XXXIV .
A farther Account of the Giant 's Causeway in the County of Antrim in Ireland , by the Rev. Richard Pocock , LL. D. Archdeacon of Dublin , and F. R. S. IN a letter , which I wrote in 1747 to Martin Folks , Esq ; President of the Royal Society , which was read in January , and printed in the Philosophical Transactions for that month , I observed , in relation to the Giant 's Causeway , that there appeared in the Sea-cliffs three strata of pillars between thirty and forty feet high , with strata of a black rock between them ; that the causeway itself was the lowest of all these , extending in a point into the sea ; and that another is seen towards the top of the cliff .
Read May 24 , 1753 .
Last summer I took another view of it ; I went from Bally-Castle , which is about 10 miles to the east of the Causeway .
When I came two miles to the west of Bally-Castle , within less than a mile of Ballintoy , half a mile to the south of the sea-cliffs , and about a quarter to the south of the road , I saw the same kind of pillars in a low hill ; I observed both hexagons and pentagons .
The rocks towards the sea appeared as if they were formed in the same manner ; but when I came to them , I found it was only common rock in several strata , and perpendicular joints .
I went on about two miles to a peninsula called Donseverik , where I saw some tendency in the rock towards this work of nature ; and going about half a mile farther , came to the beginning of the pillars in the sea-cliff , as I believe , about five miles from the causeway : and the shore and cliffs being shaped mostly in little semicircular bays , I had many very beautiful views of the upper and middle strata of pillars : in one , particularly , they had much of the appearance of ruined portico 's one over the other ; and turning the little end of a spy-glass , it appeared something like the ruins of Palmyra , as a view of them is represented in a copper plate , published in the Philosophical Transactions .
This wonderful work of nature is continued on in the cliffs for about a quarter of a mile beyond the Giant 's Causeway .
I saw it again in the road to Coleraine , five miles to the west of the Causeway , in a low hill a furlong to the south of the road , and two miles to the south of the sea .
The pillars here are small ; and being about a mile and a half from Ballimagarry , where the earl of Antrim has a ruined house , lately burnt down , it served , as I suppose , as a quarry for building part of that house , in which I saw a great number of the stones , and particularly one of nine sides .
I saw others near two miles farther , to the south of the road in a low hill , within two miles of Coleraine ; so that the whole extends for about eleven Irish miles , or fourteen English .
Beyond Coleraine , to the east of Magilligan , I saw in the rocks towards the sea-cliffs , the stones in the rocks towards the sea-cliffs , the stones in the hills very regular , appearing at a distance much like these pillars .
This is six computed miles beyond Coleraine , and consequently about ten English miles from the last pillars .
At Fairhead also , a high point of land , three miles to the east of Ballycastle , towards the top of it , the rock appears as in grand pillars .
They say it is not in joints , but it has something of the appearance of a grand Gothic piece of workmanship .
As I spent a week at the Causeway , and sent away by sea to Dublin as great a variety of the stones as I could conveniently get , particularly a large octagon , with the eight large stones round it ; a pair of less , with eight pair , that encompass it ; two small pentagon pillars , about fourteen inches over , one of them three feet ten inches and a half high , the other five feet seven inches ; one hexagon pillar , about the same size , and five feet five inches high ; all which I have placed in my garden ; so I have had an opportunity of considering it at leisure .
It is a black stone , weighty and brittle : and I have been informed , that it was tried in a glass-house , and that it melted with kelp , so as to make the black glass bottles : which experiment , I have been told , was made by Mr. Dobbs of this kingdom , who is now in London .
Mr. Drury , whom I shall have occasion to mention , found in a stone of the Causeway a rough pebble in the shape of an egg , about three quarters of an inch long , and above an inch thick ; and when it was polished , it proved to be a white cornelian .
They are from three sides to nine sides , frequently encompassed with as many stones as there are sides ; but many of them have a narrow side , which has no stone to it , but is filled up with a piece or pieces of stone , that shall be further explained ; which pieces , when the stones are moved , commonly separate , and break off .
