However difficult it may be to account for Father Frisius 's expressions , I shall hazard yet another conjecture .
His great zeal for Sir Isaac , for which he is certainly to be commended ( if not blinded by that zeal ) has hindered him from distinguishing between the different ways of opposing that great man 's sentiments .
Perceiving then , that my calculations ( ~ L. Part II .
) had led me to a result quite different from Sir Isaac 's assertion , ( Prop. XX .
lib. 3 .
) he was offended at my boldness to such a degree , that he was unable to examine impartially what I said ; and , instead of discussing a mathematical question quite independent of any actual measure , wherein if I were mistaken , he would have forced every geometrician to condemn me , he has supposed , that I have built my argument upon an operation , which was not performed at the time when I wrote .
This conjecture would appear to me the true cause of F. Frisius 's error , if it were not inconsistent with a proceeding of his towards Sir Isaac , which I will venture to relate .
After F. Frisius has examined himself the 19 problem of the third book of the Principia , which is much less complicated than that I spoke of , the truth of which is incontestable , he finds , by his own mistake , a disagreement with the result of that proposition , and charges that illustrious author , without the least apology , with an error , which , says he , ( quite from the purpose ) is the sixth , that has been found in the same work , and also gives an enumeration of the five others , altho ' they are not at all concerned in the question .
I cannot forbear saying , that the manner , in which I have proposed my remarks upon the 20th proposition of Sir Isaac , has nothing of that slight way of treating so great a man ; and as my utmost wish is to be judged on that account by the Royal Society , I shall relate what were my objections ; which I cannot effect in a more concise and clear method , than by giving the translation of the article , which contains it .
~ LI .
of the second part of the theory , &amp;c. In which is seen what had induced Sir Is .
Newton to think , that the planets , when denser at the center than at the surface , ought to be flatter than in case of homogeneity .
Some years ago I gave , in the Philos. Trans. No 449 , the theorem of the precedent article ; and on this occasion I mentioned a passage of Sir Isaac contrary to it .
Not having at that time looked into the second edition of his Principia , I could not know what had engaged that illustrious philosopher to think so ; and far from suspecting any mistake in his proposition , I was contented to think , that the difference between our conclusions arose from a different way of conceiving the inside of the earth ; and I imagined , that he had happened to fall upon such a disposition of parts , as would answer to his assertion .
I then follow 'd only his commentators , and especially Dr. Gregory , showing , that his explanation of Sir Isaac 's conclusion was wrong , as grounded upon a proposition , which did not hold in the present case For that proposition ( which is , that the gravity at any point of the earth is inversedly as the distance from the center ) has only room , when the earth is homogeneous ; and , consequently , ought not to be made use of , when the density is greater towards the center than at the superficies .
Since I have discovered , that the theorem , the demonstration of which I had given in the Philos. Trans. for the case of beds supposed of the same ellipticity , has room in an infinity of other suppositions , I have taken greater care to discover what could have induced Sir Isaac to think , that the earth is flatter , as the gravity is more decreasing from the pole towards the equator ; and I believe I have found it out in the second edition of the Principia , and it is , for having built upon the same argument as Dr. Gregory .
In p. 386 , after having observed , that the experiments gave a diminution of two lines to the second pendulum from the pole to the equator , he argues thus : Since , says he , the case of homogeneity afforded only 1 87/ 5000 4 , the difference 71/ 6 miles between the two diameters ( which follow 'd from the same hypothesis ) is to be magnified in the ratio of 1 87/ 1000 to 2 , and it will come out 31 7/ 12 miles for the real difference .
For , pursues he , the retardation of the pendulum at the equator denotes the diminution of the gravity in that place ; and the lighter the matter is there , the higher will it rise to be equiponderant with that of the pole .
Further , p. 387 , examining the measures of the degrees of latitude made in France by M. Cassini , by which the earth is higher at the pole than at the equator by about 95 miles , he pretends , that accordingly the pendulum should be longer at the equator than at the pole by about half an inch .
