III .
A Letter from the Rev. Mr. George Costard , Fellow of Wadham-College , Oxford , to Dr. Bevis , concerning the Year of the Eclipse foretold by Thales .
Dear Sir , I THANK you greatly for the use of the Petersburg Acts , while in London , where Bayer supposes the eclipse foretold by Thales to the Ionians fell out the year before Christ 603 .
Since my return home , upon looking over some papers , that I had formerly drawn up on that subject , I find , that I had determined it to have been the very same year .
I will not trouble you with the chronological arguments , on which I founded that determination ; and therefore shall only transcribe so much of those papers as relates to calculation .
C Riccioli Read Jan. 25 , Riccioli supposes , that the eclipse foretold by Thales happened the year before Christ 585 ; and quotes both Theon and Cleomedes , in confirmation of the opinion .
Theon , perhaps , had Cleomedes 's words in view ; but neither of these authors have circumstances enough to determine what eclipse in particular they meant .
The passage of Theon is in his chapter concerning the moon 's parallax , where he says , that Hipparchus , being in doubt whether the sun had any parallax at all , supposed , in the first book of his treatise concerning Magnitudes and Distances , that the earth , in respect of the sun , was only a point ; from whence , by means of an eclipse there set down by him , he framed two distances of the sun , a less and a greater .
~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
All then that is here said is , that the eclipse made use of by Hipparchus was total at the Hellespont ; but at Alexandria in Egypt a little more than 5 digits only .
But he hath neither given us the aera of Nabonassar , the place of the luminaries , nor any one circumstance besides , by which we might form any conclusion what year this eclipse was in .
Cleomedes , who perhaps saw the same treatise of Hipparchus , is as uncircumstantial as Theon .
He says only , that the diameter of the moon 's shadow at the earth is something more than 4000 stadia .
And to confirm this assertion , he says , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
By the quantity of obscuration here mentioned , this seems to have been the same eclipse with that quoted by Theon from Hipparchus ; but as the place of observation in both these authors appears to have been Alexandria in Egypt , it must have been after that place was built .
Consequently it was probably observed there by Hipparchus himself , and therefore could not have been the eclipse foretold by Thales .
Besides , was this eclipse total upon the banks of the Hellespont , I know not what reason there is for supposing , that the battle between the Lydians and the Medes was fought there .
It should rather seem , that the engagement was on the confines of the two kingdoms : consequently in a more southern latitude , and in a longitude more to the east of Alexandria , this eclipse could not have been total ; nor therefore ( as Herodotus said it did ) turn day into night .
Sir Isaac Newton , in his chronology , likewise supposes the eclipse meant to have been that in May , the year before Christ 585 .
But in this , perhaps , he rather followed others , than adopted it after any examination of his own .
That treatise never had the finishing hand of its great author , and it is well known now in what manner it came abroad .
According to Riccioli , this eclipse was at the Hellespont central , and at Sardes fell out at 6 of the clock in the afternoon ; and therefore is rejected , you find , by Maier , in the Petersburg Acts , as being too late in the day .
` ` Quia ad littora Asiae minoris ( says he ) sub folis occasum appulit , in Natolia nulla fuit eclipsis totalis , quin nec conspicua ob instantem solis occasum .
' ' According to my computation , the apparent time of the true conjunction was at Greenwich , May 28 , 4h 35~ 15 ' ' .
so~~ The place of the luminaries 1 29 0 24 Moon 's latitude north 20 54 Semidiameter of the earth 's disk 61 14 Semidiameter of the penumbra 32 40 Time of the greatest obscuration at dh ' ' ' Greenwich 28 4 32 33 Beginning of the general eclipse 23 20 End of the general eclipse 71 46 Duration 4 58 26 o ' Longitude of Sardes east from London 29 5 Its longitude north 38 10 Time of sun-set there May 28 , 7h 6~ 54~ .
The passage of the centre of the penumbra over the earth 's disk was at the following times , as reckoned at Greenwich , thus : Times Longitudes Latitudes h~~~~~o~~ 3 22 33 115 5 10W 22 10 40 N 4 02 33 95 24 50 31 30 10 4 32 33 75 52 30 38 49 10 4 35 55 73 34 40 39 31 10 4 43 34 68 80 41 2 23 5 02 33 52 22 10 44 11 30 5 32 33 25 20 20 46 36 30 By this , I think , it pretty plainly appears , that the centre of the shadow passed so far from any place , where we can reasonably suppose the battle between the Lydians and Medes to have been fought , that this can hardly have been the eclipse mentioned by Herodotus .
Father Hardouin , in his chronology of the Old Testament , rejects this eclipse , as not happening , he says , in the reign of Cyaxares , but in that of Astyages ; not on the fourth year of the Olympiad , but a month before it began ; as falling out too late in the day ; the greatest obscuration being ( at Sardes , I suppose he means ) scarce half an hour before sun-set ; and not total , or central , or 12.56~ digits , as Riccioli makes it , but almost 9 .
Tho ' Pliny therefore says this eclipse was Olymp .
XLVIII .
4 .
&amp; A. V. C. CLX .
yet six MSS .
he observes , in the French king 's library , have CLXX .
and so most printed copies .
He thinks therefore , that , instead of CLXX the number should be CLVII .
which , he says , is Olympiad XLVIII .
4 .
and the year before Christ 597 ; when there was an eclipse of the sun , on Wednesday July the 9 , at 6 of the clock in the morning .
