XXVI .
An Account of the Case of the late Right Honourable Horace Lord Walpole ; being a Sequel to his own Account published in the Philosophical Transactions , Vol. xlvii .
p. 43 .
and 472 .
I. Copy of a Letter from John Pringle , M. D. F. R. S. to Dr. Robert Whytt , Professor of Medicine in the University of Edinburgh , and F. R. S. relating to the Case of the Right Honourable Lord Walpole ; with Dr. Whytt 's Answer .
Communicated by Dr. Pringle .
SIR , London , 22 Feb. 1757 .
I Imagined , that upon hearing of Lord Walpole 's death , you would be desirous to know the state of his Lordship 's health from the time he published his own case ; whether he continued the use of his medicines to the last ; what distemper he died of ; and , if his body was opened , what was the condition of his bladder and kidneys .
I informed myself , as well as I could , of all these particulars ; and I hope I shall be able to give you some satisfactory account of most of them .
Read April 21 , 1757 .
Last year , in the month of March , about ten months before his Lordship 's death , I happened to meet him at a friend 's house , where he dined , and never saw any man of his age with a more healthful appearance .
He was then in his 78th year .
He eat with an appetite , and of a variety of dishes ; drank some Madeira , and was very cheerful the whole time .
His Lordship then told me , that he had enjoyed perfect health since he sent his case to the Royal Society ; that he thought it probable there was still a stone in his bladder , but so diminished , or smoothed , as to give him no uneasiness ; that he did not think it safe to go about the streets of London in a coach , but that he went every where in a chair ; and that , in the country , he could travel 40 miles a day in his post-chaise , without fatigue , or feeling any of his old pains upon the motion .
That he continued to drink , for a constancy , three pints of oystershell lime-water daily ; and to take , as often , from half an ounce to a whole ounce of soap , by way of lenitive .
All these circumstances I am sure of , because I noted them down when I came home .
From this time to the beginning of winter , Lord Walpole ( as Mr. Graham , his apothecary , informed me ) continued in the same state of health ; but some time after coming to town , his Lordship was seized with a lingering feverish disorder , very much affecting his spirits , but entirely unconnected with the stone .
Dr. Shaw , who attended his Lordship for about a fortnight before his death , told me , that there had never been any stoppage of water , or passing of bloody urine , or any pain about his bladder or kidneys , during his last illness ; but that he now and then felt some irritation in making water , a symptom too inconsiderable to require any other medicine than the continuation of his lime-water ; which , in a smaller quantity , he drank till within two or three days of his end .
Mr. Ranby and Mr. Hawkins , surgeons , with Mr. Graham , were present at the opening of the body ; and from the two last I received the account of the dissection .
The coats of the bladder appeared to be a little thicker than natural , but were otherwise sound .
The glandula prostata was of a large size , but not distempered .
They found three calculi , two lying loose in the bladder , and the other , a very small one , sticking in the passage , at that part , which is surrounded by the prostate gland .
Mr. Graham favoured me with a sight of them all .
The two first were very much alike , being of the shape and size of the kernel of a Spanish nut ; only the sides were irregularly flattened , but without forming any sharp angle .
The surface of each was every where smooth , except where there had been a separation of some small scales , not so thick as one 's nail ; and the largest exfoliation from one of these stones appeared to have been nearly about the breadth of the nail of my little finger .
The polish otherwise , as well as the colour of both , might be compared to a boy 's marble .
One of these calculi weighed 21 grains , the other 22 grains : they were heavy for their bulk , and seemingly of a hard substance .
The smallest stone having been put up with some others of the same size , taken out of the gallbladder , Mr. Graham could not be positive which of them it was ; and therefore I can only say , that what he thought most likely to be so , was about the size and shape of the seed of an apple , with the point broken off and the edge ragged .
This , as I observed , was found in the passage , seemed to be coming away , and probably had occasioned that irritation tation the patient had now and then felt during his last illness .
It weighed only about a grain .
No parts could have a sounder appearance than both the ureters and kidneys .
The first were not dilated ; nor did the last contain any stone , mucus , or gravel : the pelvis in each was of a natural size .
The rest of the abdominal viscera were in the same healthful state , except the gall-bladder , which was full of stones .
The largest was about the size of a small chesnut , but rounder .
The surface was smooth , particularly at one part , where it seemed to have rubbed upon a lesser calculus , of the shape of one of the vertebrae of a small animal , without the processes .
