XXVIII .
An Account of the Impressions of Plants on the Slates of Coals : In a Letter to the Right Honourable George Earl of Macclesfield , President of the R. S. from Mr. Emanuel Mends da Costa , F. R. S. My Lord , I Have the honour to address this letter to your Lordship , in order to be communicated to the Royal Society , if your Lordship deems it worthy the attention of that learned and illustrious assembly .
Read April 28 , 1757 .
The impressions of various kinds of plants are frequently , I might say always , found in some of the strata lying over coal ; but more particularly in a stratum of earthy slat , which , in my History of Fossils , page 168 .
Species IV .
I have synonymed Schistus terrestris niger carbonarius , and which always lies immediately upon the coal-stratum , not only in the coal-pits of this kingdom , but of many other parts of Europe , e. g. France , Saxony , Bohemia , Silesia , &amp;c. Most of these impressions , my Lord , are of the herbae capillares et affines , the gramineous , and the reed tribes : but , however , among them many rare and beautiful impressions undoubtedly of vegetable origin , and impressed by plants hitherto unknown to botanists , are not unfrequently met with .
Besides these , my Lord , found over coal-pits , there are likewise found in some parts of this kingdom , as at Robinhood's-bay in Yorkshire , Coalbrookdale Fig. 2 .
Fig. 3 .
Fig. 7 .
Philos. Trans. Vol. L. TAB.v.p .
229 .
Fig. 1 .
Fig. 4 .
Fig. 5 .
in Shropshire , &amp;c. many curious impressions of the fern tribe in regular nodules of iron-stone ; and , in the latter place , not only impressions of plants , but even the cones or iuli of some kinds of trees are met with , very perfect and fair , and curiously imbedded in masses of iron-stone .
The most part of the impressions of ferns , grasses , &amp;c. are easily recognizable , they so minutely tally to the plants they represent .
Others indeed , tho ' they do not exactly answer any known species , yet have characters so distinctly expressed , that they are easily arranged under their respective genera ( I ) .
Therefore I shall not trouble your Lordship with any further remarks on all such , but shall only touch on those elegant and extraordinary impressions , probably of unknown vegetables , above-mentioned : for that they are the parts and impressions of vegetables , I think clearly evinced , if we attentively and with a philosophical mind consider them , and reflect on the various circumstances , which attend them in the places , where they now lie buried .
I have therefore the honour , my Lord , to exhibit the drawings of seven such extraordinary impressions , and the fossiles themselves , for your Lordship 's and this learned body 's inspection ( See TAB. V. ) .
The impression figured N~ .
I~ is from Mr. Mytton~ 's collieries at Drilt , near Oswestry , in Shropshire ; ~as are also those figured N~ .
2 , 4 , and 7 : they are found ~ The celebrated Dr. Scheuchzer has arranged the fossile plants botanically , by Tournefort 's system , in his folio work , entitled , Herbarium Diluvianum ; and Dr. Woodwand 's ~ plants , Catalogue B , he informs us , were botanically considered and arranged by those famous botanists'Dr .
Plukenet , and Mess .
~Doody , Buddle , and ~ .
sometimes two feet in length , and are generally covered with a thin crust of coal .
The specimina Dr. Woodward exhibits , Catalogue B , pages 106 , 107 .
specimina q. 22 .
and q. 32 .
are analogous to this , tho ' not exactly the same .
The Doctor 's fossiles were from Haigh in Lancashire ; and he imagines the impressions to be made by vegetables of the fir kind .
Volckman also , in his Silesia subterranea , tab .
22 .
fig. 2 .
figures a branch with a rhomboidal work on it , and with three long narrow leaves , which seems akin to this impression .
N~ .
2 .
seems of the reed tribe : the knobs placed in rows , which are like the vesicles on the quercus marina , and some other algae , are very remarkable .
Woodward , Catalogue B. page 9 .
specimen a. I. exhibits an impression akin to this , which he imagines to be of the fern kind .
N~ .
3 .
from a coal-pit in Yorkshire .
I cannot but think this impression is owing to somewhat of the fir kind .
Dr. Woodward , who exhibits such a like impression , Catalogue B. p. 16 .
specimen a. 108 .
imagines the same : his words are , ` ` The impression is much like what might be made by the branches of the common fir , after the leaves are fallen or stripped off .
' ' N~ .
4 .
seems to be of the same kind as N~ .
2 .
N~ .
5 .
This extraordinary impression is from Mostyn-colliery in Flintshire .
It is a little obscured ; but , when attentively viewed , exhibits a reticular impression , the meshes whereof are rhomboidal hollows , and the sides of the rhombs , or the net-work , are raised , or in relief .
N~ .
6 .
is from Newcastle .
Volckman , ibid. part 3 .
tab .
4 .
fig. 9 .
seems to be of this kind .
No. 7 .
The same author , Volckman , figures a somewhat-like impression , ibid. fig. 5 .
Only these seven extraordinary impressions I have presumed , my Lord , to treat of at this present time ; but I have many more in my cabinet equally curious , some few of which I here exhibit to the Society , without taking any further notice of them : only I shall add , that many extraordinary impressions occur in Woodward 's and other collections , and many are iconed in authors , worthy the attention of the curious .
These impressions , my Lord , are not only met with in small pieces ; but large evident branches , some feet in length , have been found .
I have , in the collieries of Derbyshire , frequently traced branches with ( what seemed to me ) long narrow leaves proceeding from them , and parts of other vegetables , above a foot 's length : but the hardness of the substance they are immersed in renders it impossible to get them out without breaking them to pieces ( 2 ) .
