Philos. Trans. Vol. XLVIII .
TAB. III .
p.55 .
Sylley Islands their Distances &amp; Flats .
~ .
W E~ ~~ ~I~A F ~ .
~ G~D~B~~ EKC Islands ~ Land 's End L~ ~H ~ ~ 12345 miles An Account of the great Alterations which the Islands of Sylley have undergone since the Time of the Ancients , who mention them , as to their Number , Extent , and Position : In a Letter to the Rev. Thomas Birch , D.D. Secr. R. S. by the Rev. Mr. Wm Borlase , M. A. F. R. S. Reverend Sir , HAVING made a little tour to the islands of Sylley last summer , and finding them very different from what I imagined , and from the descriptions given us of them , and the trade to them , by the ancients , had concluded them to be , you will excuse my sending you an observation or two , which occurred to me relating to their natural history , and the considerable alterations , which they must have undergone , since they were first taken notice of in history , and what I think may have been the cause of these alterations .
Read Feb. 8 , 1753 .
These islands being so noted among the ancients , I expected to find among the inhabitants a conscious esteem of their own antiquity , and of their appearance in history before the other parts of Britain were at all known .
I was not without hopes of finding old towns and castles , perhaps inscriptions , and works of grandeur .
But there is nothing of this kind ; the inhabitants are all new-comers ; not an old habitation worth notice ; nor any remains of Phenician , Grecian , or Roman art , either in town , castle , port , temple , or sepulchre .
All the antiquities here to be seen are of the rudest Druid times ; and , if borrowed in any measure , from those eastern traders before-mention 'd ( superstition being very catching and infectious ) were borrowed from their most ancient and simple rites .
We are not to think , however , but that Sylley was really inhabited , and as frequently resorted to antiently , as the old historians relate .
All the islands ( several of which are now without cattle , or inhabitant ) by the mains of hedges , walls , foundations of many contiguous houses , and a great number of sepulchral barrows , show , that they have been fully cultivated , and inhabited .
That they were inhabited by Britons , is past all doubt , not only from their neighbourhood to England , but from the Druid monuments ; several rude stone pillars ; Circles of stones erect ; Kist-vaens without number ; Rock-basons ; Tolmens ; all monuments common in Cornwall and Wales , and equal evidences of the antiquity , religion , and original of the old inhabitants .
They have also British names for their little islands , tenements , and creeks .
How came these ancient inhabitants then ( it may be asked ) to vanish , so as that the present have no pretensions pretensions to any affinity or connexion of any kind with them , either in blood , language , or customs ?
How came they to disappear , and leave so few traces of trade , plenty , or arts , and no posterity , that we can learn , behind them ?
This is what the curious will be solicitous to know ; and two causes of this fact occurred to me whilst I was at Sylley , which may perhaps satisfy their inquiries : The manifest encroachments of the sea , and as manifest a subsidence of some parts of the land .
~ 2 .
The sea is the insatiable monster , which devours these little islands , gorges itself with the earth , sand , clay , and all the yielding parts , and leaves nothing , where it can reach , but the skeleton , the bared rock .
The continual advances , which the sea makes upon the low-lands , at present , are plain to all people of observation , and within these last thirty years have been very considerable .
What we see happening every day may assure us of what has happened in former times ; and from the banks of sand and earth giving way to the sea , and the breaches becoming still more open , and irrecoverable , it appears , that repeated tempests have occasioned a gradual dissolution of the solids for many ages , and as gradual progressive ascendency of the fluids .
Again ; the flats , which stretch from one island to another , are plain evidences of a former union subsisting between many now distinct islands .
The flats between Trescaw , Brehar , and Sampson , ( marked DE in the map ) are quite dry at a spring-tide , and men easily pass dry-shod from one island to another , over sand-banks , ( where , upon the shifting of the sands , walls , and ruins are frequently discovered ) upon which at full sea there are ten and twelve feet of water~ From the southern side of St. Martin 's , ( marked A ) in the map annexed , there stretches out a large shoal towards Treseaw and St. Mary 's ; and from St. Mary 's , a flat called Sandy-bar ( marked C ) shoots away to meet it ; and between these two shoals there are but four feet of water , in the chanel called Crow-sound : All strong arguments , that these islands were once one continued tract of land , tho ' now , as to their low-lands , over-run with the sea and sand .
History confirms their former union .
` ` The isles Cassiterides ( says Strabo * ) are ten in number , close to one another ; one of them is desert and unpeopled , the rest are inhabited .
' ' But see how the sea has multiplied these islands ; there are now reckoned one hundred and forty : Into so many fragments are they divided , and yet there are but six inhabited .
~ 3 .
