II .
An Account of a Book , entitled , P. D. Pauli Frisii Mediolanensis , &amp;c. Disquisitio mathematica in causam physicam figurae et magnitudinis Telluris nostrae ; printed at Milan in 1752 .
inscribed to the Count de Sylva , and consisting of Ten Sheets and a half in Quarto : By Mr. J. Short , F. R. S. IT may be laid down as a rule in mixed mathematics , ` ` That the determination of no physical quantity be carried farther than the observations , or other mechanical measures , can bear ; ' ' lest there follow this incongruity , of the conclusion being more extensive than the premises .
It were absurd , for instance , in the resolution of a triangle , to compute an angle to the exactness of seconds , or a side to centesms of an inch , when , perhaps , the instruments used can measure no angle less than 10 minutes , or a side but to the exactness of a foot The conclusions of arithmetic and geometry are indeed rigorously true , but they are only hypothetical ; and whenever the quantities , that enter any practical question , cannot be measured , but within certain limits , it were in vain to look for an answer perfectly accurate .
The error of the instrument becomes itself one of the data ; and we must content ourselves to find the limits , which the quantity sought cannot well exceed , or fall short of , by such rules , as the great Mr. Cotes has left us in his excellent treatise on the subject .
2 .
In like manner , when any physical theory is deduced from observations , its accuracy will still be in proportion to that of the observations , on which it is founded .
Sir Isaac Newton , we find , in computing the ratio of the earth 's axis to its equatorial diameter , confines himself to a reasonable approximation , and to three places of figures ( 229 to 230 ) ; because , whether that ratio is deduced from the different lengths of isochronous pendulums in different latitudes , from the measurement of distant degrees of a meridian , or from both ; the elements of the calculus can scarcely furnish a greater degree of exactness .
And of the same judicious caution we have many other examples in the works of that incomparable author .
3 .
On the other hand , when observations and theories are brought together , and compared , nothing can be justly inferred against a theory from its disagreement with the observations , unless that disagreement is greater , than can be fairly imputed to the imperfection of instruments , and to the unavoidable mistakes of an observer ; especially , if the difference should be sometimes in excess , and at other times in defect ; or , according to some of the observations , should entirely vanish .
4 .
Altho ' these rules , manifestly well-founded , have been followed by all the best writers , our author observes , that several ingenious men , both in France , and in Italy , have deviated from them ; particularly in treating of the famous question concerning the figure of the earth .
Some , with Messieurs Clairaut and Bouguer , attributing too much to the observations , that have been made , and taking them for absolutely exact , have concluded Sir Isaac Newton 's reasonings on that subject to be faulty ; while Father Boscowic , a Jesuit at Rome , making them quite loose and uncertain , thinks no argument at all can be drawn from them , concerning the earth 's figure ; far less in confirmation of the Newtonian theory .
5 .
In opposition to these two extremes , equally contrary to reason , as they are to each other , F. Frisi writes the treatise now before us ; in the introduction to which he shows , 1 .
That , altho ' the ratio of the axis of the earth to its equatorial diameter is , from M. de Maupertuis 's operations in Lapland , and afterwards in France , that of 177 to 178 ; and by the theory only 229 to 230 ; yet the difference is no more , than what might arise from a mistake of about 60 toises in the measure of either of the two degrees , that are compared , or of 30 toises in each of them .
Or , suppose the measure of the arcs to be exact , the same difference might be owing to an error of 4 or 5 seconds in the astronomical part .
And such errors , or others equivalent to them , in a course of so many combined operations , our author looks upon as difficult to be avoided .
But he adds , if the observations of M. de Maupertuis , and his fellow academicians , seem to differ from the theory , those of Messieurs Bouguer and de la Condamine exactly agree with it : According to whom , a degree at the equator , containing 56753 toises , and in latitude 49~ 22~ 57183 toises , the difference of the axis and equatorial diameter comes out to be 1/ 229 .
6 .
In answer to F. Boscowic , and those who make no account of the observations , our author allows , that , if they were such , as M. Cassini , and some other academicians , made in France , of the measure of a parallel of latitude , they could not be much depended on ; that method being liable to several obvious inconveniences .
