XXXII .
An Account of a Treatise , presented to the Royal Society , entitled , ` ` Letters concerning Electricity ; in which the latest Discoveries upon this Subject , and the Consequences which may be deduced from them , are examined ; by the Abbe Nollet , Member of the Royal Academy of Sciences of Paris , Fellow of the Royal Society , of the Institute of Bologna , &amp;c. ' ' extracted and translated from the French , by Mr. William Watson , F. R. S. THE work before us contains 262 pages in 12mo , exclusive of the preface , and four copper plates , representing seventeen figures .
Read May 17 , 1753 .
This treatise is the production of a great master upon the subject of electricity : he has already published two volumes expressly thereupon , besides several memoirs among the works of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris .
For several years he has done me the honour of being my correspondent , and I have communicated several valuable papers from him to the Royal Society .
The discoveries made in the summer of the year 1752 will make it memorable in the history of electricity .
These have opened a new field to philosoC c phers , phers , and have given them room to hope , that what they have learned before in their museums , they may apply , with more propriety than they hitherto could have done , in illustrating the nature and effects of thunder ; a phenomenon hitherto almost inaccessible to their inquiries .
But to make the most certain advantage of these new discoveries , we should confine ourselves to facts ; and if we do draw consequences from them , they should be immediate and necessary ones ; for , whenever our discoveries seem to promise to be useful and important , we are apt to hope and expect great success from them : we must therefore be careful to restrain our imagination , or we shall fall into error .
These considerations have induced our author to examine with care , what may truly be concluded from the experiments proposed by Mr. Franklin of Philadelphia , and since carried into execution in France , and elsewhere , in relation to the electricity of the clouds during a storm ; by weighing every circumstance , and comparing the greatness of the effects , which have been had in view , with the more than apparent insufficiency of the means , which have been employed to produce them .
He thinks , he sees clearly , that the considering the electrisation of pointed bodies as a proof of lessening the matter of thunder , is abusing a real discovery to flatter ourselves with a vain hope ; and it is chiefly to dissipate this error , if it yet subsists , that determined our author to print , in the work before us , some reflexions , which he had made at first only for himself , and a few persons , to whom he was desirous of communicating his opinion .
Mr. Franklin 's treatise upon electricity contains a great many very curious experiments ; but the deductions from them being different from those , which the Abbe Nollet has given upon the same subjects , it might be imagined , if he were silent upon this head , that he had given up his former opinions .
The honour , which the Royal Academy of Sciences has done them , in publishing them in their Memoirs , and the kind reception , which the public has given them , has obliged him to re-examine these opinions , and to undertake their defence ; more especially as he sees , that he has powerful reasons to support them .
This has also been a motive for the present publication , which our author is desirous should be considered , less as a criticism upon Mr. Franklin 's doctrine , than as a defence of his own .
In some parts of these letters , our author mentions an electricity , which is very often , and perhaps always , in our atmosphere , when there is no appearance of thunder .
He speaks of this , as if he only suspected it , and , in a manner , as if it wanted confirmation .
He was then unacquainted with some decisive experiments made upon this subject by Dr. le Monnier* , at St. Germain-en-laye , and which have been just published .
He now considers , as a thing certain , that electricity is a very common meteor , which may manifest itself , when the weather is most serene ; * In a memoir read to the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , Nov. 15 , 1752 .
serene ; and that thunder is , strictly speaking , only one of its modifications , which renders it more sensible to us .
The Abbe Nollet 's treatise contains nine letters ; six of which are addressed to Mr. Franklin , one to Mademoiselle Ardinghelli , who , when only sixteen years old , translated Dr. Hales 's treatise of Haemastatics into Italian , and added thereto some very ingenious remarks ; one to Mr. Jallabert of Geneva , and one to Mr. Boze of Wittemberg : To these are added some experiments in electricity , made in support of opinions , laid down in this work , in the presence of Messieurs Bouguer , de Montigny , de Courtivron , d'Alembert , and le Roi , who were appointed by the Royal Academy of Sciences for that purpose .
In the first letter our author gives his correspondent Mademoiselle Ardinghelli an account of the discoveries in electricity in the year 1752 ; among which he takes particular notice of the experiment made on May 10 , at Marly-la-ville , in consequence of Mr. Franklin 's hypothesis ; wherein pointed non-electrics , supported by electrics per se , gave manifest signs of electricity during a thunder-storm .
