XLVII .
Extracts of two Letters from Father Gaubil , of the Society of Jesus , at Peking in China , translated from the French .
To Dr. Cromwell Mortimer , M. D. Secretary to the Royal Society , Peking , Nov. 2 , 1752 .
THE chronology of China , which I sent to France in 1749 , had been long the object of the researches of the late M. Freret , who did me the honour to ask my sentiments upon the essays , which he sent me .
This correspondence continued many years ; and that learned man wrote several very curious dissertations upon that subject .
I have not seen the last , which must have been published in the eighteenth tome of the Memoirs of the Academy of Inscriptions &amp; Belles Lettres .
I wrote to several persons detached pieces of what came into my thoughts on the subject , as they consulted me upon it .
To avoid many inconveniences , I thought proper myself to digest my own rough draughts upon that topic ; and accordingly sent the result in three parts to France in 1749 .
Read Nov. 15 , 1753 .
What I have thus done in chronology , I am desirous of doing with regard to astronomy , or , at least , furnishing materials ranged in order upon that science .
For it is necessary to draw up anew , or , at least , to correct , what has been printed in the work , which Mr. Costard has criticized in the Philos. Transact. No 483 , p. 476 , 477 , &amp; seq. It was not sent from hence to France with a view of being printed , but of being examined by men of skill and abilities ( a ) .
I have already sent you the catalogue of some ancient observations .
What relates to Jupiter is proper to correct what is remarked by Father Souciet .
I have sent either to that Father , or to M. de Lisle , a great number of corrections and additions , which are requisite to be made ; and I will soon digest into order what shall appear to me necessary .
Mr. Costard will there , I believe , see the solution of his doubts .
The Jesuits are much obliged to him for the honour , which he has done them , in saying , that the best memoirs relating to China are owing to them .
When he shall have examined what there is of reality with respect to antiquity , and the manner of coming at the knowlege of the ancient history and astronomy , his doubts will vanish .
The Chinese , without being consummate , or even passable astronomers , might be capable of seeing an eclipse , and of making observations on it , and of looking upon the shadow of the gnomon of a sun-dial .
The knowlege , which they had from time immemorial of the rectangle triangle , and of its principal properties , ( a ) The Chinese texts were written by men , who knew nothing , or almost nothing , of astronomy and antiquity ; and there are many faults in the Chinese contexts , and likewise some in the copies of the translations , and in what was added or corrected for the impression .
They are only memoirs , which ought to be examined , and digested into a better order , after having taken the proper measures to restore the Chinese texts , which had been altered , and to explain the obscure parts by those , which are intelligible ; notwithstanding which there will be many Chinese texts still unintelligible .
properties , might easily teach them a thousand curious things in geometry , without knowing the theory of trigonometry .
The Chinese , from time immemorial , knew the passage of the sun in the ecliptic ; they knew the stars ; they had globes and hemispheres ; and , by means of divers practices and precepts , received from their ancients , without any great knowlege of spherical trigonometry , might be able upon the globe itself to resolve many problems .
We ought to conclude , that our ancients were possessed of several kinds of knowlege , received from the patriarchs , and transmitted to the Chinese .
Without these kinds of knowlege , and these traditions , by mere observations alone , the Chinese could not perform what they did at first .
They never well understood the stations and retrogressions of the planets .
Reflections upon the eclipses of the sun and stars taught them antiently , by practice , something of the parallaxes of the moon .
Every thing was almost forgot , about the time of Tfin chi hoam , 240 or 246 years before Christ .
But it is evident , that , before that time , the Chinese must have known something of the calculations of the eclipses of the moon and sun , and of some equations for reducing the mean motion to the true , and for calculating the solstices .
Mengtse , a classical author , who wrote before the burning of their books , mentions clearly enough part , at least , of what I say .
They certainly knew indifferently well the proper motion of the fixed stars ; which was afterwards forgot , for want of examining what was extant written in many books .
I shall say no more upon this subject ; but hope , that Mr. Costard , and many other gentlemen in England , France , and elsewhere , will lay aside their doubts or prejudices about the Chinese astronomy and antiquities .
It is , indeed , really difficult , to take the just medium between those , who too highly extol , and those who too much despise , the Chinese literature .
I thought , that Father Hallerstein would not have gone so soon to Macao ; and when he was obliged to go thither , the plan of Peking , which I ordered to be copied for you , with some explications of it , was not finished .
I have now received it , but I cannot send it by the post with this letter ; nor can I send it till next year , when I shall have a favourable opportunity for it .
I shall then likewise send some other present for your illustrious Society .
On the 15 of August , an ambassador from the king of Portugal arrived at Macao , with presents for the emperor of China .
