XXIII .
A Letter from the Rev. Mr. George Costard to Dr. Bevis , concerning an Eclipse mentioned by Xenophon .
Dear Sir , OF what use the doctrine of eclipses is in history and chronology , you know too well for me to tell you .
The earliest account of any in the Greek history is that said to have been foretold by Thales to the Ionians .
Of this I shall say nothing more at present , for fear of repeating what I have already observed to you upon that subject .
The next , that is generally taken notice of by writers , is , that in the first year of the Peloponnesian war mentioned by Thucydides .
But there is another before that , as I apprehend , equally remarkable , which , as Mr. Jackson ( Vol. I. p. 426 .
) hath quoted me for , may deserve some farther consideration .
Read April 12~ 1753 .
It is well known , that Herodotus and other writers make Cyrus to have deposed Astyages .
On the contrary , Xenophon says , that Astyages was succeeded by his son Cyaxares , who left the kingdom to Cyrus by will .
The truth , I believe , is , that Cyrus did not depose Astyages , and therefore so far Xenophon is right , but deposed Cyaxares ; in which he was designedly wrong .
That he knew the Persians forced the empire from the Medes , I think , appears from some no very obscure hints even in the Cyropaedia itself .
But that argument I shall not enter into farther at present .
In his Anabasis , which is nothing but a journal of his march , and where he relates things as he found them , he expressly asserts it .
For he says , that the Greeks in their return home , came down to the river Tigris , where had formerly been a large but at that time deserted city called Larissa , inhabited formerly by the Medes .
~ , continues he , ~ NON ~ ~ ~ Tho ' Xenophon calls this a cloud , yet the word ~ anon , probably made use of by those , from whom he received his account , not only signifies a cloud , but any obstacle in general .
That such effects could be owing to no common cloud , I imagined must be evident enough .
And as the year before Christ 547 , from a number of arguments , too long to be here insisted on , appeared to me to be the year , when Cyrus finished his reduction of the Median empire , I was naturally led to try , whether there was any solar eclipse that year , that could be the cause of so remarkable a darkness .
The geography of the east is so very imperfect , that it may be difficult to determine the situation of this Larissa .
For Xenophon hath given no other account of it , than that it lay on the banks of the Tigris .
It is not improbable however , as Bochart thinks , that Xenophon inquired upon the spot , What ruins those were ?
And was answered ~ Laresen , i. e. Resen 's , or the ruins of Resen .
But this he easily mistook , or changed into Larissa , a name he was much better acquainted with .
Resen is a place mentioned Gen. x. 12 .
and there said to lie between Nineveh and Calah .
This perhaps may help us in some sort towards its situation .
Mausil ( says Abulfeda ) metropolis est regionum Mesopotamiae .
Imposita est Tigri , a latere ejus occiduo .
Ex adversum , a latere ejus eoo , est civitas Nineveh ruinis sepulta .
Ad austrum Mausilae effundit sese Zabus minor in Tigrim .
In Abulfeda , the longitude of Mausil is 67~ , and its latitude north 36~ 30~ .
But in Ulugh Beigh , and Nassir Ettusi , it hath longitude 77~ .
The last of these two authors agrees with Abulfeda , as to its latitude , but the former of them assigns it 34~ 30~ ; which makes a difference of two degrees , or 120 geographical miles .
Chrysococca , in his tables , hath ~ , to which he assigns longitude ( ~ ) 69 , and latitude ( ~ ) 35 .
This author reckons his longitudes ~~~~ ~ , as Abulfeda doth his .
But Nassir Ettusi and Ulugh Beigh begin theirs ~~~ from the Fortunate Islands .
The difference between the two computations is 10 degrees , according to Abulseda , tho ' others make it 17~ 30~ .
Varenius , and modern geographers , place Mousol in longitude east from London 43~ , and in latitude north 34~ 32~ : And this , I suppose , is as exact as any .
In the year before Christ , therefore , 547 , the apparent time of the true conjunction was at Greenwich , October 21d 23h 39~ 18~ .