This experiment , in the letters to Mr. Collinson , Mr. Franklin had proposed , but , as far as may be judged , had not then carried into execution .
The experiment of Marlyla-ville was soon after verified by Dr. le Monnier at St. Germain-en-laye , who found further , first , that the like effects were produced , whether the iron rods were pointed , or not ; and that it was indifferent , whether their position was horizontal , or not .
Secondly , that thunder electrised not only iron , but also wood , living bodies , and other electrisable substances .
Thirdly , that it was not absolutely necessary to place these bodies at the tops of buildings ; and that it was sufficient for them to be placed about four feet from the ground in an open situation , and at some distance from large buildings .
Fourthly , that bodies electrised in this manner produced the like phenomenon with those electrised by glass after the usual manner .
It was afterwards discovered , that electrisable bodies , thus disposed in open air , were sometimes electrised under thick clouds , but without thunder , lightning , or even without rain or hail .
The Abbe Nollet recommends , that these experiments should be made with circumspection , as he has been informed by letters from Florence and Bologna , that those , who have made them there , have had their curiosity more than satisfied by the violent shocks , which they have sustained , in drawing off the sparks from an iron bar electrised by thunder .
One of these in particular says , that once , as he was endeavouring to fasten a small chain , with a copper ball at one of its extremities , to a great chain , which communicated with the bar at the top of the building , in order to draw off the electrical sparks by means of the oscillations of this ball , there came a flash of lightning , which he did not see , but which affected the chain with a noise like wild-fire .
At that instant , the electricity communicated itself to the chain of the copper-ball , and gave the observer so violent a commotion , that the ball fell out of his hands , and he was struck backwards four or five paces .
He never had been so much shocked by the experiment of Leyden .
From the experiment at Marly-la-ville , and those which have been made since , have been drawn two consequences ; one , that the matter of thunder , and that of electricity , are one and the same : the other , that , by the means of pointed iron rods , one might , without its doing any harm , draw off all the fulminating matter from a stormy cloud .
But our author has shown , that bodies being pointed are not absolutely necessary ; and is desirous , we should not too hastily believe , that mischiefs arising from thunder may be averted by the apparatus proposed .
He thinks the means vastly too small for the greatness of the cause .
Our author 's first letter to Mr. Franklin is an introduction to the five subsequent ones .
The second letter treats of the nature of the electric matter .
In this its analogy with fire is considered and proved ; and our author takes notice , that Mr. Franklin , he imagines , who has certainly made some important discoveries into the properties of electricity , cannot but be dissatisfied with the editors of his work , for publishing , ` ` that he exhibited to our consideration an invisible subtle matter , disseminated throughout all nature , &amp;c. which had hitherto escaped our observations .
' ' The latter part of which assertion is not strictly true ; as the considering the matter of fire , and that of electricity , to be one and the same , is a fundamental principle of what both the Abbe Nollet and myself formerly published upon this subject .
The third letter to Mr. Franklin contains several proofs , that glass is not impermeable to the electric matter .
Some of the experiments of our author upon this subject I heretofore did myself the honour to lay before you ; and they are in my opinion fully conclusive .
The fourth letter to Mr. Franklin relates to seveveral phenomenon of the experiment of Leyden .
In this letter it is examined , whether the effects of this experiment proceed from the glass phial , or from the non-electrics contained therein ; and experiments are produced to prove , that the power of giving a shock in an electrised phial of water , proceeds from the water in the phial , and not from the phial itself , as Mr. Franklin imagines .
In this letter likewise is an examination of Mr. Franklin 's opinion , that , in the charged phial , as much fire as is received by one of its surfaces is lost by the other .
The fifth letter to Mr. Franklin is in relation to the power of pointed non-electric bodies drawing off and throwing off electrical fire , at a much greater distance than obtuse bodies do of the same kind .
Our author thinks , that Mr. Franklin has attributed more power to pointed bodies , than , upon experiment he finds to be true .
The sixth letter to Mr. Franklin is upon the analogy of thunder with electricity .
This is a fact at present so well established , as to admit of no doubt .
