XXXIV .
An Account of Professor Winkler 's Experiments relating to Odours passing through electrised Globes and Tubes , being the Extract and Translation from the Latin of two Letters sent by that Gentleman to Cromwell Mortimer , M. D. Secretary of the Royal Society .
With an Account of the Result of some Experiments made here with Globes and Tubes , transmitted from Leipsic by Mr. Winkler to the Royal Society , in order to verify the Facts beforementioned , by Mr. W. Watson , F. R. S. PROFESSOR Winkler , in his first letter to Dr. Mortimer , dated at Leipsic , March 12 , 1748 , mentions , among other particulars , that if odoriferous substances were included in glass globes and tubes closely stopped , and if these globes were electrised , the smell of the odoriferous substances would as easily as the magnetical power pass through the glass , and be conveyed with the electrical effluvia to considerable distances , upon substances readily conducting electricity : that when a man was electrised with a globe of this sort , the odoriferous matter pervaded his whole body ; and that not only his skin and his cloaths , but his breath , saliva , and sweat , were impregnated with the smell of the substance included in the glass .
That after these globes had been rubbed a few minutes , the flavour 4 of Read June 20 .
of their contents would be strongly perceptible upon entering the chamber , in which this operation was performing ; and that the substances which he had then tried , were sulphur , cinnamon , and balsam of Peru .
Mr. Winkler mentions , that when he made use of sulphur in his globe , in company with his friend Mr. Haubold , and others , the smell of the sulphur was perceived at more than ten feet 's distance , and was so prevalent , that his company was driven away thereby : but that himself staying therein some time longer , his cloaths , his body , and his breath , were infected thereby ; and that this smell even continued upon him the next day .
Moreover upon his repeating this experiment , as he had before found , that sulphur had been useful to him , he on the third day found in his mouth manifest indications of an inflamed blood .
After this he wanted to transmit a pleasant odour ; and for this purpose employed cinnamon , which under the like circumstances sent forth its odour in great abundance ; so that it was not only immediately perceptible to any one entering the chamber , but continued there the next day .
Balsam of Peru , under the like treatment , so impregnated the air of the room , that the cloaths and the breath of the persons therein smelled of the balsam , after having passed through several streets ; and that Mr. Winkler , when drinking his tea next morning , still perceived the flavour thereof .
A few days after , when the smell of the chamber was gone off , he conducted a chain upon silk lines from thence through the open air into another chamber quite separate from the former .
In this second chamber he placed a man upon a silk net , who held the chain in his hand , and after having electrised him with the sphere containing balsam of Peru for a quarter of an hour , any person , who was perfectly ignorant of what was doing , would immediately smell the balsam therein .
The man , who was electrised , said , that his tea next morning had a finer taste than usual .
As these experiments did not succeed here , though attempted with a due attention to whatever could be imagined necessary thereto ; and as they had done so no-where upon the continent , Italy alone excepted , Dr. Mortimer was desired by the Royal Society to acquaint Mr. Winkler of this want of success , and at the same time to desire him to transmit hither , not only a circumstantial account of the manner of making his experiments , but likewise , lest the difference of the result might arise from employing different kinds of glass , some globes and tubes fitted up under his own eye in the most advantageous manner .
This Mr. Winkler was so obliging as to comply with ; and accordingly the Society has received from him two globes and four tubes ; and at the same time this gentleman sent a letter to Dr. Mortimeri dated at Leipsic , Nov. 23 , 1750 , of which the following is a translation from the Latin of so much as relates to these matters .
You desire me , as soon as the grief for the loss of my wife would permit me , to explain , in the most clear and intelligible manner , my experiments , whereby spices and balsams , by their fragrance , pervade glass , when electrised .
Glass globes and tubes ought to have this property , that , when the latter are rubbed backwards and forwards through the hand , or the former with the hand applied thereto , they give manifest tokens of the electric power .
Moreover the glass of these tubes and globes ought to be thin ; lest the thickness of the glass should prevent the transmission of the odours .
It is necessary , that the spices be dry , and broken small , and that spirituous liquors , as well as the more liquid balsams , should be well mixed with powdered chalk .
But how great the quantity may be , either of the spices , balsams , or spirituous liquors , which should be included , cannot be determined ; because it is not yet certain , how much of the electrical power is necessary for dissolving the odoriferous particles , and carrying them along with it .
But as the fact itself is manifest , I have taken upon me to transmit to the Royal Society , for which I have the highest regard , two globes and four tubes .
