M K Po O Fig. 4 .
p. 68 .
Horizon Orientalis .
SGLAkTB a m m h p * 30 * * * 20 10 ~ Horizon Occidentalis Fig. 5 .
p. 73 .
Q D A M C T a d m XI .
A Letter from the Rev. Patrick Murdocke , F. R. S. concerning the mean Motion of the Moon 's Apogee , to the Rev. Dr. Robert Smith , Master of Trinity College Cambridge .
Reverend Sir , LAST summer , when I was to pay my respects to you at Trinity College , I gave you some account of the warm dispute , then lately arisen between Mr. de Buffon and Mr. Clairaut , two eminent academicians at Paris ; the latter pretending , that the Newtonian law of attraction is inconsistent with the motion of the moon 's apogee ; and that its quantity ought not to be expressed by 1/ x2 of the distance , but by two , or perhaps more , terms of a series , as 1/ x2 + a/ x4 .
Which new doctrine Mr. Clairaut had got inserted in the memoirs of the academy , and Mr. de Buffon had followed him close with another memoir , confuting it .
Read Jan. 31 .
1750 .
When I first heard of this controversy , it was impossible to judge of the validity of Mr. Clairaut 's reasons , because he kept his calculus a profound secret .
But an absurd consequence of his new law of attraction occurred to me , as soon as Mr. de Buffon mentioned the thing , that , ` ` *if we should put the attraction , expressed by his two terms , of an assumed quantity G , and resolve the equation , there would necessarily arise two different values of the distance x , for the same attractive force .
' ' Suspecting therefore , that some error must have slipped into Mr. Clairaut 's reasonings ( as he himself afterwards found there had ) I resolved to try , whether , by an arithmetical calculation , from Sir Isaac Newton 's propositions only , the motion in question might not be accounted for .
The result of this inquiry I should have taken the liberty to send you before now , but that , other things intervening , I did not think of revising and transcribing it , till lately ; that Mr. Walmesley having made me a present of his ingenious treatise on the same subject , it appears , that , however Mr. Clairaut 's hypothesis is given up , yet a notion still prevails , as if Sir Isaac Newton 's propositions , concerning the motion of apsids , were mere mathematical fictions , not applicable to nature .
How far I have succeeded in showing the contrary , is now submitted to your judgment .
And I , at the same time , embrace , with pleasure , an opportunity of professing myself , with the highest respect , Reverend Sir , Sradishall , 6 April , 1750 .
Your most obliged , and most obedient humble servant , Pat .
Murdocke .
Of the mean motion of the moon 's apogee , according to Sir Isaac Newton .
The rule given by Sir Isaac Newton , in the 9 section of his first book , is to this purpose : Tab. Fig. 3 .
1 .
That , supposing the common law of attraction , and that a central body T attracts the body P , revolving round it in an orbit nearly circular , with a force as unity ; if to this be added a constant force , whose ratio to the former is expressed by c ; then the angular velocity of the body P , in an immovable plane , will be to its angular velocity , reckoned from the apsis of its orbit , in the subduplicate ratio of 1+c to 1+ 4c , or as ~1+ c/ 1 + 4c to unity .
And therefore , if A represents any arc described by the revolving body in an immovable plane , A~~1+ 4c/ 1 +c will be the corresponding arc in its orbit , reckoned from the apsis .
And their difference A~~1+ 4c/ 1 +c -1 , will be the gress of the apsis .
But if the force of the central body T is diminished by some constant force as c , then the sign of c is changed in these expressions ; and the direct motion of the apsis will be A~1~1 4c/ 1 c. 2 .
And hence , if some foreign variable force , added to , or substracted from , the central force of attraction , produces a given motion of the apsis , retrograde or direct ; it is easy to find a constant force as c , which should produce the same motion .
3 .
Let S represent the sun , at an immense distance , T the earth ( supposed , for the present , at rest ) P the moon 's place in her orbit ADBC , in which C , D , are the quadratures , A , B , the fyzygies : then if PK , parallel to AB , and cutting TC in K , be produced till KL is double of PK ; and LM parallel to PT meet AB produced in M ; LM and MT will represent the disturbing forces of the sun , by which the moon is urged in the directions PT , MT .
See Princip .
lib. i. prop. 66 .
and lib. iii .
prop. 25 , 26 .
And if TR is made perpendicular to LM , the force MT shall be resolved into two forces as RT and MR ; whereof the latter , MR , taken from LM , reduces the disturbing force , in the direction PT , to their difference LR .
4 .
Put now PT ( =LM)=1 ; PK , the sine of the are PC=s : and then TM ( =PL=3 s ) : MR : : 1 : s ; that is MR=3s2 , an ~ LR , the disturbing force in the direction PT , is as 1-3s2 .