But our author cannot agree with Mr. Franklin in his opinion , ` ` that thunder is at present in the power of men , and that we are able to dissipate it at our pleasure : that an iron rod ( such a one as Mr. Franklin has directed , and such a one as has been made use of ) is sufficient to discharge of all its fire a stormy cloud against which it is directed .
' ' For his part he confesses , that he cannot believe it ; first , because he sees too great a disproportion between the effect and the cause : secondly , because the principle , which is given us to support this opinion , is not sufficiently established .
He can hardly think , that the sulminating matter , contained in a cloud , capable of covering a great city , can be drawn off in a few minutes by a pointed bar , as thick as your finger .
If even a number of these placed upon the tops of eminencies were only necessary to prevent the effects of thunder , would not the vanes and crosses at the tops of our steeples have been sufficient to procure us this advantage ?
These buildings however , in all times , have not been exempted from the mischiefs of thunder .
He despairs of our weak efforts ever being able to disarm the heavens .
Our author here gives us the representation and description of his apparatus for electrising during the thunder : it differs in nothing essential from those , which we used last year .
In this letter are likewise considered the validity of Mr. Franklin 's hypothesis of electric and non-electric clouds ; the former arising from the sea , the latter from the land ; their operation , upon their approaching one near the other ; the difference , according to Mr. Franklin , between electrical and common fire ; and several other parts of Mr. Franklin 's doctrine .
The eighth letter is addressed to our worthy brother Professor Jallabert of Geneva ; and , among other curious particulars , inserts part of a letter , which our author had received from Mr. Jallabert , giving an account of an experiment , which Mr. Jallabert had some time since made at the water-works at Geneva .
An account of this experiment was communicated by myself to the Society ; and it has near relation to the experiment , which we made here in electrising the river Thames six years ago .
Mr. Jallabert consults the Abbe Nollet in relation to the solution of the phenomenon of this experiment ; and the Abbe does me the honour now to give the same solution thereto , which I first gave to a similar experiment of Dr. le Monnier 's , and laid before the Society in January * 1746 , and since applied upon other occacasions in illustrating the electrical circuit .
The ninth letter is addressed to Mr. Bose , professor of mathematics and philosophy at Wittemberg ; and is in answer to one of Mr. Bose , in which this gentleman expresses himself surprised , that so many ages have passed , without it having been discovered , that thunder electrises bodies ; since it depends upon an experiment so simple , and which it is hardly possible to fail in , when you desire to repeat it under proper circumstances .
Upon this our author observes , that people in general only see the facts , and are ignorant of , or do not consider , the means , by which philosophers arrive at them ; nor perceive the circumstances , without which these phenomenon could never have been made known to us ; and that Mr. Bose will cease to be surprised , as he is so well versed in these phenomenon , when he reflects upon what our author offers .
To * See Phil. Trans. Vol. XLIV .
p. 388 .
To make the experiment in question , it is necessary that bodies should be supported by glass , silk , or resin , without touching any thing else communicating with what we now call non-electrics ; without which , the signs of electricity , which are sought for , cannot manifest themselves .
To this experiment , therefore , a previous knowlege is required , of insulating bodies to be electrised ; but where is the man who was acquainted with this fact thirty years ago ?
Before that period , it was not even guessed at by any one .
Since Mr. Gray discovered , that bodies must be insulated , to communicate to them a perceptible electric virtue , to what purpose could we set up iron bars under a stormy cloud ?
This thought could not have happened , but to those who had taken notice of the analogy between lightning and electricity , and upon whom this idea had made a strong impression .
And no one could think seriously upon this analogy , but since the discovery of the experiment of Leyden , that is , since the year 1746 .
Before that time the electrisation of bodies by thunder could not have been perceived , but by an accident very difficult to meet , on account of the conditions requisite .
Nevertheless it may be urged , that bodies , being really electrised , have shown themselves in all ages * , as *I formerly took notice , that the electrical attraction had been observed so early , as to be mentioned by Theophrastus ( see Phil. Trans. Vol. XLIV .
p. 732 ) ; so its luminous appearance , though only considered as a meteor , is mentioned by Plutarch , in the life of Lysander .
Pliny , in the second book of his natural history , chap .
as historians both ancient and modern have made formal mention thereof .
