CXVI .
An Account of a Treatise , in Latin , presented and dedicated to the Royal Society , entitled , ` ` Gottlob Caroli Springsfeld , M. D. &amp;c. &amp;c. commentatio de prerogativa Thermarum Carolinarum in dissolvendo calculo vesicae prae aqua calcis vivae , ' ' by William Watson , Member of the Royal Academy of Physicians at Madrid , and F. R. S. DR. Springsfeld 's Treatise , which he lately communicated to the Royal Society , contains a series of experiments and observations upon the Carlsbad waters in Bohemia , as a solvent for the stone in the bladder ; from whence it appears , that these waters have that property in a much higher degree than even lime-water .
The Carlsbad waters have been long celebrated for their excellent effects in removing , or at least relieving , many of the disorders to which mankind is subject .
How high they stood in the opinion of the great Hoffman almost every part of his writings bears testimony ; and if to their other before-known properties they should prove a safe , easy , and effectual solvent for the stone in the kidneys and bladder , it certainly would greatly enhance their value .
Read Dec. 23 , 1756 .
Our author has very attentively considered the writings of Doctors Jurin , Hales , Hartley , Whytt , and others , concerning solvents for the stone .
He has administred to several patients , with little or no success , the late Mrs. Stephens 's medicine , with the strictest observance of all the cautions , said to be necessary in courses of that medicine .
And , though he allows every thing to be true that has been laid down by Dr. Whytt and others in relation to oystershell lime-water , he does not scruple to assert , that the Carlsbad waters , which , as will hereafter appear , have great analogy to calcarious waters , are a far more excellent solvent for the stone in the kidneys and bladder than any lime-water .
Of this truth he is satisfied by various experiments , several of which were made by himself alone , and others in conjunction with our learned and ingenious brother Dr. Lieberkuhn , whose exactness as well as fidelity in making experiments of this kind no one will question .
Dr. Springsfeld , in a treatise upon the Carlsbad waters , published by him in the year 1749 , has shown by undoubted experiments , that these waters partake always of an alcaline principle ; for every pint of them , besides the neutral purging salt , contains three grains of alcaline salt , and ten grains of calcarious earth ; for which reason they ferment with every species of acids .
I before mentioned , that these waters have great analogy with lime-water ; and if they continue in the baths for any considerable time , they not only turn milky , like lime-water , but have a pellicle upon them as that water is observed to have .
They have likewise a gently constringing taste ; that was it not for their saline taste they could not easily be distinguished from lime-water .
It must here be premised , that all hard bodies , viz. pieces of wood , bone , stones , earthen vessels , bits of straw , and such-like , are encrusted over by lying in the Carlsbad waters , and that in a very little time .
These bodies in the space of a night will be covered with a tophaceous crust , which continually increases .
But human calculi , though hard in themselves , are not encrusted thereby ; but are rather dissolved ; which is the more remarkable .
The same effects are observed upon pieces of the hardest cheese , which swell in these waters , and are changed into a kind of pultice .
In the treatise before us our author has given the detail of many experiments , which prove the solvent power of these waters .
I shall lay a few of them only before you , from which an opinion both of our author 's exactness in making them , as well as how far he is justified in his conclusions , may be formed .
And here I must observe , which should be a very comfortable consideration for the inhabitants in these parts , that our author has been obliged frequently to suspend his researches for want of human calculi , which is a disease exceedingly rare in Bohemia .
June 20 , 1749 .
A stone of a brown colour , which weighed near two ounces and half , was placed in a china bason near that source , which is called Brudel , in such a manner as to be continually covered with the warm water .
Upon the next day the external crust began to grow soft ; upon the third , you might make an impression thereupon with your nail as upon cheese ; upon the fourth and fifth , it was difsolved to the nucleus ; upon the sixth , the nucleus itself was dissolved , and in the bottom of the bason there was left a white viscid mass , like pultice , or newly steeped cheese : this was impalpable between the singers .
In this time the bason was encrusted with a very hard tophaceous mass , of the thickness of a quill .
Certain calculi , not bigger than peas , were dissolved thoroughly , some in one day and the rest in two .
1750 .
June 12 .
A stone , weighing more than half an ounce , was placed in the same manner as the former , and not a grain of it remained on the fourth day .
At this time a clergyman , who was in a course of these waters for gouty complaints , voided six stones , which all were dissolved in the same manner .
A nobleman , who was afflicted with bloody urine , from calculi in the kidneys , came to Carlsbad for the relief of his complaints ; and brought with him some small calculi , which he had voided a few years before .
By Dr. Lieberkuhn 's advice Dr. Springsfeld divided these calculi into four equal parts , each of which weighed six grains .
One part of these was infused in the water of the source called Brudel ; the second , in the New Spring ; the third , in that near the mill .
In twelve hours the first part had lost five grains ; the second , four ; and the third , only one grain .
The fourth portion was put upon a linen rag , which was stretched over the bottom of a funnel .
Into this funnel the nobleman was directed to make water every day before dinner , after his having drank his quantity of Carlsbad water .
