XXXV .
A Method proposed to restore the Hearing , when injured from an Obstruction of the Tuba Eustachiana .
By Mr. Jonathan Wathen , Surgeon , in Devonshire-Square .
WHatever obstructs that passage leading from the ear into the nose , called tuba Eustachiana , so as to hinder the ingress of the air through it into the cavity of the tympanum , is , I believe , universally esteemed destructive to the sense of hearing .
Hippocrates observed , that in a quinsey of the fauces , the patient became deaf , by its compressing and closing up this tube ( a ) .
Many practical writers assert the same to have happened from adjacent ulcers , ~c .
( b ) ; and I have known a swelled tonsil occasion deafness .
Read May 29 , 1755 .
This canal opens into the lateral and anterior part of the cavity of the tympanum ; is so shaped that it first decreases , as it descends towards the posterior part of the nose , becoming very narrow ; then suddenly diverging , is much enlarged , opening into the ( a ) Coac .
11 .
n. 35 .
( b ) Haller in Boerhav .
de auditu , p. 380 , and 416 .
Tulpius ~ .
n. 35 .
a tumore palati .
Valsalva , cap. v. page .
90 .
a polypo .
&amp; ulcere ( viz. a certain yeoman had an ulcer above the uvula , on the left side , which communicated with , and corroded part of , the orifice of the left tuba eustachiana ; which , when he stopped with a tent dipped in medicine , he immediately lost his hearing in that ear , but recovered it as ~ as the tent was taken out ) .
posterior part of the nose by an elliptic orifice , a little prominent , turning inwards and forward , placed laterally , and just above the velum pendulum palati .
This canal then is composed of two distinct cones , the extremities of which unite together , but their bases diverge differently : it is likewise lined with a porous membrane , full of criptae and mucous cells , continued from and like to the membrane of the nares ( c ) .
When therefore we consider the structure of the eustachian tube , and its free communication with the atmosphere , we may reasonably suppose it subject to inflammation of its membrane , and concretion of its mucus , from cold , ~c .
like the external meatus ; and although its mucus is of a very different nature , it is nevertheless liable to inspissate by heat , when its thinner parts are exhaled * .
And from the form of this passage we may easily conceive , that an obstruction , pretty far advanced , is not to be removed without difficulty , and that in proportion , as it is more or less complete , the hearing will be more or less injured .
Why then may not this be suspected , as sometimes the cause of deafness ?
Perhaps it is not unfrequently so : e. g. When ( c ) Haller in Boerh .
de Auditu , page .
378~ Not .
e Physiologia .
Haller .
de Auditu , ~ .
485 .
Valsalva , cap. 2 .
page .
32 .
idem Fig. XIV .
* Morganni and others tell us , that they constantly find the cavity of the tympanum in infants always much clogged with mucus ; and Mr. Douglas has often observed the same in adults , and is of opinion that it is concomitant with an obstructed tube in general , and that the injection is equally as effectual as if the tube only was obstructed .
a patient is somewhat deaf from cold , and the outer ~ has been examined , and found clear of hardened wax , ~c .
it is nevertheless not uncommon to find himself suddenly relieved by a great noise in his ear ( d ) .
This is probably owing to the breaking away of the congealed mucus , and the instantaneous rushing of the air into the tympanum ; so that when this disorder is but slight and recent , nature seems frequently to relieve herself ; but when more confirmed , her efforts are ineffectual for its removal .
These considerations inclined me strongly to think , the hearing might suffer from that cause , and I was much confirmed herein by the following very remarkable case .
Richard Evans , aged thirty-five , was exceeding deaf in both his ears , and no visible disorder in the external meatus .
It arose from cold , and had subsisted several years , during which time no art or means whatsoever , could procure him the least relief .
In August last he died of the small-pox , at the hospital in Cold-bath fields .
I took that opportunity to examine the eustachian tube of each ear , and found them both stuffed quite full of congealed mucus , which was observed by two gentlemen of the profession present .
This was the only visible cause of his deafness , the other parts appearing in their natural state .
As all these concurring circumstances strengthened me in my opinion , they likewise incited me to make trial of an operation that was some time ago proposed ( d ) ~ in Boerhaav .
de Auditu , page .