It were to be wished , that this embassy might produce some advantage to us ; but this is extremely doubtful .
The queen-mother of the king of Portugal ordered the ambassador to desire , that Father Hallerstein , whom she personally knew , might come to him to Macao , with a mandarin sent by the emperor .
The emperor consented to this without any difficulty , and dispatched the mandarin and Father Hallerstein to the ambassador .
He will be here again in May .
I am of opinion , that the reigning emperor will never permit any missionaries in the provinces ; and that they will find it very difficult to conceal themselves .
But there is no appearance , that we shall be properties , might easily teach them a thousand curious things in geometry , without knowing the theory of trigonometry .
The Chinese , from time immemorial , knew the passage of the sun in the ecliptic ; they knew the stars ; they had globes and hemispheres ; and , by means of divers practices and precepts , received from their ancients , without any great knowlege of spherical trigonometry , might be able upon the globe itself to resolve many problems .
We ought to conclude , that our ancients were possessed of several kinds of knowlege , received from the patriarchs , and transmitted to the Chinese .
Without these kinds of knowlege , and these traditions , by mere observations alone , ~ first .
They never well understood the stations and retrogressions of the planets .
Reflections upon the the Chinese could not perform what they did at~ eclipses of the sun and stars taught them antiently , by practice , something of the parallaxes of the moon .
Every thing was almost forgot , about the time of Tfin chi hoam , 240 or 246 years before Christ .
But it is evident , that , before that time , the Chinese must have known something of the calculations of the eclipses of the moon and sun , and of some equations for reducing the mean motion to the true , and for calculating the solstices .
Mengtse , a classical author , who wrote before the burning of their books , mentions clearly enough part , at least , of what I say .
They certainly knew indifferently well the proper motion of the fixed stars ; which was afterwards forgot , for want of examining what was extant written in many books .
I shall say no more upon this subject ; but hope , that Mr. Costard , and many other gentlemen in England , France , and elsewhere , will lay aside their doubts or prejudices about the Chinese astronomy and antiquities .
It is , indeed , really difficult , to take the just medium between those , who too highly extol , and those who too much despise , the Chinese literature .
I thought , that Father Hallerstein would not have gone so soon to Macao ; and when he was obliged to go thither , the plan of Peking , which I ordered to be copied for you , with some explications of it , was not finished .
I have now received it , but I cannot send it by the post with this letter ; nor can I send it till next year , when I shall have a favourable opportunity for it .
I shall then likewise send some other present for your illustrious Society .
On the 15 of August , an ambassador from the king of Portugal arrived at Macao , with presents for the emperor of China .
It were to be wished , that this embassy might produce some advantage to us ; but this is extremely doubtful .
The queen-mother of the king of Portugal ordered the ambassador to desire , that Father Hallerstein , whom she personally knew , might come to him to Macao , with a mandarin sent by the emperor .
The emperor consented to this without any difficulty , and dispatched the mandarin and Father Hallerstein to the ambassador .
He will be here again in May .
I am of opinion , that the reigning emperor will never permit any missionaries in the provinces ; and that they will find it very difficult to conceal themselves .
But there is no appearance , that we shall be sent sent away from Peking : on the contrary , those , who shall be sent thither , will be well received , if they have but the qualifications requisite .
The observation of Mercury in the Sun in May 1740 is very curious , and does honour to the calculation of Dr. Halley .
I had seen that calculation ; and doubting that of Manfredi in his Ephemerides from the tables of M. Cassini , I prepared to observe that passage of Mercury here at Peking ; but the weather was not favourable .
And I see , by the observation made at Cambridge near Boston in New England , that I might have had one at Peking .
I hope , that we shall be able to observe the passage of Mercury in May next year .
It is of great importance , and we shall endeavour to do it in the best manner ; and if we succeed , we shall communicate it to you .
II .
To Mons. de L'Isle of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris .
SIR , Peking , Nov. 18 , 1751 .
YOU know , that I have , for many years , corresponded with the late famous Monsieur Freret , [ Secretary of the Academy of Inscriptions and Belles Lettres ] who honoured me with his friendship .
Monsieur de Bougainville , his successor , wrote to me last year , and acquainting me with the melancholy news of his death , informed me , that he was just ready to commit to the press a great work of that eminently learned man upon the Chinese chronology .
I had seen some essays of it in the Memoirs of the Academy of Inscriptions and Belles Lettres , of which he made me a present .
I had furnished him with a quantity of memoirs , as I had likewise done to others , both seculars , and those of our own society .
I digested into order all that I had collected ; and , in 1749 , sent a complete treatise on the Chinese chronology , by two different ways , into France .
I directed it to M , Freret , and to the Fathers of our society at Paris .
It was in three parts .
