L. A second Account of the new Method of opening the Cornea , for taking away the Cataract ; by Samuel Sharp , Surgeon to Guy 's Hospital , and F. R. S. IHAD the honour , last April , to lay before the Society a new method of opening the cornea , in order to take away the cataract ; being intended as an improvement on Monsieur Daviel 's manner of doing that operation : and having now practised it on several subjects , I here take the liberty to give a short account of the success , with a few observations on the principal phenomenon attending this operation ; to which I shall add a description of a farther improvement of the operation itself .
For a fuller view of the history of these cases , I have here set down the ages of the patients , the dates of the days on which they underwent the operation , and the particular circumstance of its being done on one or both eyes .
Names .
Age .
Date .
Eyes .
AB 55 April 71 AC 54 April 16 2 AD 70 May 12 2 AE 65 June 62 AF 65 July 16 2 AG 63 August 82 AH 48 Sept. 19 2 AI 64 Sept. 19 1 AK 67 Sept. 19 2 AL 58 Oct. 42 AM 47 Oct. 22 1 From Read Nov. 22 , From this catalogue it appears , that the operation has been performed on nineteen eyes ; and , from the most exact information , which I have been able to procure , the state of the success stands thus : A C , A D , A F , A G , A L , all which had the operation performed on both eyes , have every one of them recovered the sight of both eyes , to as great a perfection as can be supposed , without the help of the crystalline humour ; that is , they can read and write , with proper spectacles The first of them , A C , has found so much benefit , as to be able to carry on the exercise of his profession , that of a surgeon .
AH sees with both eyes , but not so well as the other five .
I have just now an account from the surgeon , who has attended her ( in a distant country ) , that her eyes look well , and her sight improves* .
A I , another patient , at a distance from London , had the operation done on one eye only ; which he recovered , as my correspondent informs me , so as to see tolerably well .
A M , on one eye only , with which he already sees very well .
AE had it performed on both ; one of which was lost , and the other recovered ; but continues inflamed , and cannot bear much light .
AB had it done on one eye only , which was lost .
Ss2 Both * Some weeks after this paper was read , Mr. Sharp received an account , that the pupils of both eyes had lately contracted so much , as hardly to leave room for the admission of light ; and it was apprehended the patient would soon become blind .
Both the eyes , in which the operation failed , were destroyed by the subsequent inflammation : but , to do justice to this new operation , I might here take notice , with regard to the case of A B , that the ill success was partly owing to the imperfection of my instrument ; a disadvantage , that must frequently attend on the execution of new attempts .
It was the first operation I performed , and I had provided a knife with so thin a blade , that , after I had passed through the cornea into the anterior chamber of the eye , the point was so blunted , that , upon endeavouring to carry it through the cornea out on the other side , the blade bent , and I was apprehensive it might break : however , withdrawing it a little , I made two or three efforts , and succeeded in the incision , and the removal of the cataract .
During this operation , the aqueous humour being discharged , and the patient struggling , I wounded the iris ; which bled profusely , and continued for several days to discharge a great quantity of blood , and bloody ichor : and it is to this accident that I am inclined to impute the miscarriage of the operation ; though Mr. Daviel affirms , that the wounds of the iris have been very seldom followed with bad effects in his practice .
I have reserved the mention of A K 's history to the last , because of its singularity .
She was altogether as blind as those , whose cataracts are ripe ; but hers had the appearance of a beginning cataract , being of a light blue , and but little opake .
Upon making the compression , the crystalline did not advance through the pupil , as in the other instances : and I found , found , that , if I exerted more force , I should soon evacuate all the vitreous humour .
It was evident , by the great distance of the cataract behind the iris , that this disappointment did not arise from an adhesion to the iris : however , I had immediately recourse to the experiment of cutting through the capsula with the point of my knife ; hoping , by that means , to have set free the crystalline , but it gave me no assistance .
I then passed the curette ( a little scoop ) through the pupil , and turned it several times round , in expectation of breaking the capsula ; but found not the least resistance to my instruments ; so that both operations proved ineffectual ; the circumstances being exactly the same in each eye .
I have , in couching , met with cataracts of this nature ; but I had no apprehension that I could not have discharged , by the wound of the cornea , the matter of a cataract , in however fluid a state it might prove .
