CXIII .
A Letter to George Lewis Scot , Esquire , concerning the present Increase of the People in Britain and Ireland : From William Brakenridge , D. D. Rector of St. Michael Bassishaw , London , and F. R. S. Dear Sir , YOUR favourable acceptance of my two former letters , concerning the number of people in this city , and throughout England , has encouraged me to add this as a supplement to them ; in which if the observations are not so agreeable as could be wished , they may perhaps be useful in our reasoning upon matters of Government , and help us to discover some things that may be wrong , or inconsistent with the public utility .
From the proportion of births and burials in England , and the number of people found , you have already seen what the annual increase might be ; which appeared so small , that I was in some doubt whether there was any increase at all , after the deduction of our losses by our ordinary commerce at Sea , our wars , and emigrations to our Colonies .
However , supposing , that there was an annual increase , I showed the method of computing it , after any number of years ; which sometimes may be of use in conside ing the increase of mankind in general .
But now , having considered this subject farther , I think it may be proved , that there is no increase at VOL. 49 .
5T all Read Dec. 9 .
all from both our British Isles , after the deduction of our losses ; and that in England , taken by itself , the natives would be in a decreasing state , if it were not for the supplies from Scotland and Ireland .
As this seems to be of some importance to discover , because of its consequence with regard to Policy , and the influence it may sometimes have , I shall endeavour to show it as plainly , as the present circumstances of things will allow .
Dr. Halley has shown , from his Table of the Probabilities of life at Breslau , that the number of men able to carry arms in any country , between 18 and 56 years of age , or , as they are called , the fencible men , may be estimated as a fourth part of the whole people , children included .
From which it demonstrably follows , that the fourth part of the annual increase will likewise be the increase of the fencible men ; and that their increase or decrease will always be in that proportion .
And therefore , if in England the annual increase of the people does not exceed 18000 , as I have before proved from the proportion of births and burials , and the whole number being six millions , the annual increase of the fencible men will not be above 4500 .
But in Scotland and Ireland this increase may be reasonably supposed to be more , in proportion as there are more marriages than in England .
And therefore , to avoid any uncertainty in calculation , we will suppose the annual increase in those countries , to be double in proportion .
That is , as we have from observation , assumed the births to be to the burials as 112 to 100 at an average through England , we will now allow them in Scotland and Ireland to be as 124 to 100 ; where the difference , which is the increase , is double to the other , and by which the whole people would be doubled in about 114 years ; which is surely as much as can be supposed .
And then , by the method that has been shown in my last letter , if the people in both countries do not exceed 2,500,000 , the annual increase will be found to be 15,000 , and the fencible men will be 3750 .
From the account given in the Philosophical Transactions , No. 261 , the number of people in Ireland , in the year 1696 , did not appear to be more than 1,034,000 ; since which time there has been little increase , as I shall presently show ; and in Scotland they are supposed to be less than 1,500,000 ; and so both together they cannot be reckoned at more than 2,500,000 : and therefore the annual increase of the fencible men cannot possibly be more than 3750 , in both countries ; which with those in England will be 8250 , for the annual increase in Britain and Ireland , or a little above 8000 men .
And no reasonable computation can make them more .
It is true it may be said , that besides this increase , there is a considerable number of Foreigners , who come from all parts of Europe to settle among us , especially at London ; but it may be justly supposed , that they are nearly balanced by the number that go from hence , to reside in other kingdoms , for the purposes of trade and other considerations .
And there cannot be so great an accession of Foreigners , as is commonly imagined ; for they almost all come to this City , and yet it is not in an increasing state , as has been shown in my first letter , notwithstanding 5T2 all all its supplies from them , and from Scotland and Ireland .
The number then 8250 may be considered , at the utmost , as the yearly increase of the fencible men ; from which all our public losses in our ordinary commerce at Sea , and in our wars by Land and Sea , and by our Colonies , are to be deducted .
And it is plain , if in all these ways our losses are annually equal to about 8000 men , there can be no increase at all of our fencible men ; and consequently no increase of our people , which must always be in proportion to them ; but if our losses are more , we must be in a decreasing state .
To make a just and moderate estimate of our losses it will be proper , that we take fifty or sixty years at an average to avoid any uncertainty .