I desired them to communicate it to you , and to Mons. de Mairan .
I have had no account of the arrival of that treatise , in which I had laboured for above two-and-twenty years past .
It seemed to me necessary , on account of the great number of pieces , either printed or manuscript , which were sent hither on that subject .
If I find , that my treatise is lost , I can easily digest it into order again , from the rough draught , which I have by me .
Besides many astronomical observations , which I have punctually sent you , I have transmitted to you the treatise of Father Duchamp upon the Indian astronomy , a collection of ancient approximations and occultations of the stars and planets , both by each other , and by the moon , and with the moon ; which I had collected and made for determining the longitude and latitude of Peking , &amp;c. This year I have sent to Paris , by two different ways , a memoir , which had been desired of me , concerning the isles of Lequoyo , or Licoukicou , which Kempfer calls Roukou .
I have directed , that this memoir should be communicated to you .
It is a pretty long one .
I had an opportunity of being well informed about these isles ; but there are many things yet wanting to be known .
To this memoir I have added some remarks concerning the longitude of Namgazaki , and other places on the south coast of Japan , and the south coast of Coree , with its distance from Japan , and the island of Touyma , which , in the map of Father du Halde , is called Touyla Tao , or the island of Touyla .
It should be called Touy Ma .
It is the isle Tsutsima .
It depends upon Japan .
I have spoken here with several Coreans , who have been in that island .
I have already sent to you observations made here to the close of the year 1750 , and during this year .
I now send you others of 1750 ; and others I enclosed to you at large in 1749 and 1750 .
I wait for some answer from you ; and especially your opinion concerning the manner , in which I ought to dispose my memoirs concerning the Chinese astronomy .
I am resolved to put my last hand to that work .
But memoirs of that kind ought to be examined by persons intelligent and zealous like yourself .
At Petersburg you must undoubtedly have seen what I wrote to Mr. Bayer about what the Chinese have said concerning the Huns and Turcs .
Dr. Mortimer has written to me , that he had received from a nephew of Mons. Fourmont a small piece upon the origin of the Turcs and Huns , as drawn from the Chinese books I shall speak again of that subject in the memoirs , which I have of the history of the Great Dynasty of Tang. There are a great number of very interesting things upon what the Chinese have delivered at that time concerning the empire of the Persians , and its destruction by the Mahometans ; concerning the Mahometans , and the assistance , which they gave to Chinese emperors against their rebels ; concerning the Christian religion , or the Tatsin , but in very obscure terms ; concerning the sects and countries of the Indians , Japan , Coree , Tartary , and the countries between China and the Caspian Sea , Tybet , and its princes .
All these particulars may be of considerable service to unravel the eastern history from the year 500 of Christ to the year 1000 after him , and even much higher .
If I have not time to reduce my memoirs into proper order , I will address them to some learned man , like yourself , who can digest them , or see them digested .
It is seevral years since I received any thing from Father Boudier .
He has , undoubtedly , sent every thing to Paris .
However , I have a good part of what he did , till 1738 , and 1739 ; and I find , that he is much mistaken with respect to the diameter of the sun , and the obliquity of the ecliptic .
I do not know whether the right ascensions of the stars are very exact .
He had not then any knowlege of the aberration of the stars .
His voyage from Chandernager to Agra , Dheli , Jaepour , is curious .
I have the chart with the observations of the latitude and longitude of Fatepour , Agra , Dheli , Jaepour , and Chandernager .
I could have wished to have had the exact distance from Agra and Dheli to the Ganges .
I have discoursed here with some religious Indians , who have been at Sirnegar , and as far as the sources of the Ganges ; but their account is very obscure .
There are here a great number of Lama 's and Tartars , who have gone from Lassa , the capital of Thibet , to the lakes and mountains , where the sources of the Ganges are , and at Latac , &amp;c. in the country to the north of Thibet and Latac ; but what they say is extremely confused ; and this part of geography is still very little known to us here .
It would be of great use to us , if you are informed of it , and would do me the pleasure of giving me an account of it .
Mr. Hodgson has sent hither , to the two German Fathers , his theory and tables of the satellites of Jupiter .
There are a great number of observations made at Peking ; many of which are not certain , nor proper for the forming of tables .
The catalogue of the longitudes and latitudes of places is very erroneous .
He will undoubtedly correct them .
However , the work itself is a very good and useful one .
Yourself and the other astronomers are able to judge of it much better than I can here .
The Memoires de Trevoux speak in a manner , which , they say , they had learned from you , concerning the rotation of the axis of the earth , and the consequences , which Dr. Bradley draws from it .
It is a discovery worthy a man of his profound sagacity ; but will render it necessary to make a vast number of new calculations .