Upon this , these calculi , after eight days , had lost two-thirds of their weight ; viz. four grains .
It must be here remarked , that this nobleman , during the regimen , did void several small calculi , which he had not done for some years .
A larger quantity of bloody urine than usual attended the parting with these stones ; but but this continued only two or three days , and afterwards went quite off ; and this nobleman from that time was relieved from his former complaints , has enjoyed and does yet enjoy the most perfect health .
In the year 1754 , our author became possessed of a calculus , which was of a flinty hardness , and bore a bright polish .
It weighed a quarter of an ounce .
He conjectured , that a much longer time would be necessary to dissolve this stone ; but what was very remarkable it dissolved sooner than the rest : for after having been immersed twenty-four hours , two grains of it only remained undissolved .
This stone was not placed in the china bason as the others were , but suspended in a little loose-woven net , that it might more freely be washed by the water .
Dr. Lieberkuhn was at this time at Carlsbad ; he was present at this experiment , and was witness of its truth .
The net used in this experiment was covered with a tophaceous crust , from being steeped in the water .
The next year , when Dr. Lieberkuhn returned to Carlsbad , he brought with him , for experiment-sake , several calculi , some of which were large ones .
He made there many experiments , in which our author assisted .
A large stone was sawed into four pieces nearly equal .
One of these , weighing 99 grains , was put into a little linen bag , and immersed in the source called Brudel : the second , in like manner , which weighed 96 grains , into that called the New Spring : the third , weighing 93 grains , into that near the mill : the fourth was set apart for other trials .
After four days immersion they were severally examined .
The first had lost 85 grains ; the second , thirty-three grains ; the third , only 16 grains .
That it might be estimated in what degree the solvent power of the Carlsbad water did exceed that of limewater , the following experiment was tried .
Three pieces of calculi , each exactly thirty grains in weight , were put into separate phials .
Upon one was poured some fresh egg-shell lime-water : upon the second , some Carlsbad water : upon the third , some of the urine of a person daily drinking these waters for the recovery of his health .
These phials were all placed in one of the canals , which carries off the waste water from the baths : the degree of heat in this place was by Fahrenheit 's thermometer 96 , much the same as the heat of human blood .
The limewater , the Carlsbad water , and the urine , were changed every day , and the process continued for fourteen days .
Upon the fifteenth , the remaining fragments of stone were taken out of the phials , and weighed when dried .
The piece macerated in limewater had lost one grain : that in the Carlsbad water , six grains : that in the urine , five grains .
According therefore to this experiment the solvent power of the Carlsbad water was six times , that of the urine five times greater than that of the lime-water .
The solvent power of medicated urine is of very great importance , and requires more particular attention ; as our greatest expectations in dissolving the stone in the bladder must arise from that .
It was therefore very fit that our author should investigate , as far as was in his power , the solvent property of the urine of those who drank these waters .
He therefore suspended to the end of a funnel a sufficiently hard and compact calculus , weighing about an ounce .
This was contained in a linen rag , so that the urine might readily pass over it ; and a person , who used the Carlsbad waters every morning , after having taken them , constantly made water into that funnel ; from whence it came to pass , that on the sixteenth day the stone was half dissolved , and the remaining part was become so porous and friable , that it almost fell to pieces .
No one can suppose that the urine of a man perfectly in health would have the same solvent property ; lest however that should happen , our author suspended a piece of a calculus , weighing two drams , in the same manner with the preceeding , and made water upon it himself many times a day : but this piece of calculus , after twelve days , was so far from being lessened , that it had increased two grains in weight .
Our author , lest he should be thought to have depended too much upon one set of experiments , made others .
Among several calculi , which Dr. Lieberkuhn had communicated to him , there was one exceedingly hard .
This he cut into four parts , each weighing exactly eighty grains .
Each of these was put into a separate phial .
Upon the first was poured fresh oyster-shell lime-water : upon the second , Carlsbad water : upon the third , the urine of one who drank these waters : upon the fourth , the urine of one perfectly in health , and who only drank for his breakfast some cups of tea .
These phials were placed in the same manner with those before-mentioned , and their heat kept constantly the same .
Everyday these calculi had fresh liquid poured upon them after the old was separated .
At the end of twenty days these stones were dried and weighed .
The fragment inVOL .
49 .
5Y fused fused in oyster-shell lime-water was found to have lost almost three grains : that in Carlsbad water twenty-two grains : that in medicated urine fourteen grains : but that infused in the urine of the man in health had increased three grains .
These experiments therefore leave no room to doubt of , either the solvent power of the Carlsbad water itself , or that of the urine of those who drink these waters .
Our author has a very curious remark in relation to a person who laboured under the stone , and who drank these waters for two months .
He daily voided with his urine a large quantity of white viscid mucus ; which , after filtration of the aqueous parts from it , was found to be a white earthy powder , rubbed off as it were from a stone .
The quantity of this powder saved during the space of a month amounted to more than three ounces .
If some of this powder was put into the urine of one who drank Carlsbad water , it was immediately converted into a pultaceous substance ; but if into that of one , who did not drink this water , it fell quite undissolved to the bottom of the vessel .
