XVII .
An Account of a new medicinal Well , lately discovered near Moffat , in Annandale , in the County of Dumfries .
By Mr. John Walker , of Borgue-House , near Kirkudbright , in Scotland .
THIS mineral spring was found out by one Mr. Williamson , a few years ago , when he was overseeing a mine , which was at that time carrying on in its neighbourhood .
It is situate about four miles distant from Moffat , in the bottom of a deep scar , which is on the west side of a large mountain called Hartfell , from which it has acquired the name of Hartfellspaw .
This scar is a part of the mountain , thro ' which a small stream of water has worn its way to a considerable depth ; by which it has laid open , and exposed to view , the strata of the earth on each side : and in the bottom of this scar , and near to the brink of this small brook , the mineral water springs up .
When Read Feb. 10 , &amp; When I saw it , it consisted of two springs , which were very well ordered by Mr. Williamson , so as to run from two wooden spouts , immediately at their rise out of the earth ; which indeed must be of very great advantage to all mineral waters : and I am persuaded there are many , whose medical qualities are greatly impaired by falling into reservoirs , and continuing in them for some time after they spring from the earth .
The one of these springs was situate about ten or twelve yards further up the brook than the other ; and they were then distinguished by the names of the upper and lower spring : but I have been since informed , that their situation is now altered .
Each of these springs did at that time run nearly the same quantity of water , which , as I thought , was above an English quart in a minute , and that during a season of very dry weather .
As there are many instances of mineral waters springing out of the earth very near each other , which at the same time are impregnated with very different principles ; it therefore seemed not at all improbable , that as these waters did appear to run , for some part of their course , in different channels , they might in some respects be different from each other .
And this suspicion I found not to be altogether groundless with regard to these springs , as will be shown afterwards .
For which reason it may be observed , that the following trials were all made upon the water of the upper fountain , except where the other is particularly mentioned ; and also that they were made within 24 hours after the water was taken from the spring , being carried to Moffat in bottles carefully sealed .
According to what may be inferred from the following experiments , it may be premised , that this water appears to contain in it a large proportion of iron , but in two different forms ; and an aluminous salt , which is conjoined with a terrestrial principle .
As the contents of several mineral waters have been the cause of many different opinions , and of great disputes among physicians and chymists ; as the inquiry I made into the principles of these waters , which I am now considering , was not performed with that nicety and exactness I could have wished ; and as I am persuaded , that to dogmatize in any branch of philosophy can never tend to its advancement ; I shall not therefore pretend to determine with certainty in any part of this subject , where the contrary opinion can be admitted with the least degree of probability .
These trials are indeed but few and imperfect , and are no-way sufficient to form an exact account of this mineral water ; yet I believe they may afford some conclusions , which may be serviceable in compiling a more complete history of it .
They render it pretty evident , that the abovementioned principles are contained in these waters : and tho ' I will not pretend absolutely to exclude all others , yet I must say , that , by what inquiry I made , I could not observe them to be in the least impregnated with any other kind of mineral substance .
After a good deal of observation upon the water of this Spaw ; and after many fruitless attempts , which I have at different times made upon several other waters of the chalybeat kind in Scotland , in quest of the volatile spirit , which has been commonly artributed to them ; I must own , that I have been induced to think , that there is no such thing exists in these waters at all .
What has been generally called the spirit of steel waters , seems to me to be very unintelligible ; altho ' the existence of it in these waters has been asserted by all the writers on this subject , which I have yet had occasion to see .
The spirit of a mixed body is commonly taken to be a subtle , penetrating , light , and volatile substance , more susceptible of motion than any other of its parts , and most easily separable from them by avolation .
But that any chalybeat water contains such a substance , I think has never been made evident , unless where the water has been found to be impregnated with some other mineral principles .
Some steel waters , I believe , contain a large proportion of air , whose elasticity may occasion it to break forth with an explosive force ; some others there are , which contain a volatile and sulphureous halitus ; and to one or other of these two causes , or to some other mineral principle , I think most of the phenomenon may be referred , which have been attributed to a ferrugineous or vitriolic volatile spirit .
As the first thing observable in a mineral water is its outward form , we must therefore take notice , that the water of this Spaw equals the clearest springwater in transparency ; and is likewise as free of any colour or odour : yet its taste is very strong , and may be discerned to be compounded of a sweet , subacid , and astringent taste .
Its sweetness and acidity appear sensibly to arise from alum ; and its high styptic and astringent taste does as evidently proceed from that mineral salt , joined with some earthy or ferrugineous parts .
I must likewise observe , that when I first compared the taste of these two springs , I could plainly discern , that the water of the lower spring was more acid , and less astringent , than that of the upper one ; and , on the contrary , the water of the upper spring seemed more astringent , and less acid .
This induced me to think , that the mineral parts , which caused the acid and astringent tastes , were mixed in the waters of these two springs in different proportions .
