An Account of the Orthoceratites : In a Letter from Edward Wright , M. D. to Mr. Peter Collinson , F. R. S. SIR , IHAD the honour of sending you some time ago a drawing and short account of a very large Orthoceratites , which I hope you have received .
As you are so good to accept favourably my poor observations , and to honour me with your correspondence , I here take the liberty to send you a few remarks , which the consideration of this and other fossils , and of the strata of the surface of the earth , naturally lead me to .
If I am obliged to differ from Mons. de Buffon , and other modern theorists , it is only for the sake of truth , and its unalterable laws ; it being quite contrary to my inclina5 tion Read June 17 , tion to criticize the works of others , especially those of so learned a gentleman , as the above-mentioned academician , for whose merit and talents I have a particular respect , except where the clearest conviction , in opposition to his opinions , forces me to so disagreeable a task .
I. The Orthoceratites is one of those shells , which are never found in the recent state , and is to be classed among Conchae pelagiae of the naturalists , which never approach the shore , but continue always at great depths of the sea , contrary to the littorales , which frequent the shores and shallow places ; and hence , when found fossil , are easily to be matched with recent specimens .
Pelagian or ocean shells are frequently found fossil very near the surface , as every naturalist knows , which proves , that such places have formerly been the sea-shore .
Hence it is clear , that the cause , which transported them thither , acted suddenly ; which agrees perfectly with the account of the deluge given by Moses in the holy scripture ; and , at the same time , overturns the system of Mons. de Buffon , and the author of Telliamed , who pretend , that the earth was for many ages covered with water , and that in that long course of time it was , that the shells , which we now find fossil , were gradually produced ; hence that they are to be considered as the remains of innumerable successive generations of marine bodies , formerly the only inhabitants of the globe .
The greatest depths of the sea , as yet sounded , have been found to be about 3000 fathoms , and the ordinary depths are about 150 ; which makes it evident , that were the theories of these gentlemen true , such fossil shells ought never to be found at less depths in the earth than from 150 to 3000 fathoms .
II .
Though fossil shells are to be found in almost all the plainer parts of the surface of the earth , yet there are certain very large tracts , where such bodies are never found , viz. the mountains , which seem to be the remains of the original strata of the earth .
It is true indeed , that there are many eminences , which have been by our modern theorists taken for mountains , where sea-shells , and calcareous matter , of every kind , are to be found in great abundance : but these are very inconsiderable , and only appear as little hillocks , compared with the large mountains , which contain mines , veins of metal , and precious stones , and may be traced in immense chains , without almost any discontinuity from one continent to another ; and from continents to neighbouring and opposite islands , &amp;c. insomuch that all these chains not only of the old , but likewise of the new world seem connected one with another ; an observation .
which alone would indicate the importance of diligently inquiring into their structure , in order to form a true theory of the earth .
Mons. de Buffon and the author of Telliamed , who endeavour to prove , that all mountains have been formed by sea-currents , and bring one of their principal arguments in proof of this opinion from marine bodies being found in great quantities in the strata , of which they are composed , seem never to have made observations on mountains ; else they might have observed this remarkable difference between them and the calcareous strata of the plains , that the former contain none of those marine bodies , though the latter are almost entirely made up of them .
In the Alps , Appennines , and Pyreneans , no shells nor marine bodies of any kind are to be found : in the Ochels , a branch of the large Grampian Mountains in Scotland , which I have had occasion diligently to examine , I could discover no marine bodies .
The same is observed of all the large mountains of Africa , and of Asia ; and in the huge chain of Cordilleres in Perou Mons. de la Condamine searched in vain for such bodies .
This kind of mountains , ( which indeed alone deserve that name ) are chiefly composed of vitrifiable matter ; and if they are sometimes found to contain sea-shells , it is never to great depths , nor in their original metallic or stony strata ; though such bodies are found in great abundance at the foot of mountains , and in the adjacent valleys , in which there are many eminences in some parts continued in small chains , though but of small extent , which contain marble , sea-shells , chalk , and other calcinable matter , but never any veins of metal , though we frequently find in them pyrites , ocre , vitriols , and other minerals , which have been washed down from veins of iron and other metals , with which the higher mountains abound , and have afterwards been deposited in the calcareous strata of the valleys .
III .
Mons. de Buffon pretends , that all mountains have been formed by sea-currents ; and a little afterwards tells us , that all sea-currents are occasioned by sea-mountains .
