Some Observations upon the Sex of Flowers by W. Watson , F. R. S. occasioned by a Letter upon the same Subject , by Mr. Mylius of Berlin .
Extract of Mr. Mylius 's Letter to Mr. Watson , dated at Berlin , Feb. 20 , 1750-51 .
THE sex of plants is very well confirmed by an experiment , that has been made here on the palma major foliis flabelliformibus .
There is a great tree of this kind in the garden of the royal academy .
It has flowered and bore fruit these thirty years ; but the fruit never ripened ; and when planted , it did not vegetate .
The palm-tree , as you know , is a planta dioecia ; that is , one of those , in which the male and female parts of generation are upon different plants .
We having therefore no male plant , the Y ` ` flowers Read May 2 .
flowers of our female were never impregnated by the farina of the male .
There is a male plant of this kind in a garden at Leipsic , twenty German miles from Berlin .
We procured from thence in April 1749 a branch of male flowers , and suspended it over our female ones ; and our experiment succeeded so well , that our palm-tree produced more than an hundred perfectly ripe fruit ; from which we have already eleven young palmtrees .
This experiment was repeated last year , and our palm-tree bore above two thousand ripe fruit .
As I do not remember a like experiment , I thought convenient to mention it to you ; and , if you think proper , be pleased to communicate it to the Royal Society .
' ' In pursuance of my correspondent 's desire , I take the liberty of laying this account before you , which I think very curious ; not on account of its novelty , or of its confirming the sex of plants , which is now sufficiently established ; but on account of the male and female palm-tree 's flourishing so completely , even under all possible advantages , in such high latitudes as those of Leipsic and Berlin .
The impregnation of the female palm-tree by the male has been known in the most ancient times .
Herodotus * , whom Cicero calls the father of history , when * Herodot .
~ ~ ~ ~ when speaking of the palm-tree , says , ` ` that the Greeks call some of these trees male , the fruit of which they bind to the other kind , which bears dates ; that the small flies , wherewith the male abounds , may assist in ripening the fruit ; for , says this author , the male palm-tree produces in its fruit small flies , just as the fig-tree does .
' ' The very remote age , in which Herodotus wrote , sufficiently apologizes for his believing , that what was really brought about by the farina faecundans of the male flower , was to be attributed to the insects frequently found therein , and which perhaps very often do carry this farina from the male to the female .
They had seen the effects of caprification in fig-trees by these insects , and were misled by the analogy .
I have here translated them small flies , but they had a particular appellation given them by Herodotus , Aristotle * , and Theophrastus , who call them ~ .
Pliny , in his history , when treating of caprification , which is almost a translation from Theophrastus , calls them culices , Linnaeus ichneumones , and Tournefort moucherons .
Theophrastus ~ , the most early writer of plants , except Artistotle , that has been handed down to us , in his account of the palm-tree gives us the very process mentioned by our correspondent .
` ` They bring together ( says this author ) the males and the females , which causes the fruit to continue , and ripen upon the trees .
Some , from the similiY 2 ` ` tude * Aristoteles ~ ~ .
~~~~~~ ~ .
~ Theoph .
~ ~ .
~ .
~ .
tude of this to what happens in fig-trees , call it caprification ; and it is performed in the following manner : While the male plant is in flower , they cut off a branch of these flowers , and scatter the dust and down therein upon the flowers of the female plant .
By these means , ' ' he goes on , ` ` the female does~not cast her fruit , but preserves them to maturity .
' ' Pliny* also mentions the like process .
Among more modern authors , Prosper Alpinus ~ gives us at large the manner of the impregnation of the female palm-tree by the male , for the purposes before-mentioned .
We have also copious accounts of the same process by Tournefort ~ , Kaemfer ~ , and Ludwig ** .
As Kaempfer was an eye-witness , his account of this matter is most to be depended upon .
He says , ` ` Plena res dignissimaque admirationis est modus palmas faemininas faecundandi .
Habet id tot popularium , Persidis , Arabiae , AEgypti , nutrix inter plantas singular , ut animalium exemplo , mari stato tempore miscenda , atque singuli ejus uteri , quasi conjugali coitu , impregnandi sint ; secus omnia sua , quae in lucem prodiderat , fructuum rudimenta , indeclinabili abortu dimissura .
Palmicolis itaque incumbit , ut impregnandis arboribus quotannis impendant operam , siquidem in se redundare annonam cupiunt .
Modus procedendi hic *~ Hist. Not .
lib. xiii .
cap. iv .
~ Alpin .
de plant .
AEgypt .
p. 16 .
~ Isagog .
instit .
~ herbar .
p. 69 .
~ Amaen .
exot .
p. 706 .