Some stones have two , or three , or more , of these sides : so that it is possible , a stone , that has any number of stones round it , may have double the number of sides : tho ' I saw none , that I had reason to think were of this kind , except some , that had probably only three stones round them ; being hexagons , with three broad sides , and three very narrow sides .
Whatever the outward figure of the stone is , the concavity or convexity is either circular , or part of a circle ; consequently , as the sides of the pillars are plain , the part between the inside circle and the outward figure must either be filled up ( as it is seen ) by stone , which sometimes separates , as mentioned above , and as will be further explained ; or by the matter pressed up from the sides , as will be more plainly described .
In the former case , when the end is convex , this stone often comes off all round at the joint , and leaves the convex end as part of a sphere , and the concave as a mould fitting to it .
I have some stones exactly like a hexagon cut in two , which might be part of a hexagon pillar split ; for sometimes a whole pillar appears as split all the way down ; of which there is a remarkable one at the Causeway .
In relation to the joints in the pillars , this work of nature seems to be different from any thing yet known : and it must be very difficult to assign any satisfactory causes of it .
I submit to the judgment of persons more experienced in these things what has occurred to me .
I suppose , for reasons , which I shall give , that the several parts of these pillars were at first formed either in the shape of a cylinder , with the upper end in a spherical figure , if not both ends ; or that they were either spherical or oblate spheroids .
For , being composed of crystal of six sides , and spar of three , and of a very fine black sand , it may be supposed , that , as the crystals and spars united , and formed an irregular body , the fine black sand filled up the interstices , and formed such cylindrical or spherical bodies , as yet soft ; but , in thin horizontal laminae or plates like talc , as they mostly appear to be ; and , if great force is applied , the stones will separate in such plates between the joints ; and those parts of the pillars , which have been exposed to the weather , and corroded by it , appear in such plates .
Sometimes indeed there are perpendicular joints ; as in the split pillar , there seems to have been such a one all down the pillar .
It is therefore probable , that , when this matter was in a fluid state , and when the stratum of rock was formed , on which it was made , the fluid contiguous to the rock still continued in motion ; that , after a time , some of the particles of matter , which compose these pillars , being disengaged from the particles of water , ceased to move , and formed the parts of these pillars , which are next to the rock , in the above-mention 'd figures ; so much being formed only at once , or in a very short time , as extends to the first joint : that then , either by change of season , or some other accident , so much more water mixed with these particles , as prevented their continuing to form themselves into such a shape , and gave the former motion : that , afterwards , the decrease of the water might again be the cause of the former effect ; and so on , till the entire pillars were formed ; and the top of the last formed being convex , that , which was formed upon it , would probably be concave , and fit to it , either by its gravity , or by being softer .
All being as yet in some one or other of these figures , we suppose the gravitation of the second stratum above the first joint to operate in such a manner on that which was first formed , and still soft , as to press it down ; and so eight stones being round one stone , would naturally press the middle stone into an octagon .
The reasons for concluding , that they were at first in some of these figures , are these : That the concavity or convexity are either in an entire circle , or part of a circle : That sometimes the ends of the stones appear to be of a spherical form for some space down , all round the stone ; filled up only by a matter , that separates from it , as shall be further explained .
For it is to be observed , that the pillar is not always so pressed out , as in each stone to form a regular multangular figure ; but sometimes there is a narrow side , against which there is no stone , as observed before : sometimes it is pressed out only in part ; and this , together with the spherical part , is filled up , probably at first with the floating matter ; which , I suppose , when the other stone was formed upon it , so united with it , that it remains as a part of the other stone , and breaks off from it , when they are moved : and if this happened to the lower part of the upper stone , this matter , which fills up , might unite with the lower stone ; for sometimes this narrow side is seen in the same stone both above and below , the angle being formed in the middle of the stone ; and then it is filled up with the matter , which united with the stone above , and the stone below .