Is it not natural here to ask , Which of these two causes pre-existed ?
Can such reasoning as this , a circulus viciosus of the grossest kind , ever tend to improve our knowledge , or give us just views of the works of the great Creator ?
The learned academician founds his opinion of all mountains having been formed by sea-currents , principally upon two observations .
The first is , that they are made up of strata composed of sea-shells , and petrified marine bodies of different kinds : the second , that in chains of mountains the prominent angles always correspond with the depressed ones on the opposite side of the valley , in the same serpentine way as we observe in rivers , the banks of which are alternately hollowed and prominent , according to the different resistance they give to the current of the water .
This observation was first made by Mons. Bourguet , and must be owned to be curious and interesting .
Mons. de Buffon is of opinion , that these two essential observations put together form an invincible argument in proof of his theory , and such as could scarce have been expected in so seemingly obscure a point .
As to the first observation , that all mountains are made up of strata composed of marine bodies , it is so far from being true , that no mountains , properly so called , contain such bodies : and as to the second , of the correspondence of the opposite angles of mountainous tracts , it does not at all prove , as he would have it , that sea-currents have formed these mountains , but only that there have been formerly such currents running between them , which currents have given them that form we now observe them to have .
To assert , that because currents of water have given them that figure , therefore they have produced them , is as ridiculous , as if one should say , that a river had reared its own banks , merely because it had given them a serpentine form .
IV .
Mons. de Buffon , who pretends , that the earth was at first entirely covered with water , which afterwards dug channels for itself , and thus separated the sea from the land ; and the author of Telliamed , who endeavours to prove , that this water goes insensibly off by evaporation ; and who , as well as Mons. de Buffon , attributes the number of sea-shells , found fossil , to the length of time he supposes the now inhabited parts of the earth to have been covered with water , seem not to have given sufficient attention to an observation of consequence , which is , that the greatest part of our fossil shells are entirely foreign to Europe , and belong to the Equator or Tropicks .
Mons. de Buffon himself seems to have been somewhat aware , how much this observation might make against his theory ; for he observes in answer to it , that not to mention such shellfish , as inhabit the bottom of the sea , and from hence , being difficult to be caught , are regarded as unknown and foreign , though they may be produced in our seas ; by comparing our fossil shells with their analogous living shell-fish , we shall find amongst them more shells belonging to our own coasts than of foreign ones ; for example , that pectens , pectuncles , mussels , oysters , sea-glands , buccina , sea-ears , patellae , &amp;c. which we find fossil almost every-where , are certainly productions of our own seas .
But unluckily for our ingenious theorist , these shells , he mentions as common on our coasts , are produced in all the seas of the globe , and are equally inhabitants of the equator and poles ; though we frequently discover fossil species of them , which are peculiar to the warmer climates .
Since then it is certain , that all our fossil shells are foreign to our climates , except such , as are common to the whole globe , we may conclude , that Mons. de Buffon 's theory is in this respect absolutely defective .
Besides , we find not only a very great quantity of fossil shells and other marine bodies , but likewise a great number of impressions of foreign plants , mostly of the capillary kind , on slates and other stones ; and it is now certain , that all the fossil wood of Loughneagh in Ireland ( as in most other places , where such wood is found ) has been produced in a different climate ; and , if I mistake not , has been compared and found to agree with recent specimens from America .
Bones , and even entire skeletons of rhinoceroses , elephants , and other foreign land animals , are discovered pretty commonly through all Europe ; and in Ireland , very large horns of American moose-deer have been dug up .
All these substances are commonly found near to , or in the same strata with , fossil shells , and other marine bodies ; and all of them , whether original productions of sea or land , appear evidently to have been deposited in the places , where we now find them , by one and the same cause .
To account for these phenomena , I believe Mons. de Buffon must admit a universal deluge , such as is related in the Holy Scripture : and if a deluge of this kind is once admitted , why should we assign other causes for the transportation of marine and terrestrial bodies into climates foreign to those , where they were produced ?
Why , say Mons. de Buffon and the author of Telliamed , because many thousands of years seem to have been requisite for the production of so immense a quantity of sea-shells as those we find every-where fossil ; and besides , says the author of Telliamed , their disposition is so regular , that it is plain the confusion of a deluge could never have placed them in such a manner .
