A Letter from the Reverend William Brakenridge , D.D. and F.R.S. to George Lewis Scot , Esq ; F. R. S. concerning the Number of Inhabitants within the London Bills of Mortality .
Dear Sir , ASI have lately had the curiosity to consider , the number of inhabitants in London and Westminster , whether they increase or decrease ; I presume to send you the observations I have made .
For as no one understands numbers better than yourself , your approbation will much confirm me in my opinion , and perhaps have weight with many others ; when you can easily find out any paralogism or mistake , that I may have made .
And if you can spare any time from your great employment , to think upon the subject , and to rectify any thing that may be amiss in my method of computeing ; it will be very obliging .
Read Nov. 21 , 1754 .
I have consulted the yearly bills of mortality for the last fifty years , which I imagine will be sufficient for my purpose ; and from them I have extracted all the numbers of the baptisms and burials , both within the walls of London , and at large within the bills : for I thought that within the city walls , where the number of houses is nearly known , the baptisms and burials might be very useful to reason upon , concerning the whole inhabitants both within and without .
And because it may be surer , to compute from a number of years taken at an average , than from the numbers in any one year as they stand in the bills ; I have taken the sums of the numbers , for each five years of the fifty , and then the fifth part of each of these sums ; which will at a medium be the number for any particular year .
And in like manner , I have taken the sums of the numbers for each ten years , and the tenth part of each of the sums will be the number for any year , at an average .
And the numbers so found will appear thus : Years .
Baptisms .
Burials .
Baptisms .
Burials .
17048 1870 2553 15867 22103 1709-13 1805 2551 15288 21701 1714-18 1890 2706 17586 24641 1719-23 1871 2719 18360 26978 1724-28 1829 2727 18442 27670 1729-33 1578 2532 17452 26267 1734-38 1406 2242 16762 26165 1739-43 1221 2397 15034 28219 1744-48 1062 1989 14402 23884 1749-53 1087 1790 14850 22006 1704-13 1837 2552 15577 21602 1714-23 1880 2712 18073 25809 1724-33 1703 2647 17920 27168 1734-43 1313 2320 15898 27192 1744-53 1074 1890 14626 22945 Where the numbers are ranged in five columns .
The first denotes the years , the second and third the baptisms and burials within the city walls , and the third and fourth show the baptisms , and burials at large within the bills .
Thus , for instance , 22945 is the number of burials , at a medium , for any of the ten years within the bills from 1744 to 1753 inclusive .
And in like manner , 1221 is the number of baptisms for any year , at an average for five years , from 1739 to 1743 inclusive , and so of others .
The numbers above the line are computed for five years , and those below are for ten .
In the burials it is always to be considered , that there are perhaps 2000 more , than what the bills represent them .
For there are burying-grounds belonging to the Protestant Dissenters , the Quakers , and the Jews ; of which there is no account taken , and that are very considerable .
In the first of which in Bunyan-Fields , I have been informed there are about 400 burials in the year , and in the others , together , there may be about 400 more ; which sum of 800 we may suppose comes from all parts within the bills .
But I think the one-half , viz. 400 , must at least come from within the city ; where there are most Protestant Dissenters and Jews .
So that 400 may always be added to the burials , within the city .
It is likewise to be remembered , that both from within and without the city , a great many burials go out into the country , of which there is no notice taken .
But from what I have observed , if we were to suppose , that there are 1200 in the whole , carried out into the country , over and above the 800 mentioned above , in the burying-grounds ; I should imagine that to be the outmost .
And therefore in our calculations we shall suppose 2000 burials yearly , more than in the bills at large .
And which , whether we are exact enough or not in the supposition , will by no means hinder us to discover the increase , or decrease of the people .
It is next to be observed , that in the bills the baptisms are always about two-fifth parts at least , less than the burials , with the numbers added to them above-mentioned ; and that this difference within the city seems continually to increase , so that it is much greater now than it was some years ago ; which appears plainly to arise from two causes ; the number of Dissenters of various denominations , and the multitude of people that live unmarried .
But I think it is rather owing to the last : for in London and Westminster the one-half of the people at least live single , that are above twenty-one years of age ; which must prevent almost as many more births , that might be reasonably expected .
And this is not mere conjecture ; for I have had some proof from a particular detail given me of one parish within the city ; where the greater part of those that are above that age are single .
In the natural state of mankind it seems plain , that the number of births should be greater than the burials , and I believe that in many parishes in the country they are near double .
I found it so in the Isle of Wight , where I lived some time , and had an opportunity to see their registers ; for there the births were generally near double .
And even in London , before the great fire in 1666 , it appears , from some parish registers , that the baptisms were near about equal to the burials , and never afterwards : the reason of which I do not understand , unless it be that more people were then married , and that from that time there was a greater confluence of strangers : for there certainly were more Dissenters at that time than ever after .
It is farther to be observed , that in the bills from the year 1704 to the year 1728 , without the city , both the number of christenings and burials continually increased ; and that from that time to 1743 , they continued nearly the same ; but that after 1743 they gradually decreased till this time ; which plainly shows , that the inhabitants were increasing till about the year 1728 ; and that from thence to 1743 , they remained in the same state nearly ; but that afterwards , during the last ten years , till 1753 , they were constantly diminishing .
