XXX .
A Dissertation upon the Cancer of the Eye-lids , Nose , great Angle of the Eye , and its neighbouring Parts , commonly called the Noli-me-tangere , deemed hitherto incureable by both Ancients and Moderns , but now shown to be as curable as other Distempers .
Addressed to the Royal Society of London by Mons. Daviel , consulting Surgeon in ordinary , and Oculist to the King ; Master of Arts , and of Surgery at Marseilles ; Royal Professor and Demonstrator of Anatomy of the same City ; Member of the Academy of Sciences of Toulose , Bologne , and that of Surgery of Paris ; and translated from the French by James Parsons , M. D. and F. R. S. Paris , April 20 , 1754 .
OF all the diseases which seize the eye-lids , nose , angle of the eye , and its neighbouring parts , none appears so formidable as Read May 8 , as the cancer , in the opinion even of the most able oculists , who have written upon this subject , such as Antoine Maitre Jean , St. Yves , and others .
They have constantly declared it to be incurable in these parts , and have even forbad meddling with it : Antoine Maitre Jean says , ` ` The operation is so doubtful , that it is rejected by the best practitioners , not only for cancers of the lids , but also for all those of the face , &amp;c. ' ' And St. Yves is of the same sentiment , where he says , ` ` That when the edges of the ulcer are accompanied with callosities , there is nothing to be done but by palliatives .
' ' The patients would have reason to complain , if we were willing to have regard to what these authors have advanced , as well as others , upon the same subject , who were of the same opinion .
The most able oculists have indeed met so many difficulties in this case , that they entered into an opinion , that they were impossible to be cured ; and therefore never dared to undertake them .
Some are content to treat them with palliatives , such as frog-spawn-water , and other such ingredients , as serve only to amuse the patient ; whilst others , more bold , touch them with liquid caustics , or the lapis infernalis , from which they have had no better success than from the application of the water ; because the best managed caustics only serve to irritate these kinds of tumors , as experience has too often showed .
But why therefore should these parts be incurable ?
Is it that they differ from the other parts of the human body ?
Certainly no. Why should these therefore be thought more desperate than the breasts , lips , and many other parts , which often yield to the knife , when directed by a skilful hand : I will venture to say , it is indolence , little or no experience , and an ill-grounded fear , in oculists , both ancient and modern , that made them believe these kinds of diseases ought to be treated differently from all others .
A bad prejudice !
which yet seduces a great part of our most able practitioners : but it must be averred , that they are deceived , if , in order to put it upon the footing of an ill-grounded fear , we must say , it has often hindered them from helping a number of patients , who have perished in a miserable manner , by not properly attempting their cure .
I am willing to free myself from so hard a law ; I reprimand both ancients and moderns , and the opportunities I have had of operating upon cancers of the lids and face , easily showed me , that they were very curable , and that the cure ought not to be given up to an uncertain issue .
The examinations I made in these kinds of tumors have informed me , that cancers of the lids , nose , and adjacent parts , have all their seat in the Periosteum , and Perichondrium ; and that we cannot hope for a thorough cure , without taking them entirely off : in a word , the vessels that go from the cancerous tumor are strongly connected with the Periosteum and Perichondrium , that they seem but one body , which becomes at length so greatly swelled , that the very bone is often affected .
When a wen or wart ( which is often the beginning of a cancer ) , begins to appear , and they endeavour to pull them off , they become irritated , and spread to that degree , that the edges are reversed , and become callous and livid , accompanied with a pain , and every other symptom which characterise the cancer .
These kinds of wens , warts , and tubercles , which are situated in the great angle of the eye , upon the lids , or the nose , very often shoot out their roots upon the cartilages , that is , upon the very membranes which cover them , and the roots sink in sometimes to the substance of the cartilage itself , which they swell and tear in the end .
The more cancers are touched with caustics , the more they are irritated ; therefore there is but one method , but it is a sure one , of curing them , and hindering their progress ; which is , to take them off with a cutting instrument , destroying the Periosteum and Perichondrium , or even the lids , if the cancer has penetrated them in their substance , with their cartilages : which the following observations will prove .
Observation I. upon a cancerous upper-lid .
August the 11th , 1736 , I was called to Madam de la Fague , an Urseline Nun , at Bourdeax , fortyfive years old ; to see a tumor upon the upper-lid of the right eye , which she had for twenty years : it begun by a small wen , and increased by degrees , so as very much to incommode the patient .