And what I observed of them afterwards still confirmed this conjecture .
But , in order to give some evidence for the existence of the above-mentioned minerals in the waters of these springs , we shall consider them separately~ by relating the experiments , which seemed to indicate , that they are contained in these waters in a very considerable proportion , and by offering some conclusions , which may be reasonably drawn from them .
And as the first trials were made in quest of iron , it may perhaps be most proper to consider it in the first place .
Experiment 1 .
Some pieces of galls being added to equal quantities of the water of the two springs , an exceeding deep and bright blue colour was immediately produced in the water of the upper spring , which in a little time turned to a perfect black .
The water of the lower spring , tho ' indeed it was turned of the same colour , yet was not of so deep a shade , but was somewhat lighter than the former .
The tincture of galls caused the same appearances .
2 .
A tincture of balaustine-flowers produced the above blue colours in both waters .
3 .
A quantity of the water being thoroughly tinged with galls , was allowed to stand 24 hours : being then filtrated thro ' brown paper , the water , tho ' almost quite colourless , would not again receive any tincture with galls .
4 .
After elixation the water became of a turbid yellow colour with ochre , and afforded very little tincture with galls .
5 .
A solution of sal Martis , chemically prepared , being mixed with galls , immediately turned of a bright dark blue colour , exactly similar to that produced in the water .
6 .
A solution of common and rock alum was noways changed in its colour with galls .
7 .
A solution of sal Martis and alum being mixed in equal quantities , the mixture was turned of a bright blue colour with galls ; yet not of so deep a hue , but of a more diluted colour than the solution of sal Martis , without alum .
From these experiments we must first of all observe , that the colour , which these waters afford with galls and pomegranate-flowers , is very uncommon .
The more iron , that any mineral water contains , it will afford the deeper colour with such astringents : but tho ' I have tried this experiment upon a great many of the ferrugineous waters in Scotland , and also upon the water of some of the foreign Spaws , I never observed one , that afforded so deep a colour as this , which we now consider .
Some of the weakest of them gives only a red or faint purple tincture , and the strongest only a deep purple : but I never saw or heard of any chalybeat water , but this , either in Scotland or elsewhere , that afforded an intense black and inky colour with galls .
From which , I think we may venture to conclude , that the water of this Spaw contains a far larger proportion of iron than most , or perhaps than any , other chalybeat water hitherto discovered : and for this reason , I dare say , it will likewise be so much the more preferable to most others in medicinal virtues ; which has indeed already appeared by many surprising cures it has performed , and which , I am persuaded , will more fully appear , when its medicinal effects shall be better known .
There must needs be a very great quantity of iron in this water , when it yields as deep a colour with galls as a strong solution of sal Martis .
I was indeed at first apprehensive , that this perhaps might not be owing so much to a large and uncommon proportion of chalybeat parts , as to the commixture of alum , which I judged to be in the water .
But we see the contrary appears by these trials : for alum of itself affords no tincture with astringents , and , instead of rendering a solution of sal Martis with galls of a more intense colour , rather makes it lighter and more diluted .
We see here , that the ferrugineous matter is entirely separated from the water by an infusion of galls .
The like also happens by elixation ; after which it is almost deprived of its tinging quality .
Yet other chalybeat waters lose this quality by a much less degree of heat .
As there is an ochrous earth separated from all steel waters , when exposed to the air , which subsides to the bottom , and a metalline scum or cremor , which swim on their surface ; we shall next consider the appearances , which they make in this water .
Exp. 8 .
A solution of saccharum Saturni being dropped into common spring-water , left the upper parts of the water clear and colourless , but formed a lactescency towards the bottom .
The same solution being added to the mineral water , soon turned it of a turbid yellow colour , which afterwards subsided , and formed a deep yellow cloud in the bottom of the glass ; and below this yellow sediment there adhered to the bottom of the glass a whitish substance , which I took to be the metalline parts of the saccharum Saturni separated from the purer parts of the salt , which were still suspended in the water , and which made it of a muddy whitish colour .
9 .
Forty drops of oleum tartari per deliquium being added to an ounce of the water , made it of an uniform light yellow colour ; but in an hour afterwards there were many small yellow terrene nubeculae formed in it .
These the next day were more conspicuous , being thoroughly separated from the water , and precipitated to the bottom , leaving the water quite clear , as it was before the mixture .
A small quantity of this limpid water being taken , it would afford no tincture with galls .
It was then all poured off , except so much in the bottom of the glass as contained the above-mentioned clouds : to this there were some galls added , which in half an hour turned these clouds from a light yellow to a deep red colour , but did not change the colour of the water , in which they swam .
10 .
Immediately after the affusion of ol .
tart .
p. d. to the water , galls were added to the mixture , which tinged it of a deep and bright red colour .
