XXX .
Remarks on the Opinion of Henry Eels , Esq ; concerning the Ascent of Vapour , published in the Philosoph. Transact. Vol. xlix .
Part i. p. 124 .
By Erasmus Darwin , M. D. Communicated by Mr. William Watson , F. R. S. To Mr. William Watson , F. R. S. SIR , THE enclosed papers were designed for the perusal of the Royal Soeiety ; being an endeavour to confute the opinion of Mr. Eels about the ascent of vapours , published in the last volume of their Transactions .
But the author , having no electrical friend , whose sagacity he could confide in , has at length prevailed upon himself to be so free to send them to Mr. Watson ; to whom the world is so much indebted for the advancement of their knowlege in electricity .
Whence , Sir , if you should think , that these papers have truth , the great Diana of real philosophers , to patronize them , you will confer a favour upon me , by laying them before that learned Body .
If , on the contrary , you should deem this confutation trifling or or futil , I hope you will be humane enough to suppress them , and give me your objections ; and by that means lay a still greater obligation on one , who has not the pleasure to be personally acquainted with you .
From , March 23 .
1757 .
SIR , Your very humble Servant , Erasmus Darwin , Physician at Litchfield , Staffordshire .
LETTER I. To the very honourable and learned the PRESIDENT and MEMBERS of the Royal Society .
Gentlemen , THERE is ever such a charm attendant upon novelty , that be it in philosophy , medicine , or religion , the gazing world are too often led to adore , what they ought only to admire : whilst this vehemence of enthusiasm has generally soon rendered that object contemptible , that would otherwise have long laid claim to a more sober esteem .
This was once the fate of chemistry : the vain and pompous boasts of her adepts brought the whole art into disrespect ; and I should be sorry , if her sister electricity should share the same misfortunes .
It is hence the ingenious Mr. Eels will excuse me , for endeavouring to lay before you my opinion on the ascent of vapours , tho ' it by no means coincides with that he is so strenuous to establish , and plucks a plume from his idol goddess electricity .
VO L. 50 .
Ii The Read May 5 .
The probability , supporting the hypothesis of Mr. Eels , according to his own expressions , rests on this : That every particle of vapour is endued with a portion of electric fire ; and that there is no other sufficient cause assigned for their ascending .
' ' ( Phil. Trans. vol. xlix .
part .
i. p. 134 .
) .
My design is therefore first to attempt to show , that another theory , founded on principles better known , will sufficiently explain the ascent of vapours : and then , that some kinds of vapours are not endued with a more or less than their natural share of electric aether .
The immense rarefaction of explosive bodies by heat , depends either on the escape of air before condensed in them , or on the expansion of the constituent parts of those bodies .
This distinction has not been sufficiently considered by any one to my knowledge ; nor shall I at present amuse the Society upon this head ; it being enough for my present purpose to observe , that they may be thus distinguished : where air is emitted , it cannot be condensed again into the same bulk by cold ; but the expansion of heated parts of bodies , as soon as that heat is withdrawn , ceases to exist .
Nitre comes under the first of these classes : in detonation it emits great quantities of air , not afterwards condensible to the like space .
This may be seen by firing a few grains of gunpowder in an unblown bladder , or in a vessel nearly full of water with its mouth inverted .
The same is true of all the solid parts of animals and vegetables , when subjected to fire ; as appears from the experiments of that learned philanthropist , Dr. Hales .
But of water the contrary is evident .
In the steamengine , engine , a jet of cold water , we find , instantly condenses that immense rarefaction ; which I apprehend could not be , if it was constituted of escaped elastic air .
And altho ' this steam must be acknowledged to put on some properties of air ; such as ventilating a fire ; or that a taper blown out by it , is capable of being again lighted immediately , and that without a crackling noise , which occurs when touched with water ; this does not in the least invalidate our opinion , tho ' it has certainly conduced very much to propagate the former one : since from this way of reasoning , the whole must be air , and we should have no water at all in vapour .
From considering this power of expansion , which the constituent parts of some bodies acquire by heat ; and withal , that some bodies have a greater affinity to heat , that is , acquire it sooner and retain it longer than others ; which affinity appears from experiments , and which , I apprehend , is in some ratio of their specific gravities and their powers of refraction , reflexion , or absorption of light ; or at least in some ratio much greater than that of their specific gravities alone .
From considering these , I say , many things , before utterly inexplicable , became easily understood by me .
Such as , Why when bismuth and zinc are fused together , and set to cool , the zinc , which is specifically heavier , is found above the bismuth ?
Why the buff covering of inflammatory blood , the skum of heated milk , the sedative salt of borax , which are all specifically heavier than the liquids in which they are formed , are still formed at the surface of them ?
