LIII .
The Resolution of a General Proposition for Determining the horary Alteration of the Position of the Terrestrial Equator , from the Attraction of the Sun and Moon : With some Remarks on the Solutions given by other Authors to that difficult and important Problem .
By Mr. Tho. Simpson , F. R. S. SINCE the time , that that excellent Astronomer , my much honoured friend Dr. Bradley , published his observations and discoveries concerning the inequalities of the precession of the equinox , and of the obliquity of the ecliptic , depending on the position of the lunar nodes , mathematicians , in different parts of Europe , have set themselves diligently to compute , from physical principles , the effects produced by the sun and moon , in the position of the terrestrial equator ; and to examine whether these effects do really correspond with the observations Read Dec. 22 , 1757 .
Two papers on this subject have already appeared in the Philosophical Transactions ; in which the authors have shown evident marks of skill and penetration .
There is , nevertheless , one part of the subject , that seems to have been passed over without a due degree of attention , as well by both those gentlemen , as by Sir Isaac Newton himself .
This part , which , upon account of physical difficulties , is indeed somewhat slippery and perplexing , I shall make the principal subject of this essay .
GENERALPROPOSITIO N. Supposing an homogeneous sphere OABCD ( Fig. 1 .
) revolving uniformly about its centre , to be acted on at the extremity A of the radius O A , in a direction AL perpendicular to the plane of the equator ABC D , and parallel to the axis of rotation Pp , by a given force , tending to generate a new motion of rotation at right angles to the former ; It is proposed to determine the change , that will arise in the direction of the rotation in consequence of the said force .
FI G. 1 .
B AP LOC p NM RD Let F denote the given force , whereby the motion about the axis Pp is disturbed , supposing f to represent the centrifugal force of a small particle of matter in the circumference of the equator , arising from the sphere 's rotation ; and let the whole number of such particles , or the content of the sphere , be denoted by c : let also the momentum of rotation of the whole sphere , or of all the particles , be supposed , in proportion to the momentum of an equal number of particles , revolving at the distance OA of the remotest point A , as n is to unity .
It is well known , that the centripetal force , whereby any body is made to revolve in the circumference of a circle , is such , as is sufficient to generate all the motion in the body , in a time equal to that , wherein the body describes an arch of the circumference , equal in length to the radius .
Therefore , if we here take the arch AR=O A , and assume m to express the time , in which that arch would be uniformly described by the point A , the motion of a particle of matter at A ( whose central force is represented by f ) will be equal to that , which might be uniformly generated by the force f , in the time m ; and the motion of as many particles ( revolving , all , at the same distance ) as are expressed by cn ( which , by hypothesis , is equal to the momentum of the whole body ) , will , consequently , be equal to the momentum , that might be generated by the force f~ cn , in the same time m. Whence it appears , that the momentum of the whole body about its axe Pp is in proportion to the momentum generated in a given particle of time m~ , by the given force F in the direction A L , as ncf~m is to F~ m~ , or , as unity to F/ n cf~ m~/ m ( because the quantities of motion produced by unequal forces , in unequal times , are in the ratio of the forces and of the times , conjunctly ) .
Let , therefore , AL be taken in proportion to A M , as E/ n cf~ m~/ m is to unity ( supposing AM to be a tangent to the circle ABCD in A ) , and let the parallelogram AMNL be completed ; drawing also the diagonal A N ; then , by the composition of forces , the angle NAM ( whose tangent , to the radius O A , is expressed by OA~ F/ n cf~ m~/ m ) will be the change of the direction of the rotation , at the end of the aforesaid time ( m~ ) .
But , this angle being exceeding small , the tangent may be taken to represent the measure of the angle itself ; and , if Z be assumed to represent the arch described by A , in the same time ( m~ ) about the center O , we shall also have m~/ m = Z/ A R= Z/ A O , and consequently OA~ F/ n cf~ m~/ m =Z~ F/ n c f. From whence it appears , that the angle expressing the change of the direction of the rotation , during any small particle of time , will be in proportion to the angle described about the axe of rotation in the same time , as F/ n cf is to unity .