After standing for some time , there were red clouds precipitated to the bottom , and the water continued of a dusky opake red colour .
11 .
There is a small brook , formerly mentioned , which runs near by these springs ; into which the water , that flows from them , is discharged .
I observed the stones and channel of this brook all tinged with ochre of a deep yellow colour , so far up as the water of these springs flowed into it ; but the channel , which the mineral water ran over before it was mixed with the water of the brook , was very little or nothing discoloured with ochre .
As I conjectured what this was owing to , I afterwards took two equal quantities of the mineral water , into one of which I put an equal quantity of common water .
In two hours the mixture became less transparent , and appeared yellowish , while the simple mineral water retained its clearness .
Next day there was much ochre separated from the mixture , which subsided to the bottom of the glass : but the unmixed mineral water remained still clear and colourless , as at first .
All chalybeat waters separate their ochrous parts , when exposed some time to the air ; but this separation is made sooner by the commixture of several kinds of salts .
Thus we see the ochre in this water is immediately separated and precipitated by the solution of saccharum Saturni .
The oil of tartar causes a precipitation of these ferrugineous parts in the same manner .
Which parts must be the sole cause , that the water receives a tincture from galls ; since , after they are precipitate , it loses that quality , which they notwithstanding retain even after they are separated from the water .
This precipitation of the ochrous parts of the water were the only visible effects that I could perceive to follow from the affusion of the ol .
tart .
p. d. I remember indeed , when I was at Moffat , I saw the manuscript of Dr. Horsburgh 's experiments upon this mineral water ; which appeared to be very accurate ; and which I understand are since printed , in a volume lately published by the Philosophical Society at Edinburgh .
Amongst these I observed one , which I thought so very remarkable , that I particularly adverted to it .
It was the effects of the affusion of ol .
tart .
p. d. to the water , producing in it clouds , or a coagulation of a green or grass-green colour .
I think these were the words ; and I own I was something surprised at them .
A solution of vitriolum Martis , mixed with this alkaline oil , does indeed produce a green coagulum : but I could scarcely think , that this , or any other chalybeat water , contained so large a proportion of that vitriol , as to be sufficient to produce these effects , when I considered , that so many writers , which I had seen , upon this subject , have all failed in their attempts of extracting a conspicuous martial vitriol from such mineral waters .
I had tried this experiment upon four or five chalybeat springs in Scotland , and likewise upon the Spa and Pyrmont waters , which had been well preserved ; but there never resulted any such effects from the mixture of these with oil of tartar , as are related in the above experiment .
All the alteration it pro7 duced duced in these waters was the precipitation of an ochrous earth , but without the least appearance of any green colour .
As I looked upon this as a leading experiment in the history of vitriolic waters ; as I had often tried it , and as often seen the green coagulum produced with the solution of the factitious vitriol , and never could observe it produced in any of the above water ; I began to suspect , that these waters were either not possessed of a vitriolic salt at all , or else , that it was in some respects very different from the factitious vitriol .
For these reasons , Dr. Horsburgh 's experiment appeared very extraordinary ; tho ' at the same time I was greatly pleased , that I should have the opportunity of repeating it , and of observing those phenomenon in this ferrugineous water , which I had sought for in vain in several others .
But when I came to make the trial , I was yet more surprised , when I found it misgive , and that the ol .
tart .
p. d. produced no green colour or coagulum in this mineral water , nor caused any other alteration in it , than the separation of a large quantity of ochrous earth of a yellow colour , exactly the same with what I had observed in the other steel waters .
This failure made me immediately conclude , that I had somehow or other committed an error in the experiment : and tho ' I was pretty sure , that the mineral water , which I had used in it , was quite fresh , yet I could not be so positive as to the oil of tartar , which I suspected to have been long kept .
Yet that this could have been the cause of my being so unsuccessful , I could scarcely believe , tho ' indeed I could assign no other .
I was sorry , that I had not afterwards an opportunity of repeating this experiment with more accuracy , from which I might have expected to reap more success , as it is perhaps one of the most consequence , that can be performed on this mineral water , as it is capable of demonstrating the existence of a substantial vitriolum Martis in it ; which is more than has been hitherto done , or perhaps ever will be done , concerning any one of the vast number of chalybeat waters , which have been yet discovered .
When galls are added to the water , at the same time with oil of tartar , instead of its deep blue colour , it affords only a red tincture .
It appears from the 11th experiment , that an addition of common water causes the mineral water to precipitate its ochre ; and the reason of this is obvious : for if these ochrous parts be altogether terrene , as they appear to be , and exist in the water unconnected with any other principle , then it must happen , that as these parts are uniformly diffused thro ' the water , in which they are suspended as in a menstruum ; by the addition of common water , this menstruum being diluted , the cohesion of these terrene parts must be thereby weakened , and their contact destroyed ; so that their menstrual equilibrium being thus taken off , they can be no longer supported in the fluid , but must be precipitated by the force of their own gravity .