This last had a hollow on each side corresponding to the convexity of the large stone ; and these cavities being finely polished , it seemed as if sometimes one side , sometimes the other , of the small stone had been turned to the great one , and had been shaped in that manner by the attrition .
The largest calculus weighed one drachm two scruples and two grains ; the small one but nine grains : they both sunk in water ; and felt specifically heavier than any stones I have ever seen taken out of the gall-bladder .
Besides these two , there were several very small calculi of irregular shapes , and of rough surfaces , which all together did not weigh above five grains .
Mr. Graham , who had attended his Lordship for about 40 years , assured me , that he never had any symptom that indicated a stoppage of the bile , or the passage of a stone from the gall-bladder into the intestines .
Neither the head nor breast were opened .
These are all the materials , I can furnish you with , relating to this case .
If you desire to be more particularly cularly informed of any of these circumstances , let me know , and I will endeavour to procure you all the lights I can .
In the mean while , I should be glad to have your remarks upon what I have now sent you ; and since you have been so long in the train of thinking , with more than usual attention , on this subject , I presume it would be very agreeable to the gentlemen of the Royal Society to have a paper from you on this occasion ; and the rather , as his Lordship began his course of soap and lime-water , upon hearing of your success by that method of cure .
I am , SIR , &amp;c. John Pringle .
II .
Some Observations on the Case of the late Right Honourable Lord Walpole , of Woolterton : In a Letter to Dr. John Pringle , F. R. S. By Robert Whytt , M. D. F. R. S. SIR , Edinburgh , March 16 .
1757 .
PHYSICIANS have not , perhaps , differed more widely in any thing , than in their opinions of the medicines lately proposed for the cure of the stone .
While some imagined , that Mrs. Stephens 's medicines , or soap and lime-water , were in most cases to accomplish a dissolution of the stone ; others have been positive , that nothing of this kind was to be expected from them : nay , they have condemned these medicines , when used in large quantities , and long persisted in , as hurtful to the VO L. 50 .
Ee stomach , Read April 21 , stomach , guts , and urinary passages ; and have ascribed the remarkable ease , which they almost always give to calculous patients , to their depositing a calcarious powder upon the surface of the stone , by which it is rendered less hurtful to the bladder .
And this opinion seems to have been not a little strengthened , by the great quantity of white sediment observed in the urine of those patients , who have used soap and lime-water in considerable quantities .
Now , as I am of opinion , that most of these objections and doubts , concerning the effects of soap and limewater in the cure of the stone , may be cleared by a candid consideration of Lord Walpole 's case , I shall trouble you with a few remarks , which have occurred to me , in comparing it with the appearances found in his Lordship 's body after death , of which you were so obliging as to send me a particular account .
1 .
Whatever doubts may have been entertained concerning the cause of Lord Walpole 's complaints , yet it now appears evidently beyond dispute , that they must have been owing , not to a scorbutic corrosive humour in his bladder , as was imagined by some ( 1 ) , but to stones lodged in it .
These stones may possibly have lain there since 1734 ; for from that time to spring 1747 , his Lordship was free of any gravelish complaints , only passing some red sand at times .
But at what time soever they may have first arrived in the bladder , in 1747 and 1748 they ( 1 ) Philosoph. Transact. Vol. xlvii .
p. 48 .
and Essay on the Virtues of Lime~water , &amp;c. edit .
2d .
p. 197 .
seem to have acquired such a bulk , or were become so rough or pointed in their surface , as to occasion great pain , frequent provocations to urine , and sometimes bloody urine ; especially after any considerable motion .
These complaints , however , were soon relieved , by swallowing daily an ounce of Alicant soap , and three English pints of lime-water made with calcined oyster-shells : and from 1748 to 1757 his Lordship was kept almost entirely free from any return of them , except for some months of 1750 and 1751 , during which he took only one-third part of the quantity of soap and lime-water abovementioned ( 2 ) .
2 .
It is highly probable , nay , I think , altogether certain , that the soap and lime-water not only relieved Lord Walpole of the painful symptoms occasioned by the stones in his bladder , but also prevented their increase .
If these stones came into the bladder in 1734 , they must , in so many years as his Lordship lived after this , have acquired a very great bulk : nay , if we suppose them not to have been lodged in the bladder above a year before they began to occasion frequent inclination to make urine , with pain , and sometimes sudden stoppages of urine ; yet , from 1746 to 1757 , they ought to have grown to a much larger size than that of the kernel of a Spanish nut ( 3 ) .