When ~p , the moon 's distance from the quadrature , is an arc of 35~ 15~ 52~ , in which case 1332=0 , l and r coincide ; and the disturbing force vanishing , the line of the apsids becomes stationary .
But if the moon 's distance from her quadrature is still greater , as at ~ , then ~~ exceeds ~~ ; and their difference ~~ is a force represented by 1 3s2 , acting in the direction T ~ .
This force , at the syzygies , is double of TC .
5 .
Whence , and from ~ 1 , it follows ; that c being the sun 's disturbing force , in the direction CT , at the quadrature ; at any other point , as P , it will be ~c~ 1-3s2 .
And that writing for c the variable quantity c~ 1-3s2 , and A for the fluxion of the are CP , the fluent of A~~1+ 4c~1-3s2/ 1 +c~ 1-3s2 will give the motions of the apsis .
6 .
The quantity c being 1000/ 178725 of the earth 's mean attractive force at the moon ; by computing , as above , it will be found , that while the moon moves from C to p , through an arc of 35~ 15~ 52~ , the total regress of the apsis is to the arc Cp as.005404 ( =n ) to unity : and that the sum of its direct motions , while the moon moves from p to A , is to the are pA as.0105707 ( =N ) to unity .
It will be found likewise , by the inverse operation hinted in ~ 2 , that putting k =.00362552 , and K= .0069611 ; +k and -K are forces , which acting constantly , the one from C to p , the other from p to A , would produce the same motions of the apsis .
7 .
The quantities k and K might have been found , pretty near the truth , only by summing the ordinates 1~ R , or 1 3s2 , upon the arc A : in which case we should have had k=c ~.648869 =.00370925 , and K=c~ 1.24018 =.006939 : and the motions thence computed would not have been much different from their just quantity .
This however is mentioned , not as if the method itself were sufficiently exact ; but to show , that if , hereafter , in cases , where the limits of the forces are incomparably narrower , we shall , instead of summing the momenta , make use of a mean force determined in a like manner , there is no sensible error to be apprehended .
8 .
Hitherto we have considered the body T , round which P revolves , as quiescent ; and it is thus authors have always considered it : altho ' the case in nature , to which they meant to apply Sir Isaac Newton 's rule , is widely different .
The earth and moon revolve about their common centre of gravity : their distances from which being inversely as their masses , and the forces , by which either is attracted by the other , as also the forces of the sun to disturb their motions , being in the same ratio ; it follows , that the earth in her motion round the common centre of gravity will suffer disturbances every way similar to those of the moon .
And the whole motion of the apsis of the moon 's orbit , resulting from the two disturbing forces , will be near the double of what either of them could produce separately , round a fixed centre * .
9 .
To * ` ` Quatenus terra et luna circum commune gravitatis centrum revolvuntur , perturbabitur etiam motus terrae circa centrum illud a viribus consimilibus ; sed summas tam virium quam motuum refer licet ad lunam .
' ' Princip .
p. 429 .
And p. 141 .
Apsis lunae est duplo velocior circiter : but this has been strangely mistaken , as if the author having revised and printed his 9th section a third time , and above forty years after it was invented , should , after all , own , that it signified nothing to his purpose .
Would this be the nil molitur inepte , so justly applied to Newton ?
See likewise , p. 423 ; where having deduced the motion of the apsids of Jupiter 's satellites from that of our moon 's , he adds , Diminui tamen debet motus augis sic inventus in ratione 5 ad 9 , vel 1 ad 2 , circiter , ob causam , quam hic exponere non vacat .
' ' The reason is not , that the orbits of Jupiter 's moons are less excentric than that of ours , as some have imagined ; for , ` ` augendo vel diminuendo excentricitatem et inclinationem orbis , non mutatur motus augis sensibiliter , nisi ubi eaedem sunt nimis magnae , ' ' p. 180 .
Is it not rather , because the action of the several satellites upon their primary and upon one another , in all the possible variety of directions , reduces the case of any particular satellite to that of a single body revolving round a fixed centre , viz. that of Jupiter 's system ?
9 .
To determine which , we may conceive the earth as revolving in an orbit that is already in motion from the sun 's disturbing force upon the moon : the retrograde motion of the orbit , while the earth moves from C to p , being n~ Cp ; and the direct motion , for the rest of the quadrant , being N~p A ; whence it will follow , that the disturbing force =k affects the earth 's motion thro ' an arc of her orbit equal to Cp ~1+ n ; and the force K acts thro ' the arc pA ~1+ N. And the motions of the apsis being in the same ratio 's , if r is the regress of the apsis of the moon 's orbit ( determined as in ~ 6 ) and p its progress ; the regress of the apsis of the earth 's orbit will be r~1+ n , and its direct motion , p~1 N. That is , the whole motions of the apsis , resulting from the sun 's action upon the earth and moon together , will be ( R = ) r~2+ n , and ( P = ) p~2 N ; and the motions to be ascribed to either arc , r~1+ 1/ 2n , and p~1 1/ 2N .