Exp. 12 .
When the water was exposed for some days to the air , there was a cremor separated from it of a shining chalybeat colour .
This , like other kinds of cremor , takes a considerable time to complete its entire separation from the fluid , out of which it is expelled : for when it was despumated , a new cremor always succeeded , until the whole quantity , which the water contained , was exhausted .
13 .
When this cremor first appeared on the water , it was of a faint blueish colour : but as it increased , it changed into a deeper and more bright shining blue : and , after longer standing , it became blotched with various colours , as red , orange , yellow , green , blue , purple , and violet .
14 .
A quantity of the water being put in a gentle heat , this cremor was quickly separated from it , and appeared on the surface of the water .
A like quantity of the water , with its cremor already upon its surface , was put over a gentle heat , which by degrees broke the cremor into very small parts ; but whether they did evaporate , or precipitate in the water , I could not be certain .
But , by other trials , this cremor was found to have a great degree of fixity , bearing a considerable heat without avolation ; yet not without the appearance of some of its parts flying off , altho ' most of them were fixed ; because what remained lost its fine colours , and was changed into a shining chalybeat colour .
15 .
The water of the lower spring afforded a much less quantity of the cremor , than the water of the upper spring .
It took also a longer time to separate , was of a blueish colour , and had not the vivid colours , which the water of the upper spring showed .
16 .
When ol .
tart .
p. d. and spirit of sal ammoniac were added to the water , it did not separate its cremor .
This cremor , which is separated from the water , is the same with that , which appears on the surface of a solution of vitriolum Martis , when exposed for some time to the air : and an infusion of iron in common water also emits a cremor of the same kind .
I remember , as I was once carefully observing a large glass full of a chalybeat water , which contained much of this cremor ; soon after it was exposed to the air , I observed a tenuious blueish vapour rising in the parts of the water next the surface , which very much diminished its transparency ; and by degrees this vapour was emitted by the lowest parts of the water : but as the cremor increased on its surface , the water became gradually deprived of the blueish tincture , which it received from this halituous body ; which was apparently nothing else but the parts of the cremor separating from the water , and ascending upwards .
From whence we may conclude , that this cremor consists of the very finest parts of iron attenuated to the highest degree .
It has been the opinion of most naturalists , that these kind of mineral waters do abound in sulphureous parts .
This they have conjectured from the foetor , that often attends them .
But in what quantity or form these parts exist in the fluid , or by what means they can be rendered conspicuous , has not as yet been sufficiently determined .
Yet , I think , we may suspect some of the parts of this cremor to be sulphureous .
They are volatile , and , being heated , do fly off from the pure metalline parts , which being more fixed , are thereby left destitute of those vivid colours , which they enjoyed from the sulphureous parts .
These are evident marks of sulphur , and are altogether analogous to some other appearances of that mineral .
Another observation tending to support this is the want of those vivid colours in the cremor , which appears on an infusion of iron ; the reason of which seems to be the loss of the sulphureous parts of the chalybeat minerals by avolation , during the operations of the fire , which they undergo in refining .
It appears from the fifteenth experiment , that the water of these two springs contains a very different proportion of this cremor : and from the last , that it is precipitated along with the ochrous parts , which happens upon the affusion of these alkaline liquors .
The next trials were in quest of alum .
Exp. 17 .
A quantity of the water being kept for some time in a boiling heat , and after it was cool being filtred quite clear from its ochrous matter , it still retained a subacid and aluminous taste in a very strong degree .
18 .
To an ounce of common spring-water there was added two guts of fresh sweet milk .
This mixture being shaken , the milk mixed intimately with the water , without any kind of coagulation .
19 .
The same experiment being made with the mineral water , the milk , upon its affusion , was so curdled , or separated into clouds , that the greatest shaking could not mix or incorporate it with the water .
20 .
This experiment being also made with a weak solution of alum in spring-water , its effects upon the milk were not in the least different from those of the mineral water .
21 .
And the same trial being again repeated with the water , when boiled and filtred from its ochrous parts , the milk was in the same manner coagulated as before elixation .
22 .
One part of sweet milk being added to four parts of the mineral water , the milk subsided , and formed a cloud in the bottom of the glass , leaving the upper parts of the water clear .
This mixture being heartily shaken , the milk mixed so well with the water , that it appeared to be but a very little curdled .
23 .
When a larger quantity of milk was added to a smaller quantity of water , and even when equal parts of the milk and mineral water were mixed and shaken together , there could be no curdling or coagulation observed .
24 .
An equal quantity of the water and milk being boiled together , the greatest part of the milk was coagulated into a thick white curd ; and the remainder , with the mineral water , turned of a pure white milky colour , which drank like whey , and was very agreeable .