But he insists , that , with the excellent instruments , which were used , and , considering the distinguished skill of the observers , as well at the polar circle as in France , and at the equator , the error upon one degree of the meridian could not exceed 60 or 70 toises ; which is a degree of exactness not only sufficient for the determination of the first question , viz. whether the spheroid of the earth is flat or long ; but likewise to found an agreement between the observations and the theory , as near as can be expected or desired .
7 .
The work itself is divided into ten chapters : I. De observationibus circa telluris figuram hactenus institutis .
II .
De principiis et hypothesibus quibusdam .
III .
De rotatione corporum , et vi centrifuga .
IV .
De mutationibus ex motu circulari ortis .
V. De attractione corporum rotundorum .
VI .
De comparatione gravitatis in variis homogeneae sphaeroidis locis .
VII .
De figura terrae .
VIII .
De gradibus meridiani et parallelorum .
IX .
De loxodromiis nautarum , de parallaxi lunae , et aliis ex eadem theoria pendentibus .
X. De theoriae et observationum consensu .
8 .
In chap .
1 .
we have a short history of the inquiries , that have been made into the magnitude and figure figure of the earth down to the present times ; and the preference is justly given to the measurements of Mr. Norwood in England , A. D. 1635 , and of the members of the French Academy of Sciences since that time .
From these he gathers , that , within less than 60 or 70 toises , the lengths of a degree of the meridian are as follows : 8~ Toises .
Lat. 00 56753 45 0 57100 49 22 57183 53 0 57300 66 20 57400 9 .
Chap. II .
contains an account of the principles , on which this theory is founded ; viz. the universal gravitation of matter , and the diurnal rotation of the earth .
Our author mentions likewise the hypothesis of the earth 's being originally in a fluid state ; but rejects it as precarious and improbable .
He allows however , that , with regard to the present question , it is all one whether it was first a fluid or not , seeing the ocean is circumfused just in the same manner , and to the same altitude , as if the whole was still a fluid .
10 .
Chap. III .
and IV .
are employed in the doctrine of centrifugal forces , and their effect in changing a fluid sphere into the form of an oblate spheroid .
In the former of these chapters , the author resolves , as usual , the centrifugal force of a particle into two others ; one , that acts directly contrary to the gravitation of the particle ; and the other a force in a direction perpendicular to it .
And this last he considers again as acting laterally upon the contiguous particles impelling them towards the equator .
But the quantity of this force , when greatest at the octant , he computes to be only 1/ 6 68168 of the force of gravity ; and therefore , says he , it may be safely neglected .
The truth is , after the spheroid is come to be in a permanent state , and all its parts in aequilibrio , there is no longer any such lateral force at all ; it being now entirely satisfied by the gradual contraction of the earth 's axis .
11 .
The general contents of the following chapters are sufficiently expressed in their titles already given .
Nor can we be more particular , without entering into a detail of algebraical operations , which would be improper for this place ; and which is the less necessary , as the same things have been treated of by several other authors .
This does not , however , in the least detract from the merit of F. Frisi ; who discovers throughout this work much acuteness and skill , joined with all the candor and ingenuity , that become a philosopher .
And as he has not yet exceeded his 23d year , it may be expected , that the sciences will one day be greatly indebted to him ; especially as we find him actually engaged in composing a complete body of physicomathematical learning .
12 .
There is only , in his VI .
Chapter , a criticism upon one of Sir Isaac Newton 's demonstrations , in which we cannot agree with this ingenious author .
And as this demonstration has proved a stumblingblock , not only to F. Frisi , but to many other learned men , we shall be obliged to consider that part of it , which has been mistaken , at some length , by the help of the following scheme : A a PQ pCq b B In which let the ellipsis ApBqA , whose axes AB , pq , are in any given ratio , as of m to n , have the circles apbq , and APBQ , inscribed and circumscribed to it : And if the figure revolves on the axis PQ , there will be generated an oblate spheroid ApBqA , with two spheres , the greater circumscribed to the spheroid , and touching it in its equator AP A , and the lesser inscribed and touching it in the poles pq ; the solid content of the spheroid being the first of the two mean proportionals between the solidity of the exterior sphere , and that of the interior .
