LV .
An Account of a Memoir read at the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , by M. de Barros , a Portuguese Gentleman , concerning certain Phenomenon observed by him at Paris , in the last Transit of Mercury over the Sun : by J. Short , A.M. F.R.S. THE author says , he made use of an excellent Gregorian reflector of four feet in length , taking in the eye-piece , together with as much of the great tube , as exceeds the focal lengths of the two eye-glasses ( I suppose it should be the two speculums ) : that the focus of the great speculum is 33 ( Paris ) inches ; that of the small one four inches ; the focus of the eye-glass next the eye 18 lines ; the focus of the glass furthest from the eye 5 inches ; and , lastly , that the combined power of these two glasses is nearly equal to that of a single eye-glass of 3 inches .
This telescope , therefore , according to my computation , magnified about 130 times .
Read Dec. 13 , 1753 .
That he was placed in the most commodious situation for observing the egress ; that his smoaked glass was fixed perpendicular to the axis of his telescope within a close tube ; and that he always made use of the same part of this glass .
He took notice , that the interior contact of Mercury 's and the Sun 's limbs * was very rapid , having observed it with a green-colour 'd glass held over the Zz smoaked smoaked glass : immediately after which , looking thro ' the smoaked glass only , he perceived , that a small thread of light was still visible between the limbs , before , what he calls , the second contact took place , which was not till four seconds after ; that the exterior contact appeared stationary , or seemed to last 6 or 7 seconds ; that having observed the total egress with the coloured glass upon the smoaked one , he brought Mercury upon the Sun 's limb again , by removing the coloured glass ; and that the second total egress did not happen till 6 or 7 seconds after the first .
When he observed him at the distance of about 3 of his diameters from the Sun 's limb with both the glasses , he remarked , that the said distance seemed diminished , and Mercury 's diameter increased .
That the part of the Sun 's limb , where Mercury went off , to the extent of six degrees of circumference , seemed under much the same configuration , as the illuminate limb of the Moon about the quadrature , somewhat uneven and undulating .
The same looked also redder than the rest of the disk .
This was about 18 or 20 seconds before Mercury disappeared , and was seen thro ' the smoaked glass alone : for when the green glass was applied , the appearance in a manner vanished .
The evening before the transit , he viewed the Sun with different-colour 'd glasses , variously combined with one another , and with a smoaked glass ; and found , that a green glass before the smoaked one did best : the Sun appearing of a silvery hue , like the Moon , and the spots and the limb exceedingly well defined .
M. de Barros , having thus described the particular phenomenon , attempts , and indeed very ingeniously , to account for them all , from this single supposition ; namely , that the disks of the Sun , and of Mercury seen thereon , are environed with a certain corona of light ( like that which Sir Isaac Newton calls the circle of aberration or dissipation in refracting telescopes ) , whereby the apparent diameter of the Sun is enlarged , and that of Mercury contracted .
But , as this gentleman made use of a reflecting telescope , and as no such circle , from the known principle of reflexion , can take place in such a telescope , if well made , as Sir Isaac has proved long ago ; I shall not take up the Society 's time in pursuing him thro ' all his particular suppositions ; but shall endeavour to show , that his hypothesis has really no foundation .
Sir Isaac , as I before hinted , in several of his writings , remarks , that the images of all objects seen in refracting telescopes are surrounded with a circle of aberration ; which is always less , the longer the telescopes are .
In his optics he tells us , that , to avoid the indistinctness arising from this circle , he would propose catadioptric telescopes , in which , if the speculums , under limited apertures , be justly figured , no such circle of aberration can confuse the image : but , if the speculums are of a spherical figure , with too large apertures , then indeed a circle of aberration will take place ; as it also will , when the figure deviates from the circular towards the hyperbolic , even under a small aperture ; and the same thing will happen , if the spherical figure be inaccurate .
About three days from the change of the Moon , her whole body is visible : that part of the limb , which is directly enlightened by the solar rays apZ z2 pearing pearing to the naked eye , as an arc of a greater circle , than the other , which receives the reflex light from the earth .
Look thro ' a refracting telescope , and you will perceive the apparent difference of these circles very much diminished : and if they be viewed with a good reflector , they will be perfectly reduced to an equality , even if measured with a micrometer in the focus , as we have often found .
If a reflecting telescope , well constructed in all respects , be directed any considerable time to the sun , such a circle of aberration will be generated , from the little speculum 's being heated , and thereby its figure altered , from the sun 's rays falling condensed thereon from the great one ; and if it continues long under this circumstance , the image will be rendered utterly indistinct and confused .