25 .
Eight guts of sweet milk being added to four ounces of the water , and the mixture boiled , part of the milk was thereby curdled , and swam upon the top of the water .
The ochrous parts of the water were likewise separated , and falling to the bottom , their colour did not appear of a clear yellow , as usual , but was something milky .
All these experiments strongly indicate the existence of alum in this water .
It retains its aluminous taste , and coagulates milk , after the chalybeat parts are almost all expelled by elixation .
The coagulation tion of the milk demonstrates an acidity in the water , and the other appearances show that acidity to be owing to an aluminous salt .
It appears , that the milk requires a large quantity of the water , to make a sensible coagulation in it : for , in the 22d experiment , one part of the milk being added to four parts of the mineral water , the coagulation was scarcely discernible : and in the 23d , when an equal or larger quantity of milk was added to the water , the coagulation was not at all observable .
I have heard it confidently averred , that this mineral water did not at all curdle milk ; which , I suppose , has been thro ' a mistake in the experiment , in addding too large a proportion of milk to the water : for in this way the coagulation cannot be observed .
I imagined , that when the water was boiled with milk , the mixture would have become of a muddy yellow colour , by the separation of the ochre : but it did not even appear , that the ochre was at all separated from the mixture , as it is from the water when boiled by itself .
On the contrary , not only the coagulum , but also the liquor , was of a pure white colour , and of a pleasant taste : and this makes me think it worth the inquiring into , whether or not the water does retain its medical qualities after it is prepared in this manner with milk ?
For , if it does , such a preparation might certainly be very serviceable in many cases .
These experiments , which we next relate , do not only ascertain the existence of alum in the water with greater certainty , but also , that there is a particular kind of earth conjoined with this salt .
Exp. 26 .
An English quart of the water being kept boiling for a quarter of an hour , it turned thick , muddy , and yellow , by the separation of its ochrous parts ; and , being set to cool in a clean bowl , the next day all the ochre was subsided to the bottom , from which the water was carefully filtred : whereby it became almost as clear and limpid as before the elixation , retaining a sharp aluminous taste , but was deprived of the strong ferrugineous taste , which it had at first .
This water was again boiled ; by which means it was again turned a little yellow , by the separation of some more ochre .
It was therefore again filtred , and rendered clear , and its aluminous taste was stronger than before .
After this filtration , the water was evaporated in a sand-heat to about a sixteenth part of the original quantity , and then it tasted like a strong solution of alum joined with a small degree of a chalybeat taste .
And this being totally evaporated in a glass , there adhered upon its sides a pure white salt ; and a larger quantity of the same salt remained in the bottom of the glass , which was not so white , but more impure than the former , and of a brown colour .
27 .
This salt , thus procured from the water , being mixed with distilled vinegar and spirit of vitriol , there was not the least effervescence produced .
28 .
Some of the brown-coloured salt being put upon a red-hot iron , it did neither sparkle nor decrepitate ; but was turned into a blackish cineritious substance , which in a short time became a white calx .
And tho ' some of the salt was put upon the iron finely powdered , yet it concreted , and run together in a cinder , whose cohesion was afterwards destroyed when calcined by a further degree of heat .
29 .
As I was accidentally deprived of the opportunity of obtaining the crystals of this salt , which would have been the best means of knowing to what species it was to be referred ; I dissolved the whole mass in a small quantity of spring-water , and , by filtrating this solution , I obtained a large proportion of fine earth of a brown colour .
30 .
This solution of the salt afforded a deep blue tincture with galls .
31 .
The same solution , being mixed with syrup of violets , became of a reddish colour .
32 .
Saccharum Saturni being added to the solution , precipitated a thick lactescent cloud .
33 .
Ol .
tart .
p. d. being also added to this solution , it caused no visible effervescence , yet raised some bubbles of air , and caused a coagulation of many small brown terrene nubeculae in the water ; which , after standing some time , subsided to the bottom , and left the water clear .
These experiments do plainly evince , that this water contains an aluminous salt , conjoined with a fine terrene substance , which is probably a part of the matrix , from whence the salt has been formed .
This salt gives no signs of any alkaline principle ; but , on the contrary , of an acidity , as its solution reddens with syrup of violets .
With this salt there are also intimately conjoined some very subtle chalybeat parts , which are not separable from it by elixation or evaporation .
Alum is distinguishable from all other mineral salts , by liquifying and bubbling upon a red-hot iron , and turning into a white calx .
But this could not be well expected from this aluminous salt , which we had extracted from the water , because it was extremely foul , by being combined with so large a proportion of earth ; which earthy parts were the occasion of turning the salt of a blackish colour upon the iron .
However , we see it turns white by a further degree of heat .
But if the salt had been dissolved , filtrated , and crystallized , till it had been purified and freed from this terrene matter , it would then certainly have had the same appearance upon the red-hot iron , as a pure aluminous salt .
