XXXVIII .
An Account of some Experiments on the Sensibility and Irritability of the several Parts of Animals ; in a Letter from Richard Brocklesby , M. D. F. R. S. to the Reverend Thomas Birch , D. D. Secr. R. S. Dear Sir , A New doctrine some time since propagated by a most faithful observer of the animal oeconomy , Dr. Haller , the illustrious commentator on Boerhaave 's institutions , prevailed on me to do violence to my own temper , whilst I was to be witness to the success of most of the experiments , which have been mentioned in his Dissertation upon the Irritability of animal Fibres , as it deserves to be distinguished from sensibility .
Nothing short of the general importance of this inquiry could have induced me to be spectator of such cruelties , as indeed I have been within this month past .
But as I shall anticipate partly the conclusions that every gentleman conversant in such matters will draw from what follows afterwards , I am confident , that , however cruel my experiments may at first hearing sound in your ears , yet in the end you will conclude , that the pain and misery by me caused even to the victims of this subject , were to be regarded much less than what happens every day in Smithfield to twenty oxen and sheep , by cutting off their tails , and other parts of the skin , and driving them miles afterwards .
But Read June 19 , But to avoid , as much as might be , unnecessary privation of animal life , I selected at various times many objects , more than I shall , for a particular reason , at present relate ; but most of them immediately devoted to death by the butcher for the use of the market , if I had not been present .
The first experiment I propose to relate , was made by cutting four inches of a young lamb 's skin , which covered the great tendon of the hinder leg , and is known to anatomists by name of the Tendo Achillis .
This of course caused violent struggles , and other marks of the injury felt ; and on touching the extremity of the skin , whilst united to other parts of the animal , it cried loud , urined , and voided its excrement , when I poured diluted spirit of vitriol upon the edges of the skin , that were fixed to the contiguous parts ; but did not express much pain by irritating the raised skin , at the farthest extremity of its separation , by an affusion of diluted spirit of vitriol .
Nearer however to the fixed parts underneath , the sensation in the raised part of the skin continued much longer .
I then made the butcher cut into the tendon half way , and divide it upwards more than two inches , and attentively stood over the animal , to watch his motions , and discover if there was any apparent pain : but whilst that was doing , I could discern none , nor any marks of sensation in the animal , whilst I handled and pulled the cut tendon , nor yet any on touching it with dulcified spirit of nitre , and sharp acid spirit of vitriol ; and what yet surprised me more , was to find the creature as insensible upon the tendon , as if it was a mere piece of glue , when I put a strong muria of sea-salt and nitre all over it ; and after a very few minutes I laid the raised part of the tendon in its natural direction , upon the correspondent fixed part , and they were both exactly congruous ; so that the loose part had not contracted itself , nor was at all shorter , after these repeated trials , than its correspondent fixed part .
I then put the creature on its legs , to see whether it had suffered so much , that it could not use the leg ; but it was found to walk , though favouring greatly that side where so much had been done ; however , it walked fairly on all its legs .
After about five minutes torment , the butcher ended all its pains , and I performed the same processes on a sheep just destined to be slaughtered , in which I found all the appearances as above-mentioned .
I was induced to make two other very cruel experiments on different animals , by laying bare their patella 's of the knees : having cut off all the skin round about , I then pricked and touched with the aforementioned escharotics the capsular ligaments of these joints , without discovering any tokens of pain thereby occasioned ; but as soon as the sharp fluids had spread over the surface , so as to reach the extremity of the skin , the creature underwent as much pain as cutting before had caused .
I desired the butcher to take off as much skin from the forehead , as was necessary to perform the operation of the trepan ; and before I began to apply the instrument to the sheep 's forehead , I vellicated the pericranium with the end of a knife , but could not observe the membrane sensible , or thereby thrown into contractions ; and when the operation was over , and the bone taken from the subjacent dura matter , I poured on this membrane dulcified spirit of nitre , and diluted spirit of vitriol , and powdered common salt , but without perceiving any agitations whatsoever , brought on by these substances acting upon these living parts ; though in some creatures I am dubious , whether sea-salt and nitre in powder did not create some sense , though no manifest contractions of the dura matter .