I hope , that these tubes , when rubbed as usual between the hands furnished with a piece of thin and somewhat rough cloth , and that these globes , if mounted upon the pillars of an electrical machine , and either rubbed with a naked but very dry hand , or with a piece of silk or woollen cloth , will transmit odours , plainly different from the odour of the electric matter , and which persons here at Leipsic of good noses have distinctly perceived .
To know indeed this difference , it is necessary , that , before the prepared tube is rubbed , a tube containing nothing odoriferous be tried ; and lest the friction should be attended with no effect , great care must be taken that the outward surface of the globes and tubes be perfectly dry .
Of the tubes one contains flowers of sulphur : this was sent me from Dresden by Mr. Haubold , mathematician and geographer to the king of Poland .
It is the same sort with one , with which that gentleman showed the late Count Saxe the penetration of the sulphureous odour , when he was last year at Dresden .
In another I have included balsam of Peru , mixed with powdered chalk .
In the third , opobalsamum ; and in the fourth , spirit of wine with chalk .
The larger globe contains opobalsamum , and the smaller beaten cinnamon .
In making use of the globe with cinnamon , this method is to be observed .
After that , from the rotation against the hand or a rubber , the globe is warmed , let the motion be discontinued .
After this discontinuance , let the hand be immediately applied to the globe , and the nose of any person , who is willing to make the trial , is to be held within an inch or two thereof ; and the rotation to be repeated by little and little , and to be made slowly .
In this repeated and gentle rotation the observer will perceive the agreeable vapour of cinnamon ; but this vapour quickly vanishes upon continuing the rotation .
It is therefore necessary , that , as soon as the globe is heated again , the rotation should be stopped , and be begun again by little and little , when , upon the first turn of the globe , the exhalation of the cinnamon will be perceived .
And this may be repeated as often as you please , only observing , as often as the globe is heated , that after a short respite you begin the rotation of the globe in a very gentle manner .
I beg of you , sir , in the most solemn manner , that you would explain these rules to Mr. Watson , and entreat him , that , when the trials of these globes and tubes shall be made in the presence of several persons , all these circumstances may be regarded ; lest any thing be omitted , which may conduce to the knowledge of the truth .
' ' The tubes and globes referred to in the above letter were received by the Royal Society about the middle of May 1751 , and were presented to that body by the President at their next meeting ; and they were put into my hands , in order that their effects upon trial might be reported at a future meeting .
The largest sphere was of crystal glass of about seven inches diameter , fixed to its wooden spindles by a resinous cement , and contained not more than half an ounce of a terebinthinate fluid , less deep in colour than balsam of Peru , and more so than balm of Gilead .
The smaller globe was five inches in diater , was mounted nearly as the larger one , and contained about half an ounce of beaten cinnamon .
The tube containing the flowers of sulphur was two feet in length , and about half an inch in diameter : it , like the globes and the other tubes , was of crystal glass , and in like manner with the rest of the tubes was hermetically sealed .
The tube , said to contain balsam of Peru and chalk , was about twenty inches long , and 3/ 8 of an inch in diameter : that said to contain opobalsamum was about sixteen inches long , and half an inch in diameter : and that with spirit of wine and chalk was about seventeen inches long , and about half an inch in diameter .
The manner of mounting these globes might be somewhat exceptionable for the purposes intended , as the necks were fitted to their wooden blocks with a resinous cement without glass stoppers ; so that when the globes , from their being rubbed , had warmed the cement , if an odour of the matter contained in the glass had been perceptible , it might have been urged , that it came through the cement with more probability than through the glass : but nothing of this kind could be objected to the tubes , as they were hermetically sealed .
June 12 , 1751 , there met me at my house , in order to make trial of the effects of these glasses , Martin Folks Esq ; President , Nicholas Mann Esq ; Vice-president , Dr. Mortimer and Peter Daval Esq ; Secretaries , Mr. Canton , Fellow of the Royal Society ; and Mr. Schrader , a gentleman of distinction well known to , and corresponding with Mr. Winkler .
The presence of this gentleman was highly agreeable to the company ; as he was thereby enabled to satisfy both himself and his friend Mr. Winkler of the zeal and address , which we exerted in order to verify Mr. Winkler 's assertions .
The weather was dry , and very fit for electrical experiments .
Not the least alteration had been made in Mr. Winkler 's globes ; but as , with its mounting , one of them was too wide to be placed between the posts of my electrical machine , these posts were altered for that purpose .