** Dissert .
de sexu plant .
p. 29 .
hie est : spaltae masculae incluso tumentes flore , et ad thalami consortium maturo , sub finem Februarii ex arboris fastigio extrahuntur ; quibus in longum dissectis eximuntur spadices , flosculis nondum ofcitantibus , sed in unam massam compactis conserti .
Hos protinus in surculos sive bacillos , spadicibus faemininis inserendos divellunt .
Bacillos alii amant recentes , atque illico insinuare spadicibus , si qui jam lucem nacti sunt ; alii eos prius exsiccant , et in Martium usque mensem custodiunt , quo hiantibus uteris ad unum omnibus insitionem uno actu et opera instituant .
' ' As I am now upon the sex of plants , I cannot but observe , that although the ancients distinguished rightly , in determining the true sexes of the palmtree , it is the only plant , in which they have not erred .
Though they called plants of the same genus , or of others very nearly related thereto , male and female , it was upon an imaginary , a false principle ; and that usually taken from their size , the difference of their leaves , or the figure of their fruit ; and what therefore they have denominated male and female , must not with the modern exactness be rigorously considered as such .
Thus Aristotle * after having taken notice that there was the distinction of male and female observable in plants , says , ` ` that the male ~ plant is more rough and strong , the female more weak and fruitful .
' ' And Theophrastus ~ , when speaking * De plant .
lib. i. cap. 2 .
~ ~ Aristot .
ibid. ~ Plantar .
histor .
lib. iii .
cap. 10 .
ing of the male and female pine-tree , says , ` ` that the Macedonians have trees nearly related to pines , of which the male is of shorter growth , and has harder leaves ; that the female is taller , and has its leaves softer , and more fleshy .
' ' He says , upon his own authority , ` ` that the wood of the male pine is hard , that of the female more soft .
' ' Pliny * also in his history gives a like reason for his distinguishing the sex of the pine : he says farther ~ , in another part of the valuable monument he has left us , that the most expert naturalists assert , that every tree , and every herb , which the earth produces , hath both sexes : ' ' but this is to be understood in the manner I just now mentioned ; and so likewise is the distinction among the more modern botanists in their denominations of several plants , such as Veronica , Eupatorium , Anagallis , Tilia , Paeonia , Balsamita , Filix , Quercus , Orchis , Laureola , Abrotanum , Cornus , Polygonum , Equisetum , Mandragora , and others , which are termed imaginarily male and female ; as the discovery of the real sex of plants was reserved for the accuracy of the present age .
Besides the before-mention 'd erroneous principle , from which the ancients , as well as some more modern authors , determined the sex of plants , there is yet another , which I think right to mention in this place ; and that is , a denomination of plants from their sex , which is absolutely false : and in order to elucidate this position , and to show at the same time wherein * Lib. xvi .
cap. 10 .
~ Lib. xiii .
cap. 4 .
wherein the sex of plants does really consist , I must beg leave to premise , that it is in the flowers of vegetables only , that the parts subservient to generation are produced .
Simple flowers ( I use this term in opposition to the compound flowers of the botanists ) are either male , female , or hermaphrodite .
By male flowers , I would be understood to mean those , which are possessed only of those organs of generation , analogous to the male parts of animals ; and these are , what former botanists have denominated stamina and apices , but are named more properly by Linnaeus since , filamentum and anthera .
The female flower is only endowed with parts like those , which perform the office of generation in females ; and these are the pistillum and its appertenances , which by Linnaeus , with his accustomed accuracy , are divided into three parts ; viz. the germen , stylus , and stigma .
The hermaphrodite flower , which constitutes the great bulk of the vegetable creation , is possessed of all these parts in itself , and is itself thereby capable of propagating its species without any foreign assistance ; which , by many incontestable experiments it has been found neither the male nor female flower simply is able to do .
Much the greater number of plants , as I have just hinted , have hermaphrodite flowers ; but there are some , which have both the male and female flowers growing from the same root .
Such are Mays or Indian corn , nettles , box , elm , birch , oak , walnut , beech , hazel , hornbeam , the plane-tree , pine , fir , cypress , cedar , the larch-tree , melons , cucumers , gourds , and several others .
In many of these , though the male and female flowers are at considerable distances , distances , the farina faecundans , which Providence , on account of its being liable to be spoiled by rain , or dissipated by winds , has provided in great abundance , is conveyed to the female by means of the atmosphere .
It is this class of vegetables , and the following , the quantity of the produce of which is much more precarious than those plants , which have hermaphrodite flowers ; as the impregnation of these last may be performed within their own calyx ; whereas the former must necessarily commit their farina to the circumambient air .
It is for this reason , that if during the time of the flowering of these plants , the weather is either very wet or stormy , their produce of fruit will be very inconsiderable , from the spoiling or hasty dissipation of the male farina .
Thus independent of frosts , the fruit of the nut and filberdtree will be most numerous in those years , in which the months of January and February are the least stormy and wet ; as at that time their flowers are produced .