This eclipse Petavius likewise prefers ; tho~ he makes the digits eclipsed only 9.22~ Which is strange enough , as it could not have been by any means the cause of such a darkness , as is described by Herodotus .
But F. Hardouin supposes , that this battle was fought upon the banks of the river Halys in Cappadocia , and in latitude north 40~ ; where , says he , this eclipse must have been central and annular .
According to Dr. Halley 's tables , the year before Christ 597 the apparent time of the true conjunction at Greenwich was July 8d 21h 50~ 9~ ; and so ' ' ' The place of the luminaries 39 17 0 Moon 's latitude north 33 32 Semidiameter of the earth 's disk 54 38 Semidiameter of the penumbra 30 44 dh ' ' ' Beginning of the general eclipse 19 8 16 End of the general eclipse 90 49 2 Duration 5 41 6 o ' ' ' Sun rose centrally eclipsed , in longitude west from Greenwich 83 33 0 And in latitude north 43 26 50 Sun set centrally eclipsed , in longitude east from Greenwich 132 37 20 And in latitude north 26 25 20 The place of the centre of the penumbra was at the following times , as reckoned at Greenwich , thus : Times Longitudes Latitudes h ' ' ' ~ ' ' ' ~ ' ' ' 21 46 15 30 21 0E 62 30 34 N 21 58 39 42 53 30 60 53 0 22 13 39 56 32 40 58 8 20 22 28 39 68 58 0 54 41 40 This eclipse , therefore , at Sardes , or any-where else that we can well suppose this battle to have been fought , could not have been great enough to turn day into night ; and therefore doth not answer Herodotus 's description .
Archbishop Usher rejects both these eclipses , as inconsistent with his chronology ; and supposes that intended to have been A. M. 4113 .
An. Nab .
147 .
before Christ 601 .
Olymp .
XLIV .
4 .
Sunday July 20 .
3h 25~ .
before noon , digits eclipsed 9 .
But this likewise is greatly defective as to quantity .
But tho ' this is insufficient for the purpose , yet there was one two years before this , or the year before Christ 603 , that will be found by good tables entirely satisfactory .
Petavius , indeed , makes the digits eclipsed only 7.20~ ; but , according to Dr. Halley 's tables , the apparent time of the true conjunction was at Greenwich , May 17d 20h 42~19~ .
The place of the luminaries 1s .
19~ 12~ and the moon 's latitude north 25~ 17~ .
~~ Semidiameter of the sun 15 49 Semidiameter of the moon 16 45 Semidiameter of the penumbra 32 34 Semidiameter of the earth 's disk 60 50 h~~ Beginning of the central eclipse 19 13 27 End of the central eclipse 22 3 47 Duration 2 50 20 Sun rose centrally eclipsed , in longitude o~~ west from Greenwich 43 46 10 And in latitude north 2 54 0 Sun set centrally eclipsed , in longitude east from Greenwich 155 56 20 And in latitude north 42 38 10 The place of the centre was at the following times , as reckoned there , thus : Times Longitudes Latitudes h~~o~~o~~ 19 13 27 43 46 10 W2 54 0N 20 8 37 19 19 30 E 31 33 0 20 23 37 28 28 10 E 35 47 50 20 42 19 40 29 30 E 40 41 20 22 3 47 155 56 20 E 42 38 10 By this it appears , that , if modern maps and geographers may be depended upon , the center of the shadow passed over the kingdom of Barca and Africa , and crossed the Mediterranean between Candia and Cyprus , and then over Antiochetta and Erzroum , and a little to the south of Kars .
You will see , Sir , how this agrees with what is said in the Petersburg Acts , page .
332 .
which , therefore , I shall not transcribe .
I shall only add , that , if any allowance is to be made for the moon 's for the moon 's acceleration , or any other cause , the track here given , as you know , will be a little different .
As I cannot make several ancient eclipses , that I have tried , succeed to my mind , without some such supposition , I have done the same with regard to this .
What the quantity to be allowed is , I leave to you and others to determine : At present I make it 45~ ; at Mr. Whifton 's rate of 1~ in 54 years , or thereabouts .
Then dh~~ The apparent time of the true conjunction at Greenwich 17 20 42 19 For the moon 's acceleration 45 0 Apparent time of the moon 's conjunction at Greenwich corrected 17 19 57 19 Erom hence I find the passage of the penumbra at the following times as reckoned at Greenwich , thus : Times Longitudes Latitudes h~~o~~o~~ 19 23 37 30 49 30 E 31 33 0N 19 38 37 39 58 10 35 47 50 19 57 19 60 30 0 40 41 20 By this table it appears , that the center passed more to the south than the former , and went near Tripoli , Aracta , Nisabin , and Ardbil .
It is much to be wished , that Herodotus had told us where this battle was fought ; that , by this means , we might have known , which of these two paths to have preferred .
However , as he hath not , and there is nothing in either of them , that is inconsistent with the history , I conclude , from a number of other circumstances besides , that this really was the eclipse foretold by Thales .
I was not a little pleased , upon looking into my papers , to find , that Bayer and I agreed so exactly in the very year , as I was a stranger to what he had said upon that subject , till you brought me that volume of the Petersburgh Acts ; and as the principles I proceeded upon were something different from his .
This , however , is a presumption , that we are right , and confirms my opinion of some other articles in chronology , wherein I differ from some very great names .
I am , Dear Sir , Islip , May 21 , Your very faithful and 1752 .
obliged humble servant ,

