XXVII .
An Account of the Virtues of Soap in dissolving the Stone , in the Case of the Rev. Mr. Matthew Simson .
Communicated by John Pringle , M. D. F. R. S. To the Rev. Tho. Birch , D. D. F. R. S. SIR , A Few days ago I received from Dr. Austin , physician at Edinburgh , the case of the Rev. Mr. Simson , drawn up by himself , in the form of a letter to Dr. Austin ; and which you may remember was alluded to by Dr. Whytt , in the paper read at the last meeting of the Society .
Read April 28 , 1757 .
As I am at liberty to communicate this account to others , I thought it would not be unacceptable to the gentlemen of the Society , to have another wellattested instance laid before them of the virtues of soap in dissolving the stone , or , at least , in removing all those painful symptoms , which usually accompany that distemper .
To the patient 's own narration I have subjoined an extract from Dr. Austin 's letter to me , containing the sequel of the case from the date of Mr. Simson 's letter to his death ; with an account of the state of his bladder , as it appeared to Dr. Austin upon dissection .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient humble Servant , John Pringle .
Pall-Mall , 27 April , 1757 .
A Letter from the Rev. Mr. Simson , Minister at Pencaitland , to Dr. Adam Austin , Physician in Edinburgh .
Dear Sir , ACcording to your desire , I send you the history of my case ; which is as follows : Read April 28 .
1757 .
I was of an healthy constitution till the year 1730 , when I was seized with a frequent inclination to make water , without any previous pain in the kidneys or ureters .
This symptom continued till the year 1733 , without giving me much uneasiness .
In June 1733 , as I was riding from Edinburgh to my own house at Pencaitland , I was seized with a great difficulty and pain in making water , which went off when I got home .
In the month of July , having again got on horseback , I was seized with the same complaint , but more violent ; for then some drops of blood came away .
From this time , if I rode eight or ten miles , I passed some blood , but without pain .
In September I made a journey of 60 miles on horseback ; but every two miles was obliged to dismount , and made some bloody water .
I continued much in the same way all the year 1734 , as the preceding ; only had one additional complaint , of a pain in the glans after making water , and likewise in the neck of the bladder .
The only thing I did for it was , to drink plentifully of warm milk and water ; and gave over riding , on account of the bloody urine .
In the month of August I was sounded by my nephew , Dr. Simson , professor of medicine in the university of St. Andrew 's ; but he found no stone , which he attributed to a wrong posture I was in , when he sounded me .
During the winter , if I walked more than usual , I was sure to have a return of the bloody urine and strangury .
In November 1735 , I was sounded by Mr. Balderstone , surgeon , in Edinburgh , a gentleman very expert in that operation , and likewise by Dr. Drummond of Perthshire .
They both distinctly felt a stone : and I myself took hold of the catheter , when it was in my bladder , and felt the stone as distinctly , as if it had been in my hand .
~ About Christmas I was seized with a pain along the left ureter , and violent vomitings ; but , upon using a turpentine clyster and opiates , it went off .
During the year 1736 , I continued much the same as the preceding year , always drinking great plenty of milk and water ; which gave me great relief , as to the bloody urine .
I was advised by my nephew , Dr. Simson , to go to London , and be cut by Mr. Cheselden ; the rest of my friends advising me to be cut by Mr. Smith , a lithotomist at Perth .
However , I deferred the operation , and continued much the same all the year 1737 , having severe fits now and then .
In the year 1738 Sir Alexander Gibson , of Addiston , informed me , that he had been in my condition~ , had passed several small stones , and had found incredible service from the use of soap pills : for , from not being able to get out of bed , in the space of two months after using the soap he was able to go a hunting .
However , for some time I was afraid to try the soap , not knowing what effects it might have on a confirmed stone ; Sir Alexander Gibson 's case being only that of small stones .
But the Rev. Mr. Lundie , of Salton , by experiments convinced me of the efficacy of soap in dissolving a confirmed stone out of the bladder ; for the stone gradually grew smoother and smoother , and at last was quite dissolved .
On the 12th of February 1739 , I first began the use of the soap , and in the beginning took only a drachm in the 24 hours .
The first week it made me a little qualmish : however , I gradually increased the dose ; so that in six weeks I took six drachms a day , without its disagreeing in the least with me .
I made it up into pills , and washed them down with a draught of warm milk and water .