Of all the 19 there was not one , that escaped an inflammation ; whereas , after couching , there are great numbers , who have neither inflammation nor pain .
But it is to be remarked , that , notwithstanding the violent inflammation , which sometimes ensues after the incision of the cornea , even to an enlargement of the eyelids , and vesication of the tunica conjunctiva , the patient complains rather of a tenderness of the eye , upon touching it , than of pain ; being generally exempt from those dreadful dartings in the head , which , for the most part , accompany an inflammation after couching .
And I believe I may assert , that none suffered very much in that particular , except cept A E ; who was extremely bad , and lost the eye on that side , where the pain was .
I presume it will not be difficult to conceive , how it should happen , that these inflammations should excite such different symptoms , when we reflect , that , in the incision of the cornea , the cornea only suffers ; and in couching , the conjunctiva , the sclerotica , the choroides , and the tunica retina , are punctured ; most of which organs are either tendinous or nervous ; and every surgeon knows the painfulness and obstinacy of inflammations , when they follow upon wounds and punctures of tendinous or nervous parts .
I have not mentioned , in this comparison , the violence done to the vitreous humour ; because I believe it does not occasion the subsequent pain ; and because it seems to be often as much or more injured in the new operation , without any notable inconvenience .
It has not occurred in any of these cases , that the inflammation has been so slight , as to disappear entirely in a fortnight , or three weeks ; most of them requiring six weeks , and some longer , for the total removal of them .
The first ten days , or more , the light is generally very offensive ; and I have observed , in three or four instances , that , upon forcibly opening the eyelids during that time , the patient was only sensible of a glare of light , though the eye then appeared clear , and he afterwards recovered his sight .
Which I mention , to obviate the melancholy prognostic one would be disposed to make upon a first examination .
However , this is not to be understood as a constant fact ; some patients distinguishing objects immediately from the time of the operation .
It sometimes happens , after this operation , that the pupil loses its circular figure : which , I imagine , is owing to the great tenderness of the iris , that , upon the least violence , is subject to be ruptured ; and , I suppose , in this operation , a slight pressure from the back or the flat of the blade may have produced the accident in the instances alluded to .
Possibly the sudden dilatation of the pupil , from the rapid passage of the cataract through it , may sometlmes occasion it ; but the following history would induce one rather to ascribe it to the cause , which I first mentioned .
Before I had thought of the knife for opening the cornea , I used the scissors , as Mons. Daviel directs ; and , in a certain patient , after I had made the wound of the cornea , and was going to compress the eye , for the expulsion of the cataract , I discovered , that , from the disturbance I had given to the humours by the foregoing process , it was sunk almost as much as if it had depressed by a couching needle .
I therefore left it in that situation , and the man afterwards saw very well ; tho ' the cataract remained visible something below the pupil .
Now , in this instance , the cataract had not passed thro ' the pupil ; and yet it was lacerated , so as to lose its circular form : but , whatever may be the cause , I do not find , that the accident itself proves prejudicial to the sight .
I shall finish these observations with a remark on one disadvantage , to which this operation and couching are incident ; and that is a possibility of an incomplete gutto serena being complicated with the cataract .
It has , indeed , been a rule with surgeons , tho ' the cataract appear fair , never to perform the operation , but when the patient is sensible of a glimmering of light ; because a total privation of sight argues some other disorder of the eye .
But the criterion is not infallible ; for it may happen , that a gutta serena shall prevail to a degree , that does not take away the sense of light , and yet prevents the distinction of objects : So that when a cataract is thus circumstanced , the operation will be fruitless .
It remains now to speak of the operation itself .
In my former paper , after having described the manner of making the incision , I directed the operator to compress the inferior part of the globe of the eye with his thumb gently , till the cataract should be expelled through the incision of the cornea , upon the patient 's cheek ; and in this method I have performed it upon several subjects .
But remarking , that tho ' , upon the evacuation of the aqueous humour , the crystalline readily advanced through the pupil into the anterior chamber , yet that it required some force to expel it from its membrane through the wound of the cornea , and in that action it sometimes suddenly drew after it a portion of the vitreous humour , I changed my method , and no longer pressed the eye , when once the crystalline was in the anterior chamber , but immediately stuck the point of my knife into the body of it , and extracted it contained in its capsula , without spilling any of the vitreous humour .
