XCII .
Extracts of Two Letters of the Abbe Nollet , F. R. S. to Mr. William Watson , F. R. S. relating to the extracting Electricity from the Clouds .
Translated from the French .
Paris , June 6 .
1752 .
N. S. THE Abbe , after having taken notice of the discovery of M. Dalibard in France , in relation to the extracting the electricity from the clouds during a thunder-storm , in consequence of Mr. Franklin 's hypothesis , acquaints Mr. Watson , that he is more interested than any body to come at the facts , which prove a true analogy between lightning and electricity ; since these experiments establish incontestably a truth , which he had conceived , and which he ventured to lay before the public more than four years ago .
Examine but the fourth volume of his Lecons de Physique , page .
314 , and you will find what follows : ` ` If any one should take upon him to prove , from a well-connected comparison of phenomenon , that thunder is in the hands of nature , what electricity is in ours ; that the wonders , which we now exhibit at our pleasure , are little imitations of those great effects which frighten us ; and that the whole depends upon the same mechanism ; if it is to be demonstrated , that a cloud , prepared by the action of the winds , by heat , by a mixture of exhalations , &amp;c. is opposite to a terrestrial object ; that this is the electrised body , and at a certain proximity from Aaaa ` ` that Read June 11 , that which is not ; I avow , that this idea , if it was well supported , would give me a great deal of pleasure ; and , in support of it , how many specious reasons present themselves to a man , who is well acquainted with electricity !
The universality of the electric matter , the readiness of its action , its inflammability , and its activity in giving fire to other bodies ; its property in striking bodies externally and internally , even to their smallest parts ; the remarkable example we have of this effect in the experiment of Leyden ; the idea , which we might truly adopt in supposing a greater degree of electric power , &amp;c. all these points of analogy , which I have been some time meditating , begin to make me believe , that one might , by taking electricity for the model , form to one 's self , in relation to thunder and lightning , more perfect and more probable ideas , than what have been offered hitherto , &amp;c. ' ' To demonstrate , that glass is not absolutely impermeable to the electric fluid , I offer the following experiment : Let the neck of a small thin phial A ( see the Fig. ) be placed in that of the receiver B ; and lute it in such a manner , as that the air cannot pass through their joining .
Exhaust the receiver , and pour the little phial three parts full of water , and conduct the electricity therein , by means of an iron wire , suspended to the conductor .
Make the experiment in a dark place , and , for the greater surety , fix the receiver to the plate of the air pump , not with wet leathers , as usual , but with soft cement .
You will see the electric matter pass , as through a sieve , through the small phial into the receiver , and present itself in an infinite number of luminous streams , of extraordinary beauty ; and , if you do not take care , you will be smartly shocked , as in the experiment of Leyden , by laying one hand upon the receiver , and touching with the other the plate of the air-pump .
To prove , that , in the experiment of Leyden , the electrical virtue , or power of giving a shock , does not reside only in the glass , make the following experiment : Electrise a phial two thirds full of water ; pour this water into another thin phial , placed upon a glass stand ; plunge therein an iron wire , and attempt , while the phial is in one hand , to draw a spark with the other ; it is certain , that , if this is done with a little readiness , you will make the experiment of Leyden with this water ~ .
Possibly you may not always succeed with water ; but with mercury , under the same treatment , it never fails .
Whence proceeds the power of giving the shock to the second glass , if it is not by means of the water , which it has received ?
Electrise a bolt-head of glass , void of air , and sealed hermetically ; you may make use of it for the experiment of Leyden , and you will succeed .
Is Aaaa2 there ~ Some years ago I showed this experiment to several members of the Royal Society , and did not only therewith produce the experiment of Leyden , but by pouring the electrised water into a bason , held in one hand of an assistant standing upon cakes of wax , who , upon his presenting a finger of his other hand to some warm spirit of wine in a spoon , held in the hand of a person standing upon the floor , set it on fire .
I then considered this experiment , as a proof of the electricity being accumulated in the water .
there not then a communication between the exterior and interior surface of the glass ?
And is it not evident , further , that the electric matter , which is perceived running within like a torrent of fire , passes through the glass ?
When you force a hole through a piece of paper or pasteboard , attend to one thing , which I constantly observe .
If you electrise the plate of glass , A B , underneath , and that , by means of a thick iron wire somewhat bent , D , you draw the spark thro ' a piece of pasteboard , C , placed upon the metal , with which the glass is coated , the hole will appear invariably larger underneath , than on the top of the pasteboard ; and this hole will have an impression at the place , where the iron wire shall have been supported .
These two effects leave no room to doubt , but that the stroke of fire was directed from the glass to the conductor , E , by the bent iron wire .
Besides , if the electric fire proceeds from the upper surface of the glass , which receives the electricity from the under surface , it necessarily follows , that it must have passed through the whole thickness of the plate of glass ; and , consequently , that the glass is not impermeable to the electric fluid .
E D A C B Paris , July 22 , 1752 .
THE electrical experiments , which have been made here during the thunder , are now sufficiently verified .
Dr. Le Monnier , assisted by his advantageous situation , has sufficiently experienced , first , that a bar of iron , pointed or not , is electrised during a storm : Secondly , that a vertical or horizontal situation is equally fitting for these experiments : Thirdly , that even wood is electrised : Fourthly , that , by these means a man may be sufficiently electrised to set fire to spirit of wine with his finger , and repeat almost all the usual experiments of artificial electricity ; for thus I denominate that , which is excited by friction .
Read Dec. 14 , 1752 .
Seeing , therefore , that these experiments succeeded so well , I attempted them at Paris with a tube of tin , eighteen feet in length , and of an inch and half in diameter ; half of which tube I put out of my window , while the other half was placed upon , and fastened to , silk lines : And though I live in the lowest part of Paris , and my apartment in the Louvre is covered with an immense building , both in height and extent , at any time when the thunder was but moderate , I perceived therefrom signs of electricity .
The sparks were more frequent after the lightning than after the thunder ; and it even seemed , that the clap of thunder put a stop , for a very short time , to the force of the electricity .
Mons. Cassini de Thury , who was desirous of observing these effects with the apparatus , which we had erected upon the terrace of the observatory , made the same remarks ; and he has had a greater opportunity tunity of observing them , because the effects there were more considerable than at my apartment , on account of the situation .
He even remarked to-day very evident signs of electricity , although there was neither lightning nor thunder , but only the sky covered with such thick clouds , as seemed to forebode a storm .
Mons. Le Roy , a member of the Academy of Sciences , who lives near me , has repeated also a great number of these experiments and observations , by only making use of a pole of wood twenty-five feet long , about which he turned an iron wire in form of a screw .
This , Sir , is the state of these matters with us at present , which I am very far from thinking that we are arrived at the complete knowledge of .
I have reasons for suspecting , that there frequently happens a natural electricity in the atmosphere .
It may be , that thunder is only a circumstance , and not the efficient cause , of all these effects , which now present themselves to us ; and it is not impossible , but that the great mystery of vegetation has great connection with this natural electricity .
Time and observations may throw some light upon these important questions .

