Some Observations proving , that the Foetus is in part nourished by the Liquor Amnii .
By Malcolm Fleming , M. D. BEsides the mysterious affair of generation , besides the manner of the formation of the embryo , and the changes it undergoes , while it continues extremely small , concerning all which we shall ever remain very much in the dark ; there are not a few things relating even to the mature foetus , which create matter of dispute amongst anatomists and physiologists .
Of these the manner of its nourishment in utero is not the least important .
The present state of the controversy concerning this matter turns on the following precise point , to wit , whether the foetus in utero be nourished solely by the blood , which is transmitted to it through the umbilical Read Nov. 13 , umbilical cord ; or whether it is likewise nourished in part by the liquor amnii , in which it swims .
I have said the present state of the controversy ; for I believe very few , if any at all , will maintain now-adays with Claudius de la Courv~ee and Stalpart Vander-wiel , that the whole of its nourishment is conveyed by the mouth , and none at all by bloodvessels .
Both sides of the question have been espoused by able writers , and supported with great acuteness , erudition and industry .
And as there still ~a division amongst candid and intelligent ~ concerning this matter , it would appear , that some decisive fact , some demonstrative argument hath hitherto escaped notice , which , if clearly known and duly attended to , would have by this time ended the dispute , and rendered the proposition , which declares the truth , on which-soever of the sides , an object of science ; which before was only matter of opinion .
An observation , which fell in my way two years ago , together with some subsequent ones , which I purposely made in pursuance of the hint suggested by the first , will , I hope , enable all , who candidly consider the facts themselves , and the consequences that naturally flow from them , to determine certainly , on which side the truth lies .
Before I relate my observations , let me lay down a necessary preliminary , which I observe the writers on both sides are either explicitly or implicitly agreed in ; to wit , that if it be clearly made out , that the liquor amnii is naturally received into the mouth , stomach , and intestines of the foetus , swimming in it ; in that case we are to conclude , that the foetus is in some part nourished by it .
The whole tract of the alimentary passage abounds with absorbent vessels in the foetus , more than in the adult animal ; and especially the small intestines have lacteals plentifully opening into them .
The liquor amnii is concretable by heat , like the white of an egg ; which characteristic in animal juices is , I believe , denied by none to be a proof of their alimentary nature .
To such as will not grant this postulatum , if any such there be , this paper is not addressed .
Contra negantem principia non est disputandum .
But I proceed to relate the observations .
On the 25th of July 1753 , being informed , that a calf , come to full maturity was just then brought forth dead in this town ( Brigg , in Lincolnshire ) , which had been alive , and appeared strong a very short time before its birth .
I begged it of the owner , such instances being rare .
The skin being of value , for it was an extraordinary large calf , it was sent to my house flay 'd .
I first examined the thorax , which was my chief motive for begging it .
All I shall mention now of what I observed there , is the experiment of the lungs of a new-born animal their sinking in water .
After cutting out the lungs and heart , I clipped off a piece of the former with sharp scissors , about an ounce weight , or more , and threw it into a bason full of water .
It quickly sunk to the bottom , and settled there .
Immediately after , I blew into the remaining part of the lungs , through the trachea ; and though I could by that means distend them but very little , because the air flowed out readily through the cut bronchia , and therefore acted but faintly on the other parts ; yet a piece about the same bigness with the first , clipped off in the same manner , and thrown into the same bason , constantly kept at the top .
This may seem foreign to my present purpose ; but I thought proper briefly to mention it here , not only upon the account of the importance of the experiment , but likewise to show , that I was not misinformed in the account of the calf 's being brought forth dead , and that it had not even respired ; much less taken any nourishment after exclusion , to influence the appearances , which we are now going to describe .
Having done with the thorax , I opened the abdomen , in order to take a slight view of it before the lumbering carcase should be removed .
I observed the thick intestines , especially the rectum , extremely distended with an incredible quantity of meconium ; which for several inches above the anus was formed into distinct scybala or balls .
It came into my head to make an incision in the rectum , where it was very turgid , about two inches from the anus , and to let out about twenty-five or thirty of these scybala ; which I laid upon clean paper to dry , that I might examine them at my leisure .