But to this it may be replied , that it was not enough to know the fact , unless people were enough acquainted with it to take it for what it really was ; that is , the electric virtue : for without that , observations of this kind could have very little weight with 37 , calls these appearances flars ; and tells us , not only that they settled upon the masts , and other parts of ships , but also upon mens heads : ` Exsistunt ( says that historian ) stellae et in mari terrisque .
` Vidi nocturnis militum vigiliis inhaerere pilis pro vallo fulgorem ` effigy ea : et antennis navigantium , aliisque navium partibus , ` ceu vocali quodam sono insistunt , ut volucres sedem ex sede mu ` tantes : ... .
geminae autem salutares , et prosperi cursus ` praenunciae ; quarum adventu , fugari diram illam ac minacem , ` appellatamque Helenam , ferunt .
Et ob id Polluci et Castori id ` numen assignant , eosque in mari deos invocant .
Hominum quo ` que capiti vespertinis horis , magno praesagio circumfulgent .
' ' But ( adds he ) all these things are ` incerta ratione , et in naturae ` majestate abdita .
' Seneca , in his Natural Questions , chap .
1 .
takes notice of the same phenomenon .
` Gylippo ( says he ) Syracusas petenti visa est ` stella super ipsam lancem constitisse .
In Romanorum castris visa ` sunt ardere pila , ignibus scilicet in illa delapsis .
' Caesar de Bello Africano , cap. 6 .
edit .
Amstel .
1686 .
We here find them attending a very violent storm .
` Per id tempus fere ` Caesaris exercitui res accidit incredibilis auditu ; nempe Virgili ` arum signo confecto , circiter vigilia secunda noctis , nimbus cum ` saxea grandine subito est exortus ingens ... .
Eadem nocte ` V legionis pilorum cacumina sua sponte arserunt .
' Livy , chap .
22 .
mentions two similar facts : ` In Sicilia militi ` bus aliquot spicula , in Sardinia in muro circumeunti vigilias ` equiti , scipionem , quem in manu tenuerat , arsisse , et litora cre ` bris ignibus fulsisse .
' These appearances are called by both French and Spaniards inhabiting the coasts of the mediterranean , St. Helm or St. Telme 's with any person engaged in the inquiry .
At present , indeed , when we know , from the experiment of Marly-la-ville , that a stormy cloud is a great electric mass , the action of which extends itself sensibly even to bodies , which are upon the surface of the earth , we must agree , by reflecting on them , that the lights , which have been seen upon the crosses placed on the tops of several steeples , those , which the Roman soldiers said they had observed at the end of their pikes , and those lambent flames , which appear upon the masts of ships , which mariners call St. Helmo 's fire , are so many electrical phenomenon .
But until the moment that this experiment was made , which opened our eyes with regard to the possibility and nature of these marvellous effects , these appearances were regarded either as popular illusions , or false prodigies , or even as luminous vapours , which might be ranged in the class of phosphori .
Moreover , as these were seen but seldom , if ever we had been tempted to attribute them to the influence of stormy clouds , we might have been dissuaded therefrom , by considering the little agreement there is , between the rarity of fires ; by the Italians , the fires of St. Peter and St. Nicholas , and are frequently taken notice of by the writers of voyages .
If some late accounts from France are to be depended upon , we are informed , that a Plauzet it has been observed for time immemorial ; and M. Binon , the cure of the place , bears his testimony of the truth , that , for twenty-seven years , which he has resided there in that capacity , in great storms , accompanied with black clouds , and frequent lightnings , the three pointed extremities of the cross of the steeple of that place appear surrounded with a body of flame ; and that , when this phenomenon has been seen , the storm was no longer to be dreaded , and calm weather returned soon of these effects , and the frequency of the causes , which might produce them .
We see , therefore , how important it is to describe exactly the phenomenon we observe : otherwise , how long may it be , before we can deduce any real instruction from those , which we have been informed of in a negligent and superficial manner ?
We have heard all our lives of St. Helmo 's fire , of those which the ancients call Castor and Pollux , and of the comazants of our mariners .
But , from what we have had related to us , and from what we have read , who could have been prevailed upon to range them with electrical phenomenon ?