The place of the luminaries 6~ 24~ 9~ 0~ Moon 's latitude north 46 24 Semidiameter of the earth 's disk 61 18 Semidiameter of the penumbra 33~ 11~ Beginning of the central eclipse , 22h 39~ 7~ .
End of the central eclipse 22d ~h 55~ 55~ .
Duration 2h 16~ 48~ .
Angle of the moon 's way with a circle of latiude , 84~ 25~ .
Moon 's semidiameter 16~ 50~ .
Sun 's semidiameter 16~ 21~ .
Angle of the moon 's way with a circle of latitude , 84~ 25~ .
~~~ The sun rose centrally eclipsed , in longitude west from Greenwich , 54 46 10 In latitude north 71 44 40 The sun set centrally eclipsed , in longitude east from Greenwich , 91 6 50 In latitude north , 23 9 40 The place of the center was at the following times , as computed at Greenwich , thus , Times .
Longitudes .
Latitudes .
dh~~~~~~~~ October 21 23 39 47 23 7 30E 39 48 40N 23 47 31 28 36 40 34 20 50 22 02 31 37 13 30 30 24 30 0 17 31 57 19 40 26 56 40 By this table it is easy to see , that the center of the shadow crossed the deserts of Arabia , and then passed over the Persian Gulf below the mouth of the Euphrates .
But if you will make the same allowance , as I did in my last , for the moon 's acceleration , or the small retardation of the earth 's diurnal motion , the place of the center will be found at the following times , as reckoned at Greenwich , thus , Times .
Longitudes .
Latitudes .
dh~~~~~~~~ October 21 23 2 31 39 1 40E 34 20 50N 23 17 31 47 38 30 30 24 30 23 32 31 68 9 40 26 56 40 By this table then it appears , that the center of the shadow passed more northward than the former track , and went over Kerkisia , not improbably , the Carchemish of the prophet Jeremiah , and a small matter to the north of Bagdad .
It is not improbable therefore , that it crossed the Tigris not far from the place where , it seems by Xenophon 's account , Larissa was situated , and where , consequently , it would cause such a darkness , as might well be attended with the effects he mentions .
This eclipse is , I take it , no inconsiderable acquisition to history and chronology , and is at the same time a confirmation of the suspicion , that , in these very ancient ones , there is some allowance or other to be made for the influence of some cause , whatever it may be , hitherto not fully determined .
This must be left for future observations .
In the mean time however it may be of service to the science of astronomy , to examine all the past eclipses , that can be come at , and compare them with circumstances in the best manner we are able .
I have three more by me , which may some time or other make their appearance in the same manner with the present one .
In the mean time I shall add , that in Ebn Younis 's eclipse , in the year after Christ 979 , the time of the mean opposition was , by my calculation , May 14d 3h 50~ 30~ .
~~~~ The sun 's place 1 27 53 0 The moon 's place in the ecliptic 7 27 53 0 Moon 's latitude north 37 42 Place of her apogee 4 13 50 46 Place of her node 254 14 Sun 's mean anomaly 11 1 29 47 Place of his apogee 2 25 29 30 Digits eclipsed 8d 4~ .
These numbers are something different from those , which , I think , I gave Dr. Bradley some time ago~ For I had made , some how or other , a small mistake in the place of the sun 's apogee , which was kindly hinted to me by Mr. M. I have , since that , gone over the whole calculation again , and believe it is pretty exact , and agrees well enough with what Ebn Younis relates , that Spatium , quod eclipsatum fuit de diametro ejus ( lunae ) fuit amplius quam octo digiti , et minus quam novem .
And afterwards , Et erat luna , in hac eclipsi , in propinquo distantiae suae mediae .
I have been led insensibly farther than I intended at first , which was only to explain the grounds of what I had said to Mr. Jackson .
But your love to the science will excuse the trouble I have given you , and make any farther apology needless .
I am , dear Sir , Oct. 3 , 1752 .
Your very affectionate , &amp;c. G. Costard .

