A Letter from Mr. Rich .
Dunthorne to the Rev. Dr. Long , F. R. S. Master of Pembroke-Hall in Cambridge , and Lowndes 's Professor of Astronomy and Geometry in that University , concerning Comets .
SIR , Cambridge Oct. 5 , 1751 .
THERE is a manuscript in your college library , chiefly astrological , wherein there are five tracts of different authors concerning comets .
One of them , entitled , Tractatus fratris Egidii de cometis ( written on account of a comet , which appeared in the year of our Lord 1264 ) contains these passages relating to its place and motion : Nn Prolog .
Read Nov. 14 , Prolog .
` ` Stella caudata seu crinita apparuit in regno Franciae in orient ante solis ortum a 19~ kalendas Augusti usque 5~ nonas Octobris in anno Domini 1264 .
Cap. 1 .
` ` Cometem , cujus occasion haec scripsimus , primo vidimus extra circulum zodiaci versus aquilonem contra cancrum , et demum eundem vidimus extra circulum versus austrum sub geminis inter canem et orionem .
Cap. 3 .
` ` Vidimus autem et stellam caudatam , cujus occasion hoc scripsimus , praeter motum circularem diurnum , aeque moveri motu retrogradationis , et nulli alii similis , secundum latitudinem ejus , quae est a septentrione ad austrum .
Visus est moveri per duos menses solares plusquam 40 gradus , vix per 3 gradus longitudinis permutans situm .
Cap. 7 .
` ` Cometes , cujus occasion haec scripsimus , primo visa est in vespere post solis occasum , demum post paucos dies solem pertransiens in mane circa octavum gradum cancri , et ex hinc cito processit retro in geminos : vidimus autem et cometem moveri ab aquilone ad austrum , secundum latitudinem quidem plus 50 graduum , et secundum longitudem quidem vix 5 gradus processisse .
' ' Hevelius in his Cometographia has also given us the following paragraph , among others , concerning this comet : A. C. 1264 , stella , quae dicitur cometes , apparuit , videlicet in orient , ante ortum diei , post stellam matutinam : apparuit , scilicet , ante auroram cum radiis multis : ipsi ejus radii longe lateque apparuerunt apparuerunt antequam oriretur ipsa stella cometes .
Igitur veloci cursu laboravit ipsa stella cometes , ita quod praecurrerit &amp; longe versus meridiem praecessit stellam matutinam , i. e. luciferum .
Visa est circa festum S. Mariae Magdalenae , &amp; usque ad octavam S. Augustini apparuit .
Compilat .
Chronol .
' ' Although this whole account be very slender and rude , it is however much the best I have met withal of any comet earlier than that , which was observed by Regiomontanus in the year 1472 ( except perhaps the account given us by Nicephorus Gregoras of the comet of the year 1337 , whose orbit is computed by Dr. Halley ) : for which reason , I was induced to try .
whether I could investigate a set of elements capable of representing the places of this comet agreeable to the above description , and after several attempts , some of them indeed but tentative , I fixed upon the following numbers for that purpose , viz. the place of its ascending node in ~ 19~ , the inclination of its orbit to the plane of the ecliptic 36~1/ 2 , the place of its perihelion in ~ 21~ , its perihelion distance from the sun 44500 such parts as the mean distance of the earth from the sun contains 100000 , and the time of its being in perihelion July 6d8~ p. m. The motion of the comet in this orbit was direct .
Its places computed from these elements are as in the following table .
Time .
Comet 's long .
Comet 's latit .
~ July 1 in the evening 69 25 57 22 13 North Here it might be seen in the evening after ~ sunset * .
14 in the morning 69 7 58 10 49 18 69 4852 22 69 1 40 0 30 South Here , in the southern parts of Europe , it 26 69 0 16 5 31 arose ante ortum diei post stellam matutinam .
30 II 29 35 9 59 Aug. 3 II 29 21 13 58 7 II 29 23 17 30 11 II 29 34 20 42 15 II 29 49 23 39 19 69 02 26 23 23 69 0 12 28 58 27 69 0 17 31 24 31 69 0 16 33 42 Sept. 4 69 01 35 56 8 II 29 36 38 4 Here it was inter canem et orionem .
12 II 29 0 40 6 16 II 28 12 42 4 20 II 27 7 43 55 24 II 25 46 45 41 28 II 24 8 47 18 Oct. 3 II 21 44 49 8 * Perhaps the tail might not be conspicuous enough to occasion its being taken much notice of , in its descent towards the perihelion .
~ July the 6 , the comet was in the same right ascension with the sun , and had near 41~1/ 2 north declination ; so that in the south of France it set about the going down of twilight , and did not rise again till day-break ; and therefore might escape being seen for a few days , either morning or evening , about this time .