Q. E. I. Altho ' , in the preceding proposition , the body is supposed to be a perfect sphere , the solution , nevertheless , holds equally true in every other species of figures , as is manifest from the investigation .
It is true , indeed , that the value of n will not be the same in these cases , even supposing those of c , f and F to remain unchanged ; except in the spheroid only , where , as well as in the sphere , n will be = 2/ 5 ; the momentum of any spheroid about its axis being 2-5ths of the momentum of an equal quantity of matter placed in the circumference of the equator , as is very easy to demonstrate .
But to show now the use and application of the general proportion here derived , in determining the regress of the equinoctical points of the terrestrial spheroid , let AEaF ( Fig. 2 .
) be the equator , and Pp the axis of the spheroid : also let HECF represent the plane of the ecliptic , S the place of the sun , and HAPNH the plane of the sun 's declination , making right-angles with the plane of the equator AEa F : then , if AK be supposed parallel , and OKM perpendicular , to O S , and there be assumed T and t to express the respective times of the annual and diurnal revolutions of the earth , it will appear ( from the Principia , B. III .
prop. xxv .
) that the force , with which a particle of matter at A tends to recede from the line OM in consequence of the sun 's attraction , will be expressed by 3t t/ T T~A K/ O A~ f ; f denoting the centrifugal force of the same particle , arising from the diurnal rotation .
Hence , by the resolution of forces , 3t t/ T T~A K/ O A~O K/ O A~f will be the effect of that particle , in a direction perpendicular to O A , to turn the earth about its center O. FI G. 2 .
M P AK e E SC HO F a pN But it is demonstrated by Sir Isaac Newton , and by other authors , that the force of all the particles , or of all the matter in the whole spheroid APa p , to turn it about its center , is equal to 1/ 5th of the force of a quantity of matter , placed at A , equal to the excess of the matter in the whole spheroid above that in the inscribed sphere , whose axis is P p. Now this excess ( assuming the ratio of ~ to 1 , to express that of the area of a circle to the square of the radius ) will be truly represented by 4 ~/ 3 ~OP~OA2OP 2 ; and , consequently , the force of all the matter in the whole earth , by 3t t/ T T~A K/ O A~O K/ O A~4 ~/ 15 ~OP~ OA2 OP2 .
Let , therefore , this quantity be now substituted for F , in the general formula F/ n c f , writing , at the same time , 4 ~/ 3 ~OA2~O P , and 2/ 5 , in the place of their equals c and n ; by which means we have ( here ) F/ n cf=3t t/ 2 TT~OA2OP 2/ O A2~AK~O K/ O A 2 .
Put the given quantity 3t t/ 2 TT~OA2OP 2/ O A2= k ; and let the angle EAe represent the horary alteration of the position of the terrestrial equator , arising from the force F ( here determined ) , and let the arch Ee be the regress of the equinoctial point E , corresponding thereto : then , in the triangle EAe ( considered as spherical ) it will be sin. e : sin. AE ( : : sin. EA e : sin. E e ) : : EA e : Ee ( = sin. AE~EA e/ sin. E ) =k~ sin. A E/ sin. E~ AK~O K/ O A2=k~ sin. AE~ cos. AH~ sin. A H/ sin. E. But in the triangle EH A , right-angled at A ( where HA is supposed to represent the sun 's declination , AE his right ascension , and HE his distance from the equinoctial point E * ) we have ( per spherics ) sin. A E : 1 ( rad .
) : : co-t .
E : co-t .
A H , sin. AH 2 : sin. EH 2 : : sin. E 2 : 12 ( rad .
2 ) From whence we get , sin. AE~ co-t .
AH~ sin. AH2 = sin. EH2~ co-t .
E~ sin. E 2 .
But co-t .
AH~ sin. AH= co-s .
AH~1 ( rad .
) , and co-t .
E~ sin. E = co-s .
E~1 ( rad .
) : therefore sin. AE~ co-s .
AH ~ sin. AH= sin. EH2~ co-s .
E~ sin. E ; and , consequently , k~ sin. AE~ co-s .
AH~ sin. A H/ sin. E=k~ co-s .
