A Letter from Mr. Henry Eels , to the Royal Society , concerning the Cause of Thunder .
Lismore , Ireland , June 18 , Gentlemen , 1752 .
THE greatest men of most ages having thought it worth the while to inquire , what was the cause of thunder ; and the world seeming to acquiesce in an hypothesis subscribed by some great modern names , it must appear presumptuous in me , to offer you some thoughts for a theory entirely new ( at least it is so to me ) unless I can show , that the former hypotheses are illgrounded , Read Nov. 7 , grounded , and far from being satisfactory .
In order to which I shall only object to the latest , ( to avoid prolixity ) which now has the general consent .
I think the basis , that this hypothesis stands on , is the authors assuming an analogy between thunder and fired gunpowder ; and then proving , that there are sulphureous and nitrous particles in the air , they leave them to take fire by fermentation , or some other accident , and from thence to form thunder .
First , the analogy is not just ; for there is not any thing similar to thunder in fired gunpowder , except the noise ; which may be shown from the different direction of their fire , and their very different effects .
Fired gunpowder acts from a centre to a circumference , with equal force at equal distances every way , by propelling the circumambient air by the explosion it makes .
The fire of thunder acts in rectilinear angles , ( as I have often seen , and as any body may , who will observe it ) with such subtle and distinct effects , as cannot be explained or imitated by the fire of gunpowder ; the history of which effects is too well known to need a repetition here I shall go on to show some insuperable difficulties in the formation and firing of this supposed aerial gunpowder .
And first , I think it inconceivable , that the sulphureous and nitrous particles should coalesce with some other unknown third body , in the place of charcoal , in such exact proportion , as is necessary to make gunpowder of any perfection , and to form a body compact enough to equal the noise of thunder , when fired in the open air .
For such a body must necessarily descend by its own gravity , long before it arrives to a bulk sufficient for the purpose .
And , secondly , I think it contradictory to all experience , that such a collision of nitrous particles should ever happen in the common seat of thunder , which is in the most collected showers that descend : For there the nitrous particles must be absorbed and dissipated in the water ; in which state I think it impossible for them to take fire .
These , and many other considerations , too prolix for the compass of a letter , induced me to search for some other cause of thunder ; which I think I have discovered in that fire , which is made apparent in electrical experiments .
This fire pervades and adheres to most bodies ; while it flies , and cannot be brought to mix with some particular bodies .
I shall here only mention two ; air , which it flies and shuns , and water , which it more intimately pervades than almost any other body .
I must also observe , that this fire does not only pervade bodies , but that it surrounds and covers them to a certain distance from their superficies , in proportion to the state of its activity , which is increased by heat : And that , when it is artificially or accidentally protruded upon any body beyond its natural affection , it will fly off to the next approaching body , which is not so much impregnated with this fire ; and , when it departs in any considerable quantity , it makes a great noise or crack : All which is demonstrated by electrical experiments .
Now , to show , that this fire is the real cause of thunder , we need only consider it attending every vessel of humid vapour rising into the atmosphere , and covering its superficies to a certain depth ; which I think it must certainly do .
I shall not here speak my opinion how far this fire is the cause of vapours ascending , because I shall trouble you with that hereafter .
Having got the vapour aloft attended by this fire , without assigning any cause for its ascent , so , without assigning any cause for its descent , I shall let it come down as usual , which is in drops much larger than the vesicles , in which it ascended .
Now , in the collision to form these drops , we must consider what becomes of our fire ; for the surface of these larger drops increasing only as the squares , but their solids as the cubes of their diameters , the fire , which surrounded the superficies of the vesicles , must be protruded to a much greater distance from the superficies of the larger drops , and by that means made more in proportion to the larger drops , than its natural affection would have made it join them with ; and , consequently , rendered more apt to fly off to the next approaching or approached body , not so fully impregnated by this fire .
I have observed before , that the constant seat of thunder is in those clouds , which are most compact of humid vapour , and which descend in the heaviest showers , and that generally in warm weather , when the adjacent atmosphere is serene ; so that the humid vapours are almost all collected into this chain of clouds ; where , according to the compaction , there will be a body of this fire collected , and ready to fly off , sufficient to perform the greatest effects of thunder .
Which may be easily computed , from the force of electrical experiments , where the smallest portion of this fire , flying off from an electrified body , makes an audible crack , and is able to give a considerable shock .
What then must be the force of this fire , when it is so collected , as to break from a cloud in a body of fire two or three hundred yards in length ?
which I have often seen .
Now some of these clouds coalescing in their descent , and the drops increasing in their magnitude , there is a vast body of this fire collected more than what would naturally adhere to those drops and their surfaces ; which being rendered more active in its vibrations , by the heat of the lower part of the atmosphere , the sphere of its affections ( pardon the word , for I have no other ) is also increased in proportion to the body of fire , which enables it to fly off to clouds , not so much impregnated , at a considerable distance , with that violent crack so much taken notice of ; tho ' it is far from being the most wonderful of its effects ; the dire influence of which we often happily escape , by this body 's being dissipated by the heat of the lower atmosphere , before it comes within the sphere of its affection for bodies on the surface of the earth .
There is a subsequent rumbling noise heard after the first crack or cracks of thunder , ( for this fire does not all break off from one point ) which has been taken notice of , and oddly accounted for ; but I think it neither is nor can be more than echo 's from adjacent clouds , which at this time are generally dense enough for that purpose ; and the noise growing fainter in proportion to the times of its being returned , I think sufficiently proves it .
As to the subtle effects of thunder , I shall leave you to compare them with those of electricity , only allowing for the different force of fire , which is so much greater in thunder than can possibly be procured from artificial experiments ; and I believe , that the analogy will plainly appear .
I shall only hint , that , where one body has been injured by thunder ; and another , tho ' in contact with it , has remained untouched , the latter will be found to be of that kind , which electrical fire will not join with .
I must beg you will let me know , whether this theory is worth you acceptance ; for I fear I am , like a fond mother , blind to the imperfections of my own child .
I have dandled this opinion for eighteen months past ; still fearing to lay it before you ; and now , instead of seeing its defects , I begin to fancy , that it has the face of truth and demonstration .
If you think this discovery worth the pursuit , I shall venture to trouble you hereafter with some farther attempts to show , that this fire is a most considerable agent in nature .
First , that the ascent of vapour and exhalation is principally owing to it , and that our atmosphere , by that means , is kept more homogeneal than is generally supposed , and fitter for respiration , vision , &amp;c. and that clouds of heterogeneous matter are kept suspended at their usual height merely by this fire .
Secondly , I shall prove , that this fire is the cause of reflexion , refraction , and inflexion of light .
Thirdly , I shall endeavour to show , that it is the cause of that secondary attraction and repulsion , which Sir Isaac Newton has taken notice of .
Lastly , I shall give some hints of the great use of this fire in animal life , and in vegetation .
What further I have thought of this fire , I shall not now trouble you with .
I am , Gentlemen , Your most humble and most obedient servant , Henry Eels .