From the time I began to use the soap , my gravelish symptoms gradually abated ; but , upon walking two or three miles , I made bloody urine .
However , that symptom gradually abated ; and in the year 1743 all the symptoms of a stone quite vanished , insomuch that I could walk , ride , or go in a machine , as well as ever .
From February 1739 , to July 1743 , I took every day five or six drachms of soap : but after that time I diminished the dose to half an ounce ; and never after had any return of a gravelish symptom , tho ' I still imagine the stone is not entirely dissolved ; for , after sitting some time , I find as it were something come to the neck of the bladder ; but which gives me no uneasiness .
This , Sir , according to the best of my memory , is my case : and if it can be of any benefit to you , in the cure of this painful disease , it will give great pleasure to , Nov. 20th , 1749 .
Dear Sir , Your most obedient Servant , Matthew Simson .
The Extract from Dr. Austin 's Letter to Dr. Pringle .
THE Rev. Mr. Simson 's letter to me was written in the year 1749 ; about which time he told me , that he had ridden 40 miles in a day , without any bad symptom ensuing .
Read April 28 .
1757 .
In the year 1752 he broke his thigh-bone at the neck , by a fall from his horse , and continued for six weeks in great pain ; but after that time he grew easier , and was able to put his foot to the ground .
One day , as his servant was helping him to walk across the room , he let him fall ; upon which Mr. Simson felt a severe pain : the broken leg became then evidently shorter than the other ; and by that misfortune he was confined to his bed for near two years .
However , about six months before he died , he was so well recovered , as to be able to go to church , and to perform divine service .
About the beginning of May 1756 , Mr. Simson was seized with a diarrhea , which resisted all medicine , and carried him off in the 83d year of his age .
From the date of his letter to his death he had never discontinued the use of the soap ( except during the time of his last illness ) , tho ' he had not been troubled with any painful symptom of a stone since the year 1743 .
I obtained leave of his friends to open the body , but found no stone or gravel in the bladder ; that part appearing to be , in every respect , in a natural state , except at the neck , where the coats seemed to be schirrous , and were about a quarter of an inch thick .
It is probable , that the stone had been of a softer texture , and more easily dissolved , than ordinary ; otherwise five or six drachms of soap taken daily , even for so long a time , could not have dissolved it entirely ; for many have used that medicine in much larger doses , and at the same time have drank lime-water plentifully , without obtaining such effects ; tho ' all their painful symptoms were removed by that course , as Dr. Whytt has shown in his treatise on this subject .
I shall only add , that Mr. Simson 's son , who is now minister at Fala , was present at the opening of the body , and can attest , that there was no stone found in the bladder .
Edinburgh , 15 April 1757 .
Adam Austin .
A Letter from Dr. Adam Drummond to Dr. Adam Austin , relating to the Rev. Mr. Matthew Simson 's Case .
Communicated by J. Pringle , M.D. F.R.S. I Have yours ; and was present when Mr. Balderstone founded Mr. Simson ; and both of us perceived , very distinctiy , a large stone : and Mr~ Simson himself felt it ; which we were Read June 23 , were the more sollicitous he should do , as he was sounded before by Dr. Simson , who had declared there was no stone .
But the particular magnitude of it we could not well determine at the end of a long catheter ; tho ' I remember Mr. Balderstone , who was well versed in that business , conjectured it to be pretty large .
He was sounded only once by us , as the urethra was a little hurt by turning the catheter .
There is only one circumstance in the case , which Mr. Simson seems to have omitted ; that , from the first symptoms of the stone , he passed a great deal of mucus mixed with pus , as well as blood ; and great quantities of gritty red sand , all in single grains , never any concreted into small stones .
I take the more notice of this , as I do not remember , that , after he used the soap , he ever passed any sand , but a good deal of mucus , in which the soap was discoverable by its frothing .
Could the gritty particles of sand be again suspended in the urine , so as to become invisible ?
or were they wrapped up in the soapy liquid , so as to escape observation ?
I have seen several stones of a soft consistence dissolved into mucilage by soap : but the sand passed by Mr. Simson , before he used the soap , seems to indicate his stone of a harder nature , tho ' indeed it felt obtuse at the end of the catheter .
I shall rejoice , if many instances of this kind are found afterwards : but this seems to be the only one yet , of a stone in the bladder being dissolved by soap alone .
I am , Bandeeran , June 5 .
1757 .
Dear Doctor , Your most humble Servant , Adam Drummond .