This we were thoroughly convinced of at the above-mention 'd transit of Mercury : for the reflector , a very good one , which we used , in taking , with the the micrometer , the differences of right ascension and declination between the planet and the sun 's limb , having been a good while exposed to the direct rays , was found at last to give a very indistinct image ; but was restored to its former degree of perfection , by turning it from the sun , and screwing off the eyepiece , so as to admit the cool air into the great tube , whereby the over-heated small speculum soon recovered its due temper and figure .
The last-mentioned effect is scarce sensible in the lesser reflectors of small apertures ; but in those of large ones it is very considerable .
Dr. Bevis , Mr. Canton , and Mr. Bird , who viewed Mercury going off the sun , with very good reflectors of different lengths , assure me , they saw him quite distinct and free from any corona , or circle of aberration , and the sun 's limb perfectly well defined .
For my own part , he appeared to me , thro a reflector of four feet focus , magnifying about 135 times , as truly defined as I could wish to see a black circle upon a white ground I must , however , upon this occasion , take notice , that , during the whole time of this transit of Mercury , the air was perfectly calm with us ; but that , in the two last transits of Mercury over the sun , viz. in the years 1736 and 1743 , both the sun 's and Mercury 's limbs appeared to me indistinct , and surrounded with something like what this gentleman calls a luminous crown , or circle of aberration ; tho ' I , at both these times , made use of reflecting telescopes , which I had , by former trials , esteemed good .
But it is to be observed , that , during both these transits , there was a constant hard gale of wind ; and as I had , by other observations , formerly found , that the images of the planets , in the night-time , did not appear so distinct in windy weather , as when it was calm , I therefore imputed the indistinctness of the sun 's and Mercury 's limbs to the air 's being agitated by the wind * .
And of this we may be made sensible by a familiar instance : Suppose a vessel full of water , having any thing lying at the bottom , such as a shilling , the water being at rest ; you will then perceive the image of the shilling distinctly ; but if you give any commotion to the water , the image of the shilling will then appear indistinct and confused .
* Since this paper was read , Mr. Short has been informed by M. Le Monnier , the French King 's astronomer , that , during the last transit at Paris , they had a hard gale of wind from the N. E. Somewhat analogous to this is this other appearance : If you look thro ' a telescope at any of the planets , when the stars appear hazy , dim , and languid , you will see them distinctly : but look at them again , when the stars appear most bright and sparkling , you will then find their images less distinct .
This may be accounted for by the just-mention 'd instance of the vessel of water , by supposing air instead of water .
And if we consider the infinite number of heterogeneous particles which continually float in the air , and suppose these to be at rest , or put into motion , we shall find , that it is not at all surprising , that we see the images of objects , placed beyond the medium of air , more or less distinct .
We are not so sensible of this indistinctness , arising from the agitation of the air , in refracting telescopes , as in reflectors : because the errors of reflexion , caused by any irregularity in their figure , or confusion in the air , are about five or six times greater than the same errors in refraction ; even tho ' both telescopes magnify the same number of times ; as has long ago been demonstrated .
We also took notice of M. de Barros 's first phenomenon ; to wit , the seeming greater velocity of Mercury when he was near the egress : which we thus accounted for .
When he was at a considerable distance from the limb , there being nothing near enough to refer his velocity to , he seemed in a manner stationary ; but being advanced near the sun 's edge , we could refer his motion to that , with ease ; which thus becoming sensible , it might be esteemed rapid , in comparison of the former .
I have often made the same remark on the gradual approach of two luminous nous bodies , as the appulse of the moon 's lucid limb to a star or planet .
The expedition with which the author observed his second phenomenon , is truly somewhat extraordinary ; namely , that he should first observe what he names the final contact ; secondly , that he should take away his green glass ; and then , thirdly , that he should be able suddenly to alter the conformation of his eye , so as to see distinctly with a much greater influx of light , and then take another observation , and all in the short space of four seconds !
Messieurs Mairan and Bouguer take notice of this in their certificate , which follows this memoir ; and own , that his observations were such , as seem to have required that attention of several persons .
Upon the whole , we may conclude , that the several phenomenon , observed by this gentleman , in the transit and egress of Mercury , were owing to indistinctness of vision , arising either from the eye , the telescope , or the air ; and that this alone may account for them all , without having recourse to supposed circles of aberration ; which can never possibly exist in a well-constructed reflecting telescope .

