CI .
Observations on the Abbe Mazeas 's Letter on the Count de Caylus 's Method of imitating the ancient Painting in burnt Wax : By James Parsons , M. D. F. R. S. THE subject of the Abbe Mazeas 's letter , concerning what he thinks the encaustic painting in burnt wax , is very difficult to understand ; for although the count de Caylus has made an essay to find out the method of the ancients in that kind of painting , his success , in the head of Minerva , mentioned in the Abbe 's letter , does not seem to explain Pliny 's meaning .
This author is so very short and obscure in most things , that a bare literal translation of some parts of his work would hardly be reconcileable to sense ; and this is no where more evident than in this very subject .
I confess I do not pretend to understand what he means by painting in burnt wax , though I have considered it over and over , since my having translated the above letter .
However , it may not be unentertaining to the Society , to hear a few passages of Pliny taken notice of upon the matter , by which , perhaps , some of the worthy members of this learned body may enter farther into it .
The two principal methods tried at Paris were these ; the Count 's was waxing over the cloth or board , mixing up the colours with water , and rubbing the waxed ground over with Spanish chalk , in order to make the colours adhere to the waxed ground .
The other was by mixing other ingredients with the wax 4O2 and Read July 1 , and colours and laying it on .
In both these methods the picture is moved to the fire gradually , in order to liquify the wax , and blend and unite the colours , and then moved from it by as slow degrees .
This cannot be called burning in wax , nor be counted encaustic painting ; unless uro , or the Greek ~ , could signify to liquify as well as to burn , in which sense I never met them any where .
And if these words mean only to burn , then encaustic painting can signify no more nor less than painting in enamel ; in which wax , from its very nature , can have no share .
And yet at the end of the 11th chapter of his 35th book , he seems to give uro another meaning : he is admiring the wonderful effects produced in dying stuffs , which being first scowered , are laid over with some colourless material , in whatever pattern they choose ; and upon being dipped in a caldron of boiling liquor , the stuffs appeared to be finely and variously painted ; ` ` Cortina pingit dum coquit ; et adustae vestes firmiores sunt , quam si non urerentur .
' ' Here uro must signify to boil ; for we cannot say the burnt stuffs were become stronger , than if they had not been burnt .
In the same book he has these words : Encausto pingendi duo fuisse antiquitus genera constat , cera et in ebore , cestro id est viriculo ; donec classes pingi caepere .
Hoc tertium accessit , resolutis igni ceris penicillo utendi : quae pictura navibus nec sole , nec sale ventisque corrumpitur.''The close translation of this seems to be as follows : It appears , that anciently there were two kinds of encaustic painting , in wax , and in ivory , with a stilus ; until ships began to be painted : then this third kind came up of using a brush or pencil , with wax melted by fire , &amp;c. ' ' Now tho ' Pliny uses the word pingendi in the two first , we cannot understand that he could mean the laying on of paint , since the instrument ( the cestrum ) being pointed , is incapable of such an office ; and secondly , because he immediately mentions a third kind of painting distinct from , and an absolute contrast to the other two , wherein the paint with the melted wax was laid on with a brush ; and this contrast is very strong in another passage in the same chapter , where he speaks of a famous virgin called Lala , of whom he says , ` ` Romae et penicillo pinxit , et cestro in ebore , imagines mulierum maxume .
' ' That is she painted at Rome with a pencil , and with the cestrum or stilus upon ivory , chiefly the images or portraits of women .
We cannot help thinking , that what was done with the cestrum , either upon the wax or ivory , was modelling or carving ; for the modellers of this day , in their compositions of wax and other materials , use pointed tools to repair and render their figures sharp ; and the workers in ivory use such tools of various points and edges for the same purpose .