About three or four days after , when they were dry and brittle , of the colour and consistence of aloes ; I was surprised to find , upon examination , every ball stuck full of tough , thick , white hairs , some of which were an inch long , or more .
There seemed to be some scores in each , though they , being shrunk with drying , did scarce exceed the bulk of an ordinary pea .
This unexpected appearance set me a considering , whence these hairs had come ; how got they there ?
And I could think on no other tolerable solution of the difficulty than to conclude , that they belonged originally to the calf 's skin ; and , being loosened by maceration in the liquor amnii , were propelled into the stomach and intestines ; till they were at length entangled in the meconium .
I was confirmed in the belief of this by being informed , upon inquiry , that the calf 's skin was white ; a circumstance unknown to me before , it having been sent flay 'd , as hath been already said .
From this persuasion it was natural to inser , that if hairs loosened from the skin of the foetus , and floating in the liquor amnii , can find a way into the intestines , and get entangled in the meconium , it is impossible but the liquor amnii must enter and pass through the whole alimentary passage along with them ; as a fluid may certainly penetrate where hairs cannot : but no good reason can be assigned , or even conceived , why hairs should be admitted where the fluid is excluded .
The only reasonable scruple , that remained to be got over , was , that this being but a single instance , a general conclusion was not to be too hastily drawn from it ; that it was possible there might be some morbid concretions in the meconium of this particular calf , resembling hairs , which concretions in a common and natural way might be wanting ; or some preternatural communication between the primae viae in this subject , and the liquor amnii , not to be found in the generality of other foetus 's .
To obviate all this , and farther to establish and illustrate the truth of my conclusion , as instances like that , which we have now related , cannot be commanded , manded , I laid myself out to procure the first dung of calves after they are brought forth ; which always can be nothing but meconium .
This was attended with some difficulty and delay , as cows in this neighbourhood mostly calve in the fields .
After some months , by the good offices of a sensible acquaintance in this place , I obtained what I wanted .
He was so obliging as to watch his own cow 's calving , and before he stirred from her , to catch the calf s first dung , and send it me forthwith .
Some weeks after another parcel of the same kind was sent me from another quarter .
In both which I found a great number of strong hairs all over ; so as to leave no room for doubting but that this appearance is general in the meconium of calves , in a natural way .
The reader will please to observe , that in neither of these instances I could be deceived , if I had ever so little reason to trust to the judgment and fidelity of those , who supplied me with what I wanted .
The colour and consistence of the meconium of a foetus is so very peculiar , and so widely different from that of faeces formed out of ingested aliments , that none , who have any knowlege in these matters , can mistake the one for the other .
In the mean time I omitted not to open the embryo 's of the cow-kind , such as I could procure in the shambles of the market-town I live in , and to examine their meconium .
The two most advanced towards maturity , which I met with , had stiff long hairs about the mouth , the eye-brows , the ears , and navel , and a good many on the end of the tail ; but none on their skins .
In neither of these , any more than in the younger embryo 's , which I examined , was there so much as a single hair to be found in the meconium ; for this plain reason , if I judge right , to wit , because they had not got hairs upon their bodies of long enough continuance to become loose , and float in the liquor amnii .
But as opportunities of coming at foetus 's of this species , especially such as are remarkably nearer to maturity than those two I have just now mentioned , are rare with us , I tried to supply that defect by opening those of other animals .
Accordingly I procured fix puppies , of the butcher-dog-kind , brought forth at the full time , at one litter .
Having taken out the whole meconium of every one of them , after the strictest search , I could find no hairs in any part of it .
I had likewise an opportunity of opening a colt , that died either in the birth , at the full time , or immediately after , before its meconium was discharged ; which I found in great quantities in its rectum and colon .
But neither here could I spy a single hair , though I examined whole pounds of it , and that portion thereof most carefully , which was lodged in the rectum , near the anus .
These observations may seem at first view to clash with and contradict those I have related : But , upon closer consideration , they will be found in reality to confirm them , for this reason , to wit , that puppies and colts , when brought forth , have no loose hairs on their bodies ; but calves have in great numbers .
In the puppies and colt , which I examined , the hairs were so firmly rooted on their skins , that I could scarce pull any off with my thumb and fingers ; whereas in a ripe calf , new brought forth , many are found quite loosened at their roots , and only adhering ing to their skin by the moisture on it .
