CVI .
An Account of Mr. Samuel Tull 's Method of castrating Fish .
Communicated by W. Watson , F. R. S. To the Royal Society .
Gentlemen , SEveral years since , Mr. Tull of Edmonton performed the operation of castrating fishes , before Sir Hans Sloane , Bart. and several members of the Royal Society , who met at Sir Hans 's house for that purpose .
About five or six years ago he performed the same operation in presence of our late worthy President Mr. Folks , myself , and several others .
Among these was a very valuable member of this Society , Mr. Trembley , who is with the Duke of Richmond on his travels , and is now at Feltzberg in Austria , at a country-seat of the Prince of Lichtenstein .
This nobleman , who is a great lover of natural history , as well as a zealous promoter of useful knowlege , is very curious in whatever relates to the history of fishes ; and being informed by Mr. Trembley , that he had seen fishes castrated in England , and of the advantages which he had been assured did result from it , his highness entreated him to procure him from hence the most exact account of the manner of performing this operation , and of several particulars relating thereto .
Read Dec. 19 , 1754 .
Mr. Trembley accordingly wrote me a letter , desiring me , if possible , to transmit to him this information .
In consequence of which , I wrote to Mr. Tull , who in a few days was so obliging as to answer my letter , and to send me what I had requested of him , and which I accordingly have transmitted to Mr. Trembley , for the Prince of Lichtenstein .
But as nothing of this sort has been communicated to the Royal Society , as a body , I thought it not improper to lay before you Mr. Tull 's account of his operation ; that , if it be thought worthy , it might be recorded in the journals and register-books of the Society .
In England , where in many parts sea-fish are in great plenty , the fish of rivers and ponds are less esteemed ; and improvements , either with regard to their bulk or increase , are less attended to : but in Germany , remote from the sea , where pond-fish are a great article of traffic , Mr. Tull 's method may be of great use .
Mr. Tull informs me , that he castrates both the male and female fish ; and that , although almost any time is proper for the operation , the least so is just after they have spawned , as the fish then are too weak and languid to bear , with success , so severe an operation .
The most eligible time however is when the ovaries of the female have their ova in them , and when the vessels of the male , analogous to these , have their seminal matter in them ; inasmuch as at this time these vessels are more easily distinguished from the ureters , which convey the urine from the kidneys into the bladder and are situate near the seminal vessels on each side of the spine .
These may , without sufficient attention , be taken for the ovaries ; and the more so , when these last are empty .
When fishes have spawned a few weeks , they are fit for the operation ; for , like hens , they have small eggs in their ovaries as soon as they have laid their former clutch of eggs .
When a fish is intended to be castrated , it must be held in a wet cloth , with its belly upwards ; then with a sharp pen-knife , with its point bent backwards , or other well-adapted instrument , the operator cuts through the integuments of the rim of the belly , and in doing this he carefully avoids wounding any of the intestines .
As soon as a small aperture is made , he carefully inserts a hooked pen-knife , and with this he dilates this aperture from between the two fore-fins , almost to the anus .
From the back of this instrument , being blunt , the danger of wounding the intestines is avoided .
He then , with two small blunt silver hooks , of five or six inches long , and of the * form hereunder described , by the help of an assistant , holds open the belly of the fish ; and , with a spoon or spatula , removes carefully the intestines from one side .
When these are removed , you see the ureter , a small vessel , nearly in the direction of the spine ; and at the same time the ovary , a larger vessel , lying before it , that is , nearer the integuments of the belly .
This last vessel you take up with a hook of the same kind with those before-mentioned , and detaching it from the side far enough for the purpose , divide ~ it transversely with a pair of sharp scissors ; remem* ~ ~ Mr. Tull has frequently , to prevent the re-union of the divided ovaries , by which the effect of the operation might be defeated , taken out part of them , and nevertheless the fish have survived .
bering always , that great care is taken in not wounding , or otherwise injuring , the intestines .
After one of the ovaries has been divided , proceed in the like manner to divide the other ; and then sew up the divided integuments of the belly with silk , inserting the stitches at a very small distance one from the other .
Mr. Tull first put this method into practice , in order to prevent the excessive increase of fish in some of his ponds , where the number did not permit any of them to grow to an advantageous size .
But from castration the increase was not only prevented , but the castrate fish , as Mr. Tull asserts , grew much larger than their usual size , were more fat , and , which is no trifling consideration , were always in season .
He observes further , that the spawning-time is very various : that trouts , for instance , are full about Christmas ; perch in February ; pikes in March ; and carp and tench in May .
You must always , however , make some allowance for climate and situation , with regard to the spawning of fish .
And , from a very diligent attention , he assures me , that he has been able to settle a point much controverted by naturalists , in relation to the copulation of fishes .
The most generally received opinion has been , that they did not copulate ; but that the female did cast her spawn in the water , and that then it was fecundated by the spermatic matter of the male .
Mr. Tull , in contradiction to this hypothesis , asserts , that he has frequently seen fishes in actual copulation ; and that this is generally done before the ova arrive at maturity .
After Mr. Tull has castrated his fish , they are put into the water where they are intended to continue .
He makes no particular appropriation , neither with regard to the ponds into which they are put , nor does he give them any particular nourishment ; but they take their chance in common with other fish , as though they were not castrated .
And he informs me further , that if tolerable care is taken , very few fish die of the operation , when performed in the manner here described ; though heretofore , when , instead of the belly , he made the opening in the sides of the fish , numbers died , from his wounding the intestines , and frequently dividing the ureters .
I am , with all possible respect , Gentlemen , London , Dec. Your most obedient humble servant , 11 , 1754 .
William Watson .