Now p , found as above , being 2082~.9 .
and N= .0105707 , P is 4143~.8 .
And the same way , R= 1375~.7 : whose difference PR multiplied by 4 , that is , 4~ 2768~ = 11072~ = 3~ 4~ 32~ , is the direct motion of the apsis in a revolution .
First correction for the moon 's variation .
Fig. 4 .
10 .
In the foregoing calculation , it is supposed , that the moon 's orbit is nearly circular , more nearly indeed than it possibly can be , even abstracting from its excentricity .
For altho ' the moon had been projected with a direction and force to make her describe scribe a circle round the earth , as EOL , the action of the sun would have changed this orbit into an oval , as OADBC ; whose greatest diameter , passing thro ' the quadratures CD , is to the least as 701/ 24 to 691/ 24 .
The reason and determination of which we have in Princip .
lib. iii .
prop. 26 , 28 .
11 .
That this action of the sun , and the figure resulting from it , must lessen the mean motion of the apogee , is easily shown .
For let P be the moon 's place in her orbit , when the apsis is stationary , and EOL the circle of her mean motion , cutting the orbit very near the octant O , and PT in 0 : then , the accelerating forces of the earth at P and 0 , being inversely as the squares of PT and 0T , and the sun 's disturbing force at the points P , 0 , being in the simple direct ratio of the same lines ; 0T being given , the ratio of the sun 's disturbing force at the point P , to the earth 's accelerating force at the same point , that is , the quantity c in the theorem , will be as the cube of the distance PT : and , a fortiori , in every point of the orbit , from the quadrature C to P , will exceed the mean force at O , and its effect in producing a retrograde motion of the apsis will be greater .
For the remaining part of the quadrant , where the motion of the apsis is direct , the force c is indeed greater than its mean quantity from P to O ; but , thro ' the whole octant OA , it is continually decreasing as the cube of the distance from T : whence , upon the whole , that force , and its effect , from P to A , fall short of their mean quantities at O. Seeing therefore the direct motion is diminished , and the retrograde increased ; their difference , that is , the direct rect motion in the quadrant CPA will be diminished .
But this mean motion will be diminished somewhat likewise from the inequable description of the areas ( in prop. 26 .
lib. iii .
) : on which account , the cubes of the distance PT must be every where increased or diminished in the duplicate ratio of the moments of time in which a given little angle is described , to the mean moment at the octant * .
12 .
By computing from these principles , it will be found ; 1 .
That the angle CT P , which was of 35~ 15~ 52~ in the circle , will , in the oval orbit , be diminished to 34~ 43~ 34~ .
2 .
That the ratio of the mean of the cubes of the moon 's distances in the arc C P , to the cube of the mean distance , will expressed by 1.023916 ( =g ) and * To express the distance PT by s the sine of the angle CTP , in an ellipsis not very eccentric : from any point P draw PK an ordinate to the axis CD , and meeting the circumscribed circle in M ; draw likewise Mf perpendicular to TP produced .
Then putting TC=1 , TA=d , 1 d/ d = t ; by conjoining the ratio 's of TP to PK , PK to PM , PM to Pf , it will be TP = Tf/ 1+ts2 : in which for the variable numerator Tf , we might , because of the smallness of the angle PTM , write unity : but taking it rather of its mean quantity m ( =.999987 in the moon 's orbit ) the distances , whose cubes are to be summed , will be m/ 1+ts2 ~ And the ratio of the moments of time to the mean moment is that of 110.23 to 109.73+s2 , by prop. 26 .
lib. iii .
and the like ratio , in the arc PA , by.9852467 ( =h ) .
3 .
Multiplying therefore the forces k and -K , found in ~ 6 , by g and by h , substituting the products for c , in the formula , with the arcs CN , and NG , respectively , and finishing the operation as for the circle , the regress , in a periodical month , will be 5548~.3 , and the progress 16489~.8 : whose difference is the driect mean motion sought , 3~ 21~ 2~1/ 2 .
13 .
But nearly the same conclusion may be obtained , and with much less trouble , as follows : In the circle CGD ; take CM = 35~ 15~ 52~ , and thro ' P , the point where MK perpendicular to TC , cuts the orbit , draw TPN meeting the circle in N. Then , if R is the regress of the apsis in a circular orbit , R~ CM/ CN 1/ 2 will be the regress in the oval CP A. In like manner , having inscribed in the orbit , the circle Amh , and made a similar construction for the rest of the quadrant P~ Am/ Ah 1/ 2 , will be the direct motion in the oval , P being the direct motion in a circle .