It will not be amiss in this place to take notice of the sense , in which Mons. Durand puts this passage , of which he makes a very loose translation in his history of ancient painting : viz. ` ` Il faut que j'indique ici en peu des mots ce que c'est que cette peinture en cire , que l'on perfectionne avec le feu : pour cela il faut scavoir , qu ' anciennement il y en avoit de deux sorts ; dans la premiere , on employoit la cire preparee en divers coleurs , qu'on appliquot ensuite sir le bois , suivant l'esquisse qu'on y avoit tracee , ou creusee avec un fer chaud ; dans la second on gravoit de meme dans l'yvoir , avec un fer aigu et ardant les contours et generalement l'idee de tout de sujet , apres quoi on appliquot les couleurs pour les Ombres , en laistant l'yvoire pour les jours , et perfectionnant le tout ensemble par le moyen du feu , comme on le pratiquoit aussi pour le bois .
' ' Now it is very easy to see , that Pliny 's words are very different from any thing in this translation ; and that this may be more plain , I here give a close translation of Mr. Durand 's words : viz. ` ` I must show here what this painting in wax is , which was finished by fire .
It must therefore be remarked , that in ancient times there were of two kinds of this painting ; in the first they used wax prepared in divers colours , which they then put upon the wood , according to the design they had traced out with a hot iron .
In the second , they engraved in the same manner upon the ivory , with a sharp burning iron , the contour , and generally the idea of the whole subject , after which they applied the colours for the shades , leaving the ivory for the lights , and finishing the whole by the means of fire , as they also practised it upon wood .
' ' Mons. Durand has gathered these notions from Pere Hard .
and Boulenger de pictura veterum ; which are no more applicable to Pliny , than they are practicable in themselves ; Pliny has no such meaning , for his words are very clear , as I have shown it before : but he takes the same liberty in that passage of the female male painter , Lala , just mentioned , upon whom the words of Pliny are very precise ; ` ` Romae et penici lo pinxit , et cestro in ebore : ' ' which Mons. Durand has rendered thus : ` ` elle peignot a Rome , ou sir le bois , ou sir l'yvoire , comme on vouloit , ou avec le pinceau , ou avec de cire coloree .
' ' ` ` She painted at Rome either upon wood or upon ivory , as she thought proper , either with a pencil , or with coloured wax .
' ' Now Pliny has not one word of wood or coloured wax in this passage ; nor could he mean any other , than that she sometimes painted with a pencil , and sometimes carved in ivory .
I am therefore inclined to think , that when Pliny mentions cera in the singular number , altho ' he says pingere , yet as the cestrum is mentioned with it , it must be understood to mean carving or modelling ; but that when it is in the plural , as in the following cited passage , and of burning the picture , he must mean the true encaustic or enamel painting , and the ceris must mean a composition , which was capable of enduring the fire ; for which , perhaps , the following short reasons may have some weight .
It appears in the 2d chapter of his 35th book , where Pliny is speaking of the Honos imaginum , that modelling was greatly practised , especially the busts of great men , and of very ancient standing .
These were made during the lives of the persons , and laid up in their armories , or other repositories , till their deaths , in order to be carried before the deceased in their funeral rites , and exposed to the public , while an oration was made by the nearest of kin , who pointed to the image , as he proceeded , in his Elogium upon the virtues of the person represented : and this image was modelled in wax , as our wax-work is made to this day , and painted in natural colours , in order to come the nearer to nature .
Pliny 's words are very clear in this ; ` ` expressi cera voltus singulis disponebantur armariis , ut essent imagines , quae comitterentur gentilitia funera , &amp;c. ' ' And it is also evident , that in order to take the true resemblance of the persons , whose busts they intended to make for these purposes , they took off a plaister mask from the face , and by way of mould , cast melted wax into it ; whereby they obtained every feature , and afterwards made it perfect by repairing with proper tools .