But every muscular part , which I cut while the animals were alive , discovered little sensibility of pain , though great propensity to irregular spasms of the fibres : and the muscles upon the thorax , and especially the carneae columnae of the heart , retained irritability last of all other muscular parts , even till long after the animal 's expiration .
I laid the pungent liquors and salts , as above , upon various parts of the animal , yet alive ; as upon the fat , cellular membrane of the neck , leg , and other parts within the skin , the liver , pancreas and spleen , and could not find them endowed either with remarkable sensibility or irritability ; nor had the bladder any remarkable symptoms of irritability , farther than might be occasioned by its muscular fibres ; though the well-known symptoms of the calculus show its great sensibility .
I tried the effects of a strong aqueous solution of opium upon the irritated parts of muscular fibres , but could not perceive an opiate manifestly to compose these spastic motions of the parts , as Haller alleges they do : though in some trials I fancied there were grounds for such a conclusion .
However this is no argument against the internal use of opiates , where the solids are greatly irritated .
I must add one more experiment , which I made upon the intestines of a lamb : after I had taken them from the carcase , I poured diluted spirit of vitriol on them , as well as several other pungent substances ; and upon the touch of all of them , the intestines renewed their contraction , which before had totally ceased , and surprised me with a motion almost as strong as is found in the process of chylification ; and this continued till the external cold had indurated and stiffened the fatty membrane of the omentum .
These were some of many experiments of a like nature , which the importance of these facts in daily practice of medicine required to ascertain , or reject ; and , from the result of my repeated trials , I am induced to coincide with most of the conclusions drawn by Drs. Haller , Castle , and Zimmerman ; that no part is sensible but the nerves only , and that some parts are irritable without sensibility accompanying them in any great degree ; whilst others are altogether without sense , at the same time that they are incapable of being irritated at all .
Thus , Sir , according to your desire expressed in yesterday 's conversation , I have communicated , for the amusement of some gentlemen of the Royal Society , a candid narrative of many of Dr. Haller 's experiments , as repeated by me : and whether I shall , by prosecuting the subject still farther , be able fairly to make out , that irritability , as it is distinguished from sensibility , depends upon a series of nerves different from such , as serve either for voluntary motion and sensation , at present is impossible to say .
But whatever shall be my future conclusions , I will establish nothing hypothetical , but endeavour by fair deductions to approach towards truth , as near as the abstruse nature of the subject will permit : And as I think I have actually found some variation from the common practice in rheumatisms , built upon the established fact of great irritability in the muscular fibres , succeed , to the relief of suffering patients , I cannot dismiss this subject , without relating , that only with gentle and continued frictions on the pained rheumatic parts with common salad oil , two poor patients , who lately applied for my advice in obstinate rheumatisms , were , by thus relaxing the crispation of the solids , surprisingly relieved , without any farther medicine .
So that after bleeding , where it is indicated , which above all things I find abates irritability , it may deserve to tried , how far animal oils , applied by friction long continued to the aggrieved parts , both in the gout , rheumatism , and other painful diseases , will ease the tortures , without repelling or obstructing the matter , which nature is labouring to throw off .
But I forbear to enlarge , as the experiments I have hitherto made upon the subject of irritability , are scarce sufficient to obtain what Lord Bacon calls the Vindemiatio prima in this science .
When I receive sufficient information to be convinced within myself , I shall not be wanting to communicate what may tend to advance this branch of natural knowlege , and to promote a true theory of diseases , upon which all rational practice must be established .
I have now obeyed your friendly commands ; and that the gentlemen and you may not think me tedious , I conclude with assuring you , that I am , Sir , Your most obedient humble servant , Richard Brocklesby .
New Broad-street , June 19 , 1755 .