For it is evident , that the number of inhabitants must always be in proportion , to the number of births , and burials considered together .
And hence it appears , that the cities of London and Westminster , were in the most flourishing state , with regard to numbers , from 1728 to 1743 , and that they are now past their height , and in the same state they were in the year 1708 ; and the first decrease seems to have been at the beginning of the last French war , which was in 1744 .
Within the city walls the number of the inhabitants do not seem to fluctuate , in the same periods of time , as without ; for the most numerous state of the city , appears to have been from the year 1718 , to the year 1728 , and then after that they have been continually decreasing : so that when they were most numerous within the walls , they were not then arrived at the height without ; and when they were in the highest state without , they were diminishing in the city .
Perhaps the vast number of new buildings , within the liberties of Westminster , may have in part caused this diminution .
And as from the year 1718 , within the city , the christenings have been so remarkably decreasing , that they are now but threefifths of what they were at that time , and the burials are likewise diminished above one-fourth in the last five years ; this seems to show that the inhabitants within the city walls must be near one-fourth fewer , than they were in the year 1718 .
Now , in order to calculate the number of inhabitants , it will be necessary to observe , that in a year in London there generally dies one person in thirty .
This Sir William Petty has long ago observed ; and I have found it to be near the truth , upon consulting my parish register .
For in the parish of Bassishaw , London , there are not above 800 people , as appears from an account that I had lately given me : And the burials for the last ten years in the whole amount to 262 ; which at a medium gives 26 for one year , which is the thirtieth part of 800 nearly .
In some parishes in London there die more than in this proportion , as in St. Giles 's Cripplegate ; and in others in the out-parts of the town there die fewer ; but I believe , in general it will hold true , in and about the city .
In the town of Breslaw in Germany , from which Dr. Halley formed his famous table for the probabilities of life , there die about two in sixty-nine , that is less than one in thirty-four ; as is plain from an easy computation .
But there certainly die more than in that proportion , within the London bills ; for it appears , that one-third at least of the children die under two years of age ; whereas at Breslaw there die under that age , only one-fifth ; and therefore the difference being two-fifteenths , or four-thirtieths , there die four in thirty more at London than at Breslaw , under two years of age .
In the country the case is very different ; for there does not die above one in fifty , in healthy places .
Sir William Petty has likewise observed this , and I have found it true .
For in the parish of Newchurch in the Isle of Wight , where I resided some time , there are about 900 people , and there does not die , at a medium , above eighteen yearly ; which is one in fifty exactly .
And I believe this will be found to be nearly the same , in most of the counties in Britain , where the people do not live in great towns ; which shows the great difference between the effects of the air , in London and the country .
If then it be allowed , that in London and Westminster there dies one in thirty , it will be very easy to make a calculation of the whole number of the people nearly , that are within the bills .
For if we take the number of burials at an average for some years , and multiply that by 30 , the product must be the number of the people .
Thus if we take the number of the burials , at large within the bills , for any one of the last ten years , at a medium , from 1744 to 1753 inclusive , to be 22945 , and add to this 2000 , for those burials omitted in the bills , as is supposed above , the total will be 24945 , all the burials within the limits of the bills , for one year at 1753 ; and then multiply this by 30 , the product 748350 will be the whole number of the people nearly , at present .
But if we take 27192 , the number of the burials , at a medium , for any one of the ten years preceeding 174 inclusive , and add to this 2000 , as above ; the whole of the burials at that time within the bills will be 29192 , which being multiplied by 30 gives 875760 , for the number of the people at the year 1743 .
And therefore the inhabitants are fewer now than they were in 1743 , by 127000 .
I have taken the numbers , at a medium , for ten years , to avoid any uncertainty , that might arise about a computation for a single year .
If we were to try the same calculation , by taking the burials , at a medium , only for five years to 1753 , and also for five years to 1743 inclusive , the difference will be greater .
For the numbers at these two times will be 720180 , and 906570 , of which the difference is 186390 ; so that the people would appear fewer at 1753 than they were in 1743 , by 186000 .
But this is not so much to be depended upon as the numbers above ; because there were two extraordinary bills at 1740 and 1741 .
Or if we should imagine that there might not more die at London than at Breslaw , that is one in thirty-four , still the difference would be greater than we found at first .
For taking the burials at an average for ten years , at 1753 and 1743 , as above , the numbers would at these two times be 848130 and 9925~8 , of which the difference is 144398 ; so that it seems plain , if the bills are to be depended upon , that there is a decrease of the people since 1743 of above an hundred thousand , and that at present the number is about 740000 .
And this decrease has been annually continued : for if we try the thing farther , at the distance of five years , and take at a medium for five years , the burials for 1753 and 1748 , the numbers will come out 720180 and 776520 ; of which the difference is 56340 , the number decreased for the last five years .
There is another way of computing from the number of houses ; but I think this not so certain as the other .
