Philos. Trans. Vol. XLVIII TAB. XXXIV .
p. 803 .
&amp;c. 2345 12 6 78 9 10 XCVII .
A Dissertation on the Belemnites , in a Letter to Smart Lethieullier , Esquire , F. R. S. by Mr. Gustavus Brander , F. R. S. SIR , IT is owing to the pleasure of some late conversations with you , upon the subject of natural history in general ( in which I am always sure to profit ) , that I now take the liberty to offer you my sentiments concerning the belemnites .
Read Nov. 21 .
1754 .
The belemnites is a fossil , that has hitherto perplexed the naturalists of all countries : it has been treated of by various authors , and in turn been ascribed to all the three kingdoms of nature ; but , apprehending the road to truth still open , I am encouraged to resume the subject once more , and beg leave to deliver it as my opinion , that it belongs to the testaceous part of the animal kingdom , and to the family of the nautili .
The nautilus , or sailor , is a concamerated shell , with a syphunculus running through every cell , see Tab. XXXIV .
Fig. 1 .
The syphunculus , and the concamerations , are the generical character of this tribe , and are supposed to serve the animal to buoy up its shell , by which means it can swim or sink at pleasure .
Those that are curved are very common both in the recent and fossil state : the strait ones have hitherto only been met with fossil , and are common enough in Sweden , Livonia , and several parts of Germany ; and have , by naturalists , been called or5 I2 thoceratitae ; thoceratitae ; nay , I have seen some in Dr. Mason 's private collection at Cambridge , which he told me were found in England , and , I think , came from Whitby ; the character of which being exactly the same with the nautili , I make no scruple to class them together .
Whosoever will examine nicely bodies of any genera , will have a difficulty to say , where they begin , and where they end ; the gradation is so insensible , that they must be bewildered .
From the orthoceratitae , which is undoubtedly a species of nautilus , we gradually proceed to the belemnites .
The orthoceratites is a strait concamerated shell , ending in a point ; some of which I have seen in stone eighteen inches long ; see Fig. 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , and 12 .
The nucleus , or alveolus , of the belemnites is likewise a strait concamerated shell or body , exactly resembling the other in shape and structure , but of a smaller species , Fig. 6 and 10 ; and , I think , from the very great analogy , may reasonably be deemed to be of the same family .
In the conic cavity of the belemnites , Fig. 7 .
that contains the nucleus , it is very common to observe visible marks of a shelly substance , as a farther confirmation that the nucleus was a testaceous body .
And now a word as to the belemnites itself , the counter-part to the other .
It has indeed been truly matter of speculation , how that huge solid substance called the belemnites , exclusive of the nucleus , could be formed ; and how it happens that some should have the nucleus within them , others not ; the cavity to contain the same in some very small , in others scarce or not at all visible .
These , I think , are the main difficulties , all which I shall endeavour to elucidate ; but must first acknowledge myself obliged to Monsieur de Peysonnel , and particularly to my worthy and ingenious friend Mr. John Ellis , F. R. S. for their curious observations on the nature of coral , upon which this latter part of my hypothesis is founded .
They have , I think , plainly demonstrated , that many bodies which we always took to be vegetable from their appearance , are really animal , and constructed by the polyp ; and that several coralline substances , hitherto reputed marine plants , are thick beset with a prodigious quantity of seedling-shells ( too small for the naked eye to see ) , close by each other , as diamonds in a bodkin , ready to come forth in due time out of their several nests or cellules ; see Philosophical Transactions , Vol. 47 .
page .
445 .
and Vol. 48 .
Tab. V. page .
115 .
Whereupon I very humbly submit , if it is not highly probable that the testaceous tribe in general are generated like butterflies , and flies of all kinds , the one from a maggot , the other from a polyp ?
Nay , it appears presumptive to me , that it must be so with a great many .
On which circumstances I proceed , that as corals in general , from late observation , seem to be constructed by polypi , what inconsistency then to believe them to be the primary state of all or most of the testaceous tribe ?
If so , it is almost beyond a conjecture , that the body called a belemnites ( which , on being put into acids , is found to ferment in like manner as coral , and other cretaceous ceous bodies ) , is formed likewise by a polyp , from which the nucleus seems to be the ultimate state .
And I further submit , whether this concamerated shell , or body , of which the belemnites is only the habitation , does not appear a strong voucher for this new hypothesis , by more immediately leading us into the connexion and manner of generation ( perhaps particular to the testaceous tribe ) by remaining within its nidus all its life ; whereas the generality quit them so soon as they are able to shift for themselves .
The polyp is an animal of the vermicular kind ; the bodies of some are long and slender , like a fine sinew or fibre , extremely tender ; and from the head proceeds a variety of claws , or arms , with which it catches its food , and prepares its habitation , or chrysalis .
They are without doubt of various shapes and textures , according ( as I suppose ) to the species of the animal that is hereafter to proceed from them * ; and very wonderful it is , how so small , so delicate an animal , should be capable of forming so large a body as the belemnites !
but is not every particular performance of nature equally the same to a diligent inquirer ?
so that I conceive the less cause against this opinion ; more especially as late authors have pretty clearly demosnstrated , that corals of much greater magnitude are constructed by them .
Some animals in the terrestrial part of the creation , naturally associate and herd together .