E ~ sin. EH2 ( = E e ) .
Let , now , the sun 's longitude EH be denoted by Z ( considered as a flowing quantity ) ; then , sin. Z2 being = 1/ 2 1/ 2 co-s .
2 Z , we shall have k~ co-s .
E~ sin. EH2= 1/ 2 k~ co-s .
E~1 co-s .
2 Z. But the angle described about the axe of rotation P p , in the time that the sun 's longitude is augmented by the particle ~Z , will be = T/ t ~ ~Z .
Therefore ( by the general proposition ) we have , as I : 1/ 2 k~ co-s.E ~1 co-s .
2Z : : T/ t ~ ~Z : 1/ 2 k~ T/ t ~ co-s .
E~ ~Z ~Z co-s .
2 Z , the true regress of the equinoctial point E , during * No error arises from considering the triangles EAe and AE H , as being formed on the surface of a sphere , tho ' the earth itself is not accurately such .
The angle ( E A a ) representing the effect of the solar force , is properly referred to the surface of a sphere ; therefore ( after the measure thereof is truly determined ) the figure APap is itself taken as a sphere , in order to avoid the trouble of introducing a new scheme .
that time : whose fluent , 1/ 2 k~ T/ t ~ co-s .
E~Z 1/ 2 sin. 2 Z , will consequently be the total regress of the point E , in the time that the sun , by his apparent motion , describes the arch HE or Z ; which , on the sun 's arrival at the solstice , becomes barely = 1/ 2 k~ T/ t ~ co-s .
E~ an arch of 90~ : the quadruple whereof , or 1/ 2 k~ T/ t ~ co-s .
E~ 360~ ( = 3t/ 4T ~ OA2 OP2/ OA2 ~ co-s .
E~ 360~ ) is therefore the whole annual precession of the equinox caused by the sun .
This , in numbers ( taking OP/ OA = 229/ 230 ) comes out 3/ 4 ~ 3661/ 4 ~ 2/ 2301/ 2 ~ 0.917176 ~ 360~ = 21~ 6~ .
The very ingenious M. Silvabelle , in his essay on this subject , inserted in the 48th volume of the Philosophical Transactions , makes the quantity of the annual precession of the equinox , caused by the sun , to be the half , only , of what is here determined .
But this gentleman appears to have fallen into a twofold mistake .
First , in finding the momenta of rotation of the terrestrial spheroid , and of a very slender ring ; at the equator thereof ; which momenta he refers to an axis perpendicular to the plane of the sun 's declination , instead of the proper axe of rotation , standing at right angles to the plane of the equator .
The difference , indeed , arising from thence , with respect to the spheroid ( by reason of its near approach to a sphere ) will be inconsiderable ; but , in the ring , the case will be quite otherwise ; the equinoctial points thereof being made to recede just twice as fast as they ought to do .
This may seem the more strange , if regard be had to the conclusions , relating to the nodes of a satellite , derived from this very assumption .
But , that these conclusions are true , is owing to a second , or subsequent mistake , at Art .
27 ; where the measure of the sun 's force is taken the half , only , of the true value ; by means whereof the motion of the equinoctial points of the ring is reduced to its proper quantity , and the motion of the equinoctial points of the terrestrial spheroid , to the half of what it ought to be .
That expert geometrician M. Cha .
Walmsley , in his Essay on the Precession of the Equinox , printed in the last volume of the Philosophical Transactions , has judiciously avoided all mistakes of this last kind , respecting the sun 's force , by pursuing the method , pointed out by Sir Isaac Newton ; but , in determining the effect of that force , has fallen into others , not less considerable than those above adverted to .
In his third Lemma , the momentum of the whole Earth , about its diameter , is computed on a supposition , that the momentum or force of each particle is proportional to its distance from the axis of motion , or barely as the quantity of motion in such particle , considered abstractedly .
No regard is , therefore , had to the lengths of the unequal levers , whereby the particles are supposed to receive and communicate their motion : which , without doubt , ought to have been included in the consideration .