Again , as it is peculiar to an aluminous salt to liquify in some degree with fire , so we see , that this was evidently the case of this salt .
Its eliquation indeed could not be so remarkable , as in pure alum , because of its being mixed with so much earth ; but that it did liquify in some degree is plain , because the whole mass of salt and earth , even when reduced to a powder , ran all together like a cinder .
The experiment upon the solution of this salt with ol .
tart .
p. d. is also a further proof of what we have already asserted : for tho ' there was no visible effervescence , yet the bubbles of air show , that there was an intestine conflict of the oil with the acid principle in the solution ; which being absorbed by the alkali , the earth was precipitated , to which it formerly adhered .
The two next experiments were made in order to discover , whether an acid or alkaline principle prevailed in the water .
Exp. 34 .
Forty guts of the syrup of violets being added to an ounce of the water , the mixture became of a bright sea-green colour .
35 .
A quantity of the water being kept boiling for five minutes , and afterwards allowed to stand till it became clear , was carefully filtrated from its ochrous sediment : after which , upon its mixture with syrup of violets , it turned of a faint reddish colour .
From these experiments we infer , that this mineral water contains both an alkaline and an acid principle ; the former consisting of the ochrous and ferrugineous parts , which are separated from the water by elixation ; and the latter of the aluminous salt , which remains in the water after elixation .
The following trials were made in order to know what effects are produced in the water by being exposed to the air ; and in what respects the waters of the two springs differed from each other .
Exp. 37 .
An English quart of the water of each of the springs being fully exposed to the air in two China bowls , the next day that of the under spring was neither altered in its taste , colour , or transparency , nor in any other shape whatever ; but that of the upper spring appeared of a yellowish colour , altho ' it was clear and transparent as the other .
On the second day the taste of the waters scarcely appeared to be any way diminished .
No sensible change could be observed in the lower water ; but the upper water was become more yellow than it was the day before , yet without any loss of its transparency .
They both tinged of a deep blue colour with galls ; which tinctures appeared equally deep and strong , as they did before the waters were exposed to the air .
The third day the lower water appeared clear and colourless as before , only its surface was covered with a few small spots of cremor .
The upper water appeared more yellowish than formerly , and its surface was almost wholly covered over with the cremor .
They both afforded a tincture with galls , which was not sensibly different from what they gave before their exposure .
On the fourteenth day the water of the under well had precipitated a yellow ochrous sediment , but the other water a more considerable quantity .
A large quantity of cremor continued also to swim upon the surface of the upper water , but there was very little separated from the water of the under well .
Both waters being now tried with galls , instead of the deep blue colour , which they did formerly exhibit , they now became only of a deep purple colour .
On the twentieth day the visible appearance of both waters was the same as when last observed .
On the thirty-eighth day they both afforded as deep a purple colour with galls , as they did three weeks before ; and during that time also they had not precipitated any more of their ochrous parts , nor suffered any other sensible alteration .
The water of the upper well being filtrated from all the ferrugineous matter , which it had separated during these thirty-eight days , was rendered almost as limpid and clear as when newly taken from the well : but , being boiled for some time , it became of a turbid yellow colour ; and being allowed to stand , it again precipitated abundance of an ochrous sediment ; and being filtrated , and mixed with galls , it received a faint purple colour of a blueish hue .
38 .
A bottle of the water of each of these springs , being carefully sealed , carried to Moffat , and kept for two months , suffered not the least alteration during that time , but was as fresh as when immediately taken from the fountain .
And I am informed , that after it is carried to Edinburgh , and to places at a greater distance , it will keep a much longer time without being any way spoiled .
I believe it will appear from these observations , that this mineral water continues longer entire , and particularly that it retains the quality of tinging with galls longer , than most others of the chalybeat kind : at least , of a great number , which I have seen described , I do not remember one , that retains it near so long , when exposed to the open air .
Many of them lose this quality entirely in a few hours ; and it is greatly impaired in the same time , even in those which retain it longest .
But this water , we see , remains exposed to the open air for days , without almost any alteration .
This may perhaps be owing either to the larger proportion of ferrugineous parts , with which it is impregnated ; to their being attenuated to a greater degree ; or to their more perfect commixture with the water , by means of the aluminous salt .
The longer time , that any mineral water does remain entire , without any separation of its mineral parts ; or the longer it retains the same form , which it has when newly taken from the spring ; the more perfect is the commixture of these parts with their fluid vehicle : and I believe , upon that account , will be more effectual for medicinal uses : for which reason , I suppose , these waters may prove a more beneficial medicine , than any others of the ferrugineous kind , whose mineral contents are not so intimately commixed with the aqueous fluid .
As these waters are so long in separating their mineral contents , they appear particularly well adapted for being transported to distant places : for by this quality they are fitted to undergo a long carriage , and to be kept a considerable time , without any diminution of their medicinal virtues .