How benzoin , sulphur , and even the ponderous body mercury , may be raised into vapour , again to be condensed unaltered ?
And , lastly , how water , whose parts appear from the aeolipile to be capable of immeasurable expansion , should by heat alone become specifically lighter than the common atmosphere , without having recourse to a shell enclosing air , or other assistant machinery ?
and when raised , I am persuaded we shall find , that to support them floating , perhaps many days , in the atmosphere , is not a knot so intricate , as to oblige us to conjure up a new divinity to unravel it .
But before we proceed to this second part of our task , it will be necessary previously to consider first , how small a degree of heat is required to detach or raise the vapour of water from its parent-fluid .
In the coldest day , I might say the coldest night , of winter , when the weather is not frosty or very damp , wet linen or paper will become dry in the course of a few hours .
A greater degree of heat must indeed cause a quicker evaporation .
But I am persuaded , that was it not for the pressure of the superincumbent fluid , greatly less than that of boiling water would instantly disperse the whole so heated into vapour .
Secondly , That in the opinion of Sir Isaac Newton , well illustrated by the late lamented Mr. Melvil , the sun-beams appear only to communicate heat to bodies by which they are refracted , reflected , or obstructed ; whence , by their impulse , a reaction or vibration is caused in the parts of such impacted bodies .
This is supported by the experiment of approaching some light body , or blowing smoke near the focus of the largest glasses ; and from observing , that these do not ascend , it is evident the air is not so much as warmed by the passage of those beams thro ' it , yet would instantly calcine or vitrify every opake body in nature .
And from this we may collect , that transparent bodies are only heated at their surfaces , and that perhaps in proportion to their quantity of refraction : which will further give and receive illustration from those very curious experiments , of producing cold by the evaporation of liquors , published by the learned Dr. Cullen , in the late volume of Essays Physical and Literary , at Edinburgh .
In these experiments a spirit-thermometer was immersed in spirit of wine , and being suddenly retracted , was again exposed to the air ; and as the spirit of wine adhering to the glass evaporated , the spirit contained within the thermometer was observed to subside .
Now as the difference of the refraction of spirit of wine and glass is exceedingly minute , compared with the difference of refraction of spirit of wine and air ; we may consider , in the above experiment , the heat to be communicated to the thermometer only at its surface : but here the adherent fluid escapes as soon as heated ; by which means the glass , and its contents , are deprived of that constant addition of heat , which other bodies perpetually enjoy either from the sun-beams immediately , or from the emanations of other contiguous warmer bodies ; and must thence , in a few minutes , become colder than before .
The ingenious Mr. Eels , I dare say , has already foreseen the use I am going to make of this principle ; viz. ` ` That the little spherules of vapour will thus , by refracting the solar rays , acquire a constant heat , tho ' the surrounding atmosphere remain cold .
' ' And as from the minuteness of their diameters , if they are allowed to be globules , they must do this to a very great degree , I apprehend none of those objections will take place against us , with which Mr. Eels has so sensibly confuted the former received theories on this subject .
If we are asked , how clouds come to be supported in the absence of the sun ?
it must be remembered , that large masses of vapour must for a considerable time retain much of the heat they have acquired in the day ; at the same time reflecting , how small a quantity of heat was necessary to raise them ; and that doubtless even a less will be sufficient to support them , as from the diminished pressure of the atmosphere at a given height , a less power may be able to continue them in their present state of rarefaction ; and , lastly , that clouds of particular shapes will be sustained or elevated by the motion they acquire from winds .
I should here have concluded this paper , perhaps already too long ; but upon revising it , I find , where the affinity of some bodies with heat is mentioned , that the deductions made from thence are not sufficiently explained to be intelligible .
First then , If the power of expansion of any two bodies , by heat , be in a greater proportion than their specific gravities , then will there be a certain degree of heat , in which their specific gravities will be equal ; and another , in which the gravity of that , which was lighter when cold , will exceed the gravity of that , which was heavier when cold .
Hence zinc and bismuth alter their specific gravities in fusion ; some urine , and many solutions of solids , grow turbid as they cool ; others alter their colours .
Secondly , If ( the power of expansion by heat being equal ) the power of retaining taining heat be in a greater ratio than the specific gravities ; then , during the time of cooling after being sufficiently heated , there will be an instant , when the heavier body will become the lighter , and swim upon the other .
This seems the case in the buff covering of inflamed blood , the skum of heated milk , and the cristallization of some salts : for if these effects were from the evaporation of the thinner parts at the surface , they should happen during the greatest evaporation , or when boiling ; but , on the contrary , they are all done in the greatest degree when the liquor has for some time began to cool .
Lastly , If the quickness of acquiring heat be in a greater proportion than their specific gravities ( the power of expansion being equal ) , then , during the time of their acquiring heat , there will be an instant , when the body , that was heavier when cold , will now become the lighter .
