LXXXVIII .
A Letter of Mr. James Short , F. R. S. to the Royal Society , concerning the Inventor of the Contrivance in the Pendulum of a Clock , to prevent the Irregularities of its Motion by Heat and Cold .
Gentlemen , THE subject of conversation of late having often turned upon that ingenious contrivance in the pendulum of a clock , to prevent the inequalities in its motion , arising from its different lengths , in different seasons of the year , by the effects of heat and cold ; and it having been often asked , who was the inventor of it , I have therefore thought proper to draw up the following historical account of it : And as this account contains nothing but matters of fact , supported by the best authorities , I hope it will be acceptable to this Society .
I am Read Nov. 9 , 1752 .
Your most obedient humble servant , J. Short .
SOON after the invention of pendulum-clocks ( justly ascribed to the celebrated Mr. Huygens ) , it was found , that they were liable to considerable inequalities in their motion ; which were imagined to arise from the pendulum , in its vibrations , describing an arc of a circle ; and , consequently , that the larger vibrations must be slower than the shorter ones .
In order to remedy this imperfection , the same Mr. Huygens wrote a treatise , called Horologium oscillatorium ( a piece of geometry , which does honour to the last century ) , in which he demonstrates , from the properties of the cycloid , that the vibrations of a pendulum , moving in a cycloid , would be performed in equal times , even tho ' the vibrations were unequal .
Pendulums therefore were made to vibrate in a cycloid ; but great inequalities were still observed in the motion of clocks .
We do not read of any attempts , after this , to regulate the motion of clocks , till the year 1726 , when Mr. George Graham delivered into the Royal Society a paper , which is published in the Phil. Trans. No 392 , in which he says , that it having been apprehended , that the inequalities in the motion of clocks arose from a change of length in the pendulum , by the influences of heat and cold , he , about the year 1715 , made several trials , in order to discover , whether there was any considerable difference of expansion between brass , steel , iron , silver , &amp;c. when exposed to the same degrees of heat ; conceiving , that it would not be very difficult , by making use of two sorts of metals differing considerably in their degrees of expansion and contraction , to remedy , in great measure , the irregularities , to which common pendulums are subject .
He says also , that , from the experiments he then made , he found their differences so small , as gave him no hopes of succeeding that way , which made him leave off prosecuting this affair any more at that time : That , some time after , having observed an extraordinary degree of expansion , by heat , in quicksilver , he thought of a proper manner of applying a column of it to the pendulum of a clock , in order to prevent the inequalities arising from its different lengths by the effects of heat and cold ; which succeeded accordingly , and is what is now called Mr. Graham 's quicksilver-pendulum .
Mr. Graham , in the same paper , takes notice , that , tho ' the pendulum of a clock was to remain invariable , yet there would still be some irregularities in the motion of the clock , arising from the friction of the different parts of the clock work , and from the different degrees of foulness .
In the year 1725 , Mr. John Harrison , of Barrow in Lincolnshire , made several experiments upon wires of different metals , in order to find their different degrees of expansion and contraction : For he thought , that , by a proper combination of wires of two different metals , differing considerably in their expansion and contraction , he might be enabled to keep the centre of oscillation of a pendulum always at the same distance from the point of suspension .
In consequence of these experiments , he made a pendulum , consisting of one steel wire , at the end of which is the bob or weight , and , on each side of this wire , four wires alternately brass and steel , so disposed and contrived , as to raise the pendulum the same quantity as it is lengthened by heat , and to let down the pendulum in the same proportion as it is raised by cold .
He made also a drawing of a clock , in which the wheels are disposed in a different manner from those then in use ; which drawing I have seen , signed by himself in the year 1725 .
Two of these clocks with pendulums , as described above , were finished in the year 1726 .
In these clocks Mr. Harrison has made a particular sort of pallets , so as to be almost entirely free from friction ; for tho ' he had thus happily succeeded in his contrivance to prevent the inequalities in the motion of the clock , arising from the different lengths of the pendulum by the effects of heat and cold , yet he found there were considerable errors still remaining , occasioned by the friction of the pallets , as in the common way .
He has also suspended the pendulum upon the wall of the house , entirely independent of the clock and clock-case : For he had observed considerable alterations in the going of the clock , when the pendulum is suspended as in the common manner .
His pendulum vibrates in an arc of about 15 degrees , with a bob of about three pounds , between cycloidal checks , which he himself found were necessary , tho ' he had never heard of M. Huygens 's book , till after he had made them .
He has also disposed the force of his pendulum-wheel upon the pendulum , by his sort of pallets , in such a manner , that the vibrations of the pendulum will not be affected by the different resistance of the air .
Upon the whole , this clock is made in such a manner , as to be almost entirely free from friction ; in consequence of which he uses no oil , and therefore there is no necessity ever to clean the clock .
When he settled in London , he sent for one of these clocks from the country , and set it up in his house in Orangestreet , in the year 1739 , where it has stood ever since , and in all that time has never varied above one minute from the truth .