It is to be observed , in pursuance of the proof , that the stones were originally round and spherical at the ends ; that when the pressure was not sufficient to make out the angles , which I suppose to be the cause of these narrow sides , it is in this case plainly seen , that the original circular shape of the stone is still retained ; that side not being horizontally in a strait line , but appearing plainly to be part of a circle ; as may be seen in the three pieces of stone , which I have sent , that separated from those sides , and fitted into them .
It appears also , that what has been pressed out beyond the circle at the ends is commonly flat , and not concave and convex ; as it was probably made ; not by the pressure at the ends on the spherical part , but by the pressure on the sides contiguous to it ; and when part of the circle is taken off , in that case it is probable , that the pressure on the sides was very great .
In one stone , the matter , which only in part formed the angle , force being applied to it , came off , and left that part spherical , being one of those stones , in which one part of the same end is flat , and the other convex , swelling like a cushion .
This stone I sent as a single stone .
It is a large octagon , twenty three inches over ; but after it had been some time in my garden , I perceived a crack in it , and , applying force , it divided .
The under stone had been so unequally pressed , that it is not only very thin on one side , but there is a large hole in it , about seven inches diameter , very near the edge of the stone ; so that the matter must have been pressed away to the other side of the stone , not equally concave , and the stone above it must have pressed into the stone below this ; in which lower stone the convex part , which pressed through the middle stone , must have been left , as it is broken : which I did not observe at the Causeway .
Some stones at the same end are partly concave , and partly convex ; probably occasioned by such an unequal pressure ; so that I have one , which measures nine inches deep on one side , which is convex , and four and a half on the other , which is concave : another , tho ' all convex , yet is six inches clear at one angle , and only four at the opposite angle ; so that in these stones the joint appears as indented .
We are to suppose , that , generally , the top of the lower stones is convex , and the bottom , consequently , of the stone , that lies upon it , concave .
But as sometimes both ends of a stone are concave , we must suppose , either that the lower part of the stone , which settled on it , was harder , or , being of equal hardness , by its gravitation pressed it down .
Since I left the Causeway , I have been inform d , that commonly , if the top of the stone in a pillar is found either concave or convex , the top likewise of every stone of that pillar is either concave or convex in the same manner ; which may be a subject for future observation .
It seems probable , therefore , that all the ends were originally spherical : some of the stones , it may be , exact spheres ; others , oblate spheroids ; and some longer stones in a cylindrical form , and of a spherical figure , at each end .
To which conjecture I have been led , by observing the shape of some I have , and of two models of two stones represented in cork by Mr. Drury , who presented the prospects of the Causeway engraved to the Royal Society , from the drawings of his sister Mrs. Susanna Drury .
One of these is convex at both ends ; and I have some in the same shape .
This spherical figure has been altered by the pressure , in the manner I have observed : for , in the other model , part of the spherical figure is seen round the sides towards the concave end ; and I have one exactly of the same kind .
In those also , which I have , that are at the same time partly convex and partly concave , the convex part seems to have been the natural figure of the stone , as before described : for , where both ends are concave , that , which was probably pressed by a harder stone formed before it , is perfectly concave ; whereas that concavity , which is made by a stone probably formed after it , is not so perfectly concave as the other ; but it commonly remains convex in some part , as observed before ; swelling out like a cushion pressed by any weight .
By all that I have been able to observe , the plates seem originally to have been horizontal : in some I have , which are convex , they are apparently so ; and , as far as I could remark , in all , where the plates appear .
Tho ' it is probable , where the end of the end of the stone is concave , the laminae or plates have in some measure been pressed in that form ; tho ' I could not certainly distinguish it in any of this kind .
Sometimes a joint near perpendicular begins as in a point from the side , and extends into that stone , and into all the stones of the pillar , which are beneath it ; so as ( when it has run the length of one stone ) to take off either two sides of the stones or pillar , or one side , and part of two sides .