And all that , methinks , shows the opinion , which Sir Isaac was of , that , in any case whatsoever , the equilibrium requires a gravity inversedly proportional to the length of the columns , which proportion , as I hope to have evinced , is only demonstrated in the case of homogeneity , and is not true in general .
Thus , what I argued in the Phil. Trans. against Dr. Gregory , has also room against Sir Isaac .
' ' By all that I have said , every body may judge , whether differing from Sir Isaac 's sentiments on a point , which I had for so long a time examined , I did not express my disagreement with him in as decent a manner , as any one should , when speaking of so great a man .
And in case the Royal Society thought some alterations were to be made in the form of my remarks , I declare , that I shall execute it , as may be prescribed to me by that illustrious company .
But I cannot help thinking , that , unless those , who would examine my demonstrations , find some error in them , no alteration is requisite to be made in my expressions .
I desire then either F. Frisius , or any geometrician , who thinks the question worth his examination , to take the trouble of reviewing my calculations , and to believe me ready to acknowledge my error , when shown to me by a candid and impartial examiner .
A Translation and Explanation of some Articles of the Book entitled , Theory de la Figure de la Terre ; by Mons. Clairaut , of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , and F. R. S. MR. Short , in his account of Father Frisius 's Disquisitio mathematica in causam physicam figurae et magnitudinis telluris nostrae , having reported that philosopher 's sentiments K on Read Feb. 15 , on my reflections upon the same matter , without taking the trouble to examine whether they were founded upon the truth or not , I find myself under the necessity of laying before the Royal Society the passages of my book , which , having been misunderstood by F. Frisius , have occasioned the misconstruction , which he has made of my sentiments , either upon the trust I give to the actual operation made for discovering the figure of the earth , or Sir Isaac Newton 's theoretical inquiries about the same subject .
The expressions of Father Frisius , referred to by Mr. Short , are as follow : Quia tamen plerique omnes hucusque , aut nihil pro figura telluris determinanda ex iis observationibus deduci~ posse cum geometra celeberrimo Ruggero Boscovik autumarunt , aut exinde cum Ill. Clairaut , Bouguer , aliisque , contra incomparabilem virum ac prope divinum Isaacum Newton insurgentes , admirabilem ipsius theoriam facto minus respondentem dixerunt , assignatamque in prop. 19 .
lib. 3 .
Princip .
Mathem .
terrestrium axium proportionem a vera absonam omnino esse , alios mihi observationibus parum , alios nimis tribuere visum est , omnes ferme oppositis erroribus peccasse , ubi res neque aurificis lance , neque molitoris , ut aiunt , statera librandae sunt .
' ' This , when compared with the propositions of my theory , which they are relative to , will appear , I hope , quite incoherent : and I cannot show it more clearly , than by translating the last chapter of my book , to which F. Frisius refers the reader .
For the better understanding of that chapter , it is proper to know , that the chief results of the precedent inquiries are these theorems : 1 .
Supposing the earth in its former state composed of several fluids of different densities , and settled all in equilibrium by the laws of gravity and centrifugal forces , the surfaces separating the different mediums will always affect the form of a curve ; which is so near to the ellipsis , that it may be supposed so , without any error of the least moment .
2 .
That , in the case of the denser fluids being nearer to the center , as hydrostatics require , the spheroid will always be less flat than in the homogeneous one , and vice versa .
3 .
And as to the diminution of the gravity from the pole to the equator , it will always follow the opposite rule ; viz. if the spheroid be denser towards the center , the gravity will decrease in a less ratio than in the homogeneous spheroid , and vice versa .
4 .
That if ~ represent the fraction found out for the difference of diameters , 1/ 115 ~ will express the total diminution of the gravity from the pole to the equator , not only in the case of the spheroid supposed originally fluid , but in any supposition of variation for the densities and proportion of the diameters of the beds , provided they be elliptical .