And if we begin at the year 1690 , which is 66 years ago , we shall find , that during that time , in our commerce at Sea , and in our wars by Land and Sea , we cannot have lost less than 450,000 men .
To show this it may be observed , that in all bodies or armies of fencible men , which consist generally of those between 18 and 56 years of age , there dies annually about one in 54 , by the natural decrease of life , as appears from Dr. Halley 's Table .
And therefore , if there are 80000 seamen or more , as is said in Britain and Ireland , the natural decrease , which is not here to be considered , will be about 1480 or 1500 annually .
But the number must be much greater that is lost , by the various contingencies of the Sea , by wreck , scurvy , and the inclemency of different climates , &amp;c. ; for fewer cannot be supposed to be destroyed by such incidents , than the double of those that may be by natural mortality .
I think there must be more ; for if a ship goes a voyage for a year with an hundred men on board , and returns only with the loss of half a dozen , she is reckoned to have made a healthy voyage , though the loss is above three times what might be expected from natural decrease ; that is , though the loss by the Sea only may be considered as double the other .
And it often happens , that by sickness there will be much more than this , besides all the other hazards of the Sea .
Our ships of war in long cruising have generally a greater consumption of their people : So that our losses by Sea are rather undervalued , when they are estimated to be the double , of what is from the natural decrements of life And , if this be allowed , the loss by the various contingencies of the Sea will be more than 3000 annually , over and above the number that might die by natural casualties if they were at home ; and in 66 years it must be 198,000 .
And as to our losses by war at Land and Sea , of our own people , they are commonly reckoned to be 300,000 , in all the three French wars , since 1690 : But if we abate 50,000 from that number , that we may reason with more certainty , they cannot possibly be less than 250,000 ; for in all those wars , that taken together were about twenty years , there must be more than 10,000 lost yearly by Land and Sea .
And therefore , both by our commerce and wars , from that time mentioned , we have at least lost about 448,000 , or 6800 annually .
In which are included those who died by fatigue , and other hardships , as well as those in actual Engagements .
And if we add to this , the number that is constantly and secretly drawn from Ireland , for foreign military service and on the account of religion ; and likewise those taken from Scotland , for our Regiments in the Dutch service ; all which cannot be less than 500 yearly , though some have thought it to be double this , we shall then appear to have lost 7300 annually , since the year 1690 .
To which if we put the loss of those who go from hence to our Colonies , and other settlements , particularly to Jamaica and the East-Indies ; and , last of all , the number we have lost by the use of spirituous liquors ; it will be plain , that our whole loss cannot be less but more than 8250 annually ; which is at most the yearly increase of our fencible men : And therefore that there has been no increase at all of our people these last 66 years ; but rather perhaps a decrease , though it cannot be ascertained with any precision .
And there is no avoiding this conclusion , unless it can be shown , that the annual increment of our fencible men is much greater than 8250 ; which seems impossible , without proving the number of our people to be more than six millions , and the proportion of births to burials greater than any observations through England have lately made them .
And here it is to be observed , that if there has been no increase during that period of years , the people of England cannot be more than 5,500,000 .
Because , when they are computed from the number of houses at the year 1710 , they do not exceed 5,467,000 ; and when in my last letter , I supposed there might be some increase , and gave a calculation of it to the present time , that , being added to the above , made only about six millions .
And therefore the annual increase of fencible men in England is not above 4130 , and in both Islands it does not exceed 7900 ; which being less than what we have allowed above , seems to corroborate what has been said .
Now if this can be proved , as I imagine it has , that there is no increase of our people in Britain and Ireland , because of our losses , we may make this unpleasant reflection , that our country can never be fully peopled , while our losses continue so great as they have been these last sixty years .
For it has been shown in my last letter , that we want one third more people , to be fully inhabited , and which we could conveniently maintain from our own natural produce , if our land was duly cultivated .
And it may be farther observed , that as the greatest part of those losses above-mentioned belong to England , because of its much greater trade , and the greater number of its people , it may be considered as in a decreasing state with regard to its natives ; and , if it were not supplied from Scotland and Ireland , the decrease would be plainly discovered .
For , as the people in England are double to those in both the two other countries , its losses must be in that proportion at least , or about 5300 annually , two-thirds of the whole ; which is more than the increase of its fencible men .