But no circumstance can show the great alterations , which have happened in the number and extent of these islands more than this ; viz. that the isle of Sylley , from which the little cluster of these Cyclades takes its name , is no more at present than a high rock , of about a furlong over , whose cliffs hardly any thing but birds can mount , and whose barrenness could never suffer any thing but sea-birds to inhabit it .
How then came all these islands to have their general name from such a small and useless plot ?
From the disposition of the rocks and islets here , and allowing the alterations before suggested , we may answer this question , which would otherwise be extremely difficult to solve .
From From the southermost hill of Brehar I observed the Guel hill , and the isle of Guel ( marked I ) stretching away towards the little isle of Sylley , and with it making a curve , of which Sylley is the head-land : from the furthermost hill of Brehar , a promontory shoots out in the same sweep , and at the extremity , a vast rocky Tor called the Brehar , behind which a ledge of many pointed rocks show themselves above water , intimating the former connexion , and with what great devastations the furious ocean has dissolved it .
So that Sylley , which is now a bare rock , and separated from the lands of Guel and Brehar by a narrow frith of sea , was formerly joined to them by low necks of lands , being the rocky promontory of one large island now broke into seven .
To pursue this conjecture ( if I may call that so , which has so many reasons to support it ) a little farther : When all these seven islands , Sampson , Brehar , Trescaw , St. Elen 's , Theon , St. Martin 's , and St. Mary 's , made but one , that one went by the name of Sylley , or some name of like sound and derivation * ; and , having some little islands scattered round it , imparted its name to them ; whence , what were called by the Greeks Cassiterides , were named by the Latin authors Sygdeles , Sillinae , or Silures , from the British name , as I apprehend , which they found them called by H2 among * Sul-leh signifies in Cornu-british , flat rocks , of , or dedicated to , the sun .
So the mount of St. Michael was called in Cornubritish Din-sul , the hill consecrated to the sun ; and , as I conjecture , the vast flat rocks , common in these islands , had the like dedication : For , upon the surface of one of them , there are the remains of an ancient Druid temple .
It is one plane of ~ k , edged with nine vast stones ( the rest taken away ) planted in a circular line , measuring 172 feet from north to south , and 138 feet from east to among the natives .
I must go farther still , and observe that the promontory ( at present called Sylley island ) lying westernmost of all the high lands , was the first land of all the islands discerned by traders from the Mediterranean , and Spanish coasts , and , as soon as discovered , was said to be Sylley ; nothing being more usual with sailors , upon their first seeing land , than to call the part by the name of the whole ; of which I will not detain you with proofs .
But , when this considerable island called Sylley was broke to pieces , the great portions became inhabited , and requiring distinct appellations , had first British names , as Brehar , Trescaw , Enmor ; but as soon as the regulars were placed here ( probably in Athelstan 's reign , or immediately after ) were called , according to the religion of the times , after the names of particular saints .
The chief division was entitled St. Mary 's , in honour of the holy virgin-mother ; the others dedicated to St. Nicholas , St. Martin , St. Theon , and so on ; but this remarkable promontory ( now Sylley isle ) being in no wise fit for habitation or devotion , was dedicated to no saint , but left to enjoy its ancient name ; and , notwithstanding the modern Christian dedications , sailors went on in their old way ; this high land is still called Sylley , and the islands in general are still denominated , from what was antiently their principal , Sylley isles .
It must have been a very dispiriting circumstance to the old inhabitants , to see the ocean so continually eating away their low-lands , in which they had their treasures of tin , their houses , and ports : but this gradual decay was not the only misfortune , which attended them , neither will it account for the following phenomenon .
~ 4 .
It has been mentioned before , that upon shifting of the sands in the chanel , walls and ruins are frequently seen : There are several phenomenon of the same nature , and owing to the same cause , to be seen on these shores , as particularly a strait-lin 'd ridge like a causeway , running cross the old town creek ( marked H ) in St. Mary 's , which is now never seen above water ; so that the subsidence , if any , has been different in different places .
From the island of Sampson I saw the foundations of hedges ( so we call the stone-fences of our fields , which are not built of masonry and cement ) running on in a strait line cross the frith E , towards Trescaw isle , till they were hid in sand ; which sand , when in its full tide , has from ten to twelve feet water on it .
Now we cannot suppose , that the foundation of these hedges was laid as low as high-water mark ( for who would build fences upon so dangerous a level ?
) and if , at a medium , we suppose them to have been laid only six feet above the full tide , I am persuaded it will not be thought an unreasonable calculation .
Here then we have the foundations , which were six feet above high-water mark , now ten feet under , which together make a difference as to the level of sixteen feet .