For here are two difficulties , to ascertain the number of houses , and to fix on the number of persons for each house .
As to the last , Sir William Petty thought we might allow eight persons to a house ; which I have found to be a mistake .
I have made an experiment of it , and got an exact account of the numbers in each house in a certain parish in London ; and I find that they exactly come to six in a house , empty and full together , for there is seldom above one in twenty empty .
And as in that parish the people are in a middle condition , and some of them have a number of servants ; it may be presumed they are in a middle state with regard to numbers , between the very great families and those in the lowest rank .
This is also confirmed , if we allow , as above , one in thirty to die yearly in London .
For within the city walls there were 11857 houses in the 97 parishes , as appears from Mr. Smart 's account , which was supposed to be very accurate at that time : But since he published that in 1741 , there are not so many houses within the city walls ; for in many parishes there are houses greatly enlarged , some rebuilt in place of two or three , and warehouses made of others .
I know some parishes in which there is one in twenty fewer than in his time .
In others perhaps there is no alteration .
But I think they must , at an average , be diminished three in an hundred at least ; and consequently sequently there are about 354 fewer , and the number of houses within the city walls is about 11503 ; which being multiplied by 6 , gives 69018 , for the number of inhabitants ; which is nearly equal to the burials 2290 multiplied by 30 , or 68700 ; taking the burials at a medium for ten years , and adding 400 as above .
The number of houses within the bills may then be nearly come at , from the number of burials .
For if we take the number of burials , for the last ten years , at an average , within the city to be 1890 , and add 400 , which makes 2290 , we may say , if 2290 comes from 11503 houses , then the whole number 24945 of burials within the bills , having allowed 2000 as above , must come from 125302 houses .
And there cannot be fewer ; for there are more burials within the city , in proportion to the baptisms , than in the out-parishes ; and therefore more burials in proportion to the number of houses ; which shows that the number of houses cannot be less than 125302 ; which being multiplied by 6 , will give 751812 , for the number of people for this present time ; and it is nearly equal to the number 748350 found above .
So that the numbers produced from these two methods being almost equal , this is some farther proof that our supposition of six persons to a house , empty and full , is near to the truth .
But if we suppose , that the number of houses within the walls is now the same , as in Mr. Smart 's time , 11857 ; then all the houses within the bills will be 129158 , and the number of people 774948 greater than 748350 , found above , by 26598 ; which is not much in such calculations .
Sir William Petty likewise says , that he was informed there were 84000 houses tenanted within the bills , in the year 1682 , in which he wrote ; and if so , the number of houses seem to be increased , near one-third since that time .
And , according to our way of computing , to suppose six to a house , empty and full , there could not be more than 504000 people at that time ; which is less than the number we found above for the present time , 748350 , by 244350 .
But now , instead of increasing , we are decreasing ; for since the year 1743 the inhabitants have been annually diminished ; by which it appears that this great city is past its height , and is rather upon the decline with regard to numbers .
And hence we see how far Sir William was mistaken , who imagined that it might increase continually till the year 1800 ; when the number of people would be five millions , that is near seven times as much as they are at present .
Now , to account for this decrease there may be various conjectures : I think three causes may be assigned , that may all operate jointly .
One may be the vicious custom that has prevailed of late years , among the lower people , of drinking spirituous liquors ; another the fashionable humour of living single , that daily increases ; and a third may be the great increase of trade in the northern parts of Britain , that keeps the people there employed at home , that they have no occasion , as formerly , to come hither for business ; and it were to be wished that this cause was the most prevailing .
But whatever be the cause , it seems plain to me , that it could not be the late French war , as some imagine .
For by what was shown above , there has been a decrease of 56000 since the year 1749 , after the peace ; but if the war had been the cause , there ought rather ~ have been an increase after it .
And as in the whole , we could not have lost more than 150000 , in the war by land and sea , of which there was not onefifth , or 30000 , taken from about the city ; this can never account for 64000 , the decrease before the year 1748 .
In the former war , between 1702 and 1711 , the city never decreased , but continually increased : from which one would imagine that the last war could not diminish its numbers .
Nor can this decrease in the bills be accounted for , from a greater number than formerly leaving the town in summer ; because it does not appear that there is a greater number of such , than was ten years ago .
And if it could be allowed that the number was greater , it can never be thought that it can amount to 120000 more than in year 1743 .
It is true , this decrease may appear suprising to some , when they see the number of new buildings in Westminster , continually increasing ; but then , on the other hand , it is likewise to be considered , that there are a great number of houses enlarged , or re~ , in place of two or three others , as mentioned above ; and others ~ in , and empty , about the eastern parts of the city : so that for the last twenty years the inhabitants seem only to be moving , from the eastern to the western parts ~ the town , and not increasing .
And now , Sir , I am afraid I have ~ you with this long letter , in which I have endeavoured to represent the present circumstances of this great ~ .
with regard to numbers , and , if I have committed any mistake , I hope your usual goodness will excuse , Dear Sir , Sion-College , Novem .
20 , Your most obedient servant , 1754 .