I think the computed places here set down agree as well with the foregoing description as any regular computus can be expected to do ; and the resemblance of all the elements gives some ground for conjecture , that ' this comet might possibly be the same with that which was observed by Paul Fabritius and others in the year 1556 , whose orbit Dr. Halley has computed : See his Synopsis Astronomiae cometicae .
Indeed the change in the place of the perihelion may perhaps be thought greater than could arise from the mutual gravitations of the comets disturbing one another ; but then it may be considered , that neither the place nor time of the perihelion , nor the perihelion distance of the comet of the year 1556 , could be determined very accurately from observations made only for 12 days , at 40 days distance from the perihelion , as those of Fabritius were , unless they had been more exact than his appear to be .
If these were one and the same comet , its period is 292 years ; and we may expect its return about the year 1848 .
There are in the before-mention 'd manuscript , besides the passages already quoted from Egidius , two other places which deserve to be taken notice of .
One of them is so much of a small tract , entitled , Judicium de stella comata anno Domini 1301 , as concerns the place and motion of the comet ; it is as follows : A. D. MCCC primo , primo die Septembris apparuit cometa in occidente , et per mensem vel amplius visus fuit .
Ultima autem die Septembris duabus horis 40 minutis post occasum solis inveni quod longitudo cometae in signis et gradibus erat 20 gradus scorpionis , et latitudo * 26 gradus septentrionalis : Mars autem tunc erat in 20 gradu scorpionis directus exeuns , et sic fere conjuncti erant Mars et cometa accipiendo loca ipsorum per circulum transeuntem per polos zodiaci .
Verum et sexta die Octobris , scilicet in festo Sanctae Fidis post occasum solis eadem hora inveni quod longitudo ejus erat primus gradus sagittarii , et latitudo ejus 10 gradus septentrionalis .
Cometae latitudo ecliptica circa principium apparitionis suae fuit 20 gradus et amplius septentrionalis .
Apparebat cometa moveri a septentrione in meridiem per oriens , ita quod ejus longitudo orientalis continue videbatur augeri , et ejus latitudo septentrionalis continue videbatur diminui .
In principio apparitionis suae coma protendebatur ad septentrionem ; et post motum successive movebatur per orientem ad meridiem versus stellam quae dicitur altayr hoc est vulture volans .
' ' Though this account is too imperfect for us to attempt determining the orbit therefrom , it may notwithstanding help us to know the same comet again , if any should hereafter appear whose orbit will agree with this relation ; which I believe none of those already computed will do .
The other place I hinted at as worthy of notice , is this short passage in a treatise De significatione cometarum : Et * This figure ( 2 ) is a different writing from the rest of the manuscript , and has manifestly been altered since it was first written ; it seems to have been 16~ at the first , which I think the truer reading .
Et nos invenimus modo quod apparuit in tempore nostro unus cometa in principio piscium , et cauda attingit usque ad principium geminorum in nocte Mercurii , et hoc fuit in ultimam nocte Junii , anno 499 Arab .
et sequebatur ordinem signorum quousque venit usque ad principium cancri , et dimisit ordinem signorum , et incepit deficere .
' ' The word Junii here found seems to have been transcribed by mistake for the Arabic month Jumedi.j , the last day whereof that year was Wednesday Feb. 7 .
A. C. 1106 ; whereas the last day of June fell upon Saturday .
This reading agrees with the following notes concerning the same comet collected by Hevelius in his Cometographia , p. 821 .
A. C. 1106 a prima hebdomada quadragesimae cometam immensi fulgoris usque ad passionem Domini conspeximus .
' ' Lavath ex Urspurg .
A. C. 1106 , mense Februar .
biduo post novilunium , visus est magnus cometa , ad occasum solis brumalem .
' ' Calvis .
ex Tyr .
The new moon was Feb. 5 , Ash-Wednesday that year Feb. 7 , and Good-Friday , March 23 .
If we suppose ( with Dr. Halley ) this comet to be the same with that which appeared in 1680 , and that it was in perihelio Feb. 4 , at noon ( for it must have been seen in two or three days after it had passed its perihelion ) some of its places would have been these : d~ Com. Long. Com. Lat. ~~~~ Feb. 7 6. .
~7 50. .
5 44 North Mar. 14 71/ 2. .
~ 11 49 19 8. .
~ 15 38 24 8. .
~ 19 2 The wide disagreement there is between the manuscript account of this comet , and its places here computed , must very much lessen , if it does not quite overbalance , the force of the arguments brought by Dr. Halley to prove the identity of these two comets .
Indeed if this comet had been the same with that of 1680 , it could not have come to the beginning of Cancer , without a change in the place of the perihelion too great to be easily admitted ; nor could it have left the order of the signs without a change in the elements still greater .
I am , SIR , Your obliged , and most obedient servant , Richard Dunthorne .