381 .
not .
g. to the Academy of Sciences , by Monsieur Guyot ; but the author having never practised it , he wanted the recommendation of facts to support and enforce it ; it was therefore rejected by them as impracticable ( d ) .
I first introduced my probe , a little bent at the end , through the nose , into the tubes of several dead subjects ; and , having thereby acquired a facility , I did the same on a person that was very deaf , and on whom all other means had proved ineffectual : no sooner had I withdrawn the probe , than he said , he could hear much better .
This success excited my further endeavours , so that I had pipes of different sizes adapted to a syringe , and have since injected the meatus internus in the following manner , with success .
The pipe is made of silver , about the size and length of a common probe , and a little bent at the end : this being fixed to an ivory syringe , full of liquor ( viz. a little mel rosarum in warm water ) , must be introduced between the ala and septum of the nose , with its convexity towards the upper part ( d ) Hist. de l'Acad .
1724 .
page .
53 .
Besides , Monsieur Guyot proposed doing it by the mouth , which is quite impossible , as evidently appears to any one that will give himself the trouble to examine into it .
Convinced of this , Monsieur Petit ( who has lately published a new edition of Palphin 's anatomy ) proposed , and that learned and skilful anatomist Mr. John Douglas first demonstrated the possibility of , passing the probe , ~c .
through the nose into the eustachian tube : and this he has constantly shown to those who have attended his public lectures ; and to him I freely acknowledge myself indebted for the hint , by which I was incited to make trial on the living , of an operation of so much importance to mankind .
of the aperture of the nares ; and thus continued backwards , and a little downwards , till it comes near the elliptic orifice ; then its convexity is turned toward the septum , by which the inflected extremity enters the tuba eustachiana with ease : the liquor is then impelled through it into the tube , by which the sordes , if any , being diluted , is washed out , and regurgitates through the nose , or mouth , or both , with the injection ; and , if the quantity be large , may be seen .
November 3 , 1754~ MSabout forty years of age , being troubled with a very considerable deafness , so that she could not hear any thing said at a common distance , except the voice was very loud and shrill ; people were therefore obliged to speak into her ears .
This rendered her incapable of service ; so that her mistress resolved to dismiss her : it was of two years continuance , but growing much worse of late , and originally caused by cold , I syringed her outward ears first of all , without the least benefit ; but as soon as the internal meatus was injected , she instantly affirmed , that she heard much better ; and by repeating it for two or three days , she heard , and continues to hear , almost as well as any body , and remains in her place .
November 17 , 1754 .
SLaged fifty , applied to me for relief of a deafness in both ears , that had subsisted for a year and an half , and was the effect of a cold : he could not hear what was said , without a most violent exertion of the voice , and applying one 's mouth close to his ear ; nor could I make him hear at all ; so that I was obliged to converse with him by means of a person that had a more loud and shrill voice .
Having syringed his outward ears without any success , the next day I injected the tube on one side , and washed away a very considerable quantity of congealed mucus , in little clots of a blackish colour and putrid smell , regurgitating with the liquor through his mouth , he immediately heard what was said by some persons talking in another part of the room .
The morning following I did the other ear , and with the same success ; and by repeating the operation for two or three times in as many successive days , he can now hear a common conversation ; and , if near , distinguish what is said , though the voice be very soft and low , but cannot hear founds at a great distance .
November 18 , 1754 , Lthreescore years of age , having been exceeding deaf for thirty years , desired to have this operation performed on one of his ears .
I first injected the external ear of the right side , and extracted a large plug of inspissated wax ; but this did not relieve him in the least .
The next day I syringed the tuba eustachiana of the same side ; he could then distinctly hear the ticking of his watch , applied close to his ear , which he could not do before ~ since : his deafness returned again in the evening : I repeated the operation two mornings more , ~ effects were exactly the same as the ~ .
November 20 , 1754 , EHhad been so exceeding deaf ( from a cold ) for six years , that she was incapable of any kind of employ whatever .
I tried this operation , and continued its use , every other day for a fortnight .
The benefit that she received , though not equal to the second case , is nevertheless so great , that she can now wait at table , hear what is said pretty well , though not spoke directly to her , and is become very useful in the family where she lives .
This is the more extraordinary , as her external ears have a continual spasmodical motion , which indicates a disordered state of the nerves of her ears .