This new process , I suppose , will be found of considerable advantage , as it will , in a great measure , remove the danger of evacuating the whole , or too much , of the vitreous humour : though it may be observed , to the praise of this operation , that , contrary trary to expectation , a large quantity of this humour ( perhaps a third part , or more ) has been sometimes discharged , without any bad consequence .
I have supposed , that the great and sole benefit arising from this improvement , is the easy separation of the crystalline from the bed of the vitreous humour , so that none of the vitreous humour shall be evacuated .
But perhaps it will also be approved of , as it will render unnecessary the measure prescribed by Mons. Daviel , of wounding the membrane of the crystalline , before we proceed to the extraction of the crystalline itself : To which purpose he advises the flap of the cornea to be suspended with a small spatula ; then , with a pointed cutting needle , to wound the surface of the crystalline ; after which , to introduce the same spatula through the pupil , in order to detach the cataract from the iris , and then proceed to the expulsion .
I have here recited these processes of M. Daviel 's operation , which are calculated merely to procure an easy operation of the crystalline from the vitreous humour : But they are difficult to the operator , fatiguing to the patient , and , I should hope , altogether needless , if the knife be used in the manner which I have recommended : For , whether the capsula of the crystalline be nothing more than the duplicature of the membrane of the vitreous humour , or whether it be a proper coat , which is also covered by the membrane of the vitreous humour ; in either case , since by compression the crystalline advances with so much facility through the pupil , it will be easily seized by the knife , and removed from the vitreous humour , with its enveloping membrane : Whereas , in making an incision on the surface of the crystalline , and wounding its capsula , the crystalline will frequently slip out of the capsula , which will be left behind : And , in fact , this has happened to M. Daviel , who advises pincers , and other instruments , in order to extract the remaining membrane .
However , I shall here observe , in regard to the capsula of the crystalline , that , should the humour slip out of it , before it be seized by the knife , it possibly will waste ; for , in milky cataracts , when the fluid is discharged , the membrane , in length of time , wastes : Whole cataracts , with the enveloping membrane likewise , sometimes waste : And in one of my patients ( A. C. ) the crystalline , from the mere pressure in the operation , burst out of its capsula , which I left in the eye ; but in some weeks it entirely wasted .
However , if the removing of the capsula should , by future experience , be found necessary , it may be conveniently done by the curette ; one of the instruments M. Daviel recommends upon that occasion .
This instrument may be also used for the extraction of a cataract , which has been broken to pieces by the couching needle in a former operation , and for the removal of the capsula of bag-cataract , when the fluid only has been discharged , and the bag remains behind ; but it will be most eminently useful in detaching the crystalline from the back part of the iris , when any portion of it happened to adhere : Which circumstance would render the operation fruitless , without such a precaution .
It has not happened , in any of the cases I have treated , that , either during the operation , or after the operation , the iris has been pushed forwards , or insinuated insinuated itself through the wound of the cornea~ forming a staphyloma ; but M. Daviel speaks of it as an occurrence he has met with , and says it may be easily replaced by the small spatula .
I presume a greater number of operations will prove this account very deficient : But I have here communicated all that I have done , and all that I know on the subject ; not having suppressed one experiment , nor , to the best of my remembrance , one circumstance , either to the honour or disgrace of the operation .
It is to be hoped , that , when it shall be more generally practised , ingenious men will render it still more perfect : And I should not be surprised , if the use of a speculum oculi should hereafter be esteemed an improvement : But then it must be contrived so , as that it shall not compress the globe of the eye ; or , if it does , the operator must be careful to remove it in the instant the incision is making , lest , by continuing the pressure after the wound is made , all the humours should suddenly gush out .
It was impossible for me to make any remarks on this operation , without criticising on M. Daviel , as M. Daviel has not only the honour of having first practised it , but is the only writer who has treated the subject , at least that I am acquainted with .
I therefore flatter myself , that this attempt to improve upon what he has laid down , will not be construed as a reflection on him , or his practice : For , however his invention may be perfected by others , in my opinion , it is still to him principally , that the world will be indebted for the benefit of the discovery .