To account for this , the slow advances and depredations of the sea will by no means suffice ; we must either allow , that the lands enclosed by these hedges have sunk so much lower than they were before ; or else we must allow , that , since these lands were enclosed , the whole ocean has been raised sixteen feet perpendicular ; which last will appear , Sir , I believe , to the judicious , much the harder and less tenable supposition of the two .
Here then was a great subsidence ; the land betwixt Sampson and Trescaw sunk at least sixteen feet , at a moderate computation .
This subsidence must have been follow 'd by a sudden inundation ; and this inundation is likely not only to have destroyed a great part of the inhabitants , but to have terrified others who survived , and had wherewithal to support themselves elsewhere , into a total desertion of their shattered islands .
By this means , as I imagine , that considerable people , who were the aborigines , and carried on the tin-trade with the Phenicians , Greeks , and Romans , were reduced to the last gasp .
The few poor remains of this desolation , by their necessary attention to food and raiment , must soon have lost sight of their ancient prosperity ; ( for trade will produce plenty , and plenty rightly used will make people happy ) and the faint remembrance , that was left of what the islands had been before , expired of itself , in an age or two , through the indigence of the inhabitants .
~ 5 .
That such an inundation has happened here , is still more plain , because these islands are no longer , what they were antiently , fertile in tin ; nor are there any remains of such and so many ancient workings as could maintain a trade , so greedily coveted by some of the ancients , and so industriously concealed by others .
There are no mines to be seen in any of these islands , but only on one load ( so we call our tin veins ) in Trescaw island , and the workings here are very inconsiderable , and not ancient ; and indeed the sides of the cliffs , and the strata of bare rocks , do not show , that ever there have been any considerable workings there for tin , or give us the least promising circumstance to encourage tin-adventurers .
For among such numbers of rocks and cliffs , as I passed over in St. Mary 's , and the off-islands , nothing surprised me more , than that there should be so few veins in strata formerly so famous for tin .
In the cliffs of Cornwall tis very different ; you cannot walk on any beach , without perceiving veins of one sort or other , in the clay , rubble , or rock ; but here in Sylley it is generally one continued rock , and the interstices so close~ that scarce a knife can get between .
Besides the load above-mention 'd in Trescaw , I saw a very narrow one in the same island under a place called Oliver 's battery ( marked K ) but could perceive no metal , either by inspection , or by more than ordinary weight .
I saw two veins , about two inches wide , running thro ' the rocks on the back of St. Mary 's pier ; and a gentleman in company thought he had found one in Porthmellyn ( L ) ; and these are all we could discover , tho ' our attention this way seldom left us .
There is one place on Dolphin-Downs , in Trescaw , where they worked for tin in the ancient manner , which was by laying open the ground in the same way as we now work stone quarries ; and this is every thing I could perceive , in all these islands , which looked like a workiong for tin .
It must therefore be matter of wonder where the Phenicians , Greeks , and Romans , could have found such a plenty of that useful metal .
Whatever resources they had from Cornwall , ( formerly reckoned , as I have great reason to think , among the Cassiterides ) great part of their tin must doubtless have come from these islands ; but where it was found is uncertain .
Nothing now appears aboveground , which can satisfy such an inquiry .
The story of the Phenician vessel mentioned by Strabo to have purposely run ashore , and risqu 'd the men as well as lost the ship , rather than discover to the Romans the trade to these isles , is well known , and proves beyond all doubt the commerce to have been very advantageous .
That the natives had mines , and worked them , appears from Diodorus Siculus , lib. 5 .
ch .
2 .
and from Strabo ( Geog .
lib. 3 .
) who informs us , that Publius Crassus sailing thither , and observing how they worked their mines , which were not very deep , and that the people loved peace , and at their leisure navigation , instructed them how to carry on this trade to better advantage : That is ( if I understand him rightly ) seeing their mines but shallow , yet well worth working deeper , taught them how to pursue the metal to a greater depth .
The question then is , what is become of these mines ?
And how shall this question be answered , but by confessing , that the land , in which these mines were , is now sunk , and buried under the sea ?
I am not fond of introducing earthquakes , or calling in the powerful subterraneous world to account for the superficial ; but where there has been evidently a great subsidence of the earth 's surface , I am very willing to refer to better judges than myself , whether it can be accounted for at all , without a previous trembling and concussion of the earth .
Proofs are much better drawn from nature than tradition ; but yet I cannot help observing , that what nature declares in this case , tradition seems to confirm ; there being a strong persuasion in the west n parts of Cornwall , that formerly there existed a large country betwixt the Land s-end and Sy ley , now laid many fathoms under water .
The particular arguments , by which they would support this tradition , I forbear to trouble you with , as they may be seen in Mr. Carew 's Survey of Cornwall , p. 3 .
and in the last edition of Camden , p. 11 .