In his first proposition , he determines , in a very ingenious and concise manner , the true annual motion of the nodes of a ring ( or of a single satellite ) at the earth 's equator , revolving with the earth itself , about its center , in the time of one siderial day .
This motion he finds to be =3 co-s .
23~ 29~/ 4 rad .
~ 1/ 3661/ 4 ~ 360~ .
Then , in order to infer from thence , the motion of the equinoctial points of the earth itself , he , first , diminishes that quantity , in the ratio of 2 to 5 : Because ( as is demonstrated by Sir Isaac Newton in his 2d Lemma ) the whole force of all the particles situated without the surface of a sphere , inscribed in the spheroid , to turn the body about its center , will be only 2-5ths of the force of an equal number of particles uniformly disposed round the whole circumference of the equator , in the fashion of a ring .
The quantity ( 3 co-s .
23~ 29~/ 4 rad .
~ 2/ 5 ~ 1/ 3661/ 4 ~ 360~ ) thus arising , will , therefore , express the true motion of the equinoctial points of a ring , equal in quantity of matter to the excess of the whole earth above the inscribed sphere , when the force whereby the ring tends to turn about its diameter is supposed equal to the force whereby the earth itself tends to turn about the same diameter , in consequence of the sun 's attraction .
Thus far our author agrees with Sir Isaac Newton ; but , in deriving from hence the motion of the equinoctial points of the earth itself , he differs from him ; and , in the corollary to his third Lemma , assigns the reasons , why he thinks Sir Isaac Newton , in this particular , has wandered a little from the truth .
Instead of diminishing the quantity above exhibited ( as Sir Isaac has done ) in the ratio of all the motion in the ring to the motion in the whole earth , he diminishes it in the ratio of the motion of all the matter above the surface of the inscribed sphere to the motion of the whole earth : which matter , tho ' equal to that of the ring , has nevertheless a different momentum , arising from the different situation of the particles in respect to the axis of motion .
But since the aforesaid quantity , from whence the motion of the earth 's equinox is derived , as well by this gentleman , as by Sir Isaac Newton , expresses truly the annual regress of the equinoctial points of the ring ( and not of the hollow figure formed by the said matter , which is greater , in the ratio of 5 to 4 ) it seems , at least , as reasonable to suppose , that the said quantity , to obtain from thence the true regress of the equinoctial points of the earth , ought to be diminished in the former of the two ratios above specified , as that it should be diminished in the latter .
But , indeed , both these ways are defective , even supposing the momenta to have been truly computed ; the ratio , that ought to be used here , being that of the momenta of the ring and earth about the proper axe of rotation of the two figures , standing at right-angles to the plane of the ring and of the equator .
Now this ratio , by a very easy computation , is found to be as 230 2 229 2 to 2/ 5 of 230 2 ; whence the quantity sought comes out =3 co-s .
23~ 29~/ 4 rad .
~ 1/ 3661/ 4 ~ 230 2 229 2/ 2302 ~ 360~ = 21~ 6~ : which is the same that we before found it to be , and the double of what this author makes it .
What has been said hitherto , relates to that part of the motion only , arising from the force of the sun .
It will be but justice to observe here , that the effect of the moon , and the inequalities depending on the position of her nodes , are truly assigned by both the gentlemen above-named ; the ratio of the diameters of the earth , and the density of the moon being so assumed , as to give the maxima of those inequalities , such as the observations require : in consequence whereof , and from the law of the increase and decrease ( which is rightly determined by theory , tho ' the absolute quantity is not ) a true solution , in every other circumstance , is obtained .
The freedom , with which I have expressed myself , and the liberty I have here taken , to animadvert on the works of men , who , in many places , have given incontestible proofs of skill and genius , may , I fear , stand in need of some apology .
It is possible I may be thought too peremptory .
Indeed , I might have delivered my sentiments with more caution and address : but , had not I imagined myself quite clear in what has been advanced , from a multitude of concurrent reasons , I should have thought it too great a presumption to have said any thing at all here , on this subject .
The great regard I have for this Society , of which I have the honour to be a member , will , I hope , be considered as the motive for my having attempted to rectify some oversights , that have occurred in the works of this learned body .