From one or more of which principles , I apprehend , the volatility or fixity of all minerals , and many other bodies , takes its origin .
It is no part of my design to account to you , gentlemen , in what manner such an expansion of the parts of bodies can be brought about by the action of fire .
Tho ' perhaps a rotatory motion only of each particle on its own center might be sufficient to produce such a rarefaction ; and the more so , if such parts were any other figures than spheres , as by the percussion of their angles they must result further from each other .
Nor is the existence of such a rotatory motion without some probability , when we observe the verticillary motion given to charcoal-dust thrown on nitre in fusion , or the wonderful agitation of the parts of burning phosphorus , or even of a common red letter-wafer touched by the flame of a candle .
But as in this paper I have laboured ( and I hope not without success ) to show you , that some properties of solar heat are sufficient to account for the elevation and support of vapours ; so in another letter I propose nearly to demonstrate to you , that the electric aether is far from having any share in the production of this important phenomenon .
From , Litchfield , Mar. 20 .
1757 .
GENTLEMEN , Your very humble Servant , Erasmus Darwin .
LETTER II .
To the very honourable and learned the PRESIDENT and MEMBERS of the Royal Society .
Gentlemen , EVERY theoretical inquiry , whose basis does not rest upon experiments , is at once exploded in this well-thinking age ; where truth , under your patronage , has at length broke thro ' those clouds , with which superstition , policy , or parade , had overwhelmed her .
But experiments themselves , gentlemen , are not exempted from fallacy .
A strong inventive faculty , a fine mechanic hand , a clear unbiased judgment , are at once required for the contrivance , conduct , and application , of experiments ; and even where these are joined ( such Read May 5 , ( such is the condition of humanity !
) error too frequently intrudes herself , and spoils the work .
My very respectable antagonist , Mr. Eels , to whose ear , I am convinced , the voice of truth is more agreeable than that of applause , will forgive me the following critique on his performance ; as by that means , I am persuaded , the probability of his notions will be entirely destroyed , and the foregoing theory receive additional supports .
For this purpose our first endeavour will be to show the uncertainty of some of the most material principles , that support his arguments ; and afterwards , the fallacy of the experiments he has given us .
First then , in page 130 .
Mr. Eels has asserted , that the greatest possible rarefaction of water is when it boils .
I think it might be said , with equal propriety , that the greatest rarefaction of solids was when they began to melt : and this may indeed be verbally true , if we chuse to alter the names of bodies , when they undergo any alteration by fire : so solids take the name of fluids , when they are in fusion ; and water the name of vapour , when it is greatly rarefied in the steam-engine .
Whence we find this assertion seems to be founded on a confusion in terms , and the fact far from being existent in nature .
In page 133 .
the sphere of electrical activity is said to be increased by heat .
If by electrical activity is here meant an increase of its repulsive power ( the thing , which seems to be wanted in Mr. Eeles 's hypothesis ) , I know no experiment to show it .
If it be meant , that it is capable of being attracted to a greater distance ; I conjecture it may , as the heat will rarefy the ambient air , and we know the electric aether is attracted at very great distances in vacuo ; but this cannot properly be called an increased activity of electric fire .
We are afterwards told ( page ib. ) ` ` that electric fire will not mix with air : ' ' whence , in the succeeding section , it is argued , ` ` That as each particle of vapour , with its surrounding electric fluid , will occupy a greater space than the same weight of air , they will ascend .
' ' In answer to this , it must be observed , that there are some bodies , whose parts are fine enough to penetrate the pores of other bodies , without increasing their bulk ; or to pass thro ' them , without apparently moving or disturbing them .
A certain proportion of alcohol of wine mixed with water , and of copper and tin in fusion , are instances of the first of these ; the existence and passage of light thro ' air , and , I am persuaded , of electric fire , are instances of the second .
To illustrate this , the following experiment was instituted .
A glass tube , open at one end , and with a bulb at the other , had its bulb , and half way from thence to the aperture of the tube , coated on the inside with gilt paper .
The tube was then inverted in a glass of oil of turpentine , which was placed on a cake of wax , and the tube kept in that perpendicular situation by a silk line from the ceiling of the room .
The bulb was then warmed , so that , when it became cold , the turpentine rose about half-way up the tube .
A bent wire then being introduced thro ' the oil into the air above , high electricity was given .
The oil did not appear at all to subside : whence I conclude , the electric atmosphere flowing round the wire and coating of the tube above the oil , did not displace the air , but existed in its pores .
This experiment I formerly tried various ways , as I had conceived , if the electric matter would displace air , it might have been applied to answer the end of steam in the steam-engine , and many other great mechanical purposes .