These premised , let us proceed to the said last chapter of the theory of the earth 's figure ; in which the principles laid down in the preceding chapters are compared with the observations .
~ LXVIII .
For the diminution of the gravity from the North to the South .
It has been seen in the preceding chapter , that when a spheroid is not supposed homogeneous , the diminution of the gravity from the pole to the equator will be greater than in the case of homogeneity .
Hence , if my theory holds in our globe , the whole decreasing of the gravity will be equal to 1/ 230 or greater , and never less ; since the ratio of 230 to 231 will ( ~ XXI .
) express the ratio of the action of gravity at the equator and pole , when the spheroid is homogeneous .
And this conclusion of my theory quite agrees with experience ; for , from all the observations relating to the gravity made in several places of the globe , either by actual measures of the second pendulum , or by the difference of duration of the same pendulum 's vibrations , it appears , that the gravity decreases from the north to the south in a greater ratio , than it would be if the total diminution from the pole to the equator were only 1/ 231 .
~ 69 .
For the proportion of the two diameters .
Supposing , as in the precedent chapter , the earth originally fluid , it follows , from the ~ LXV .
that the ratio of the two diameters cannot exceed that of 230 to 231 ; since , ~ XX .
230 to 231 is the ratio in the case of the homogeneous spheroid ; and as the mensurations of the gravity cannot agree with the supposition of the homogeneity , the diameters of the earth ought to be in a ratio less than 230 to 231 .
Without adhering to the supposition of the earth 's being formally fluid , but admitting , as in the chap .
3 and 4 , all generality possible in the variation of density and ratio of diameters of the beds or~ strata laid down from the center to the surface , there will still happen a difference of the diameters less than 1/ 230 .
For , by ~ L. the total diminution of the gravity from the pole to the equator being subtracted from 1/ 115 , the remainder is the difference between the diameters .
Now the diminution of the gravity having been found greater than 1/ 230 , the ellipticity or difference of diameters ought to be less than that fraction , and consequently the ratio of diameters less than 230 to 231 .
That consequence of my theory is not so happy as the preceding ; for the degree measured in the north compared to that of France give the two diameters as 177 to 178 , which ratio is greater than 230 to 231 , instead of being less , as the theory would require .
As the measures made in the north have been performed with great care and exactness , their result seems at first to be preferred to that of my theory .
But a reflection upon the errors unavoidable in actual measures , and an examination of the limits of these errors , will show , that , without violating the measures , they would be brought nearer the theory , and even agree with it .
For , by a convenient calculation , it will be found , that a diminution less than 60 toises , made to the difference between the degrees of Paris and Tornea , would give the diameters in the ratio of 230 to 231 .
And if it be considered , what is the smallness of an error of 60 toises , when divided in two operations~ which require require so great a number of astronomical and geographical observations , it will be thought , that an error a little larger may be supposed , without disparaging either our operation , or Mr. Picard 's ; and thus theory and experience would agree .
Supposing , for example , that the difference between the degrees of Paris and Tornea has been found too great by 80 toises , the difference between the two diameters will come out of about 1/ 260 , which , subtracted from 1/ 115 gives 1/ 206 for the diminution of the gravity from the pole to the equator .
And such a conclusion would agree pretty well with the observations made in France and Lapland with the excellent clock of Mr. Graham .
However , altho ' the errors to be supposed in the operations , to reconcile them with my theory , be in themselves small enough , I shall abstain from asserting , that they have been committed .
It is a fact not to be decided , till after the result of the observations , which are expected from Peru .
For the great difference , which is to be found between the degrees of Quito and Tornea , is the only means of knowing , whether the diameters be less or greater than 230 to 231 .
Were the question only to demonstrate the flatness of the earth , the measures of the degree of Paris and Tornea would be full sufficient ; but to discover the true ratio of diameters , is what can be performed only by the comparison between the degrees , whose mutual distance is the greatest .
