XXXIII .
Remarks on Dr. Job Baster 's Observationes de Corallinis , &amp;c. printed above , p. 258 .
In a Letter to the Right Honourable George Earl of Macclesfield , President of the R. S. from Mr. John Ellis , F. R. S. My Lord , IHAVE read Dr. Job Baster 's letter to the Royal Society ; wherein he endeavours to prove , that corallines are not of an animal , but a vegetable nature ; and has brought many arguments to support his system ; which , to gentlemen not well acquainted with the subject , may appear plausible .
Read June 9 .
1757 .
I could have wished the Doctor had read and examined thoroughly what has been lately written on the subject : I then should not have had occasion to trouble your Lordship with the following remarks , which I find necessary to support what I have already advanced on that head .
His first argument is , That because he does not find as many polypes in the corallines adhering to ships , flood-gates , and buoys , as in deep water on oysters , muscles , and rocks , therefore he concludes , that corallines are not formed by polypes .
In answer to this , let us examine the pliable structure of these bodies , and how wisely nature has defended such tender substances with a tough thin membranaceous covering , and we shall find , that the sea is calm enough often near the surface to give them time to grow , even in the strongest currents : but , without doubt , they are more liable to be destroyed in such agitated situations , than in the calm depths of the sea .
His second argument is , That finding polypes are not equally dispersed over the whole plant , how can they form it ?
and gives us an example , Tab. VIII .
fig. 5 .
of a coralline , that is encrusted with many other corallines or polypes on the stem , but has none on the branches .
Here we plainly see the mistake : the Doctor looks for the tender part of the polype on the surface of the coralline , considering it as a plant ; and indeed , if this was the case , he ought so to do ; but he never once takes notice of the internal hollow structure of the stem , branches , and denticles of those bodies , to inform us , whether he found an animal in those parts or no. This material point he seems not to have thought on ; which is really the true point in controversy at present among gentlemen , who have not examined these bodies recent in sea-water .
His third argument is , That almost always one and the same coralline plant cherishes polypes of different kinds ; and refers us to Tab. VIII .
fig. 2 .
and 4 .
In fig. 2 .
he gives us an elegant painting of a geniculated red conferva for a coralline , surrounded , as is very common , by many species of small corallines and escharas .
And in fig. 4 .
he gives us a drawing of one of the tubular corallines , with the head of the animal at the top of it ; the stem of this is encrusted with four different corallines and escharas , like the conferva fig. 2 ; and then he asks , which of these five polypes made the tubular coralline ?
To give him some proof of the animal nature of this coralline , let him consult Ray 's Synopsis , ed. 3 .
p. 34 .
n. 4 .
and there he will find one of this species , called adianti aurei minimi facie planta marina , taken notice of so long ago as the year 1713 .
by Dr. Lloyd , as a zoophyte , from its stem or tube 's being full of a thick reddish liquor , rather resembling blood than the juice of a plant ; which , upon pressing the stem , communicated with the little head at top .
His fourth argument is , That as upon one and the same coralline plant you shall find different kind of polypes ; so , in different species of coralline , the same polypes : and , to confirm this , he quotes my Essay on Corallines ; where I have remarked , that the polypes in the denticles of the setaceous or bristly coralline , No. 16 .
appear to be like those , that are on the lobster's-horn coralline , No. 19 .
And to illustrate this , he observes , that bees and wasps always build their cells invariably the same ; and that therefore these two corallines should be the same .
But herein he takes this matter wrong : he has considered , in all his observations , the heads of those parts of the polype , in which are the mouths , arms , or tentacula , which appear coming out of the cups , denticles , and at the ends of the tubes of the corallines , as so many whole and entire animals , without ever observing , that the body of the animal is contained in the tubular part of the root , stem , and branches ; and that these differ from one another widely both in size and shape , as he may plainly see in the two corallines he has instanced : for the more exact drawings of which , I shall refer him , viz. for the setaceous or bristly coralline , to my Plate , No. 38 .
the natural size of which is at fig. 4 .
and the magnified one at fig. D : this he will observe to have a small stem , and its branches disposed in a pinnated form : and for the lobster's-horn coralline , I shall refer him to Tab. xxii .
of Vol. xlviii .
of the Philosophical Transactions ; where , at No. 3 .
the natural size is expressed , and at C the upper part of this coralline is drawn in proportion to the bristly coralline from the same magnifying glass ; which shows the stem to be much larger , and surrounded by its branches growing in whorles at equal distances , not unlike the equisetum , or horse-tail plant ; and yet the heads of this animal nearly resemble the other , only a little larger .
Further , his comparison to bees and wasps , and their cells , is not conclusive : for these ramified , hollow , and denticulated bodies , called corallines , which we so frequently find dead on our shores , are properly skins of certain marine polypes , and not nests , as those constructed by these little winged animals are .