Others again seek * Mr. Henry Baker , F. R. S. has very ingeniously delineated a great variety of species of them , in his treatises on the polyp , and upon the microscope observed in fresh water .
solitude .
The same dispositions we find impressed on those of the aquatic system : then why not among the polypi ?
as is evidently seen from the prodigious variety of coral bodies , where it seems in some as if thousands acted in concert together ; in others , where each acts for itself ; of which latter is the belemnites .
The shape of the belemnites is generally more or less conic , terminating in a point , and of various colours , according to the juices of the stratum in which it lay : it has usually a seam or fissure , running down the whole length of it , sometimes filled with a cretaceous substance .
In some it is in the middle or axis of the body ; in others on one side .
Its interior constitution seems composed of several conoid cortices , or crusts , which , when broken transversely , appear to proceed in striae or rays from the seam or centre ; which seam I take to have been the habitation or cell of the animal in its polyp state , and in which the body was affixed ; or perhaps serving as a syphunculus , in which was a ligament that proceeded from the nucleus in its perfect state .
The crusts that it is composed of , I should apprehend , denote certain periods in the age of the animal ; as the annual rings in a piece of timber , its age : but what those periods are , we are unacquainted with ; see Fig. 7 , 8 , 9 , and 11 .
The animals of the testaceous tribe in general , as they increase in age , increase their shell in thickness , until they have lived their stated time , or attained to good old age ; and that is done by adding a new crust or lamina to it , as several , if not all the tubuli , the oysters , and the nautili , witness ( but these observations are best made on fossil bodies , when , by great length of time the immediate cause of their adhesion becomes weakened , and displays to view their texture ) ; after which they grow inactive and dull , the effect of extreme old age , suffering other marine bodies , as worms , oysters , &amp;c. to penetrate and affix themselves to their outer coat .
The like appearances we frequently meet with on belemnitae , when the animal within , I suppose , was either waxed old , or dead ; and is an additional proof that the body is of marine origin .
Every one , that has made this part of natural history his study , must have observed , that the minutiae , or exceeding small fossil shells , very frequently occur , and in the greatest abundance , especially in fine loam or clay proper to preserve them : which shows that it was spring or spawning-time when the deluge overwhelmed the country they were natives of .
And that diminishes one of the difficulties concerning the belemnites , why some have the cavity , others not , or but very small : for may we not attribute these several appearances to the different ages of the animal ; as in the spring or spawning-time , and some time after , a thousand small fish appear in the water to one grown to maturity , or seedlings on the shores of shell-fish , to one at full growth ?
and , from a parity of reasoning , is there not great likelihood to believe that every bellemnites would have had a nucleus , if it had lived ?
and to suppose that deficiency to be caused by the deluge coming on , in the early part of the season , in that spot whereof they are natives , before they had attained perfection ?
Not that I doubt of there being the same variety of species among the belemnitae as of any other tribe in the testaceous kingdom , we are convinced of that : but let us , for argument sake , suppose , that many never would have had a nucleus , that still does not hinder , but that the body itself might be formed by a polype , only of a different species from those , that have the nucleus .
And after all , if it should yet be objected , that the animal , though ever so small , would retain the exact shape of what it would be in future , let them have recourse to the fine collection of shells of my good friend Mr. Arthur Pond , F. R. S. where they may trace many families of shells from their minute state , and see the regular progressions of the animal , till it has attained full growth ; by which it will appear , that the resemblance is often very small between their first and last state .
The country of the belemnitae is unknown to us ; but there is great probability it is the same with that of the conchae anomiae in general , and ammonitae ; since they are usually found together , and are well supposed to be the inhabitants of deep or unknown seas , beyond human reach .
And now , Sir , having had so frequent occasion to mention the orthoceratitae in the course of this subject , they being here rare and uncommon fossils , I have given the figures of some few species of them , which perhaps may not be unacceptable , No. 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , and 12 .
If it should be asked , whether they proceed likewise from a belemnites ?
I answer , that I suppose them to proceed from a polype like the rest , but whether their parent polype formed itself a belemnites-like chrysalis or habitation ( being a stouter animal ) , is more than I can affirm , although very probable , as the terminating point in them is as sharp and fine as the nucleus of the belemnites ; and it is observed , that all the turbinated shells increase their circumvolutions from the point , or apex ; but that is not the immediate business of the present purpose , as nature has many ways to compass her ends .
My design will be answered , if it shall only be thought , that I have evinced the belemnites to be an animal production , formed by a polype , as other coralline bodies ; and its nucleus to be a concamerated testaceous body , of the nautili genus , proceeding therefrom .
Such is my hypothesis of this hitherto not sufficiently explained body ; which I candidly submit to better judgments , to approve or reject , as reason shall appear .
I am , with perfect regard , SIR , London , Nov. Your most obedient humble servant , 14 , 1754 .
Gustavus Brander .
Description of the PLAT E. No~ 1 .
A section of a common nautilus .
2 , 3 , 5 , and 12 .
Sections of orthoceratitae .
4 .
An orthoceratites entire .
6 .
A section of a belemnites , with the nucleus .
7 .
Ditto , without the nucleus .
8 .
An oblique section of a belemnites , to show the inward structure .
9 .
A belemnites without a cavity , only a small perforation .
10 .
A nucleus of a belemnites .
11 .
A belemnites , with a very small cavity .