It must also be noticed , that the water of the under well is by much the best of the two for carriage , or for being long kept , as it is longer in separating its mineral contents than the upper one .
From these experiments it is evident , that there is a considerable difference betwixt the waters of the two springs .
The upper one contains a much larger quantity of the ochrous earth , and metalline cremor , than the under one ; which is the reason , why it yields a deeper colour with galls , as may be observed in the first experiment .
I suspected , on the other hand , that the under water contained a greater proportion of alum , than the water of the upper spring ; but this I cannot affirm , as I find I had neglected to make the experiment , which would have determined whether it be so or not .
Tho ' the mineral contents of these two waters be similar , yet , if they be thus mixed in them in different proportions , this must certainly create a difference between them , which deserves to be attended to , as it may be sufficient to disallow of their being used promiscuously , since their medicinal effects may be thereby different .
But now , to sum up the evidence , which these experiments , taken all together , do afford , concerning the mineral ingredients of this Spaw ; I think they determine , with some degree of certainty , that it contains two different principles of iron , both of which are fixed .
The one , which is the ochrous earth , is a true minera ferri , and , altho ' it be a crude mineral , exists in the water in a very fine and subtle form ; the other , which is the cremor or pellicle , whose parts are also extremely attenuated in the water , appears to be iron , not in its mineral , but in its metalline form , and , when thrown up upon the surface of the water , shows itself like an extreme thin lamina of that metal .
There seems also to be some small proportion of sulphur joined with the metalline cremor .
The other mineral ingredient , which enters into the composition of this Spaw , is a considerable proportion of an aluminous salt , which is conjoined with a small quantity of a light brown-coloured earth ( probably a part of the matrix whence the salt is formed ) , and still more intimately connected with some of the chalybeat parts of the water , which are not separable from it either by elixation or evaporation .
Whether these be saline or terrestrial , I cannot determine .
Having thus endeavoured to discover , by some plain and simple experiments , the mineral principles , with which this medicinal water is impregnated ; I shall now only add some observations , with respect to the origin of steel waters , and particularly of this Spaw , whose origin , I think , is thereby discovered and ascertained in a very obvious manner .
Among several things , that are still deficient in the history of mineral waters , an exact knowlege of their origin seems to be the chief ; that is , from what fossils , and in what manner , these waters do acquire the mineral substances , with which they are impregnated .
As this happens in the bowels of the earth , and is therefore far removed from our view , it is not surprising , that there has been so little discovered concerning it ; tho ' indeed there have been many elaborate hypotheses framed in order to account for it .
The writers on mineral waters have been of very different and opposite opinions concerning their origin .
They have disagreed widely amongst themselves ; and I very much suspect , that the accounts , which most of them give of this matter , are not agreeable to truth : particularly with respect to chalybeat waters , I have seen none , who have given a satisfactory account of their origin .
They have all agreed , that iron , or the vitriol of that metal , does exist in mineral waters ; but they have never yet agreed , how they came to exist in them , or in what manner mineral waters come to be imbued with these fossils .
Some of the more ancient writers cannot comprehend , how simple water should be intimately impregnated with so many different kinds of minerals , except by the means of some powerful agent .
And as they thought nothing more proper for communicating and mixing mineral substances with water , than violent heat , they therefore termed all mineral waters , of whatever kind , by the name of thermae .
They saw some spring from the earth extremely hot , others moderately hot , others tepid , others excessively cold : they concluded from this , that all such various degrees of heat in these waters were owing either to the different degree of subterranean fire , which they had undergone ; or else to the great distance , which some of them had run in the earth , after they had been sufficiently heated .
They therefore maintained , that those waters particularly termed acidulae ( the greatest part of which are impregnated with iron ) , or those , which , tho ' intensely cold , contained a large proportion of mineral matter , had in some part of the earth been impregnated with it , by means of an intense heat , which they had been gradually deprived of by a long passage thro ' the colder parts of the earth .
Some naturalists again , of a later date , having exploded the former notion as chimerical , have thought , that a vapour rising from vitriolic minerals , and mixed with the neighbouring streams of water in the bowels of the earth , has imbued them with some of the parts , and with the properties , of vitriol .
Others are of opinion , that the exhalations of vitriolic minerals , passing thro ' the cavities of the earth , are there condensed by the subterraneous cold into a limpid fluid , containing the very finest parts of that mineral salt : which fluid , mixing with the praeterlabent streams of water , and issuing out of the earth with them , produce those mineral springs called vitriolic .
The last opinion I shall mention on this subject , and which indeed appears the most plausible , is of those , who think , that the iron is corroded and dissolved in these waters by means of an acid : for , as they imagine simple water incapable of doing this , they suppose , that it is first imbued with an acid in the bowels of the earth ; and then , by the corrosion of the chalybeat minerals , thro ' which it runs , it comes to be impregnated with them .