But if the figure revolves on the axis AB , there will be generated a prolate spheroid ApBqA , inscribed in the exterior sphere at the poles AB ; and circum~ scribing the interior sphere at the equator pqp , its solidity being the second of the above mean proportionB 2 als .
als .
So that if O and P stand for the solidities of the oblate and prolate spheroids , and S , s , for the two spheres ; S : O : P : s~ are in the continued proportion of m : n. And S : P , or O : s : : m2 : n2 .
As S : s : : m3 : n3 .
Or we may with Sir Isaac Newton conceive of the genesis of these solids as follows .
1 .
Let the sphere APBQ be uniformly compressed in the direction of its axis PQ , till that axis is diminished to pq , and the sphere changed into the oblate spheroid .
2 .
Let this spheroid be equally compressed in the direction of that diameter of its equator , which is perpendicular to pq and AB , or to the plane of the figure ; and it will degenerate into the prolate spheroid , whose poles are A and B. 3 .
Let this last be compressed in the direction of its axis AB , till it is changed into the sphere apbq and , in each of these compressions , the solid space , which the body contains will be diminished in the ratio of m to n. Now , as the determination of the earth 's figure depends not only upon that of the ratio of the centrifugal force , by which a body tends to recede from the axis of rotation to the power of gravity ; but likewise , upon the decrement of gravitation arising from the body 's being in that rotation actually removed to a greater distance from the centre : it is not enough , that we know , from the experiments with pendulums , the centrifugal force at the equator to be about 1/ 280 of the force of gravity .
We need , farther , two distinct propositions ; one to determine the attractive force of a spheroid at its pole ; and the other to determine its attraction at the equator .
The first of these we have in Princip .
lib. 1 .
prop. 91 .
and the second has been supplied by several authors .
But Sir Isaac , who seldom does any thing in vain , found , that he could , by one of his artifices , make that 9 1st proposition serve likewise to determine the attraction at the equator , by the following argument : Let G be the attraction of the exterior sphere at A ; and let the decrement of the attraction , when the sphere is diminished into the oblate spheroid ApBq , be d ; and ~ the decrement of this last attraction , when the oblate spheroid is.diminished into the prolate , whose poles are AB : then , I say , d is nearly equal to ~ ; the difference of the axes of the generating ellipse being small .
For the attractive matter , that is taken away , has , in both cases , the same ratio to the matter , that is left ; and its position , with respect to that which is left , is , in both cases , nearly the same : And therefore the successive attractions will be nearly in continued proportion , G : G d : : Gd+~ ~ .
Or multiplying and rejecting d2 as inconsiderable , Gd= G~ , and d=~ .
Thus , if the attractions of the sphere APBQ , and of the prolate spheroid , at its pole A , be 126 and 125 respectively ; the attraction of the intermediate oblate spheroid at its equator will be 1251/ 2 : and how nearly this approaches to the truth , may be seen from an exact computation of those attractions .
For , if the axes of the generating ellipse be 101 and 100 , and the attractive force at the surface of the sphere 126 ; the attraction at the pole of the prolate spheroid will be 124.9838 ; and that at the equator of the oblate 125.5077 ; which exceeds the arithmetical mean between the two former , only by.0068 ; that is , by about 1/ 18410th part of the attraction of the oblate spheroid at the equator .
This reasoning is more shortly expressed ( Princip .
lib. iii .
Prop. 19 .
) as follows : ... .
` ` Gravitas in loco A in sphaeroidem , convolutione ellipseos ( ApBq ) circa axem AB descriptam , est ad gravitatem in eodem loco A in sphaeram centro C radio AC descriptam , ut 125 ad 126 .
Est autem gravitas in loco A in terram media proportionalis ~ inter gravitates in dictam sphaeroidem et sphaeram ; propterea quod sphaera , diminuendo diametrum PQ in ratione 101 ad 100 , vertitur in figuram terrae ; et haec figura , diminuendo in eadem ratione diametrum tertiam , quae diametris AP , PQperpendicularis est , vertitur in dictam sphaeroidem ; et gravitas in A , in utroque casu , diminuitur in eadem ratione quam proxime .