Dr. Springsfeld observes , that the Carlsbad water has great power in dissolving the tophaceous crust , which frequently covers the teeth .
During the course of these waters , this crust most generally separates from the teeth , and falls off .
However great the power of these waters are in dissolving the stone in the bladder , they have a quite contrary effect upon gall stones .
So far from dissolving these last , our author has frequently found that these waters envelope them with their tophaceous crust .
Our ingenious brother Dr. Whytt has observed , that lime-water has no solvent power upon gall stones .
Hence we draw another proof of the analogy of lime-water with Carlsbad water .
If it should be woundered at , how it comes to pass that the urine of those who drink these waters should have the power of dissolving the stone , it is necessary to inform our readers , that this urine contains nearly the same properties which the water originally had .
It has before been observed , that these waters are impregnated with an alcaline principle , and consequently ferment with acids .
The urine of those who drink them , if made before dinner , has the very same quality as our author has frequently experienced ; especially if the accustomed quantity of water is taken , and nothing else is drank upon them .
The customary dose at Carlsbad is not less than six , seven , or eight pints of water taken every morning : for which reason we are not to wonder that the urine has the property of dissolving the stone in the kidneys and bladder , if it is long retained .
And our author makes no scruple , but that the injection of these waters into the bladder would be very powerful in relieving calculous complaints ; though this he had never tried ; neither was he much induced thereto , as the urine is possessed of all the powers which he was in search of .
It remains that we just take notice , by what means these waters are possessed of their solvent power .
It is well known , that acids , more especially mineral ones , do dissolve animal calculi , by acting upon their terrestrial parts , dividing their masses , and becoming neutral thereby .
These effects do not arise from alcalies , as they leave terrestrial substances untouched .
If sometimes we carefully attend to the operations of nature , we now and then make discoveries which must otherwise have escaped us .
If we pour nitrous or vitriolic acid upon that stony substance , which is usually called crabs-eyes , and let them remain in the glass for a considerable time perfectly still , we shall find at the bottom of the vessel , after the terrestrial parts are thoroughly dissolved , a membranous substance or jelly , exactly in size and figure resembling the crabs-eyes , and which the acid had left untouched .
Exactly such a gelatinous mass our author has observed in stones of the bladder , more particularly in small ones , after dissolving them in acids .
If crabs-eyes are infused in an alcaline lixivium for a considerable time , we see no change in them , which can be properly called a solution : about them we observe a certain viscid appearance like a cloud ; if that is taken away , and the crabs-eyes are dried , and afterwards weighed , they have not only lost part of their weight , but are become much more friable ; which is a great argument that they have lost something .
If afterwards these crabs-eyes are washed with warm water , to carry off the alcaline matter adhering to them , and afterwards set to dissolve in acids , these crabs-eyes , after the solution of their terrestrial parts , leave nothing gelatinous behind them , as they did in the other experiment ; from whence it is plain , that the gelatinous substance had been extracted and dissolved by the alcaline lixivium .
The very same thing happens to the human calculus .
It appears therefore more than probable to our author , that lime-water and Carlsbad waters , on account of their alike partaking of the alcaline and calcarious principle , do dissolve the before-mentioned animal gluten only , by which the terrestrial parts are united together ; and upon the solution of which these parts must separate and fall asunder .
From hence may be accounted for also the origin of that white viscid matter , which adheres to the bottom of the vessel like pultice , after the dissolution of calculi in the Carlsbad waters ; and which is nothing more than the terrestrial parts of the stone deprived of the animal gluten , which makes them adhere together .
Hence we see the reason why our predecessors adopted two sorts of lithontriptic remedies , and those of quite opposite properties .
Basil Valentine , Paracelsus , Helmont , and others , administered alcalies : Sylvius , Laurembergius , and Dippelius , acids .
By these last they attempted to dissolve the terrestrial parts ; by the former , the connecting gluten .
But the case in gall stones is different : their connecting gluten , which unites the bilious parts , is not an animal jelly , as in the calculus vesicae , but a fat inflamable oil , which is neither dissoluble by the Carlsbad waters nor by lime-water .
Our author conjectures that he has proved demonstratively , that the solvent power of the Carlsbad waters does exceed that of lime-water ; besides which it has this advantage , that it is not in the least nauseous , and may be continued , if necessary , for six or eight months , without any other inconvenience than that of drinking them upon the spot ; which may indeed oblige persons whose dwellings are remote from Carlsbad to take a journey thither ; whereas lime-water may be drank at home .
I have been the more copious in my account of the work before us , as the subject of it is very interesting ; one , in which some of our brethren have remarkably distinguished themselves , which occasioned Dr. Springsfeld to dedicate his performance to this learned Society .
The experiments in his work , of which there are many , are well devised , and to appearance carefully executed .
He has not attempted to amuse us with vain and fruitless speculations ; but , on the contrary , has nobly turned his thoughts towards obviating the distresses , and relieving the miseries , to which human life is unhappily subject .
W. Watson .
END of VO L. XLIX .