'Ti~ ( 2 ) Philosoph. Transact. Vol. xlvii .
p. 48 and 473 .
and Essay on Lime-water , p. 157 and 200 .
( 3 ) The two stones found in Lord Walpole 's bladder were of this size , and weighed one of them 22 and the other 21 grains .
true , the stone may increase faster in some patients , and slower in others ; but stones , after remaining a dozen or more years in the bladder , generally weigh several ounces .
Some years since I saw a stone , weighing near six ounces , taken from a boy of no more than 14 years of age .
3 .
Lord Walpole 's case not only shows the power of soap and lime-water to relieve the painful symptoms , and prevent the increase , of the stone in the bladder , but also makes it probable , that these medicines do communicate to the urine a power of dissolving the stone .
In the beginning of 1749 his Lordship voided with his urine a calculous substance of a flat shape , about the bigness of a silver penny , and covered with a soft white mucus ( 4 ) ; and upon the surfaces of the stones found in his bladder there were some inequalities , which seemed to have been made by the separation of thin lamellae or scales .
Further , the small stone found in the beginning of the urethra must have been in a dissolving state , and considerably lessened in the bulk : for , if it had lain long in the bladder , and never been larger , it ought to have been voided thro ' the urethra with the urine ; and it could not have arrived lately in the bladder , since Lord Walpole had not had , for several years before his death , any nephritic pains , or symptoms of stones passing from the kidnies ; and since it is not likely , that a stone of the size and shape of the seed of an ( 4 ) Philosoph. Transact. Vol. xlvii .
p. 47 .
apple ( 5 ) would pass thro ' the ureters without being felt .
Now if this small stone , found in the urethra , was partly dissolved by the virtue of the soap and limewater ; it will appear at least probable , that the two larger stones in the bladder were so likewise .
But altho ' Lord Walpole 's calculous concretions had remained undiminished , and without any symptoms of dissolution ; it would not therefore follow , that soap and lime-water cannot dissolve the stone in other patients , where the concretion may be of a less firm texture .
The Revd .
Dr. Richard Newcome , now Lord Bishop of Llandaff , while drinking two English quarts of lime-water daily , for the cure of the stone in his bladder , poured his urine every morning and evening upon a piece of human calculus weighing 31 grains ; by which , in the space of four months , it was reduced to three pieces , weighing in all only six grains .
Upon one of these pieces , weighing 2.31 grains , he caused to be daily poured , for two months , the fresh urine of a person , who drank no lime-water ; at the end of which time the piece of calculus was found to weigh 2.56 grains , having increased in weight a quarter of a grain .
This same piece being afterwards steeped in the bishop 's urine ( who continued to drink lime-water as above ) , from June 24th to July 9th , was in these few days quite crumbled into powder .
Since this experiment shows , beyond dispute , that lime-water , unassisted by soap , can communicate to the urine a power of dissolving the stone out of the ( 5 ) The stone found in the beginning of the passage from the bladder was of this size , and weighed about a grain .
body , it can scarcely be doubted , that it must have the like effect on it when lodged in the bladder .
And that the dissolution of the stone in the bladder has been completed by soap alone , appeared evidently in the case of the Rev. Mr. Matthew Simson , Minister of Pancaitland near Edinburgh ; an account of which will soon be made public ( 6 ) by Dr. Austin , who opened his body after death .
Mr. Simson had , from 1730 , been afflicted in a less or greater degree with the symptoms of a stone in the bladder ; and in November 1735 was sounded by Dr. Drummond of Perth , and Mr. Balderston , surgeon in this city , by whom a stone was not only plainly felt , but also by the patient himself .
In February 1737 he began to take soap ; and after 1743 never had any gravelish symptoms .
He died in May 1756 ; and , when his bladder was looked into , there was neither stone nor gravel found in it .
4 .
It appears from Lord Walpole 's case , that soap and lime-water , even when taken in large quantities , proceed very slowly in dissolving the stone .
From July 1748 , to the beginning of 1757 , his Lordship drank three English pints of lime-water , and swallowed for the most part an ounce of soap , daily ; except from April 1750 to June 1751 , during which time he took only one pint of lime-water , and one-third part of an ounce of soap , daily .
However speedily soap and lime-water may dissolve the greatest part of urinary stones out of the body , yet ( 6 ) It is printed in this volume of the Philosoph. Transactions , under the 28th of April , p. 221 , &amp; seqq .
being mixed with the aliment and humours of the stomach and guts , and afterwards with the whole mass of blood , it is impossible but their force must be greatly impaired before they arrive with the urine at the bladder .