But as from the above it appears , that the contrary is true , it is evident , that electric matter surrounding particles of vapour must , in fact , increase their specific gravity , and cannot any-ways be imagined to facilitate their ascent .
I may add further , that if this be true , that it pervades the pores of air , its specific levity cannot , by any means I know , be compared with that of air .
Its particular attraction to some bodies , at least to much the greater part of the terraqueous globe , is abundantly greater than that of air to those bodies : and hence its gravitation to the whole globe would appear , at first view , to exceed that of air .
But the more I consider this , the more perplexing and amazing it appears to me : and thence must leave it to the investigation of my very ingenious antagonist , or some other able philosopher .
I come now to the experiments , that are given us to show all vapour to be electrised .
In these Mr. Eels seems to have been led into error , by not having observed , that many bodies electrised will retain that electricity for some time , altho ' in contact with conductors .
The Leyden phial may be touched three or four times by a quick finger before the whole is discharged .
Almost all light dry animal or vegetable substances , such as feathers and cork , do this in a much greater degree : and in general I have observed , the more slow any bodies are to acquire electricity , the more avaricious they are to keep it .
Part of the plume of a feather , hanging to a green line of silk about a foot long , which was suspended from the midst of an horizontal line of the same , about four yards in length , was electrised with a dry wine-glass , according to the method of Mr. Eels ; and , after being touched nine times with my finger , at the intervals of two seconds of time , still manifested signs of electricity , by being attracted at the tenth approach of it .
A cork ball , on the same line and circumstances , after being electrised , was touched at the intervals of ten seconds repeatedly , for seven times , before it was exhausted .
The fumes of boiling water were conveyed upon this ball after being electrised ; and , after a fumigation for thirty seconds , it showed signs of electricity , by being attracted to the approaching finger ; and , after thirty seconds more , without any fumigation , it again obeyed the finger ; and again , after thirty more , but at less and less distances .
The same appearances occurred to me from the fumes of resin .
From whence I apprehend , that Mr. Eels , having dipped the electrised down of the juncus bombycinus in vapour for perhaps half a minute ( for no time is mentioned ) , and finding it still retained its electric attraction , was not aware , that this same had happened , if he had by intervals touched it with his finger , or any other known conductor of electricity .
As Mr. Eels had here objected , that there was no real opposition in the electric aether of glass , and that from wax ; the common experiment to show this was many times repeated with constant success ; viz. the cork ball , suspended as above , after being electrised by the wine-glass , and repelled from it , was strongly attracted by a rubbed stick of sealing-wax ; and vice versa .
In the same manner I observed the electric aether from a black silk stocking ( which was held horizontally extended by the top and foot , and , being rubbed in the midst with an iron poker , was applied to the cork ball ) , to be similar to that of glass , and opposite to that of wax .
But the following experiment appears to me to put this matter out of all doubt , and to demonstrate , that this difference is only a plus and minus of the same specific aether , and not different qualities of it , as Mr. Eels would suppose .
A stick of dry sealing-wax was rubbed on the side of a dry wine-glass , and a cork ball , suspended as in the former experiments , played for some time between them : but glass rubbed with glass , or wax with wax , did not manifest any electric appearance .
Whence it would appear , that in rubbing glass and wax together , the glass accumulated on its surface the identical aether that the wax lost .
Nor is this a digression from my design : for if this opposition of the electricity of glass and wax be established , it still contributes to demonstrate the fallacy of Mr. Eeles 's experiments .
But what alone would entirely destroy this electric hypothesis , is , that from the experiments of Mr. Franklin and others , the clouds are sometimes found to be electrised plus , sometimes minus , and sometimes manifest no signs of electricity at all .
Whence to say an accumulation of electric aether supports these clouds , seems an assertion built upon a very unstable foundation , whose whole superstructure may well enough be termed an air-built castle , the baseless fabric of a vision .
Add to this , that Mr. Eels , in page 140 .
tells us , that himself has passed thro ' clouds resting on the sides of mountains .
Ought not those clouds to have immediately discharged their electricity , and fallen ?
And common experience may remind us , that any cold bodies will condense vapour , whatever be their electric properties .
So mirrors , or the glass of windows , in damp rooms , are most frequently found covered with dew ; which , of all other bodies , ought most to be exempted from collecting vapours supported by electricity , as they are the least capable to attract or draw off that aether .
From all which , well examined , I am persuaded , gentlemen , you will be induced to conclude , that tho ' clouds may sometimes possess an accumulation of electricity , yet that this is only an accidental circumstance , and not a constant one ; and thence can have no possible influence either in the elevation or support of them .
I am , GENTLEMEN , Your very humble Servant , Erasmus Darwin .
Litchfield , March 23 .
1757 .