For the same reasons , a stormy or wet May destroys the chesnuts ; and the same weather in July prodigiously lessens the crop of Mays or Indian corn , as its spikes of male flowers stand lofty , and at a considerable distance from the female .
In like manner a judgment may be formed of the rest of these .
Some of the more skilful modern gardeners put in practice , with regard to melons and cucumers , the very method mentioned by Theophrastus 2000 years ago , in regard to the palm-tree .
As these plants , early in the season , are in this climate confined to frames and glasses , the air , in which they grow , is more stagnant than the open air , whereby the distribution of the farina faecundans , so necessary towards the production of the fruit for the propagation of the species , is much hindered ; to obviate which , they collect the male flowers when fully blown , and presenting them to the female ones , by a stroke of the finger they scatter the farina faecundans therein , and this prevents the falling of the fruit immaturely .
Besides the vegetables before-mentioned , which bear both male and female flowers upon the same root , there are others , which produce those necessary organs upon different roots .
In the number of these are the palm-tree ( the more particular subject of this paper ) hops , the willow-tree , mistletoe , spinach , hemp , poplar , French and dog 's mercury , the yewtree , juniper , and several others .
Among these the Valisneria of Linnaeus , as to the manner , in which its male flower impregnates the female , is one of the most singular prodigies in nature .
The manner of this operation is figured by Micheli , in his Nova plantarum genera , and described by Linnaeus , in the Hortus Cliffortianus .
As that elaborate and expensive work is in very few hands , in such only as owe it to the munificence of Mr. Clifford of Amsterdam , of which number I with pleasure acknowledge myself one , I will here lay before you a short account thereof : The Valisneria grows in rivulets , ditches , and ponds , in many parts of Europe .
The male plant , which is continually covered with water , has a short stalk , upon the top of which its flowers are produced .
As this top never reaches the surface of the water , the flowers are thrown off from it , and come unopened to the surface of the water ; where , as soon as they arrive , by the action of the air , they expand themselves , and swim round the female flowers , which are blown at the same time .
These last have a long spiral foot-stalk , by which they attain the surface of the water , and remaining there in flower a few days , are impregnated by the male flowers detached from the stalk at the bottom .
This operation seems to be thus directed , as the farina faecundans could not exert its effects in so dense a medium as water ; and we find , that even the hermaphrodite flowers of water-plants , such as those of potamogiton , ranunculus aquaticus , hottonia , and nymphaea , these , I say , never expand themselves , until they reach the surface of the water .
But to return : it was not possible for me , without premising these things , to make evident what I just now mentioned , in relation to the falsely denominating the sexes of plants ; as it is to this last class that the wrong application has been made by botanical writers .
This error seems to have been first introduced so early as by Dioscorides , and has been continued through a great variety of writers even to our own time .
It is most certain , that those plants , which produce the seed , ought to be considered as females ; but it happens that in the French and dog 's mercury , the seeds are produced in the female plants by pairs ; and these are contained in a capsule , which was thought to resemble the scrotum of animals ; and from this resticulated appearance they called these plants males , and the others females .
Thus , for example , Dioscorides * , when treating of mercurialis , or what we here call Freanch mercury , says , that ` ` the seed of the female is produced in bunches , and is copious ; that of the male grows near the leaves ; that it is small and round , and is disposed in pairs like testicles .
' ' Dodonaeus , Lobel , Dalechamp , John and Caspar Bauhin , Morrison , Tournefort , and Boerhaave , in their several works , have in this followed Dioscorides , and have denominated the seed-bearing plant of this kind , the male ; and the other , the female .
Fuchsius and John Bauhin likewise call the cynocrambe or dog 's mercury , which bears fruit , the male ; and the spiked one with male flowers only , the female .
This mistake is observable in hemp ~ , hops , and spinach .
We observe , that the operations of nature are carried on most usually by certain general laws , from which however she sometimes deviates .
Thus almost all plants have either hermaphrodite flowers , or male and female flowers growing from the same root , or male and female flowers from different roots : but there are a few of another class , which from the same root furnish either male and hermaphrodite flowers , or female and hermaphrodite flowers .
Of this kind are the mulberry-tree , the musa or plantaintree , white hellebore , pellitory , arrach , the ash-tree , and a few others .
But of this class the empetrum Z2 or * Dioscorid .
lib. iv .
cap. 9 .
edit .
Saracen .
~ ~ ~ ~ Matthiol .
in Dioscorid .
p. 663 .
semen tantum in mari gignitur .
or berry-bearing heath is the most extraordinary ; as of this are found some plants with male flowers only .
others with both male and female flowers separately , and still others with hermaphrodite flowers .
What Pere Labat mentions in his Voyage a l ' Afrique occidentale should likewise be taken notice of here .
