LXXXVI .
A Letter from James Parsons , M. D. F. R. S. to the Rev. Mr. Birch , Secr. R. S. concerning the Formation of Corals , Corallines , &amp;c. SIR , THE several ingenious opinions of some of this learned Society , upon what M. Peyssonnel has advanced , concerning the formation of some of the submarine bodies by animals , have occasioned the following conjectures ; which I lay before you , not at all presuming absolutely to decide a question of so difficult a nature , but only to endeavour at throwing a little more light upon the subject , in general , by such further observations , as I thought would be most conducive at least , to come to a little more certainty about it .
Read June 18 , 1752 .
I believe it may be said , that there can be no ocular demonstration of the fabrication of any of these bodies , whether by animals , or by vegetation ; because this happens under the water , far enough from any human observation .
Therefore , when at any time such of these , as are said to be the work of animals , have been taken up , there is no doubt , but that those soft gelatinous weakly animals may have been seen upon them , and thence have been concluded to be the makers of them .
Certainly there is nothing impossible to Divine Providence , in the order and disposition of every thing to the best advantage .
Among the animals , from the largest to the most minute , none are destitute of proper habitations ; and we see , amongst them , prodigious variety in the modes and designs of such dwelling-places .
Some are capable of erecting for themselves commodious apartments to live in , as shell-fish , even out of their own constituent parts as they grow .
Others lodge their young in the very skins of animals ; and where there are any , who have neither sagacity nor strength enough to provide places for themselves , they are at least taught by their Maker to find them ready made .
Such are the bounds set to our intellectual powers here , that we can have no means of judging of objects , which do not immediately fall under our inspection , but by comparing them to .
something else , as near them as may be ; or by considering their proportions and effects ; what is probable , what is not , in the phenomenon , that belong to them ; and what absurdities may arise from the uses and actions ascribed to them ; for certainly they may be easily seen , by considering the objects themselves .
I would neither conclude , with M. Peyssonnel , that , because I found animals upon such bodies as he mentions , they were the makers of such bodies ; nor that , if one or more kinds of those bodies were actually the work of such creatures , all others , that had any relation to them , must also be their work ; any more than I would , on the other hand , conclude , that , because one or more of these submarine substances were not made by them , none at all were produced by them .
I would rather examine the parts of those bodies in as nice and scrutinous a manner as possible , and compare their characteristics with those of other bodies in both the animal and vegetable kingdoms ; and , by finding out some of their properties only , be , in a great measure , able to range them in the rank , which they were designed to hold by Divine Providence .
In order to this , let us see first what are those animals , which we are acquainted with , who certainly fabricate their dwelling-places , as they grow for themselves ; and what the common or usual advantages are , which they are in general observed to be endowed with ; which will be best done , by taking a near view of them .
All the testaceous tribe , whether of land or water , and whatever their forms be , may be said to produce their own habitations , but not to fabricate them .
For we must observe , there are but two modes , by which these kinds of animals are furnished with them ; the one by secretion from themselves , and these necessarily grow with them ; the other by a designed apposition of parts of the animals themselves .
Now , in the first case , there is a necessity for a just proportion between the animal itself , and the shelly matter secreted from it .
It must be large enough , and have stability and strength in proportion to the matter which it secretes , and is to move about with ; and it will appear , that this is the general rule thro ' nature : Or , if it be an immovable body , the creature ought certainly to be allow 'd so much significancy and strength , as would , on the one hand , seem necessary for the secretion of so much matter , as was sufficient to constitute that body ; or , on the other , to be capable , by its own proper action , of gathering together the matter , and building up the structure .
Where this is wanting , I , for my own part , would be far from hastily concluding such work to be the fabrication of such seemingly weakly insignificant animals ; more especially if , upon these very bodies , there were appearances of other characteristics , that , at the same time , were likely to lead me into another arrangement of them .
I have produced here before you such of the shellanimals , as are unquestionably the makers of their own houses , that are furnished with these requisites mentioned ; and others I shall now offer you , being somewhat nearer those said to form the coral , &amp;c. than other testaceous kinds .
The dentalia are tubular shells , formed from their inhabitant animal , as much as a cockle , or an oyster : and we must observe , that each of these has a sufficient cavity for its habitation , and in itself has the proportional size and strength necessary for the purpose .
The vermiculi marini enjoy the same privileges , and are always attached to their shells at their posterior extremities , as well as the others , of whatsoever kind .
They are found in groups , adhering together by a natural cement , blended , and , as it were , confounded together ; and yet every one has its own cell , and is sufficient to produce in those requisites beforemention 'd .
All the kinds of these have one extremity small , and increase in diameter to the anterior extremity ; which is indeed the case of all the turbinated fish of whatsoever kind .
To these we may add , that the crusts of crustaceous animals , and those of insects in their chrysalis state , will always show , how necessarily an animal must have power and sufficiency to form his habitation , either by secretion , or actual operation .
The syringoides , so called from their forms , carry the same testimonies of their strength and power ; many species of which we find fossil , of which I have the honour to show several specimens : And I have no doubt , but it will be hard to find any creatures more deficient , or , in other words , more abandoned to destruction by the Creator , than these , in any part of nature .
Whatever is constructed by an animal , that is , among those , that we know with any certainty , it is surely to dwell in themselves , or to deposit eggs or young in .