Such a ratio once fixed , if it happen to be less than 230 to 231 , it will be very easy , by the preceding theory , to imagine some hypothesis for the inside of the earth , which shall agree with both theory and observation , whether admitting the supposition of the original fluidity of the globe , or not .
But if the diameters were found undoubtedly in a greater ratio to one another than 230 to 231 , I own , that not only the theory established in this second part of my book must be abandoned , but it would be very difficult to reconcile the measures of the pendulums with those of the degrees in Sir Isaac 's system .
And I dare say , that the success in that case would hardly depend upon any natural hypothesis .
The subsequent LXX article containing only a proof , that the preceding theory agrees with any ratio between 1/ 23 and 1/ 90 for the quantity , which expresses the excess of Jupiter 's equator above its axis , there is no necessity for the translation of the arguments leading to a result so answering to the observations ; and I pass to the conclusion of that article , which ends my book .
The preceding theory agreeing with all the measures of the pendulum , and observations of Jupiter 's diameters , if , besides , it happen , that the measures expected from Peru give , when compared with those of Lapland , a difference of diameters less than 1/ 230 , this theory will have all possible confirmation , and the universal gravitation so well agreeing with the motions of the planets will also agree with their figures .
Now I beg every candid reader to examine , whether , in that chapter quoted by F. Frisius , I have too much relied upon the certainty of observations , and attempted to disparage Sir Isaac Newton 's discoveries .
In the first place , I will ask of Father Frisius , if , before the operations , which I depended upon , were performed , I could establish any thing against their agreeing , or not , with Sir Isaac 's proposition about the same matter ?
He perhaps will answer , That my remark of the LXIX art .
But if the diameters were found undoubtedly in a greater ratio to one another than 230 to 231 , imports , that I was not thoroughly convinced , that what care soever would be taken by the gentlemen sent into Peru , they never would be able to measure their degree with a sufficient exactness , to conclude , from its length , compared with that of the other degrees , whether the diameters were in a greater or less ratio than 230 to 231 ; and consequently he will think , that my being in suspense about it was an offence against Sir Isaac 's theoretical determination .
Then , I request Father Frisius~ to tell me , why he is so good as to commend operations so void of use as those , which tended only to discover what was demonstrated before , and needed not to be confirmed , since it could not be invalidated .
Perhaps Father Frisius , in representing me as depending too much upon the observations , relied on these expressions of the LXIX art .
As the measures of the gravity cannot agree with the supposition of the homogeneity : and I confess , that it seems to me impossible to reconcile the great number of all the measures of that sort with the table , which follows the homogeneity .
For the simplicity of the means made use of in the performance of those measures cannot admit the errors , which should be supposed to bring them to Sir Isaac 's theory : but as this theory is founded on the homogeneity , which is only a mere supposition ; and as he has himself suspected , in his second and third edition , that the internal parts of the earth might be denser than those towards the superficies , I do not see how I oppose myself that illustrious philosopher , when I assume the same hypothesis , as he does .
As I shall use all possible endeavour to understand F. Frisius 's meaning , I hazard this conjecture .
Seeing that I thought favourably enough of the exactness to be obtained in astronomy , when observations have been already made in great numbers , and with all possible care , to suppose them fit to let us know , whether the diameters are in a greater or a less ratio than 230 to 231 ; and being informed afterwards , that the operation made in Peru led those , who have made use of it , to imagine the spheroid flatter than the homogeneous , he concludes , that I cannot help thinking like them , and accordingly indulges himself in exposing , how much I over-rate the validity of observations , and how little I know the submission due to a proposition of Sir Isaac ; which , I must say , by the bye , that great man has never himself given as impossible to be opposed by experience .
But yet I would ask of F. Frisius , wherefore he will guess at my sentiments , whilst I have not given room to know them on that point ?
How can he know , whether , since the examination of all the measures , I have not found any way to reconcile them with the theory ?
Which I say in no manner as a hint I intend to make any corrections in those measures , but merely to show the little foundation , which F. Frisius had to represent me as he has done .