Thus , the angle of variation MTN being ( in Dr. Halley 's tables ) 33~ 9~ , the subduplicate ratio of CM to CN will be 1.007927 , and that of Am to Ah , or of GM to GN , will be.99499 .
And therefore R ( in ~ 9 ) will be augmented to 1386~.6 , and P diminished to 4123~ : whose difference , multiplied by 4 , gives 3~ 2~ 25~ 2/ 5 ; exceeding the former only by about 4~ .
14 .
The rule is founded in this , that if , from the centre T , a circular arc Ff be described , including in the angle CTN the sector FTf , equal to the elliptic sector CTP , the cube of TF , the radius of this circle , may be taken for the mean of the cubes of the moon 's distances in the arc CP .
And because the area CPT is to the sector CMT , as PK to KM , or as TA to TC ; and T0 or TE is a geometrical mean between TA and TC , it will easily appear , that TF3 : T 03 : : CM3/ 2 : CN3/ 2 .
And that P , found from the tables , being ( nearly at least ) the stationary point in the oval , if the force k is increased in the sesquiplicate ratio of CM to CN , and the arc CN substituted sor A in the formula , we shall , by ~ 1 , find the retrograde motion of the apsis .
Now , when the constant force +k is given , the regress R is as the arc A ; and when A is given , and k is but a little augmented , R is proportional to k : in general therefore , if k is but a little augmented , R is as k~ A. Write Q for the regress in the oval , R standing for that in the circle , already found ; and it will be Q : R : : k~ CM/ CN 3/ 2 ~ CN : k~ CM , or Q=R~ CM/ CN 1/ 2 , according to the rule .
The like reasoning for the direct motion .
Second correction for the Excentricity .
Fig. 5 .
15 .
This equation is inconsiderable ; because , altho ' the ratio of the disturbing force , when the moon is at a greater than her mean distance , is more increased than it is diminished in the opposite points of her orbit ; this increase is very near compensated by the comparative smallness of the angular velocity .
Let ADa represent the moon 's elliptic orbit , whose centre is C , its axes Aa , Dd , the mean excentricity CT , and the circle of her mean motion M Dmd , cutting Aa in M and m. Then , because it is a mean motion we seek , generated while the axis Aa passes thro ' all its different aspects of the sun ; we may conceive the direct motion already found , of 3~ 2~ 21~1/ 2 , to be produced by a constant disturbing force K , acting on the moon as she revolves in her circular orbit M Dmd ; and we have only to enquire , how much this force , and its effects , are to be increased , the moon really moving about the same centre T , in the elliptic arc AD ; and how much diminished in the arc D a. 16 .
For which purpose , the constant force K is to be increased in the ratio of the mean of the cubes of the moon 's distances , in the arc AD , to the cube of TD or CA , and diminished as the mean of the cubes of the distances in Da .
Let the forces resulting be K~G and K~ H ; and these being substituted in the formula , with the arcs 2 DM , 2 Dm , respectively , the sum of the motions found will be the whole mean motion of the apogee , including the correction for the excentricity .
Now K will be found to be.00557337 , and the excentricity TC being.05505 , and Q the quadrantal arc to radius 1 ; the ratio G , or , which is the same , the sesquiplicate of the time , in which the elliptic arc AD is described , to the time in the circular arc DM , that is , Q+TC/ DM3/ 2 will be 1.110942 ; and H ( =Q-TC/ DM3/ 2 =.9001387 : whence the whole motion , found as above directed , will be 10962~ = 3~ 2~ 42~ ; the correction , on account of the excentricity , being only 21~ .
Multiply 3~ 2~ 42~ by 1.080853 , and the product 3~ 17~ 28~ is the mean motion of the apogee , in a synodical month ; exceeding the quantity marked in the tables by no more than 4~ .
17 .
Of the obliquity of the moon 's orbit , to the plane of the ecliptic , we take no notice : because , altho ' , absolutely speaking , a force in that plane , referred to the moon 's orbit , would , thence , be diminished by about 3/ 1000 parts ; yet , in the present case , the effect of the obliquity is included in the first determination of the quantity c , from the periodical times of the earth and moon ; all but what belongs to the corrections ; and which is only 110~.~003=0~.33 , to be subtracted .
18 .
The force c is , itself , the effect of the sun 's parallax , and the total effect ; excepting only a small difference between his action on the moon , when she is waxing or waning , and when she is in the other half of her orbit ; neglected as altogether inconsiderable .
Upon the whole , we may conclude , that , in this , as in the other phenomenon of the celestial motions , the principles and rules of Sir Isaac Newton are fully confirmed and verified .