But , if I were to produce them , it should only be to prove , that there was such a tradition , and not as proofs of the matter of fact ; for of that I am very dubious ; the Cassiterides , by the most ancient accounts we have of them , appearing always to have been islands .
I know it is the opinion of some naturalists , that all islands were formerly joined to the continent ; but we may , at least in my opinion , as well suppose the several parts of the continent , which are now separated by the branches of the sea , to have been once conjoined ; which will prove a great deal too much ; the present intermixtures of land and water being a much more gracious and social disposition , and for that reason more likely to be the true and original one , than so close and compact an union ; and therefore , where there are not shoals , and other evidences of a connexion ( as there are none betwixt the Land s-end and Sylley ) I think it the safest way not to suppose any .
But tho ' there are no evidences , to be depended upon , of any ancient connexion of the Land 's end and Sylley , yet that the cause of that inundation , which destroyed much of these islands , might reach also to the CorI nish nish shores , is extremely probable ; there being several evidences of a like subsidence of the land in Mount's-bay .
The principal anchoring-place , called a lake , is now a haven , or open harbour .
The mount , from its Cornish name * , we must conclude to have stood formerly in a wood , but now at full tide is half a mile in the sea , and not a tree near it ; and in the sandy-beach betwixt the Mount and Penzance , when the sands have been dispersed by violent high tides , I have seen the trunks of several large trees in their natural position , the surface of their section worn smooth by the agitation of the water , sand , and gravel , as if cut with an axe , upon which , at every full tide , there must be twelve feet water ; so that the shores in Sylley , and the neighbouring shores of Cornwall , are equal and concurrent evidences of such a subsidence , and the memory of the inundations , which were the necessary consequences of it , is preserved in tradition ; tho ' like other traditions , in proportion to their age , obscured by fable .
I should now make an apology , Sir , for troubling you with this sketch of the alterations , which the Sylley isles have suffered since the age of the ancient historians : but because I have no other view in it than testifying my respect to that honourable Society , in which you deservedly hold so eminent a station , that must be my apology .
I only beg leave to observe , that altho ' these islands are neither of that extent they were formerly , nor fruitful of tin , nor stored * Guavas lake , signifying the grey rock in a wood .
stored with such antiquities , as one might expect from their long commerce with the Phenicians , Greeks , and Romans ; yet I found them well worth seeing : they are inhabited by an industrious , apprehensive people ; their lands , fortifications , and commerce , are capable of great and easy improvements , and their harbours are of the utmost importance to the navigation of this kingdom .
I am , SIR , Ludgvan , Dec. 21 , 1752 .
Your most obedient servant , Wm. Borlase .
Extract of another Letter of Mr. Borlase to the Rev. Dr. Lyttelton , Dean of Exeter , and F. R. S. THAT there has been such a subsidence of the lands belonging to these islands , ( as is before supposed ) the present ruins of the islands testify .
That this subsidence reached even to the Mount's-bay , and laid under water a great part of the low lands , then woody , there being now 10 feet water , ( as at Sylley over the hedges , so here over the trunks and roots of trees ) I have such convincing reasons to lay before you at a proper time , as will exclude all doubt .
So that the shores in Sylley , and the shores in Cornwall , are equal proofs of such inundation , and the memory of it is preserved in tradition , tho ' , like other traditions , obscured in fable .
12 When Read Feb. 8 , When this inundation happened , it is perhaps in vain to inquire ; but two pieces of history occur to me , which possibly may lead us near the time .
In the time of Strabo and Diodorus Siculus , their commerce seems to have been in full vigour ; ` ` Abundance of tin carried in carts , ' ' says Diodorus Siculus : ` ` But ten islands in all , ( says Strabo ) and nine of those inhabited .
' ' The destruction therefore of Sylley must be placed after the time of these authors ; that is after the Augustan age : but at what time after , I find nothing as yet can determine .
Plutarch indeed ( of the Cessation of Oracles ) hints , that the islands round Britain were generally unpeopled in his time .
If he includes Sylley among them , then this desolation must have happened between the reign of Trajan , and that of Augustus .
However that be , Sylley , tho ' not entirely destitute of inhabitants , seems to have been noted for two or three banishments during the empire of the Romans in Britain .
It continued neglected , till trade began to thrive , shipping increase , and naval wars to be carried on in this western world .
Then its commodious situation at the opening into both the chanels soon showed of what importance it was for Britain to possess it , and how dangerous it might be to the safety and trade of Britain , if in an enemy 's hand .
This seems to be the reason , why Athelstan made a voyage to , and conquered , these islands .
That prince was taught by his grandfather Alfred 's wife maxims , that the proper and natural security of Britain lay in the royal navy , and its riches in traffic ; and he saw , that neither of them could be well provided vided for , if Sylley were not subdued as well as