He can depend upon it to a second in a month .
About the year 1729 , Mr. Harrison made his first machine for measuring time at sea , in which he has likewise applied this combination of wires of brass and steel , to prevent any alterations by heat and cold .
In the year 1726 , he went on board one of His Majesty 's ships of war with this machine to Lisbon , and returned , where this machine was seen by every curious and ingenious person , who were pleased to go to his house .
Since that time , he has made two more of these machines or clocks for keeping time at sea , in both which he has likewise this provision , to prevent the effects of heat and cold .
An account of these curious machines , and of the many ingenious contrivances which Mr. Harrison has made use of in them , for answering their intended purpose , and also an account of the success of his voyage to Lisbon , and back again , is contained in an excellent speech of our worthy President Martin Folks , Esq ; upon his delivering to Mr. Harrison the gold medal of Sir Godfrey Copley ; which speech is inserted in the minutes of the Society in the year 1749 .
Mr. John Shelton , who was the principal person employed by Mr. Graham in the making of astronomical clocks , informs me , that Mr. Graham , in the year 1737 , made a pendulum consisting of three bars , viz. one of steel , between two of brass , and that the steel bar acted upon a lever , so as to raise the pendulum , when lengthened by heat , and to let it down , when shortened by cold .
This lever , which is very strong , rests upon a roller ; which roller is made moveable , so as to adjust the arms of the lever to their true proportion .
The whole was made to be as free from friction , as possible , in such a construction .
Mr. Graham made observations , by transits of the fixed stars , of the motion of the clock with this sort of pendulum , and from the experience of several years ( during which the clock was kept constantly going ) he found , that the clock was liable to sudden starts and jerks in its motion .
Of this he informed Dr. Bradley , Mr. Bliss , myself , and several other gentlemen .
This clock still remains in Mr. Graham 's house , in the possession of his executors .
I have been informed , that one Mr. Frotheringham , a quaker , of Lincolnshire , caused a pendulum to be made , consisting of two bars , one of brass , and the other of steel , fastened together by screws , with levers to raise or let down the bob ; and that these levers were placed above the bob .
This clock I have seen , and was told by the maker , Mr. John Berridge , that the pendulum of it was made in the year 1738 , or 1739 , and that the dial-plate of it was engraved at Mr. Sisson 's house in the year 1738 : and this clock is in the possession of Mrs. Gibson , in Newgate-street , who has had it ever since the year 1739 .
In the Hist. of the Royal Acad. of Sciences at Paris , for the year 1741 , there is a memoir of M. Cassini , in which he describes several sorts of pendulums for clocks , compounded of bars of brass and steel , and applies a lever to raise or let down the bob of the pendulum , by the expansion or contraction of the bar of brass .
He has also given us , in the same memoir , a problem for finding the proportion , which the two arms of the lever should have , to answer the intended purpose ; and also a demonstration of it .
In June , 1752 , Mr. John Ellicott gave in to the Royal Society a paper , containing the description of a pendulum , consisting of two bars , one of brass , and the other of iron , fastened together by screws , with two levers in the bob of the pendulum , so contrived , as to raise and let down the bob , by the expansion and contraction of the brass bar ; and also to adjust the arms of the levers to their true proportion * .
He says , that he first thought of these methods of applying bars of brass and iron to prevent the irregularities of a clock , arising from the different lengths of the pendulum , by the effects of heat and cold , in the year 1732 ; and that he put this his thought in execution in the year 1738 .
In the year 1743 , I bought a clock of Mr. Graham , which he had kept going for two years before .
This clock has a pendulum , compounded of wires of brass and steel , in the manner of Mr. Harrison 's combination .
It has also a provision in the bob , to adjust the wires , in case they happen to be too long .
When I first took notice of this contrivance or provision in the bob , I asked Mr. Graham the reason of it ; who told me , that , having observed some inequalities in the motion of the clock , he imagined , that they arose from the wires being somewhat too long ; and thereU uu2 fore * He has also given us in the same paper another construction of a pendulum to prevent the effects of heat and cold , consisting of two bars , one of brass , and the other of iron ; the brass bar acting upon a lever , at the end of which is fastened the pendulum , the whole so constructed and contrived , as to raise the pendulum , when it is lengthened by heat , and to let it down , when shortened by fore added this contrivance , to adjust the length of the wires ; but that , when he had done this , he found inequalities still remaining ; and therefore justly concluded , that they arose from the difference in the friction of the different parts of the clockwork , occasioned by the differences in the fluidity of the oil , &amp;c. From what has been said above , it appears , that the improvement of clocks , by a contrivance to prevent their inequalities arising from the different lengths of the pendulum , in different seasons of the year , by the effects of heat and cold , was first thought of , and executed , by Mr. George Graham ; and that the application of wires or bars of two metals , which have different degrees of expansion or contraction , to prevent the same inequalities , was also first thought of by Mr. Graham , and first executed by Mr. John Harrison , without the least knowlege of what Mr. Graham had done before him .