As these remains of vegetables are very extraordinary , I would recommend to the curious in botany to take notice of them , as an Appendix Plantarum adhuc incognitarum .
For my part , I am so very little skilled in botany , that I hardly presume to offer my opinion ; which is , that they are impressions and parts of species of the firs and pines , of the tithymals , the cereus 's , and other arborescent plants , and of large reeds ; for some of the said ( 2 ) Woodward , Catalogue B. p. 104 .
specimen q. I. was of 6 I-half feet in length ; and Catalogue D. p. 60 .
specimen h. 38 .
was a yard long ; et alibi passim .
In the collieries at Swanvich in Derbyshire , in 1752 .
a plant of the cane kind was found 14 feet long : it ended in a point at one end , and at the root in a large knob , and in the middle measured nine inches about .
kind are embellished with ribbed , studded , and reticulated works ; e. g. the Hercules ' club , or rubi facie senticosa planta Lobelii , described by Dr. Grew , Museum Reg. Soc. p. 221 .
the cerei , &amp;c. I further exhibit to the Society some few specimina of iron-stones with cones or iuli imbedded in them .
These , my Lord , are from veins of ball iron-stone , in the lands of Lord Gower , at Okenyate , a village on the Roman road of Watling-street ; and from the iron-works at Coalbrookdale in Shropshire .
The cones are frequently met with in fragments , but rarely so entire , and are never found but in the strata of iron-stone .
I have added to these a figured fossile body , much like a cone , found sometimes in our chalk-pits in England , but chiefly in the pits at Cherry-Hinton in Cambridgeshire .
Dr. Woodward , Catalogue B. p. 22 .
specimen b. 72 .
calls them cones seeming to be of the larix ; and imagines they were not come to ripeness or maturity .
They certainly have some resemblance to cones , tho ' I much doubt them to be so ; but they most exactly resemble the roots of the cyperus rotundus vulgaris of botanists .
I shall finish this paper , my Lord , by acquainting your Lordship and Society , that I firmly believe these bodies to be of the vegetable origin , buried in the strata of the earth at the time of the universal deluge recorded by Moses .
It is , I must confess , with regret , that I find there are some , who reject the burial of these bodies at that fatal catastrophe , but substitute partial deluges to account for it .
Did those gentlemen consider , or maturely weigh , the many remarkable and strong evidences of an universal deluge , every-where obvious in the bowels of the earth , they certainly would abandon their imaginary system : for , my Lord , it is not only the immense quantities of marine remains , dispersed in all terrestrial strata , which are to be considered ( that circumstance alone might give some reasoning to their system of partial deluges ) , but the following more weighty circumstances are likewise to be added and flung into the scale .
1~ .
The heavings , displacings , trappings , and breaks of the metallic veins , and the loads of rubble , met with at vast depths , and where no marine remains were ever found ; and such heavings , &amp;c. are not rare in metallic or mineral works : of which , to give your Lordship an idea , I have presumed to sketch the following plan of such a phenomenon .
N The cross-load , which heaves or displaces the metallic load .
S E The metallic load .
The metallic load .
W These cross-loads are not unfrequent in the mines on North Downs , near Redruth , in Cornwall .
Wheal-Widden copperwork there , in 1750 , was about 60 fathom deep .
The load was 20 feet over ; and has many cross-loads two or three feet over , which sometimes heave the metallic load from one to five or six fathom .
These cross-loads are generally filled with fragments of stone , minerals , and other rubble .
2 .
If these effects proceed from local deluges , recedings of the sea , gulphs atterrated , &amp;c. we should then indeed find marine remains : but how will that account for the vast quantity of remains of terrestrial vegetables and animals , equally met with , and in like manner as the marine remains , in the bowels of the earth ?
And , 3~ .
Were local or partial deluges the cause , we should then find only the animals and plants of the climates or places , where such deluges have happened ; whereas in these fossile remains it is quite the contrary : the remains of those plants and animals , we know , are of animals and plants , the inhabitants of the most remote climes from those , where they now lie buried ; e. g. the rhinocerosbones , in the cave called Baumans-hole , in the Hartz Forest in Germany ; the strange bones in the Antra Draconum in Hungary ; the horns of the moosedeer , and other prodigious horns , and elephants bones , found in England , Ireland , Germany , Sibiria , and even America , &amp;c. of vegetables , parts of the arbor tristis in France ; bamboo 's , or great Indian reeds , frequent in England ; with numbers of other such examples .
And of those remains even of the marine shells , yet unknown to us , all appear exotic to the climes where they now lie deposited ; e. g. the cliffs at Harwich in Essex abound with a species of buccinum heterostrophum , and other shells , never yet discovered in the adjacent waters .
The ammonitae of so many species , and the innumerable variety of conchae anomiae , with which this island abounds , are yet unknown to be inhabitants of our seas , and appear exotic to this climate .
Therefore , my Lord , I reasonably conclude partial or local deluges could never have produced such effects .
However , unprejudiced to any opinion , if the learned , who favour the system of partial deluges , will either confute these my assertions , or give solid reasons for the facts alleged to be producible by local deluges , atterrations , &amp;c. I will joyfully embrace the truth : but till then , my Lord , I would recommend to those systematical gentlemen , not to pervert that excellent maxim of the great Lord Bacon , and , instead of Non fingendum neque excogitandum , sed inveniendum quid natura faciat , aut ferat , not to corrupt it into singendum atque excogitandum , non inveniendum quid natura faciat , aut ferat .
I am , with great submission and respect , MYLOR D , Your Lordship 's Most devoted , and most obliged , London , 27 April , 1757 .
humble Servant , Emanuel Mends da Costa .