When , therefore , urinary stones are of an uncommon hard texture , we are perhaps scarcely to expect any sensible dissolution of them by the use of soap and lime-water : but when they are of a softer kind , there is no reason to doubt , that these medicines will in time dissolve them ; and this will happen sooner or later , in proportion to the hardness of the stone , to the quantity of the medicines swallowed by the patient , and the exact regimen he observes , as to diet ( 7 ) .
But however slowly soap and lime-water may proceed in dissolving the stone , yet they generally give speedy relief to the patient .
Lord Walpole did not take these medicines in the full quantity till the end of July 1748 ; and , in a few months after , he was not only greatly relieved of all his complaints , but in December was able to ride an hundred miles in his coach , without finding any uneasiness , altho ' the two last days of the journey the horses went at a full trot ( 8 ) .
In winter 1750 , and spring 1751 , when his Lordship swallowed only one third part of the soap and lime-water , which he had been in use to take , his pains and frequent inclination to make urine returned in a good degree ( 9 ) ; but , after taking the medicines in the full quantity , he soon became as easy as before ( 10 ) .
( 7 ) Essay on the Virtues of Lime-water , 2d edit .
p. 140 .
( 8 ) Phil. Transact. Vol. xlvii .
p. 46 .
( 9 ) Phil. Transact. Vol. xlvii .
p. 472 , 473 .
( 10 ) Essay on Lime-water , &amp;c. p. 200 , 201 .
It would seem , while Lord Walpole used only one pint of lime-water and one third of an ounce of soap daily , that the petrifying quality of his urine was not entirely destroyed , and that the stony particles newly formed on the surface of the calculi occasioned , by their roughness , the return of his painful symptoms .
However , when he had recourse to the medicines in a larger quantity , the petrescent quality of his urine was not only destroyed , but this fluid seems to have acquired a power of dissolving the rough stony particles deposited on the surface of the calculi ; and in this way soon removed the pain , bloody urine , and frequent desire to make water , upon using any considerable exercise .
Soap and lime-water not only relieve the painful symptoms occasioned by the stone , by wearing off its sharp points , and rougher parts , which used to irritate the tender membrane , which lines the bladder ; but , when this membrane has been wounded or lacerated by the stone , there is nothing , that will heal it more speedily than lime-water ; which the ingenious Dr. Langrish has found to be remarkable also for its effects in curing the bladders of dogs , after being fretted with soap-lees ( 11 ) .
The power of soap and lime-water to alleviate the painful symptoms attending the stone is so great , that , as far as I remember , I have only met with one patient , who did not find himself considerably relieved by them .
But it is to be observed , that this patient neither took them in full quantity , nor persisted in their use for a long enough time : and , when he was afterwards cut , the stone taken out of his ( 11 ) Physical Experiments , p. 19 .
bladder was almost as thick set with sharp prickles , as the back of an hedgehog : so that , in this case , no remarkable ease could be procured to the patient by the medicines , until they had quite dissolved these sharp points , and rendered the surface of the stone smooth and equal ; which was not to be done but after a very long time , especially as the stone was of a pretty hard texture .
It may be proper to take notice , that when , along with the stone , there is any ulceration in the bladder , soap does mischief , and lime-water often fails of giving any considerable relief .
However , even in this case it is perhaps one of the best remedies we know .
5 .
Soap and lime-water , taken in large quantities , and persisted in for many years together , appear to be innocent , and no way injurious to health .
Lord Walpole , who used these medicines for upwards of eight years , was not only relieved of the painful symptoms of the stone , but had his health improved by them in other respects ( 12 ) .
His appetite , healthful look , and a degree of spirits uncommon at his age , continued till the end of 1756 , when his last illness began first to attack him .
And as his health did not appear to be any way injured by these medicines ; so , when his body was opened after death , his kidneys and ureters were observed to be quite sound and natural , as was likewise his bladder ; only its coats appeared a little thicker than usual , owing probably to the long-continued friction of the stones upon it .
Neither the kidneys , ureters , nor ( 12 ) Essay on Lime-water , &amp;c. 2d edit .
p. 171 , 201 .
bladder , were loaded or crusted with any calcarious matter ; an effect most unjustly ascribed to soap and lime-water , since in the urinary passages , to which the air has no access , they cannot deposit their calcarious part ( 13 ) ; and since the white stuff observable in the urine of such patients , as take these medicines in large quantities , is only the usual sediment of the urine changed in its nature and colour , with , perhaps , some of the dissolved particles of the stone ( 14 ) .
