding the change of soil and situation , this Sitz-dsju , or true varnish-tree , and the Fasino-ki , or spurious varnish-tree of Kaempfer , are distinct species of Rhus or Toxicodendron , and will ever remain so .
Mr. Miller now desires me , since I have seen Dr. Kaempfer 's specimens in the British Museum , to declare , whether I think I am mistaken .
In answer to this , and to satisfy Mr. Miller as well as myself , I have been very lately at the MuV O L. 50 .
Mmm seum , seum , and have looked very carefully over Dr. Kaempfer 's specimens , and do sincerely think , as did other judges at the same time , that the Sitz-dsju is not the same with the Carolina pennated Toxicodendron , nor the Fasi-no-ki the same with Father D'Incarville 's China varnish-tree .
Mr. Miller informs us , that one of the best kinds of varnishes is collected from the Anacardium in Japan .
In answer to this , I must beg leave to show the Society , that Dr. Kaempfer does not so much as mention , that this Anacardium grows in Japan ; but that the varnish , which is collected from it , is brought to them from Siam : and I believe it will appear plainly , from what follows , that there is not a plant of this kind in the kingdom of Japan ; for Siam and Cambodia , especially the parts of those kingdoms , where Kaempfer informs us this * Anacardium grows , lie in the latitudes of from 10 to 15 degrees north , which must be full as hot as our West Indies : so that it is not probable , that it would bear the cold of the winters in Japan ; for Japan lies from the latitudes of 33 to above 40 degrees north , which is about the same parallel with our North American colonies .
I shall now beg leave to lay before the Society that passage of Dr. Kaempfer , which relates to this dispute , together with my translation of it , that it may be compared with Mr. Miller 's translation , which he gives us in his reply to the Abbe Mazeas 's letter , Philosoph. Trans. vol. xlix .
p. 164 .
2d paragraph .
* This is likewise called the Malacca Bean , from its growing in great plenty on that coast , near the equinoctial line .
Dr. Kaempfer , in his Amaenitates , p. 793 .
speaking of the true varnish-tree , says , ` ` Colitur frequens in provinciis Tsi-kocko et Figo , in quibus inserti agris scapi radices agunt et caudices edunt post triennium vernicem suppeditantes .
Optima regionis , quin totius mundi , vernix perhibetur circa urbem Jassino colligi .
Vernicem ceres Japonica largitur oppido nobilem et pretiosissimam , sed admodum parcam ; nec pro operibus , quae regio construit , sufficeret , nisi prius cum , Nam Rak , i. e. vernice ignobiliore ex Siamo invecta , pro basi illinerentur .
Siamensis vernix promitur in provincia Corsama , et regno Cambodiae ex arbore Anacardo , incolis Tong Rak , i. e. Arbor Rak dicta , cujus fructus officinis nostris Anacardium dictus Luk Rak , liquor Nam Rak appellatur .
Perforatus truncus immisso tubulo , tanta copia fundit liquorem ut Sinae , Tunquino et Japoniae pro deliniendis utensilibus sufficiat , quin jam Bataviam et alia Indiae loca vasis ligneis inclusa appellit .
' ' Which , translated into English , appears to me to be thus : ` This varnish-tree is often cultivated in the pro ` vinces of Tsi-kocko and Figo : there they plant ` the cuttings or truncheons in the fields , which take ` root , and send forth vigorous shoots , which in ` three years time yield this varnish .
` The best varnish of the kingdom , nay , of the ` whole world , is said to be collected about the city ` of Jassino .
The produce in Japan of this most ` noble and very precious varnish , is so very little , ` that there would not be sufficient for the wares ` made in the kingdom , if they did not first lay on ` a ground with an ordinary kind of varnish , which ` they call Nam Rak , and is brought to them from ` Siam .
` This Siam varnish is collected in the province of ` Corsama , and in the kingdom of Cambodia , from ` the tree Anacardus , called by the inhabitants Tong ` or Tree-Rak ; the fruit of which is called in our ` shops Anacardium , or Luk Rak , and the liquor is ` called Nam Rak .
` To collect this liquor , they bore a hole in the ` trunk , and put in a tube .
By this method they ` get as much of it as is sufficient not only to varnish ` all the utensils of China , Tonquin , and Japan , but ` it is even exported in close wooden vessels to Bata ` via , and other parts of India .
' The original of Kaempfer , p. 794 .
speaking of the true Japan varnish , is as follows : ` ` Prostat non sincera modo , sed et colorata , vel cinnabari nativa Sinensi , vel terra rubra ( quam Batavi antea , nunc Sinenses advehunt ) vel atramenti popularis materia .
' ' Which I apprehend may be read thus in English : ` This varnish is not only sold quite pure , but ` likewise coloured , and that with Chinese native ` cinnabar , and a kind of red earth , which the ` Dutch formerly , but now the Chinese , bring them ; ` and also with the materials that they make their ` common ( or Japan ) ink of .
' Mr. Miller translates it thus ( See p. 164 .
vol. xlix .
Phil. Transact. ) : ` This varnish is used without mix ` ture to stain black : but the Chinese mix native ` cinnabar , or a red kind of earth , with it , to make ` a different colour .
' Here we may observe , that Mr. Miller uses the words staining black ; which is not the sense of the author , who , by mentioning the materials of Japan ink , shows , that even in varnishing black it was necessary to use this black mixture .
