LXXXVIII .
Extract of a Letter from John Lining , M. D. of Charles Town , in South Carolina , to Charles Pinckney , Esq ; in London : With his Answers to several Queries sent to him concerning his Experiment of Electricity with a Kite .
Charles Town , January 14 , 1754 .
Enclosed I send you answers to the queries , which you sent me concerning the experiment with the kite .
Read May 4 , 1754 .
Since I made that experiment last May , I have not had an opportunity of making any more , having been confined all the summer and autumn with the gout , which perhaps prevented my meeting with the same unhappy fate with professor Richman .
In the London Daily Advertiser , Thursday 27 September last , there is a more particular account of that unhappy accident .
From that account it appears , that the professor had a wire , which came down from the iron rod , erected on his house , through the galleryceiling , to an iron bar , which stood in a glass vessel , which was filled with water and filings of brass ; and that the professor stood so near that iron rod , that his face was within a foot of it .
Now if there was no wire , that went from that iron rod , or from any part of the wire above it , into the earth , it is no great wonder , that the professor was killed .
I should be extremely glad to be informed , whether the iron rod upon his house , at the time the experiment was made , had any communication , by means of metal , with the earth .
For , if it had , there is then more danger attending these experiments than I imagined .
It is likewise said in that paper , that from the electrical needle , which he observed , there was no danger .
I am at a loss to know what that electrical needle was , and should be glad to be informed .
I know , that a magnetic needle placed on a sharp point upon the prime conductor , as soon as the conductor is sufficiently electrified , will move round with so great rapidity , that in the dark the electricity , thrown off from both poles of the needle , will appear like a circle of fire .
Answers of Dr. Lining to the Queries sent to him .
Query 1 .
In what manner , and of what materials , was your kite , and the string , by which you flew it , made ?
and to what height did it rise above the earth ?
Answer .
The kite , which I used , was made in the common way ; only , in place of paper , I covered it with a silk , called alamode .
The line was a common small hempen one of three strands .
A silk line , except it had been kept continually wet , would not conduct the electricity ; and a wire , besides other inconveniences , would have been too heavy .
I had not any instrument , whereby I could take the height of the kite ; but , I believe , it was at least 250 feet high .
It was flown in the day-time .
Query 2 .
You say also , ` ` All the electrical fluid , or lightning , was drawn from the cloud , and discharged in the air ; and a greater degree of serenity succeeded , and no more of the awful noise of thunder , before expected , was heard .
' ' Now I should be glad you would inform us , whether the serenity in the air you mention , was such , as generally follows , after the clouds in the summer thunderstorms have discharged several loud thunder-claps ; and whether any flashes of lightning appeared in the skies , after you had discharged the cloud of its lightning by the kite , as commonly do after a thunder-storm is over in a summer 's night ?
For if there were no appearance of such flashes , then , I think , your assertion , that all the electric fluid , or lightning , was drawn from the cloud , stands fully proved ; but if there were such flashes after , I conceive there must have been some of the electrical matter left behind .
Answer .
During the time of my drawing the lightning from the cloud , and for some little time afterwards , it rained ; by which means , the body of the cloud being diminished , a greater degree of serenity necessarily succeeded ; and the quantity of lightning extracted from the cloud , or rather its atmosphere , proved sufficient to prevent any thunder in town that afternoon ; though there was a great appearance of thunder before the kite was raised .
But whether the same serenity succeeded , as frequently happens after a thunder-storm , and whether there were any flashes of lightning seen in the evening , I cannot now recollect .
If such flashes had afterwards been seen in the skies , as is common in a summer 's evening , especially after a thunder-storm , those might proceed from other clouds , which had passed the town , at too great a distance to be acted upon by the kite .
If three electrified clouds ( which we shall call ) A , B , and C , pass from west to east , and are so situated to one another , and to this town , that the cloud B is not only in breadth and length equal to the area of the town , but vertical over it , having an electrical atmosphere , which reaches low enough to be acted upon by sharp points , either raised by kites , or erected upon the houses ; then the cloud B may be so far deprived of its electricity , before it has passed over the town , as to be incapable of giving any flashes of lightning , till it meets with other less electrified clouds , and approaches very near them .
But the clouds A and C , being at too great a distance , in their passage by the town , to be acted upon by those points , fly on in their electrical state , till they meet with clouds , or other bodies , in a non-electric state , or at least with those , which have a less degree of electricity .
If the cloud ( suppose ) A meets , or rather approaches afterwards near enough , the cloud B , which was deprived of great part of its electricity , or any other non-electric cloud , it will discharge at once part of its electricity into B , or the non-electric cloud ; and if into the latter , which we shall call D , in that explosion , it will deliver so much of its electricity to D , as will make an equilibrium in electricity between them ; i. e. if A had 100 degrees of electricity , and D only its natural quantity , after the explosion , each will have 50 .