Therefore in the latter species , hairs from the surface may be , and actually are , incorporated with the liquor amnii , and along with it enter the mouth and alimentary canal , which cannot be the case in the former .
From these facts it is easy to draw such inferences , as are sufficient to decide the controversy , which we are treating of ; and prove incontestably , that the liquor amnii is in a constant natural way received into the mouth , stomach , and intestines , and therefore must contribute to the nutrition of the foetus .
For if we attentively consider , that in the meconium of an human foetus no hairs are found , there being no loose hairs on its skin when it is born ; that in the meconium of unripe calves there are none , before they are of so long continuance on their bodies as to be loosened , and float in the liquor amnii ; whereas in that of the ripe calves they are found in great abundance , of the same colour with those of the skin , as appears by the example we had occasion to examine most particularly ; and of such a length , stiffness , and thickness , and so constantly to be met with , as cannot with any show of reason be imputed either to morbid concretion , or preternatural frame : If , I say , all these facts are attentively considered , and duly weighed , the conclusion I have drawn will , I hope , appear to follow from them so naturally , that no candid and intelligent inquirer will call its truth in question .
POSTSCRIP T. After I had gone thus far upon my own bottom , and while I was looking about me , in order to pick up more proofs , that might , as it were ex super abundanti , confirm and illustrate the doctrine , which I was endeavouring to establish , before I should venture to publish it , I casually found what , as I here solemnly declare , I knew nothing of before , to wit , that I was not the first , who had observed hairs in the meconium of ripe calves , two authors having been before-hand with me , to wit , Aldes and Swammerdam ; the former in his Epistola contra Harveium , published in the first volume of the Bibliotheca Anatomica of Mangetus and Le Clerc : the latter in the Biblia Naturae .
Aldes , a feigned name under which Slade , an Amsterdam physician , conceals himself , barely mentions the observation , without drawing any inference from it , either on the one side or the other .
Swammerdam draws the same conclusion with me ; but , I think , he goes farther than the observation can well justify , maintaining , that it evidently follows from thence , that a calf licks his own skin in utero , thereby loosening the hairs , and swallowing them down along with the liquor amnii , its nourishment .
See the whole passage , Bibl .
Natur .
page .
319 .
However that be , it is enough for my purpose to have two such authors concurring with me , as to the reality of the fundamental fact , and quite saves me the trouble of making any farther trials to confirm it .
It is no wonder , that these passages escaped me , who have spent almost all my time in practice , and practical studies , and who never was possessed of either of these books ; but , after I found them quoted , was obliged to trouble two learned friends , at a di5 stance , stance , upon this occasion , for my own satisfaction , and that very lately .
The one was so obliging as to send me the Bibliotheca Anatomica ; the other to write out at large the passage from the Biblia Naturae .
I say , it is no wonder the passages escaped my notice , since they seem to have been overlooked by not only all the particular writers on the foetus , since Aldes and Swammerdam , but likewise , for aught I know , by all the lecturers on physiology in Europe , preceding August 1753 ; at which time I began to communicate by letters , what I then took to be a discovery , to several correspondents versed in these matters , both at home and abroad , as I can vouch by their answers .
So that I hope the public will do me the justice to believe , that though I was not the first in point of time , that made the fundamental observation , yet I was obliged to no author for it ; and that I have drawn an important truth relating to the animal oeconomy out of obscurity , and established it by supplemental observations , as well as by reasoning .
Before I conclude , let me acquaint the reader , that an ingenious student of anatomy and surgery * , to whom I had communicated my first observations , and recommended to him to examine the liquor contained in the stomachs of ripe new brought forth calves , if he had a proper opportunity , acquainted me last harvest , that he had not long before actually found hairs in abundance in the liquor contained in * Mr. John Clark , now surgeon to the Lock-Hospital , near Hyde-Park Corner .
one of the stomachs of a calf , brought forth dead at the full time , of the same colour with those on its skin .
As this observation renders the proof , however clear and unexceptionable it was before , fuller , I was unwilling to omit it here .
Malcolm Flemyng .
Brigg , July 12 ,