There was really no need to build a fabric to dwell upon ; because all those creatures , such as the polypi of every kind , which attach themselves to bodies , have innumerable sorts of matter , to which they can adhere every-where , near them : And if these of the sea have , in their nature and properties , any analogy with our fresh-water polypi , as to their propagation , and the detachment of their young from themselves ; with the several kinds of the same genus , the polypes a panache , polypes a bouquet , the bell-like polypi , and every other kind , discovered by our ingenious observer Mr. Trembley , all which detach their young from them nearly in the same manner ; one would almost be persuaded , that they were never intended to dwell in cavities , but upon nidus 's convenient for their attachment only , with full liberty , at proper times , to detach their young in like manner ; who immediately meet some or other of these submarine bodies for their security also ; for indeed there is hardly room to suppose any other way of propagation for these , than for those of M. Trembley , since they are much of the same substance and consistency every way .
And it must be remarked , that few or no animals , that have shells of any kind , can ever quit them , but must remain in them till they die .
We are now , secondly , to consider some of the most obvious marks , that distinguish vegetable from other substances .
Whatever body is fixed by its root , no matter , whether it be flat or fibrose , increasing upwards , and ramifying into smaller and smaller branches , till they become more and more pointed to their extremities ; having fibres either apparently tubular , or only porous or woody , would incline one , who had at all made the works of nature his study , rather to favour the idea of a vegetable in such a body , than that of any other production .
If these characteristics are common to any of the species of corals , corallines , madrepores , &amp;c. it would be no wonder they owed their increase to a kind of vegetation ; nor would their hardness weigh at all against it , because every one knows , that water is the universal vehicle of all matter into bodies of this kind .
It is by water , that the testaceous matter is carried into the juices of shell 'd fish , and from it detached into the order we see it in the shells .
It is from water , that sparry incrustations upon vegetables are made : It is a deposit from water , that lines our common tea-kettles with a sparry crust : And it is also this fluid , that conveys the particles of tartar into the grape , which is afterwards deposited upon the sides of the winevessel ; and no doubt but it is water , which carries up into those hard bodies their stony matter ; for there can be no doubt of their being organized bodies .
Besides , tho ' the organization , in its origin , is probably flexible enough , yet the arrangement of these petrific particles in so exact a manner would inevitably render the whole hard enough , in the course of its growth .
Is not the shell of a common egg hard enough ?
and yet its membrane , into the cellules of which the testaceous particles were secreted and ranged , in order to produce that hardness , was soft enough before .
If we were to make transverse sections of the generality of these bodies , we should see a regular radiated order of pores from their central medullary pipes , some foliated , others more tubular , others barely porous , all differing from one another only according to their own natures .
What more is there in the order of the fibres of trees or plants ?
Transverse sections of any of these will show you the most beautiful figures , in such orders , that can be conceived ; which , long ago , that accurate and learned naturalist Dr. Grew has ingeniously observed , in his Anatomy of Plants , where he has given elegant figures of such sections in a variety of examples .
And altho ' some of these bodies have their pipes and pores quite stopped up , as they grow , yet their external appearance will show them fibrose .
In like manner some trees are so very hard , from the strong connection of their parts , that , in a transverse section , neither pores nor fibres can be distinguished ; and they are as susceptible of a fine polish as any stone .
And indeed it would seem to me much more difficult to conceive , that so fine an arrangement of parts , such masses as these bodies consist of , and such regular ramifications in some , and such wellcontriv 'd organs to serve for vegetation in others , should be the operations of little , poor , helpless , jelly-like animals , rather than the work of more sure vegetation , which carries on the growth of the tallest and largest trees with the same natural ease and influence , as the minutest plant , in a manner , which I have elsewhere explained .
Is it not also somewhat particular , that , if corals are the work of these insects , there should be no cavity left behind them , as they raise it into branches ; but that they should leave it solid within ?
And would it not be very surprising , that such cellular passages , as we see diversified into many kinds , should be made by these creatures from the basis , to be left behind them , as they carry up the building , without any further purpose , in brain-stones , &amp; c ?
If this was the case , and that these little creatures could be supposed to build them , there would be a deviation from the general uniformity and purpose , that is observed every-where else : For certainly cells are built by every animal to deposit something , eggs , young , or other matter , in them ; neither of which can be said of the insects in question .
It has been said , that flies , wasps , and bees , build themselves cells ; in order to make a comparison between them and these polypi .
They do so ; but is there no distinction to be made ?
I can find several .
Bees , wasps , &amp;c. are in themselves , compact strong animals , well made for the work allotted them , very able to bring and put together the materials of their nests ; and when they have done their work , that proportion between the fabric , and the creatures which raised it , is apparent , which all nature points out , and the purpose is fulfilled soon , in their filling them with what nature had destined they should hold .
But can this be said of our polypi ?
Where is that proportion between a little configurated jelly , and the mass of matter said to be their work ?
What is deposited in the cells they form ?
What makes others solid ?
And how do these jellies so wonderfully dispose the fine arrangement of pores , fibres , nodes , branches , &amp;c. ?
And to what purpose , if they could be supposed capable of it ?
In a word , I humbly purpose to sum up this essay in two general sentiments ; and these will be the rule , by which I , for my own part , shall always judge of things of this nature ; viz. 1 .
Whatever bodies shall be found to carry the appearances and characteristic marks of vegetables ; even tho ' animals are found upon them , they certainly will pass with me for such , till stronger evidence shall evince the contrary .
And , 2 .
I shall ever expect to see , at least , a seeming power , proportion , and stability , in animals , to render them capable of performing what they may be thought to have done .
I am , SIR , With the utmost respect , Yours and the Society 's most obedient servant , J. Parsons .