Further , Mr. Miller says , that the Chinese mix these colouring ingredients with this varnish : but the original plainly says , that the Chinese import them , and the Japanese mix them with rvarnish for sale .
And in a former part of this letter , p. 162 .
vol. xlix .
Phil. Trans. he says , speaking of this true varnish-tree , that callicuts are painted with the juice of this shrub .
But this bare assertion of his , without producing a proper authority , I am persuaded this Honourable Society will never admit as a matter of proof to invalidate the discovery of the Abbe Savages .
In looking over one of the numbers of Mr. Miller 's Dictionary , under the title of Anacardium , I find he quotes a passage from Dr. Grew , which Sir Hans Sloane has placed among his observations on the Cashew-tree , Hist. Jam. vol. ii .
p. 127 .
which is , that cottons are stained with lime , and the oil , or mellaginous succus , called Mel Anacardium ( but for the account of this Mel Anacardium I shall refer to Parkinson 's Theat .
p. 1568 ) ; and Mr. Miller seems to think it difficult to know which of the Anacardiums is here meant .
One would be apt think , from this passage , and another that follows a little after in the same page of the Hist. of Jamaica , relating to the black dye of the mellagoof this nut , that Sir Hans , at the time his history was published , thought them , as Caspar Bauhin did , of the same genus , but different species ; and therefore he has mixed the observations on both together .
For , immediately after mentioning the staining of cottons with this mellaginous succus , Sir Hans says , that the gum is , in faculties and colour , like gumarabic ; and that it is given internally in female obstructions ; and that the juice stains linen , which will not wash out suddenly : but he says it is false , that they remain till they flower next year , as Du Tertre asserts .
Sir Hans further quotes , from an anonymous Brasilian author , that the apples stain linen ; and that the gum is good to paint and write ; and the bark dyes yarn and vessels serving for pots .
And in another place he quotes De Laet , who compiled a general history of America , and who likewise takes his quotation from an old Brasilian author , treating of the trees of Brasil , That the gum of the Acajou is used by painters ; the bark is used to dye cotton-yarn and earthen ware .
Here I must remark , tho ' foreign to our present purpose , that in the original of Laet , what relates to the earthen ware runs thus : ` ` Et a fair de vaisseaux de terre .
' ' So that I believe it will appear more probable , that the bark of these trees was used rather to burn earthen ware vessels , than to dye them , as we find these earthen vessels were used to boil their victuals in .
These two quotations from Sir Hans Sloane confirm the former , with regard to the use of the gum ; that is , its being fit , like gum-arabic , to be used for water-colours , and to make ink ; and that it is the juice of the apple that stains , but this we find is not durable .
Mr. Miller has now only the bark of the Cashewtree left to support his argument .
This the abovementioned Brasilian writers say , that the native Indians of Brasil used to dye their cotton-yarn with ; but of what colour no mention is made .
And whether this bark is used to give strength to this yarn , as we dye and tan our fishing-nets with oak-bark , or for ornament , is uncertain ; for a great deal of this yarn was used in the making their net-hammocks , as well as their coarse garments .
Mr. Miller then introduces Sir Hans Sloane , in opposition to Dr. Browne , whose History of Jamaica I had quoted , to prove that the juice of the Acajou was of the same nature and properties with that of the gum-arabic , and consequently not fit for varnish : whereas it plainly appears from the foregoing quotations , taken from Sir Hans Sloane , that Dr. Browne is right , and agrees exactly in opinion with him .
He then makes Sir Hans say , that the inhabitants of Jamaica stain their cottons with the bark of the Cashew-nut tree .
By this , one would naturally conclude , that Mr. Miller has been endeavouring to prove , in opposition to the Abbe Mazeas 's letter , that the art of painting or staining cottons of a fine deep black colour , equal to that discovered by the Abbe Savages , as described in his experiments on the Carolina Toxicodendron , was practised by the English forty or fifty years ago in Jamaica .
If this was the case , it is something surprising , that , notwithstanding our great intercourse with that island , the callico-printers of England never got intelligence of this valuable secret .
Further , if Mr. Miller will consult Piso and Margrave , grave , writers of the best authority on the Brasilian plants , he will find their accounts of the Acajou exactly correspond with that delivered by Dr. Browne , in his History of Jamaica , as well as Sir Hans Sloane 's : for they say , that the juice of this tree is equal in virtue , and mechanical uses , to the best gum-arabic .
And if he still doubts , I shall lastly recommend him to go to the British Museum , and there he may see a most elegant specimen of the Cashew-gum , which will put this matter quite out of all doubt .
I shall now leave the decision of this controversy , which Mr. Miller has obliged me so fully to explain in my own vindication , to the candour and impartiality of this Honourable Society .
P. S. Since the foregoing paper was read , Professor Sibthorp was so kind to deliver me an exact drawing of the Fasi-no-ki in the Sherardian collection at Oxford , taken by the Rev. Mr. William Borlase , F. R. S. the title and synonym of which are both in the Handwriting of Dr. Dillenius , as the Professor assures me .
See TAB. XVIII .
Vol. L. TAB. XVIII .
Fasinoki Joxicodendron foliis alatis fructu Rhomboide H. Elth : from Japan .
~ W.Borlase ~ .
~ .
so .
In Horto sicco ~

