LXII .
Two singular Cases of diseased Kneejoints successfully treated .
The first by topical Applications ; the second by Operation .
By Mr. Joseph Warner , F. R. S. Surgeon to Guy's-Hospital .
D Seases of the larger joints of the extremities have always been looked upon by surgeons of the greatest eminence in their proRead Jan. 22 , profession , to be attended with considerable danger to the patient ; and with the greatest reason , since they have been convinced from much experience , that these maladies are too often the consequences of depraved habits of body , arising from scrophulous , scorbutic , or some other general cause .
But tho ' we are sufficiently apprised of these facts , and that they too often baffle the greatest skill in physic and surgery , we are nevertheless not to infer from hence , that every disorder of this kind is attended with the like bad circumstances ; since it is well enough known to the experienced , that diseases of the joints , particularly those of the knee , are sometimes merely local complaints , which may not only be assisted by surgery , but perfectly cured .
These species of tumors I now hint at , are those , which are distinguished by the name of hydrops articuli , or the dropsy of the joint ; of which there are , as I have often observed , two different kinds .
The one , wherein the disease is situated in the membrana adiposa , and neighbouring parts on this side the capsular ligament .
The other is that species of disease , wherein the fluid is contained within the capsular ligament , betwixt the extremities of the thigh-bone , and the largest bone of the leg .
The first species of tumor may be distinguished from the second by the touch ; from the appearance of the tumor of the first kind , which is pale and uniform ; from a want of fluctuation ; and from the little or no degree of pain attending it .
The repeated use , for some weeks , of emollient fomentations , mercurial frictions , and gentle purges , has been often known to remove this disorder .
At other times it has been found , that these applications have had little or no effect , but that the disease has given way to , and been totally removed by the use of perpetual blisters to the part affected ; which should , in most instances , be continued for several weeks .
At other times , I have known the Pisseleon Indicum , in English called the Barbadoes tar , to have so good an effect , by being applied every day to the joint , for some weeks , even after every other remedy had failed , as to cure such a disorder of the knee-joint , as had hitherto been judged desperate : in which case there plainly appeared to be an enlargement of the bones , as well as a very considerable one of the integuments , and of the tendinous and ligamentous parts , but without any apparent inflammation .
In this instance there was no extravasated fluid could be discovered ; however , there was an immobility of the joint , and a considerable contraction of the hamstrings .
The pain was extravagantly great , which the patient described as shooting thro the ligaments of the joint , the kneepan , the extremities of the thigh-bone , and those of the leg .
He had a severe symptomatic fever , which had been of many weeks continuance , and was become greatly emaciated thereby .
The reason for my giving so particular a relation of the circumstances attending this fact proceeds from my desire of recommending a trial of the same remedy , in the like cases ; which , as far as I can judge from my own experience , may always be safely done , where there is no degree of inflammation already formed upon the integuments .
And I am farther induced to communicate a short history of the case to this Society , as it is an application I never saw made use of before , in the like case , tho ' the use of it has not been uncommon in old sprains of the joints ; wherein it has oftentimes been found to be of singular service , even when other remedies have been ineffectually tried .
The second species of hydrops articuli or that wherein the extravasated fluid is contained within the capsular ligament , may be distinguished from the first , from its deep situation ; from the fluctuation , which is felt upon patting the knee on one side , while the other hand is held immovably on the opposite side ; from the degree of pain arising from the distension , which the capsular ligament suffers , in consequence of its contents ; from the incapacity of bending the joint ; and from the circumstance of its being attended with no general complaints of body , as well as from the sudden enlargement of the tumor ; upon the increase of which depends the degree of uneasiness in the part .
This is very far from being the case , in that kind of disease called the spina ventosa , which arises originally from the medulla and bone itself being diseased ; from whence proceed grievous pricking and throbbing pains , that come on previously , in general , to any visible enlargement of the part affected , or any discoverable quantity of fluid deposited in the joint ; the difference of which symptoms resulting from the different diseases may be learned from the succeeding case , wherein it was judged necessary to cut more than once thro ' the capsular ligament , in order to evacuate its contained , extravasated fluid ; which , contrary to the common received opinion of wounds of the ligaments being attended with certain destruction to the limb , should always be done under the like bad circumstances , in reasonable expectation of removing a complaint , which totally disables the patient , and too frequently terminates in the loss of the limb , when neglected .
And I am more particularly inclined to recommend this practice , as I am convinced , that this disease is out of the reach of such applications , as are of service in other diseases of these parts , whose situation is more superficial ; that is , on this side the ligament , in which is contained the synovia .
William Drury , aged 28 , by business a porter , was put under my care , on the 5th of September , 1754 , for a disorder in his knee .
Upon enquiry , it appeared greatly swelled , was attended with excessive pain , which was continual : there was not the least degree of inflammation upon the integuments ; the patient was incapable of bending his knee in the least degree , or of setting his foot to the ground .
He could get no rest .
The disorder arose without any accountable cause , and had been only of three weeks standing .
Upon placing one hand on the outside of the knee , and by patting with the other on the inside , it was easy to discover a fluctuation ; on which account I judged it adviseable to make an opening into the tumor , which I did by incision on the upper and inside of the knee-pan , as this was the most prominent part ; upon which , a thick , gelatinous fluid , deeply tinged with blood , was discharged in a full stream to the quantity of fourteen ounces .
After the whole of it was evacuated , I passed a probe thro ' the wound , which went under the knee-pan : the wound was superficially dressed with lint , and the whole of the knee was covered with a pultice of strong beer-grounds and oatmeal .
The patient complained of of considerable pain for about four hours afterwards , when he grew easy , and so continued till the second day after the operation , when the knee became a good deal painful : there was no discharge from the wound .
Upon enquiry I found he had not been at stool for three days , which occasioned the administring of a clyster , by which stools were procured , and the pain became considerably abated .
On the third day from the operation there appeared a considerable discharge , and his knee was quite easy , which continued so till the sixth day , when the discharge was much abated .
The pain returned and continued till the eighth day , when the discharge returned again , and the pain was removed .
Observing from this time , that the discharge increased , and so continued easy till the eleventh day , which proceeded altogether from within the joint , I dilated the wound , that the matter might have a more ready issue .
This answered my expectation , and the patient continued easy till the fifteenth day , when he complained of a return of pain .
Upon examination , I perceived the outside of the knee was swelled , and upon pressure I discovered a fluctuation ; which induced me to make an incision thro ' the integuments and capsular ligament , on this side ; which , I discovered , by the use of the probe , that passed under the knee-pan , to have a communication with the wound on the inside .
From this time the patient went on very well , without any farther complaints ; and in about twelve weeks from the first operation , he became perfectly well , and still continues so , without any other complaint than that of a small degree of stiffness in the joint , as I have very lately had an opportunity of informing myself .
During the whole time of the cure , I made use of emollient fomentations , dressed the wounds superficially , and continued the pultice of strong-beer grounds and oatmeal , which were the only methods taken in surgery for his relief .
Hatton-Garden ,