And yet we find as great a regularity in the same species of these corallines , as when we compare two oak trees to one another , or two of Mr. Trembley 's branched fresh-water polypes to one another .
He then proceeds to his fifth argument , That if corallines were formed by polypes , neither the polypes , nor even their cells , would ever fix on living animals , or any other bodies .
Here we may observe , that the consequence he draws doth not follow : for corallines may be formed or produced by certain species of polypes , and yet polypes of another species may be found adhering to other bodies , and even to animal bodies .
By his sixth argument he endeavours to prove , That the vesicles , which are found in regular rows on the sea-fir coralline in winter , Tab. VIII .
fig. 6 .
do not belong to it ; and are no more than the eggs of some sea insect deposited on it , of which there may be a great variety .
But to convince him of his mistake , let him take off one of the vesicles , and apply a large magnifier to the place , and he will discover a hole , by which this vesicle or ovary has had a communication thro ' the skin with the parent polype .
For a further illustration of the manner in which these vesiculated polypes breed , let him consult the 38th Plate of my Essay , where he will find several accurate figures ( drawn by Mr. Ehret from the life ) of these vesicles , with the spawn of the polypes coming out of them ; some of which spawn we evidently discovered to be young polypes with their arms formed ; and , as they fell from the vesicle , extending themselves in the watchglass of sea-water .
In examining the drawings for his plates , I have observed , that Tab. VII .
fig. 2 .
is evidently a red conserva , which he calls a coralline .
We have no corallines , but many confervas , of this form and bright red colour on our coasts ; and these shores , I believe , are allowed to have similar marine productions with those of Holland .
Tab. VII .
fig. 5 .
he calls a branch of red coralline , which he says he kept several weeks in sea-water , and that often changed ; during which time it sprouted and grew very much .
This experiment , I am persuaded , is very true ; because it is plainly a vegetable , as appears from his own exact drawing of it ; and seems to be the fucus teres rubens minus in longum protensus of Ray 's Synopsis , ed. 3 .
p. 51 .
N. 53 .
This is one of his principal arguments to prove the vegetation of corallines .
Tab. VIII .
fig. 1 .
he calls a branch of red coralline ; and at fig. 2 .
he has it magnified , where it appears to be a geniculated red conferva , drawn and painted with great exactness .
These arguments , my Lord , and these figures of real vegetables , which the Doctor has given us for corallines , show , how much he is willing to support the old opinion of the botanists : but I am satisfied he will soon alter his opinion , when he observes the remarkable difference of the texture of vegetable and coralline bodies , when viewed in sea-water thro ' a good aquatic microscope .
And to convince him more fully , that corallines are an animal substance , let him burn them , and he will perceive the same pungent volatile alkaline smell , which he finds in burning horn , hair , or oysters ; whereas burnt fucus 's and confervas yield a smell not much unlike that of common land vegetables .
Even the stony corallines , when their cretaceous covering has been dissolved in vinegar , the membranous part , that remains of them , put into the fire , yields the same animal smell with other corallines .
Further , since I find the Doctor has promised the Royal Society to continue his researches at the seaside , the following hints may be of use to him .
And , first , he will find , that those he seems to think naked polypes , which he found adhering to corallines and other bodies , are really small corallines and escharas , with their proper skins and cells ; all which I have particularly described already .
I would then recommend him to examine such corallines as are taken out of the deepest water , which are found adhering to shells and fucus 's .
He will find Mr. Cuff 's aquatic microscope , or one of that form , the most commodious for observing these animals alive .
The most transparent ones he will find the best to discover their gelatinous inside , which runs thro ' the stem and ramifications , and ends in the heads , where the claws are .
Some of the best kinds to observe are as follows : The sea-oak coralline , the lilyflowering coralline , the great tooth coralline , the sea-thread coralline , and the branched tubular coralline .
Pieces of these should be cut off while they are in the sea water , and placed in watch-glasses full of the same : in these they should remain a while , till they recover themselves ; and when they are placed on the stage of the microscope , the motion of the internal part communicating with the heads will be easily discovered .
If the Doctor will immerse some of these corallines , when they are extended , in two thirds of spirit of wine and one third of clear sea-water , it will preserve them many years , as I have experienced .
He may then put the different sorts into distinct phials , and view them at pleasure with a lens of about one inch and half focus .
In fine , my Lord , opportunities so seldom offer at the sea-side to make these experiments with accuracy ; add likewise to this , the strong lines of vegetation that these bodies carry in their appearance , and your Lordship will not be surprised , that there are so many gentlemen , even of the Royal Society , that totally disbelieve them to be animals .
Many there are in the Society , that are wavering between both opinions .
If then , my Lord , you think , that any specimens which I have , or any demonstrations tending to clear up this point , that lie in my power , will be acceptable to your Lordship and the Society , your Lordship may freely command them , whenever you think proper , from London , June 9 .
1757 .
Your LORDSHI P'S Much obliged and most obedient Servant , John Ellis .