We have heard them represented , as thin lambent shining lights , a kind of phosphoreal vapour : but there is a passage in the memoirs of the Count de Forbin , quoted by our author , wherein mention is made of St. Helmo 's fire ; which if any one , well versed in the phenomenon of electricity , had carefully attended to and considered a few years ago , he might have prognosticated success to Mr. Franklin , when he proposed his experiment upon thunder .
` ` In the night ( says the author of those memoirs ) on a sudden it became exceedingly dark , and thundered and lightened most dreadfully .
As we were threatened with the ship 's being torn to pieces , I ordered the sails to be taken in : We saw , upon different parts of the ship , above thirty St. Helmo 's fires : Among the rest , there was one upon the top of the vane of the main-mast , which was more than a foot and half in height .
I ordered one of the sailors to take it down : When this man was on the top , he heard this fire ; its noise resembled that of fired wet gunpowder : I ordered him to lower the vane , and come down ; but scarce had he taken it from its place , but the fire left it , and fixed itself upon the top of the mainmast , from which it was impossible to remove it ; and continued there a considerable time , until it went out by little and little , &amp;c. ' ' If all the authors , who have taken notice of St. Helmo 's fire , had spoken of it as this just quoted , philosophers might have reproached themselves for its having been so long before they had a just idea thereof , and for their not having shown the principle upon which it depended .
But how few historians are there , who could have related this fact with circumstances so proper to put us in a right train , as those just mentioned ?
And here I cannot but observe , as I am convinced , that the matter of thunder and that of of electricity are one and the same , how vast an idea must the attending to the before-mentioned passage excite in the mind of persons , accustomed to the phenomenon of electricity ?
How immense a quantity of it must they conceive to have been at that time in the atmosphere surrounding the ship , and within the verge of its action , to furnish more than thirty St. Helmo 's fires ; the same , in fact , which we see at the ends of our conductors in electrising , one of which was more than a foot and half in height ?
At this time , and under these circumstances , the masts , yards , and every part of the ships , I consider as conductors of electricity , between the , at this time electrised , atmosphere , and the sea : and tho ' , being of a vegetable nature , and , if dry , even of the worst kind for this purpose , pose , they conducted electricity much less perfectly than metal under the like circumstances would have done , I doubt not , but that they were greatly instrumental in averting the danger , with which the ship was threatened .
Upon these considerations , I do not scruple to recommend , as Mr. Franklin has done , communications of metal between the spindles and ironwork at the tops of the masts of ships , and the sea ; or , which will answer the same purpose , the bilge water in the well .
This can be liable to little objection , as the doing it is neither difficult , nor expensive ; an iron wire , of the thickness of a goosequill , conducting electricity more readily than any piece of timber , however large ; and these masts do it so much the worse , as they are of a resinous nature .
From attending to these phenomenon , we every day see more and more the perfect analogy ( to compare great things with small ) between the highly electrised glass jar , in the experiment of Leyden , and a cloud replete with the matter of thunder .
But more of this possibly upon some future occasion .
Though the number and continuance of the St. Helmo 's fires , in the passage before-mentioned , probably tended greatly to preserve the ship from the destruction , with which it was then threatened , yet the cause may be too great , and come on too fast , to be lessened enough by these means to avert the mischief .
Thus in the account , published in the * Philosophical Transactions , from Captain John Waddel , * Vol. XLVI .
p. III .
Waddel , his ship was almost beaten to pieces by the thunder and lighting : although , as he expresses himself , there were sundry large comazants over head , some of which settled on the spindles on the topmast-heads , and burnt like very large torches .
When this account was written , these phenomenon were only considered as the presages or attendants of a storm , and no sort of inference proposed from them .
' ' But to return to our author : His work closes with a series of experiments , intended to demonstrate the validity of the conclusions exhibited therein .
These merit the particular attention of those conversant in these matters ; but I must refer you here to the work itself , and only observe , that some of the experiments are made in vacuo , and are of the same kind with those which I communicated to the Royal Society in February 1752 ; and which have been since published in the Philosophical Transactions * .
Upon the whole , I think the treatise before us a very valuable one , as it gives us the still riper thoughts of an able writer upon a difficult , and , till very lately , an almost unknown , subject ; of one , who , besides his inquiries into this part of philosophy , has a great compass in the knowlege of nature , and is therefore well qualified to investigate her phenomenon .
* Vol. XLVII .
p. 363 , et seq.