She applied to a surgeon , who began by applying some drops of a liquid caustic , which enraged the tumor still more ; which he appeased again by anodyne medicines ; and then the tumor remained a long time without any sensible increase ; although the patient felt a continual sharp pain in it .
But , as even the least disorders are impatiently borne , she was willing to be relieved , and consulted another surgeon , who took off the tumor with a cutting instrument , and who , seeing that the ulcer , which was the result of the operation , did not heal ; but on the contrary made great progress in its erosion , and became callous , he touched it with lapis infernalis ; and sometimes with a liquid caustic : which so much the more increased the evil , and made her resolve to suffer no more applications , because , all that had been tried , made her worse and worse .
She was now a long time in this state , when I was called to consult with Messieurs Douasan , Caudole , and Senis , physicians of note in the same town , and with Monsieur Costade , surgeon major of the hospital ; who , having examined the case , agreed with me , that there was no other method to be taken but the operation , not only to save the eye , but to prevent an incurable cancer , which threatened her life ; whilst it had already made great progress under the eye-lid ; and it was much to be feared that it would spread into the very eye , and even over the whole face .
Then the operation would be fruitless , and the patient would suffer the loss of the use of that eye , and perhaps of her life .
Wherefore I did not hesitate to propose the total extirpation of the lid : my proposal was approved of by all , as the only method of saving the eye ; and the operation was as follows : I passed a crooked needle , with a waxed thread , under the lid , by which I suspended and drew up the lid and tumor , which I cut off with my crooked scissors , as much as I could under the orbit , separating the whole to the division of the lids ; a small haemorrhage ensued , but was soon stopped with dry lint , and a dry compress and bandage .
She remained twenty-four hours without being dressed ; was bled twice in the arm , after the operation : I then dressed her up with light dossils , armed with the linimentum Arcaei , and she had not the least accident from the day of the operation to the 25th of the same month , when she was perfectly cured , without any deformity in her eye : and although the lid was cut away very high , the eye remained very neat and well , performing its several functions properly when I left Bourdeaux ; and the 13th of August 1742 , having had an opportunity of taking a journey to that town , I saw the patient again , whom I found extremely well , seeing perfectly with that eye : but what I found very singular was , that the skin of the lid descended pretty low , to the cornea , which it almost covered ; so that the whole globe was in a manner hid .
We only observed , that this resembled a lid without hairs .
Observation II .
upon another cancerous tumor in the great angle of the eye .
July 2 , 1736 .
Margaret Combaucaut , of Carcastone in Languedoc , sixty years old , had a cancerous tumor , for sixteen years , in the great angle of the right eye : it began by a little wart , which itched violently , and made her scratch it very often , which so irritated the tumor , that in a little time it became as large as a dried fig flatted , with its edges turned outward and callous .
It reached from the commissure of the lower lid , an inch and half below it , even to the right ala of the nose , which proved extremely troublesome to the woman .
I found , after a strict examination , that it adhered to the bone .
She said she tried all the remedies that she imagined would do her any good ; but that , far from relieving her , they rather made her worse , and her disease became the more insupportable ; and that she had taken a resolution to undergo any thing to be freed from a disorder which had afflicted her for sixteen years .
Having consulted Mr. Fabre , an able physician of that place , we were both of opinion , that she could not be cured without an operation , which I accordingly proceeded to as follows : I took off the tumor entirely to the periosteum , but did not lay the bone bare ; for I thought it sufficient for a complete cure to take away all the callosities ; but I was mistaken ; for , instead of the prospect of a succeeding cure , I was unhappy enough to see the swelling increase , and the wound seem larger than before .
I used in vain all the remedies commonly thought of in such cases ; I scarified the edges of the ulcer , to bring it to suppuration ; but it became thereby more hard and callous than before the operation , and much more painful .
Upon which I resolved to cut away all that remained of the tumor , with the periosteum , which appeared very much swelled .
This second operation had so much success , that the swelling , and every other bad symptom , disappeared almost suddenly ; and in three days the wound looked red and very well , without any pain , and the cicatrix was perfectly formed on the 15th day from the operation , without any sensible exfoliation of the bone , or the least deformity or staring of the eye .