But as to the immense quantity of fossil shells , upon which these gentlemen insist so much , they have been misled by imagining , that many parts of the surface of the earth contain marine bodies , which evidently do not ; and these parts are , as I observed above , the mountains properly so called , in the constituent strata of which no sea-shells nor marine bodies of any kind , no bones of land animals nor impressions of plants , are to be found .
And as to the regular disposition of these bodies , this could not have happened in supposing a violent commotion of the waters to have continued the whole time they covered the earth .
But is such a supposition natural or necessary ?
From the scripture account , I am sure , it is not ; for the rupti sunt fontes abyssi implies , that this was only to procure water sufficient for the deluge ; and that the waters afterwards receded gradually , and were restored to tranquillity before they entirely disappeared , is manifest from the same inspired writings .
Upon the whole , we may dare boldly to advance , that we meet with daily observations , that destroy all the fine hypotheses of our modern theorists , but not a single one in the least contradictory to the simple , and at the same time sublime and true account delivered by the sacred historian .
How vain are the efforts of man , when he has the boldness to set up the chimaeras of his own brain in opposition to so much of the truth , as Almighty God has permitted us to discover from his holy word , and from the observation of his works , which he has given us talents to contemplate and admire !
V. The deluge must have produced very considerable changes on the surface of the earth .
Many Volcanos seem to have been formed at that time by the accumulation of animal vegetable and mineral substances into huge masses , which have afterwards fermented and putrified , and in process of time burst out into flames .
Earthquakes must have been frequent the first years after the deluge by the fermentation of these heterogeneous bodies , before the remains of so prodigious an inundation could be dissipated ; for wherever there is any intestine commotion in the earths , it 's violence must be greatly increased , if it meets with water , and by its heat reduces it into vapour , which we know acts with an immense force * .
That this must have been the case the first years after the deluge , may be inferred from the abundance of moisture it must have left , and the fermentation of so great a quantity of heterogeneous substances buried in ruins by that memorable catastrophe .
There are many observations , which seem to prove , that the earth , or at least many parts of its surface , have suffered by fire ; not to mention the marks of it , which are to be observed on many mineral substances .
The artificial production of potter 's earth or clay is a very strong argument in support of this opinion .
Potter 's earth , as is well known , is * This seems to be the reason , why places situated upon the seashore , or upon large rivers , as was the unhappy city of Lisbon , suffer more from earthquakes than more inland situations , where such circumstances do not concur .
found plentifully in most low grounds and vallies between mountainous tracts , and where calcareous strata abound .
By exposing common flint-stones to the confined vapour of boiling water in Papin 's digester , a clay of the very same kind may be formed , and is no more than a decomposition of the flints .
Hence it would appear , that wherever this clay is to found , there the earth has undergone some violence from fire ; and that this has been effected by earthquakes soon after the deluge seems extremely probable .
The deluge has given origin to many fossil substances , and produced many combinations , which otherwise would not have happened .
Chalk is no more than the ruins of sea-shells , and limestone consists of the same bodies cemented together by a stony juice .
Amber appears evidently to be the resin of antediluvian trees ( which are frequently found along with it at this day ) united to the acid of seasalt , which abounds in the earth .
The reason of insects , straws , &amp;c. being immersed in amber , absolutely inexplicable from the hypothesis of its being of mineral origin , is now no more a secret ; for we know , that nothing is more common than to find such bodies immersed in the resin of trees .
Fossil sea-salt or salt-gem seems to have been deposited in the quarries , from whence it is dug , at the time of the deluge .
All or most part of pit-coal appears to be of diluvian origin , for it gives a caput mortuum , the texture of which exactly resembles that of burnt wood .
We may reasonably suppose large forests to have been buried at the time of the deluge , which have undergone a fermentation and putrefaction in the earth , so that the colour of the woody part has been changed , though the texture has remained entire enough to allow us to distinguish to what kingdom it belongs.-All bitumens , pissasphaltum , pessilaeum , &amp;c. seem to be no more than productions of resinous substances united with mineral acids , which have caught fire in the earth by fermenting with heterogeneous matter , and have thus undergone a sort of natural distillation and exaltation .
These are more than chimerical notions , and are even demonstrated by experiments ; for amber can be produced artificially , as likewise bitumens by the distillation of resinous substances with mineral acids ; and there is great probability , that pit-coal might be imitated .
I am , SIR , Your most obedient and Brussels , June 11 , 1756 .
obliged humble servant , Edward Wright .
CVI .
A Retractation , by Mr. Benjamin Wil-