The largest globe , said to contain opobalsamum , was first put the trial : it was first rubbed a considerable time with a dry hand chalked , and the snaps at the prime conductor were but weak ; but upon rubbing the globe , first with the cushion , which I have usually for that purpose employed , and afterwards with red leather , the snaps were much stronger ; and Mr. Canton , as well as another gentleman present , were electrised by turns therewith : but all this while no smell of the balsam could be perceived by any of the company , either upon the equator of the globe , the persons electrised , the prime conductor , or any of the rubbers made use of ; though for this purpose we carefully observed , not only the method suggested by Mr. Winkler , but such others , as appeared to us the most conducive to the present purpose .
When the globe was heated , indeed by putting our noses near the mounting , we could smell the resin therein ; but this was all .
We employed quick motion , afterwards we permitted the globe to be still , and then began again with an extremely gentle motion ; but still no odour of the balsam could be perceived in the room , though for that purpose a person was called in , well-skilled in these odours , and who , from his coming fresh out of the air , it was suggested might more readily perceive them : but this , he declared , he was not capable of doing .
We next tried the lesser globe containing cinnamon , and most punctually observed Mr. Winkler 's directions , as he is more especially exact in what , he thinks , should be observed to make this experiment succeed : but our endeavours were to no purpose , for we could never , after many trials , either smell the cinnamon , or make the electricity the least perceptible upon the prime conductor .
This indeed was what I had always heretofore observed , when I endeavoured to make this experiment ; as such a quantity of non-electric matter , unless the sides of the globe were very thick , prevented the exciting the electrical power , even when I employed globes much larger than this sent by Mr. Winkler .
We then began with the tubes : As you see by their dimensions , they were , except that containing the sulphur , by much the smallest I had ever seen used for these purposes : but every gentleman has a right to perform his experiments in his own way .
Accordingly their power in electrising was but weak ; for though some of them attracted and repelled the leaf-silver tolerably well , yet when a man was attempted to be electrised with them , the snaps from his hand were very small .
Of these four tubes , that with sulphur was much the strongest : the next to it , that said to contain opobalsamum ; then that with balsam of Peru , and chalk ; but the least of all , that with spirit of wine and chalk , which with the common rubbers scarce attracted the silver ; but when rubbed by some silk prepared with linseed-oil , and brought by Mr. Canton , the attractive power was increased , though even then it was very little .
Mr. Canton has for some time usually rubbed his tubes with this oiled silk , which he has found by experience to produce the greatest effects , but he does not think it proportionably useful in rubbing globes .
In their turns the globes and all the tubes were rubbed with this oiled silk ; but no one of the company , after very many trials in different ways , could perceive the least odour of the substances contained , either upon the outside of the tubes , or upon the substances electrised thereby .
We thus spent more than two hours without success , in our endeavours to see the effects proposed by Mr. Winkler ; for we were unfortunate enough not to be able to verify them in one single instance .
There appears a very great disparity between the two letters from Mr. Winkler to Dr. Mortimer concerning these facts .
In the first we are informed , that the effluvia from balsam of Peru were not only perceptible in the person electrised , and in the air of the room ; but that these were carried along with the current of electricity through the open air into another chamber : that his company did not chuse to bear the offensive smell of the brimstone transpiring through his glass ; and that it even heated his own blood : that cinnamon also sent forth its odour in great abundance , perceptible to any one immediately entering the chamber , and continuing there till next day .
In the second letter you will perceive , that there is a great abatement of what we were promised to expect from the first : we are there told , that the glass globes and tubes now sent , if they are electrised , transmit odours , not those directly of the substances included , but such as are plainly different in smell from the electrical effluvia , and which , to use his own words , viri odoratu valentes bic , Lipsiae distinct senserunt ; so that must we conclude , that our noses are not so good as those of the gentlemen at Leipsic ?
Mr. Winkler does not even say in his last letter , that he can electrise with the cinnamon-globe , and that the vapours sent from it are to be smelt at the entrance of the chamber ; but that , with a great deal of management , they are to be perceived within an inch or two of the globe ; which however we had the mortification not to be sensible of with the greatest-attention .
Upon the whole , what shall we say ?
Shall we believe , that Mr. Winkler , relying too much upon the honesty and veracity of Mr. Pivati , and his pretended extraordinary discoveries , suffered his heated imagination to dictate his first letter to Dr. Mortimer ; and that what he then sent , he rather hoped would prove true upon experiment , than what really was so ?
and that his second letter , in which there is so remarkable a diminution of what was promised in the first , was the retreat of one , who was unwilling to be thought to have communicated to the Royal Society any thing , which would not upon trial come out as he had represented it ?
But be that as it may ; as success both here and abroad has been wanting to the endeavours of those , who have desired to repeat these experiments , I shall determine nothing myself ; but , from an undisguised representation of the facts , as they have appeared to me , I shall leave every one to deduce his own conclusion concerning the reality