In London and Westminster the decrease has been observable from the Bills of Mortality within these last twelve years , as I have shown in my first letter ; but the greatest part of that may , I believe , be attributed to other causes , rather than national losses .
From the above calculation we may likewise see , how small the annual increase of fencible men may be in Britain , or perhaps in any other country in Europe .
For as that increase in both our Islands does not appear to be more than 8250 but rather less , or about 7900 , and the number of our whole people in them is not found to exceed 8,000,000 , the annual increase in each million must be less than 1000 , or about 987 ; that is , less than one in a thousand ; though we have allowed the increase in Scotland and Ireland to be double in proportion to what it is in England .
And from this we may form a good rule , by which we may judge of the increase , or decrease of other nations .
For though they may be supposed to increase perhaps faster than we do , by more frequent marriages , the annual increase of their fencible men will not generally much exceed 1000 , for every million of people .
And therefore , according as their losses by war , or other devastations are fewer , or exceed 1000 fencible men annually , for every million of their people , they are either in an increasing or decreasing state ; and for every 1000 men that are lost , there is the increase of a million for one year destroyed ; which it were to be wished , that Princes would attend to , in their ambitious schemes , by which they make such havoc of mankind .
And hence by the way we may observe , that France cannot be in an increasing state , unless their late encouragement for marriage has had some considerable effect ; because if the number of her people , as Sir William Petty and others have reckoned , does not exceed 14,000,000 , the annual increase of her fencible men will not be much more than 14,000 : Which number seems to be exhausted during these last 66 years , in her frequent wars , her ordinary commerce at Sea , and emigrations to her Colonies .
For all the annual increments put together , in that time , will not make above a million , and the losses cannot be computed at much less .
And this is some comfort to us in Britain , that our neighbours , who are rivals to us in trade and power , are not better aeconomists of their people than we are ; and that their scheme of Government and superstition will never suffer them to increase , so much as they might reasonably do .
We may in general likewise observe , that in all Europe the annual increase of people must be much less than it was in some former ages .
For the advancement of trade in the maritime countries , must greatly augment the loss of their fencible men .
In Britain there is one-third of the increase of them destroyed by our concerns at Sea , and in Holland perhaps the whole of it ; and this added to the superstitious celibacy of other nations , must diminish much the increase of people .
The above method of showing our want of increase , from the losses of our fencible men ; which are always in proportion to the whole body of the people , seems to me to be clear and demonstrative : But the same thing may likewise be conjectured , from the exportation of our corn .
For there is as much now sent abroad as was forty years ago , or perhaps more ; besides a great deal of it distilled , which was not formerly done .
And if there is the same quantity exported , there must be nearly the same conVOL .
49 .
5U sumption sumption at home , and consequently about the same number of people , unless there is a much greater quantity of land improved .
But it seems evident , that if we were in an increasing state , our late improvements of land could not cause such a surplus , over our home-consumption .
For there is near about a fifth part , of our whole crop of wheat exported annually .
A quantity that shows we want people to consume our natural produce , and that our country is but thinly peopled .
Now , to account for the cause of the want of increase in our British Isles , it seems to be chiefly owing to three things , that operate together .
The fashionable humour that greatly prevails , by which above one-third of our people in England above twenty-one years of age are single , occasioned by a variety of circumstances ; and to our wars and commerce at Sea , which are rather beyond our natural strength , by destroying more of our people than can well be spared , and which , if preserved , might improve our country , and augment our power ; and lastly , to the use of spirituous liquors , by which numbers have been and are daily lost .
But there may be easy remedies for two of those evils , by a little attention of the Legislature ; which would greatly conduce to the public happiness .
And thus , Sir , I have wrote this third Letter to you , upon a very uncommon subject : but I hope the importance of it will plead my excuse .
And if I have discovered any thing that has not been known , and that may be useful in our speculations upon Government , I shall think my time and pains have not been misapplied ; but if I have been mistaken , your usual goodness will , I trust , forgive Your most affectionate and faithful servant , Sion College , Nov. 25 , 1756 .
Wm. Brakenridge .
