XI .
Extract of a Letter of Mr. Abraham Trembley , F. R. S. to Tho. Birch , D. D. Secret .
R. S. Translated from the French .
SIR , Hague , 1 Feb. 1757 .
I Wrote to you on the 26th of November last , concerning the earthquake felt some time before between the Rhine and the Meuse .
I have been since informed by Professor Donati of Turin , that a slight shock had been perceived there on the 13th of August 1756 , at a quarter after nine in the morning .
It was likewise felt in other parts of Piedmont .
He has also communicated to me an extract of a letter of a professor of Genoa , one of his friends , of which the following is a translation .
Read Feb. 17 , 1757 .
On the 9th of November we felt here two shocks of an earthquake ; one at 20 3/ 4 hours , according to the Italian way of reckoning ; the other at about 4 1/ 2 hours at night .
I did not perceive the first , being then walking in the house ; but I felt the second .
I was then laid down , and going to sleep .
The direction of the undulations was from north to south , as far as I could judge .
' ' Mons. Donati took last summer , according to his custom , a journey , in order to prosecute his researches into natural history .
He was accompanied by Dr. Ascanius , Fellow of the Royal Society ; who was still in doubt about coral 's being a composition of animals .
Mons. Donati carried him to the sea of Provence .
He ordered coral to be fished up in his presence .
He placed it in a large vessel full of water ; and carried this vessel on shore ; where he soon convinced Dr. Ascanius , by his own eyes , that coral is a mass of animals of the polype-kind .
Mons. Donati has written to me , that he has thoroughly satisfied himself by his last observations , that the polypes are fixed to their cells ; of which he had before doubted .
What he says afterwards of coral appears to me to express with more truth and precision what we ought to think of this kind of animals , than any of the descriptions , which have been given since the new discoveries have changed our sentiments on that subject .
Polype-beds , and the cells , which they contain , are commonly spoken of as being the work of polypes .
They are compared to the honeycomb made by bees .
It is more exact to say , that coral , and other coralline bodies , have the same relation to the polypes united to them , that there is between the shell of a snail and the snail itself , or between the bones of an animal , and the animal itself .
Mons. Donati 's words are as follow .
I am now of opinion , that coral is nothing else than a real animal , which has a very great number of heads .
I consider the polypes of coral only as the heads of the animal .
This animal has a bone ramified in the shape of a shrub .
This bone is covered with a kind of flesh , which is the flesh of the animal .
My observations have discovered to me several analogies between the animals of kinds approaching to this .
There are , for instance , keratophyta , which do not differ from coral , except in the bone or part , that forms the prop of the animal .
In the coral it is testaceous , and in the keratophyta it is horny .
' ' The observations , which I have made upon some kinds of polype-beds , lead me to think , that what are called polypes , in those bodies , which are observed to come out of and return into the cells , are more than the heads of the animal .
I have seen some , which had a bag , into which passed their food , which I saw them swallow ; and another bag , into which passed the grossest part of that food , after it was digested .
This is the case , for instance , of the plumed polypes , which I described at the end of the third memoir , in the work published by me on one kind of fresh-water polypes .
Mons. Donati has observed divers very curious facts in the journey , which he made into the mountains .
He has , in particular , traced out an immense bed of marine bodies .
This bed crosses the highest mountains , which separate Provence from Piedmont , and loses itself in the plains of Piedmont .
He has likewise observed a mass of rock , which forms the extremity of a pretty high mountain , the foot of which is washed by the sea .
This rock is , at a considerable height , entirely pierced by pholades , that species of marine shell-fish so well known , which digs cells in the stones .
It appears from hence , that this rock was some time covered by the sea .
According to Mons. Donati , the sea has insensibly retired from the parts , which were washed by it ; and he thinks , that there must have been a very considerable space of time between that and the time , when this mountain , pierced by pholades , was covered by the waters of the sea .
He deduces his opinion from the following fact .
There is in this rock , pretty near the surface of the sea , a natural cavern filled with earth .
In this earth have been found ancient Roman sarcophagi and lamps .
It follows from hence , that even in the time of the Romans this part of the rock , in which this cavern is situated , was not under water .
As there is but a small distance between the cavern and the surface of the water , it follows , that the water has sunk but very little since the time of the Romans .
If it has sunk in the same proportion since the time , when it covered the top of the rock , there is no doubt , but that the time , when it was entirely covered by the sea , must have been very distant .
If the same manner of reasoning be used , with respect to the bed of marine bodies , mentioned above , which crosses the mountains , that separate Provence from Piedmont , we shall be obliged to presume , that the time , when those mountains were under the waters of the sea , was at a very great distance from the present .
Mons. Donati concludes from these facts , and the consequences deduced from them , that the Mediterranean sea is a very ancient , and not a modern one , as Mons. de Buffon imagines .
Those , who explain all the phenomenon of marine bodies found out of the sea , by an universal deluge , do not admit the consequences drawn by Mons. Donati from those marine bodies now under consideration .
It is plain , that most of the naturalists , who have observed a great number of these marine bodies , are not of opinion , that all those phenomenon can be explained by an universal duluge .
Upon these subjects , before we undertake to judge , it is proper to be well informed of the nature of marine fossile bodies , which are found in divers parts , and of their situation and arrangement .
It is necessary likewise to be acquainted quainted with the state of those , which are found actually under the sea , and the revolutions , to which they are subject , while they are covered by it .
It is still farther requisite to have an attention to the revolutions , which have been and are constantly observed , with respect to the sea-shores , which change their situation in several parts , some advancing upon the land , and others retiring .
If all these different facts be compared together , it will not be doubted , but there are actually under the earth marine bodies , which are found there only in consequence of these slow revolutions , and not of an universal deluge .
Perhaps this notion might be extended to the greatest part of the marine fossile bodies , which are known to us .
Mons. Donati informs me , that he would be glad to present to the Royal Society an history of coral , if he thought , that it would be agreeable to them .