This is fully declared in his 12th chapter of the same book , which treats of plastics : wherein after he has mentioned Dibutades a potter of Sicyon to be the first inventor of forming the likeness of things in clay or plaster , and of first making images upon the corners of his tiles , he gives the invention of taking off masks from the face , for making busts , to Lisistratus , of the same town , brother of Lysippus , in these words : ` ` Hominis autem imaginem gypso e facie ipsa primus omnium , expressit , ceraque in eam formam gypsi infusa , emendare instituit Lisistratus Sicyonius , frater Lyssippi ; hic et similitudinem reddere instituit.-crevitque res in tantum , ut nulla signa statuaeve sine argilla fierent ; quo adparet antiquiorem hanc fuisse scientiam , quam fundendi aeris .
' ' In a word , they appear , in the sequel of this chapter , to have imitated fruits , fishes , and everything else , by making clay moulds , and casting the wax or other matter into them .
It is , by the way , remarkable , that in all these cases of casting or modelling cera is in the singular number , and must be taken in its literal sense , as being a matter very capable of such a manufacture .
Now on the other hand , when that word is in the plural , there is some reason to conjecture , that a certain composition is meant , capable , as I have said before , of bearing the fire , or when it is laid upon ships with a brush ; for we can neither suppose , that wax was ever capable simply to bear being burnt , as the encausticae picturae expresses and denotes it ; nor that the ceris igni resolutis was to be simply laid on their ships without paint , rosin , turpentine , or some other matters , both to render it ductile and fluid enough not to clog the brush as it cooled , which every one must allow wax would infallibly do ; and also to give it such a body , as that , when dry , it might stand the injuries of the weather ; for the heat of the sun would melt simple wax , and make it run down in streams , without an admixtion of something else to give it the necessary firmness .
The following I believe to be the words , which the Count de Caylus and the French painters have endeavoured to follow .
Plin .
lib. xxxv .
chap .
xi .
Ceris pingere ac picturam inurere quis primus excogitaverit , non constat : quidam Aristidis inventum putant , postea consummatum a Praxitile ; sed aliquanto vetustiores encaustae picturae extitere , &amp;c. ' ' Here again is the ceris in the plural , where he talks of burning in the picture , and where in the same sentence he calls it encaustae picturae .
I would , therefore , humbly ask , whether wax painting , strictly speaking , would ever bear burning in ; or whether , according to the count 's manner , a gentle colliquation by a gradual slow approach of the picture to the fire , and as slow a removal of it back again , can be called encaustic painting ?
I might add much more to my purpose , by entering into the nature of varnishes , pottery , glass-making , and furnaces of the ancients ; which would throw more light upon the subject , and show , that they were well acquainted with what colours would bear the fire , as well as with such as would not ; for Pliny 's chapter upon the different pigments must have been collected from ancient authors as well as from his contemporaries , and contains a catalogue of those used by the painters , which consists of a very great number of articles .
That the ancients were well acquainted with enamel painting cannot be doubted , since there are great numbers of their enamel pieces in the cabinets of the curious in many places .
There is one , which is a Roman cup curiously enamelled upon brass , found at Froxfield , in the possession of Lord Hertford : there is a Roman enamelled platter upon the same metal , probably belong to the cup , with figures and inscriptions curiously painted in the enamel , of Leg .
ii .
Aug. and Leg .
xx.v.v .
in Britain , a drawing of which Dr. Stukely made in its colours .
( See Buonoroti 's Osservazzioni on the Duke of Tuscany 's Medallions .
) And the Doctor has now an enamelled fibula of the same kind of workmanship ; nor are there wanting cups with portraits of some friends enamelled at the bottoms , which were used inter pocula , to drink to their memories ; and I cannot but think it probable , that the enamelled ware of cups , platters , ewers , and such like , which the great Raphael was concerned in making , many of which are now in England , were made in imitation of the ancients ; since in every other part of his art , he was so close a follower of their most correct works , and since the colours and appearance are exactly the same in his , that are upon those ancient pieces mentioned .
All I have further to say is , that if there be any-thing amiss in these conjectures , I freely submit to the judgment and correction of any better judge .