Then D is in a condition to flash into a non-electric cloud ; but that explosion will be much weaker than that was from A ; because D , in exploding into a non-electric cloud , will only part with one-half ( if those two clouds are of equal dimensions ) ; that is with 25 degrees grees of its electricity .
But if it exploded upon a house , tree , or the like , the loudness of that explosion would be equal to the first ; as in this case , it has an opportunity of parting , at once , with its whole charge of electricity , which , by supposition , was 50 .
Hence we see , that one electrified cloud only may be productive of many claps of thunder ; and that those proceeding originally from that cloud , will become weaker , as the whole quantity of electricity may at last be divided amongst many clouds ; and from hence several phenomenon , which appear during a thunder-storm , and which succeed it , may be accounted for .
If therefore any flashes of lightning were seen that evening , after the experiment with the kite , you see how those might be produced , whether the cloud was deprived of its electricity or not .
Electrified clouds have an electrical atmosphere , as well as the prime-conductor , when it is electrified ; and the diameter of that atmosphere , caeteris paribus , will bear some proportion to the size of the cloud .
My smallest prime-conductor is two inches and an half in diameter ; and when it is fully charged , its atmosphere extends to the distance of about three feet from the surface of the conductor .
How great then must the extent be of the atmosphere , which surrounds a large cloud fully electrified ?
It perhaps may extend to many hundreds of feet round the cloud , and may even reach so low as to touch the surface of the earth : And when that is the case , a man , or a rod of metal , placed on a cake of resin on the ground , may be electrified , and yield sparks of fire .
When a sharp point is presented to that atmosphere , it cannot deprive the cloud of its whole quantity of electricity , except the sharp point be so near , that the cloud may explode upon it ; and , in that case , the cloud must have a communication with the ground , by means of some non-electric body .
Suppose an electrified cloud to have an atmosphere , which extends round it to the distance of 90 feet from its surface ; and let that atmosphere be divided into three parts A , B , and C , each 30 feet in diameter : Now if a sharp metalline point ( a ) erected on a kite , or otherwise , is placed either vertically or horizontally in the most interior part of the atmosphere C , that point will continue to act till a quan30 30 30 A Cloud Its elect .
Atmosphere A B a C tity of the lightning is drawn off , equal to the quantity which was contained in that atmosphere , and no longer .
For then the semi-diameter of the atmosphere being reduced to 60 feet , every part of it is above , and not in contact with , the sharp point ( a ) , and consequently beyond its sphere of action .
But let the sharp point be then advanced into the atmosphere B , and it will act as before , &amp;c. The truth of this , however contradictory it may be , to the general opinion of the action of sharp points , in drawing off the electricity or lightning * , may be illustrated by the following experiment on the prime-conductor .
Electrify the prime-conductor in a dark room , and draw back the globe to a sufficient distance from the prime-conductor , to prevent its being supplied with any more electricity from the globe , while you are taking off the electrical atmosphere with a sharp point .
Bring then a sharp point , either vertically or horizontally , or in any other direction , within two feet of the prime-conductor ; and the point , for some time , will appear luminous .
After that light disappears , advance the point three or four inches nearer to the conductor , and you will observe the same phenomenon as before ; and by advancing the point gradually in this manner , as the light upon it disappears , the point will be alternately luminous and dark , till you have taken off the whole atmosphere in different laminae .
As the * Mr. Franklin says , speaking of sharp points , ` ` At whatever distance you see the light , you may draw off the electrical fire .
' ' page ii .
point appears more and more luminous , the nearer that it approaches the prime-conductor , the electrical atmosphere may have different degrees of density , being perhaps denser near the prime-conductor , and rarer at a greater distance from it .
If a phial is charged on the prime-conductor , when this experiment is made , the light upon the sharp point will be much greater , and continue longer .
Query 3 .
Did you make any trial , at what distance you could kill an animal with a discharge of the electrical fluid from the key or the bottle suspended to it ?
Answer .
I have not hitherto had an opportunity of making any such experiments with the kite .
But as to the first , I apprehend , that no animal could be killed by the discharge of any quantity of electricity accumulated on the key ; as the key in that experiment answers the same end as the prime-conductor , and , like it , is capable of receiving only a certain charge of electricity , except the lightning flows down the line too fast , or the kite be so near the cloud that it may explode , when one standing on the ground approaches the key to draw sparks from it : but such an explosion would probably be fatal to the operator .
When a phial is suspended to the key , after it has received its charge , if you let it continue hanging on the key , the surcharge will fly off from the hook of the phial , and the phial , when charged in that manner , will not give a greater shock than if it had been charged in the common way with the globe .
J. L.