This indeed sometimes happens to be in the middle of the pillar , and in the same manner all the way down , so as to form two distinct pillars .
Thus I have some , which , by this means , have a side less at one end than at the other ; and I have one , in which the spherical part takes off at one end two sides of the multangular figure , and makes part of a circle , as in some it takes off all the sides at one end ; or , more properly , the stone remains in its original spherical figure .
The pieces , which fill up where the stone is not pressed into a multangular figure , sometimes do not break off , as may be seen in the model .
Of the other models made by Mr. Drury , four of them fit to one another , and represent part of a pillar in the Causeway : The seven models not referred to , show a variety of stones ; the measures of all of them are marked in inches , and they are made by a scale of a tenth to an inch .
The ends , which are cut smooth in the cork , or are marked with a pencil , are such , as he could not see , or neglected to observe .
The fourth stone I have sent , which forms part of a circle , broke off from a stone flat at one end , is the spherical part of a stone , such as it appears towards the concave end of one already mentioned .
From these observations , those , who are well versed in natural philosophy , may possibly form some better judgment , and be more happy in their conjectures in relation to this difficult subject , the cause of the joints in the pillars of this extraordinary work of nature .
TA B. X. Represents the plan and profile of the stones brought to Dublin by the Rev. Archdeacon Pococke .
Explanation of the Figures Fig. 1 .
A plan of the pillar , with the measures of the lengths of the sides , A , B , C , D. Fig. 2 .
A plan of the pillar , with the lengths of the other four sides ; viz. E , F , G , H , and the distances of the circle from the sides of the polygon .
Fig. 3 .
A profile of the stones , showing the sides A , B , C , D. Fig. 4 .
A profile showing the sides E , F , G , H. The black lines show the deviation of the circles from a plane : and the large pricked waved lines show the profile of the swelling and concavity within them .
The upper row of figures in each stone shows the heights of the sides at the angles so far as they are strait .
4 3 1/ 2 3 1/ 2 434 3 1/ 2 4 1/ 2 1 1/ 4 5 1/ 4 43 1/ 2 25 J. Mind sc .
Fig. 4 .
5 1/ 2 22 1/ 2 Fig. 3 .
1 Fig. 6 .
6 1/ 2 7 1/ 2 6 1/ 2 3 1/ 2 45 1/ 2 3 1/ 2 423 1/ 2 1 23 1/ 2 3 3/ 4 43443 1/ 2 3 1/ 2 3 1/ 2 1/ 4 A 12 H 1/ 4 8 G B 1/ 2 Fig. 2 .
10 Fig. 7 .
CF 1/ 2 ~ DE 12 1/ 4 3/ 4 E F6 3/ 4 D G 13 Fig. 1 .
C Fig. 5 .
HB4 A9 1/ 4 Philos. Trans. Vol. XLVIII .
TAB. X. p. 236 The under row of figures shows the remainder of the height of the stone at that angle ; or it is the height of the angular curved pieces , which , before they fell off , were the complements filling up the prism , and making the sides of the pillar wholly flat , and the edges or angles of the pillar all strait lines .
Fig. 5 .
Two upper stones of a pillar , as they stood on the Causeway , showing 4 sides of the pillar .
Diameter of the upper circle of the upper stone 22 inches .
The circle is about half an inch within the polygon at the side D ; but is cut off by the side C , about three quarters of an inch .
The sides B and ba little broken .
Fig. 6 .
The two stones turned together upside-down ; showing the other four sides of the pillar .
Diameter of the ( now ) uppermost circle about twenty-one inches .
The side H much broken .
Angle f , rounded off from the circle to the ( now ) lower end of the stone .
Angle G is not rounded off .
Fig. 7 .
The two stones separated a little to show the bottom of the upper stone , and top of the under one .
Diameter of the circles , which meet twenty-two inches .
The convex part of the bottom of the upper stone fitting the concave part of the top of the under one ; and the concave part of the bottom of the upper stone fitting the convex part of the top of the under stone .