She has remained very well ever since ; for I saw her the 10th of August 1741 , at Carcastone , in perfect health ; and the cicatrix of the part very even .
I must observe here , that I laid the entire bone bare , wherever the tumor touched , even down to the ala of the nose of that side .
Observation the 3d , is upon a cancerous tumor of the same nature , and in the same situation , and the treatment just the same : it was as big as a filbert , and the officer was afflicted with it twenty years .
It differs from the former only in this , that the year before the officer came to Marseilles , to put himself under Monsieur Daviel 's cure , the tumor broke , and discharged a very fetid acrimonious matter , which , running into the eye , brought on a troublesome opthalmia , and the edges were livid , and had a very terrible aspect .
As to his operation , it consisted , as before , of a total extirpation of the cancer , periosteum and all , to the bare bone .
He dressed the bone with dry lint only , and his digestive was a mixture of the linimentum Arcaei , with the unguentum styracis : and in about nineteen days he was so perfectly cured , that when he returned to his friends , several of them asked him , upon which eye the operation had been made ?
Observation 4 , differs in nothing from the former .
Observation 5 , upon a cancerous tumor upon the nose , which reached from the root of the nose down to the middle of the cartilage .
He treated it in the same manner , taking off the whole with the periosteum ; and , as it was partly upon the cartilage , he also cut away the perichondrium , laying that , as well as the bone , bare : and the cure was completed , without leaving any deformity behind , in eighteen days .
Observation 6 , of a cancerous tumor upon the great angle of the right eye of a woman at Marseilles , of seventy years old .
This he treated exactly in the same manner , and she was cured in twenty days .
The 7th Observation mentions another cancerous tumor upon the nose , and its cartilage , of a gentleman , which is circumstantially the same with the former : it was cured in five days .
After this case he makes this conclusion : that from all that has been already said , it is plain , that the seat of the cancers of the eye-lids , nose , and other neighbouring parts , is absolutely in the periosteum and perichondrium , as well as the fat ; and that there can be no hopes of a cure without taking off these membranes , the fat , and even any parts of the very cartilages that may be contaminated : but that in this manner they are as curable as cancers upon other parts of the body , notwithstanding what all oculists have said to the contrary .
The 8th Observation is upon a cancer upon the lower eye-lid of a woman , cured in the same manner .
The 9th Observation treats of a cancer , as big as a large filbert , in the angle , and upon the lower lid of the eye , of a gentleman ; which began by a small tubercle in the angle , and was pulled off , and grew again several times .
Monsieur Daviel was consulted , in the presence of another surgeon , Monsieur Maillot , and declared for taking the tumor and eye-lid entirely off ; making this prognostic , that if any part was left behind , the eye would be deformed and staring ; but the other surgeon thought , that half the lid with the tumor would be sufficient for the cure : Mons. Daviel therefore only cut away half the lid with the tumor ; with which he also took off a large quantity of hard white fat , and dressed up the part as usual ; but in the progress the lid was turned outward , and then they resolved upon the total extirpation of the lid ; which , being obliged to depart from thence , he left to Mons. Maillot , who performed it with such success , that his cure was complete in fifteen days , without the least deformity whatever .
The 10th Observation is a case of the same nature with the former , with this difference , that when he had taken off the tumor and under lid in the same manner as usual ; the patient continued growing well till the ninth day from the operation ; when Mons. Daviel perceived a small fungus in the middle of the tumor , which he touched with the lapis infernalis , which produced very ill effects : the eye grew painful , the conjunctive swelled very much , the wound , which was half healed up , opened afresh , and grew ragged .
This made him set about cutting away all the bad flesh he could perceive , with the inequalities of the conjunctive , which was much swelled : he scarified the cornea , and the inner surface of the upper lid , which was also greatly tumefied , and even opened it on the upper surface .
Thus , after having emptied the vessels well , he fomented the whole with a decoction of marshmallows , mullein , violet-leaves , camomile-flowers , melilot , leaves and flowers of rosemary , thyme , lavender , rue , and marjoram , of each half a handful , in a sufficient quantity of water ; to a quart of which he put a bit of camphire as big as a nut .
The frequent applicaC c2 tion tion of this that day produced so good an effect , that all her pain ceased : he also bled her in the arm and foot , ordering emollient clysters .
She was purged some days after , with manna and cassia , which did very well ; and she was perfectly cured , without the least deformity , and could see better than before the