November 30 , 1754 , Aaged twenty-seven , deaf in both ears~ from cold , and of two years standing , one much worse than the other , I began with the deafest , and extracted much wax , ~c .
from the external meatus , without the least benefit ; but on syringing the tube of that ear , she received so much relief that she can hear considerably better with it than the other .
I then injected the other ear , on which it produced no alteration at all , though repeated several times .
February 1 , 1755~ AAdeaf to the greatest degree imaginable , could understand only one particular person , whose voice , or rather physiognomy , he had long been used to .
He had been thus for eighteen years , and was suddenly seized , or as it were struck , with this disorder , together with an affection of his eyes , which presented a variety of colours continually floating before them , to the great detriment of his sight ; and this , together with his deafness , has continued , with very little alteration , till the latterend of January last , about which time I syringed his eustachian tubes , by which he instantly heard his own voice , which he could not in the least before .
I repeated the operation for three or four times , at a day or two distance from each other .
He soon perceived a remarkable alteration for the better , together with this peculiar circumstance , that if spoke to as loud as was before necessary , the sound irritated his ear , causing a very painful titillation , or ( as he himself termed it ) a scratching in his ear .
The same thing happened when he spoke , nor could he distinguish what himself or others said , except the voice was many degrees softer than he had long been used to : he can now hear a middle-ton 'd voice , and converse with others very tolerably , if the room be quiet , and free from noise .
He formerly taught the learned languages , by which he acquired three hundred pounds ; all which he has spent in fruitless endeavours to regain his hearing .
He has been twice deeply salivated , and his head profusely sweated for a long time together , and has undergone several physical courses ; but nothing ever procured him the least help , till this operation was used ; and it is remarkable , that the disorder of his eyes disappeared after the second time his ears had been injected .
Thus five out of the six cases received more or less benefit from the operation ; without which they must probably have ever remained as they were , hopeless , and destitute of help .
I have endeavoured to ascertain the symptoms that indicate an obstructed tube , but have not been able to do it with any degree of certainty ; nor can I see the great utility of it , could it be done ; for the only disorders of the ear , that at present admit of chirurgical helps , are those of the external meatus , ulcerated and swelled tonsils , &amp;c. all of which are generally visible ; and when they are not the cause of deafness , little or nothing is ever attempted , the patient being left to shift for himself .
But now another probable chance at least is given to the unhappy sufferer , and being the only one ( e. g. the others either improper , or tried before without success ) , Philos. Trans. Vol D B~F N ~ CM ~ KQ WR VZ IS T ~ .
Vol. XLIX .
TAB. VI .
p. 221 .
cess ) , may be made use of without delay , or attendance to corroborating symptoms , at least till they render themselves more conspicuous and certain than I have hitherto been able to find them : and as the operation is not at all dangerous , it neither has , nor will , I believe , be thought painful by those who desire to recover their hearing .
Explanation of the References in PLATE VI .
A , The cavity of the cranium , containing the cerebrum .
B , Process of the dura matter , called tentorium .
C , Cavity containing the cerebellum .
D , Posterior process of the dura matter .
E , Transverse spinous process of the sphenoid bone .
F , Orbiter process of the frontal bone .
G , Frontal sinus .
H , Body of the sphenoid bone .
I , Spongious substance of its body .
K , Holes in the sphenoid bone , through which the 3d , 4th , 5th , and 6th pair of nerves pass out of the cranium .
L , Sphenoidal sinus .
M , Sella turcica , in which may be seen N , The glandula pituitaria .
O , Cribriform lamella of the ethmoid bone .
P , Cellulae ethmoideae .
Q , Os spongiosum superius .
R , Os spongiosum inferius ; by its concave surface a groove is formed which serves as a director to the pipe of the syringe , in its course to the tuba eustachiana .
S~ Palatine process of the os maxillare , whose upper surface is strictly a horizontal plane , and not convex , from behind forward , as is always , tho ' very unjustly~ painted .
T~ The orifice of the tuba ~ , whose posterior edge V , is cartilaginous and prominent , forming a resistance to the extremity of the instrument , when pushed against it .
W , The upper and lateral part of the fauces .
X , Velum pendulum palati .
Y , Part of the foramen magnum occipitis .
Z , The inflected extremity of the syringe in the orifice of the tuba eustachiana .