As the urinary passages were no-way injured , so neither were the stomach , guts , and other viscera of the lower belly .
These had all a healthful appearance , except the gall-bladder , which was almost full of biliary concretions : nor is it surprising , that soap and lime-water , which prevent the growth of urinary calculi , should have no effect on biliary stones , since , altho ' these medicines dissolve the former out of the body , yet they do not make the smallest impression on the latter .
I presume it will be needless to take notice , that the lingering nervous fever , of which Lord Walpole died , cannot , with any colour of reason , be ascribed to the large use of soap and lime-water ; since , if they could have produced such an effect , they must have done it in much less time than eight years and an haf It may not be amiss to observe , that altho ' soap and lime-water , taken in large quantities , are noway injurious to health , yet in some cases they may ( 13 ) Essay on Lime-water , &amp;c. 2d edit .
p. 170 .
( 14 ) Ibid. p. 24 , 25 .
30 &amp; 31 .
become improper , on account of the particular state of the patient .
Thus , in a scorbutic or putrid disposition of the humours , soap at least ought to be totally omitted ; and such patients , who are much troubled with the haemorrhoids , ought to be sparing in its use , as the alkaline salt , with which it abounds , will scarcely fail to exasperate their pain .
Where the patient is naturally very costive , less lime-water and more soap ought to be used ; and , on the contrary , where the body is too loose , little or no soap is to be taken , but the cure is to be trusted to lime-water alone ; which , in this case , ought to be drank to the quantity of two English quarts a day .
As the foregoing observations will , I am afraid , appear more tedious than important , I shall only add , that I am , with great esteem , SIR , Your most obedient humble Servant , Robert Whytt .
III .
Dr. Pringle 's Paper read after Dr. Whytt 's Letter .
DR~ Pringle begs leave to inform the Society , that having read the copy of his letter , within these few days , to Dr. Shaw , Mr. Hawkins , and Mr. Graham , those gentlemen found his account agreeable to their several observations ; only Mr. Graham took notice , that , of late years , Lord Walpole , in his journies to Norfolk , had Ff2 twice Read April 21 , twice voided some blood with his urine , but with little uneasiness ; and that at other times he had passed some sand and stony particles ( tho ' never larger than the head of a small pin ) , attended with frettings of the parts , scarce painful .
But Mr. Graham was not sure , whether these accidents were prior or subsequent to the sequel of the case , communicated to the Society by his Lordship .
Dr. Pringle thinks it may be likewise proper to acquaint the Society with another circumstance in Lord Walpole 's case , which he had both from Dr. Shaw and Mr. Graham , viz. that after using the soap and lime-water for some time , his Lordship was freed from a very obstinate dry and scurfy eruption , which had resisted several other medicines .
But as there were no marks of a putrid scurvy ( that species expressly alluded to towards the end of Dr. Whytt 's letter ) the Society will easily understand , how the lithontriptic medicines may be prejudicial to one troubled with the true putrid seurvy ( such as is most incident to sailors ) and yet not be improper for those , that are subject to the scurfy eruptions , which are commonly , tho ' erroneously , called scorbutic .
Pall-Mall , 20 April , 1757 .
moved , I believe I may now with freedom offer this very curious case to the attention of the Society .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient humble Servant , John Pringle .
Postscript to Dr. Whytt 's Observations on Lord Walpole 's Case * .
I Do not know , if it be worth while to observe , that lately , in making some experiments with different calculi , there was one almost as white as chalk , but of a less hard substance than the others ; and which was not in the least degree dissolved or softned by being infused 20 days in oystershell lime-water , but yielded somewhat to a solution of Spanish soap in common water .
Read Dec. 8 , 1757 .
From this experiment one may conclude , that it is better to prescribe both soap and lime-water for the stone , than any one of them alone ; and that if one of these remedies has failed of giving relief , the other ought to be tried : for as the above white calculus , which yielded a little to the solution of soap , resisted lime-water ; so there may perhaps be others , that are readily dissolved by lime-water , but little affected by soap .
Dr. Springsfeld 's experiments with lime-water are somehow not just ; for in several calculi I have found the dissolving power of oystershell lime-water above eight times greater than he