I once received this opinion , as the most probable I could then observe , concerning the origin of these springs : yet not as being satisfactory ; for there are many objections against it , which it is difficult either to elude or to answer .
The supposition of an acidity in ferrugineous waters , I thought but ill confirmed , because , upon trial , they discover no vestiges of it , but rather appear to be alkaline .
Besides , in considering the causes of mineral waters , it seems more probable , that whatever minerals they contain , they must be such , as can be received or extracted by common water in its passage thro ' the earth , by solution , abrasion , or the like simple operations ; and in this way alone I think we may come to account not only for the commixtion of the saline and terrene minerals , which are found in medical waters , but likewise of those , that are metalline or sulphureous ; for which simple water , at first sight , may perhaps seem to be an insufficient solvent .
It was this notion , that first induced me to make trial upon various mineral and metallic bodies , in order to know how far they could communicate their virtues to common water by infusion .
I thought this might throw some light upon the origin of mineral waters : yet , tho ' I made a great many experiments of this sort , and particularly upon several kinds of native chalybeat minerals , I was as little satisfied concerning their origin as before .
I at length , however , met , by accident , with what I had inquired after with so little success .
As I happened to be at a gentleman 's house near Edinburgh , in whose estate there was a great deal of coal , and who was at that time working a level or adit , in order to drain off the water , I observed , that the current of water , which flowed from this level , separated a great quantity of ochre , and , emptying itself into a river soon after it came from the entry of the level , tinged all the stones and the channel of the river , for a good way , of an ochrous colour .
The taste of this water was exactly like that of a common steel Spaw ; and it afforded a purple colour with galls * .
As I knew , that this water flowed off a great body of coal , I often infused that fossil , taken from the pits near this level , in common water ; but the infusions never yielded any tincture with galls .
I tried in the same way another mineral , that the miners call blaes ; which is a cliffery stratum of a blueish colour , that often lies both above and below the coal : also another fossil of a brown colour , which is very ponderous , and is called by the miners dogger ; a thin seam of which often lies in the midst of the coal .
However , neither of these would afford an infusion , that would tinge with galls .
At last I got another mineral out of these coalpits , which is sometimes found amongst the coal , but is not so frequent as any of the former ; and this fully * Within two miles of this place there is a steel Spaw of good repute for the performance of several extraordinary cures , which gives the same tincture with galls , and appears in every respect to be the same with the water , that flows from this level .
answered my expectation .
It is found either in round or broad pieces , is exceeding ponderous , and of a shining yellow colour , and is called by the miners brass lumps .
When I infused this mineral for a short time in common water , it communicated to it all the properties of a steel Spaw ; its taste was exactly the same ; and it received a tincture from galls , which was of a more diluted or intense purple , according to the proportion of the mineral added to the water , or to the time of the infusion .
This simple experiment does therefore clearly discover to us the origin of steel waters , and the manner , in which they are impregnated with their mineral contents in the bowels of the earth .
This observation , which I had made concerning the origin of steel waters , led me , when I first visited Hartfell-Spaw , to inquire into the adjacent fossils : which was the more easily done , as the strata of the earth about the well , for a considerable depth , are exposed to view .
After some search among these , I found a stratum of cliffery rock , about three or four feet thick , of a grey colour , and , I think , about twenty paces from the spring .
In some of the hollow places of this rock , where the rain and wind did not reach , I observed a white saline efflorescence on its surface , which when I had taken off and tasted , I concluded , from its styptic and chalybeat taste , that it was a native vitriolum Martis , notwithstanding its white colour ; but I found it , upon trial , to be alum , having some fine attenuated parts of iron conjoined with it , and the same salt with that contained in the Spaw water .
Having taken some pieces of this rock , which were quite free from the saline effervescence , and infused them in common spring-water for some hours , this water did thereby acquire the true taste of the Hartfell-Spaw .
It likewise in the same manner received a deep blue tincture with galls , and contained all the other qualities of that mineral water , without the least difference , that I could observe : which , I think , ascertains the true origin of this mineral spring in the most obvious and undeniable manner .
I am persuaded , that this plain and easy method of investigating the origin of mineral springs is not only superior to the most learned discussions and elaborate theories , but will be found to be the surest , yea~ the only way of extending and completing our knowlege concerning them .
As I have not yet had the opportunity of making the experiments , which I designed , upon the two fossils , that we find to be the cause of the above mineral waters , and which will be necessary to elucidate and complete these observations , which we have made concerning their origin ; I shall now only add one thing , and recommend it to the observation of others : ` ` Whether or not , from such a knowlege of the origin of mineral waters , we may not acquire artificial ones of as great , or perhaps of greater , medicinal use , than those , which are naturally produced ?
' '