P.S. Since the above was written , I have been certainly informed , that from the survey lately made of the window lights , after the year 1750 , there are about 690,000 houses charged to that Tax in England and Wales , besides cottages that pay nothing .
And though the number of cottages is not accurately known , it appears from the accounts given in , that they cannot amount to above 200,000 .
And therefore there are not in England and Wales more than 890,000 houses , or 5,340,000 people , allowing six to a house ; which well agrees with what I have said in this and my former letter , and corroborates the whole of my reasoning .
For if the survey made before the year 1710 was near the truth , from which it appeared , that there was not above 729,048 houses , besides cottages , or 929,048 houses in the whole ; which will make about 5,570,000 people ; then there must have been no increment since that time , but rather a decrease , notwithstanding the continual supplies from Scotland and Ireland , and from Foreigners .
I beg leave likewise to mention , that I find some people have objected to the Bills of Mor5 U2 tality , tality , from which I computed our numbers in London and Westminster , in my first Letter ; That they are too uncertain to found any calculations upon ; that sometimes in the weekly Bills there are omissions of some of the largest Parishes , and perhaps in the yearly Bills .
To which it is answered .
If there are omissions sometimes in the weekly Bills , these are afterwards supplied in the subsequent weeks , and at the end of the year the whole account to each parish is made up , as accurately as the circumstances will allow ; so that upon the whole it is presumed , the yearly Bills are done in such manner , that they may be depended upon ; for otherwise they would be a vile imposition upon the Public .
And if they are properly taken care of , they may be considered as the index of the health and numbers of the people , as they are in other cities in Europe ; in which view they have always had some credit , for a century past , and been attended to as of some importance ; and many ingenious men have deduced useful speculations from them .
But if it should be allowed , that there are inaccuracies in them , it cannot reasonably be supposed , that there are more now than ever have been ; for there is as much care taken of them lately as ever .
The argument then from which I inferred , that there is a decrease of the inhabitants within the Bills is this ; That , before the year 1743 , for twenty years , the burials in them were at an average above 27,000 , and the baptisms between 15,000 and 17,000 ; but since that time they are both gradually decreased ; so that now the burials are about 22,000 , and the baptisms between 14,000 and 15,000 , taken at an average for ten years : And therefore these different numbers , continued so long , cannot come from the same number of people ; but that as the burials and baptisms are both decreased , the whole people must be also diminished .
This seems be fair reasoning , if the Bills are true .
The times were as healthy before the year 1743 , as ever since ; there were as many burials carried out into the country before that time as afterwards ; and there were as many D'ssenters to lessen the number of burials and baptisms before that time as ever after .
What then is to be concluded , the circumstances being the same , but that there must be a diminution of the people ?
And this may be imperceptibly made ; either by the increase of celibacy , or by fewer coming annually to reside in Town than formerly , and more retiring from it ; which last case I consider rather as an advantage to the kingdom , as it may tend to the improvement of the country .
It is true , we do not see so great an increase of empty houses , that may answer to the decrease in the Bills ; but it may be easily imagined , that some hundreds of families may be diminished , and not one house left empty .
The one half of our people consist of Lodgers , Inmates , and Children ; and therefore there may be a great decrease of these , and yet not many more houses empty : Though it is also to be considered , that there are much sewer houses now within the Liberties of the city , than were before 1743 ; many being built in place of two or three , or more , and warehouses houses made of others .
I know some Parishes , in which they have lost one tenth of their number , by this means , since that time ; so that within the walls I find there is above double the number lost , that I mentioned in my Letter .
To~ live in large houses is now a part of our luxury .
But if there be an increase of houses in Padington , Mary le bone , &amp;c. without the Bills of Mortality , this does not affect my argument ; which was only to show , that there was a decrease of the people within them ; and surely such a small increment is not to be compared to the probable decrease on the whole .
In that first Letter I reasoned , and made my calculation , upon the same principles with Sir William Petty , Mr. Grant , and other approved Authors .
From a continued increase in the Bills they inferred , that there must be a proportional increase of inhabitants ; and I from the continued decrease in them , in the same circumstances , have endeavoured to prove a similar decrease of people .
If their reasoning is just , mine cannot be false ; and if the Bills never again appear so high , as formerly for a continuance , in healthy times , it will be a demonstration .