This author , after having laid down the different methods of impregnating the female palm-tree by the male , says , that this process is not absolutely necessary for the production of dates ; for being at Martinico , he there saw growing by an old convent near the place , where they anchored , a palm-tree bearing dates , although the only one of its kind , which was thereabouts .
Whether it was male or female , he did not pretend to determine , but was certain , that there then was none , nor had been one , within two leagues of the place where it grew .
He doubts indeed , whether or no this tree bearing fruit did not proceed from the farina faecundans of the male cocoa tree , which is a species of palm , and which grew in abundance near the tree that bore dates : but he observes , that the stones of these dates did not vegetate , and that those , who were desirous of propagating date-trees , were obliged to plant the Barbary dates ; as he believed the others had not the germ proper to produce the tree .
From this account it is very obvious , that the palm-tree here mentioned was a female , in which though the fruit ripened , it was in such a state of imperfection , as not to be able to propagate its species .
In this manner we have eggs furnished us by hens , even without a cock ; but these eggs produce no chickens .
What this father says of the female palm-tree 's bearing fruit without the assistance of the male , our very ingenious and worthy brother Mr. Miller assures me , has been fully confirmed to him by several persons : and John Bauhin * , an author of great credit , describes and figures the whole fructification of a palm-tree , which himself saw growing at Montpelier , and which not only produced branches of male flowers , but also female ones bearing dates .
Mr. Ray many years after tells us in his history of plants ~ , that he himself at Montpelier saw this very remarkable tree mentioned by John Bauhin .
This variety in the fructification of the palm-tree , singular as it may seem , has been likewise observed in some few others .
The learned Jungius , in his Doxoscopia ~ , mentioning that class of trees , which are male and female in different parts of the same tree , says , ` ` that trees of this kind , when they have for many years produced flowers without fruit , afterwards produce fruit without flowers .
This , he thinks , should be further inquired into .
' ' This , since Jungius 's time , has been done , and it has been found that sometimes some of the trees of this class are wholly male , while young ; but as they advance in age , they have flowers of both sexes , and afterwards become entirely female .
This fact Mr. Miller has frequently himself observed in the mulberry tree ; and the Chevalier Rathgeb , at present the emperor 's minister at Venice , *~ plant .
~ .
i. p. 351 .
~~~~ ~ .
p. 1354 .
~ ~ .
p. 145 .
~ al quo ~ flores tulerunt sine fructu , deinue ~ serre sine flore , quod amplius ~ .
nice , a gentleman excellently well versed in whatever relates to vegetation , has observed , that a large lentiscus , or mastich-tree , near his garden , had for thirty years produced only male flowers , but that for three years past it had produced plenty of fruit .
The foundation of the discovery of the real sex of plants , which is of no less importance in natural history , than that of the circulation of the blood in the animal oeconomy , was laid by the members of this learned Society ; although much of the honour due to them is attributed by foreigners to the late ingenious Monsieur Vaillant of Paris : and this may have arisen from our language not being generally understood upon the continent .
Sir Thomas Millington * , sometime Sedleian lecturer of natural philosophy at Oxford , as we see by our worthy member Dr. Grew 's anatomy of plants ~ , seems first to have assigned a more noble purpose to the stamina and apices of flowers , than that which had been attributed thereto by preceding writers , and by Monsieur Tournefort afterwards ; viz. that of secreting some excrementitious juices , which were supposed hurtful to the embryo 's of the fruit .
Sir Thomas conjectured , and rightly , ` ` that the stamina and apices served as the male for the generation of seed .
' ' This hint , which was afterwards adopted by our learned brother Mr. Ray , in the preface to * Dr. Grew calls Sir Thomas Millington Savilian professor , which is a mistake .
See Wood 's Fasti .
Oxon .
vol. ii .
col .
126 .
2d edit .
to his Sylloge stirpium exterarum , Dr. Grew carried farther , as we find by his works ; and it was followed by ~ Rodolphus Jacobus Camerarius , professor at Tubingen : but our very industrious and sagacious member Mr. Morland * pursued long after this inquiry still much higher , as we see by his excellent memoir published in the Philosophical Transactions , to which I must beg leave to refer you .
After these , Messieurs Vaillant and Geoffroy illustrated and strengthened these discoveries by very curious and well adapted experiments ; so that at present nothing seems wanting for the confirmation of the truth of this doctrine .
So much for the discovery of the sex of plants in general , upon which professor Linnaeus of Upsal has founded his system of botany , at present so much and so well received Whoever therefore would consider minutely the structure of flowers and the almost infinite variety of the number and disposition of their parts , may consult Linnaeus 's Philosophia botanica lately published , where this subject is treated in a very copious and instructive manner .
~ Vide epistol .
de sexu plant .
Tubing 1694 .
* Philosoph. Trans. numb. 287 .