' ' In which the expression ` ` eadem ratione ' ' occurring a second time has misled F. Frisi and others , to think this last ratio to be likewise that of the axes , or of 101 to 100 : Whereas the identity of ratio 's here asserted is to be referred only to the words ` ` utroque casu ; ' ' the ratio itself being not that of the axes , or of m to n ; but the half of that ratio ( whatever it is found to be by Prop. 91 .
lib. i. ) which the attraction of the sphere has to the polar attraction of the inscribed spheroid .
This inadvertence , however , of his own F. Frisi charges upon Sir Isaac Newton ; and files it up , as the sixth of the errors , which he says have been discovered in the Principia ... .
` ` Ita dum stabilitae in 19 lib. iii .
propositione terrestrium axium proportionis portionis fulcimentum et patrocinium quaerimus , aliud in propositione eadem sophisma sese offert , quod eorum , quae in principiis mathematicis Newtoni nacta ( i. e. detecta ) sunt hactenus , sextum est , &amp;c. ' ' But we may take it off the file again ; and , for the present , leave the other five , till they are considered of at more leisure .
13 .
In his 10th and last chapter , our author sums up the evidence , and finds , that all the good observations , that have been made , as well by pendulums , as by actual mensuration , concur with the theory , in making the ratio of the earth 's axis and equatorial diameter to be as 229 to 230 .
This is indeed a sufficient confirmation of the theory of gravitation : But it must be observed , that the coincidence is not perhaps quite so perfect as F. Frisi imagines .
That ratio corresponds well enough to the exactness , to which the first elements of the calculus can be obtained ; the length of a second pendulum , and that of the earth 's equatorial diameter , from which the centrifugal force ( 1/ 289 ) is deduced .
But , if we suppose that force to be accurately 1/ 289 , and compute more rigorously , we shall find the ratio in question to be very nearly that of 225 to 226 ; agreeing still with the observations as well as can be desired ; and showing , at the same time , the inimitable art of Sir Isaac Newton in the contrivance and use of approximations ; seeing the strictest calculation raises the equator not the third part of a mean geographical mile above what he had found by his method .
I sent F. Frisi 's book to my ingenious and learned friend the reverend Mr. Murdock , Fellow of this Society , who has fully considered the question concerning cerning the figure of the earth ; and who , after having perused the book , and discovered the above mistake of F. Frisi , sent me the above theorem , and its demonstration .
He likewise sent me the following theorems , which , he says , he had communicated to M. de Bremond , in the year 1740 , when he was translating his treatise on sailing : But M. de Bremond dying soon after , those , who had the care of publishing the translation , printed it incorrect in several places ; particularly the theorems for the prolate spheroid : On which account , he says , if they are thought worth preserving , they may be inserted in the Philophical Transactions .
Postscript .
Theorems for computing the ratio of the attractive force of a spheroid , at its pole or equator , to that of the inscribed or circumscribed sphere .
1 .
In an oblate spheroid , the ratio is , Pole 1+ 1/ m2-1 m2/ m2-1~3/ 2 X A : 1/ 3 Equator m2/ m2-1~3/ 2 XA 1/ m2-1 : 2/ 3 2 .
In a prolate spheroid , the ratio is , Pole 1 m2/ m2-1 + m/ m2-1~3/ 2 X l : 1/ 3 Equator m2/ m2-1 m/ m2-1~3/ ~ X l : ~/ 3 In which m : 1 , as the greater axis of the generating ellipse is to the lesser .
A is a circular arc , to the radius 1 , whose tangent is ~m2-1 , or its reciprocal , if m2-1 ~ 1 .
And l is the natural logarithm of S/ V , S being the sine of the arc , whose co-sine is 1/ m x ~m2-1 , and V the versed sine of the same arc .
Note , The two first theorems , by substituting t for ~m2-1 , coincide with those of Mr. Maclaurin for the oblate spheroid , in his dissertation on the

