XXI .
Queries sent to a Friend in Constantinople ; by Dr. Maty , F. R. S. ; and answered by his Excellency James Porter , Esq ; his Majesty 's Ambassador at Constantinople , and F. R. S. The Queries proposed were the Seven following : WHether we may know with any certainty , how many people are generally carried off by the plague at Constantinople ?
Read April 10 , 1 .
1755 .
2 .
Whether the number of inhabitants in that capital may be ascertained ?
3 .
Whether what has been advanced by some travellers , and from them assumed by writers on politics , be true , that there are more women than men born in the east ?
4 .
Whether plurality of wives is in fact , as it was confidently affirmed to be , in the order of nature , favourable to the increase of manking ?
5 .
What is the actual state of inoculation in the east ?
6 .
What is become of the printing-house at Constantinople ?
and are there any original maps of the Turkish dominions , drawn from actual surveys ?
7 .
What sort of learning is cultivated among the Greeks , and among the Turks ?
To these Queries his Excellency James Porter , Esq ; his Majesty 's Ambassador at Constantinople , and Fellow of this Society , was pleased to make the following Answer : 1 .
The only plague , which I observed at Constantinople , in the course of seven years , was that of the year 1751 : there are almost annually dispersed accidents , some perhaps real , some suggested by trick and design , to serve sinister purposes .
I attempted that year to throw some observations on paper ; but all that I could make out of them was so unsatisfactory , trite , and imperfect , that I thought them , on a review , scarce worth notice .
I am convinced , that whatever is told us of that distemper is scarce to be depended on ; rather conjecture than observation , rather the play of imagination than fact .
However , I had made it a principal study to attain to some data , whereby I could draw a probable conclusion concerning the number of the dead , that year , which might also have led me to have ascertained that of the inhabitants at Constantinople .
2 .
The Turks have no register , no bills of mortality : they are prohibited , by their law , to enumerate the people .
I applied to the Reis Effendi , and other ministers of the Port , to know what probable calculation they could make concerning the number of dead ; but they all concurred in one general answer , that they had no other but what was founded on the decrease of the consumption of the quantity of corn , or bread ; and in general talked of about 150000 .
I therefore betook myself , with all my care and industry , to try what probable conclusions I could draw from that imperfect datum .
Corn is delivered out by an officer of consideration , and an exact register kept .
Before the commencement of the plague , that was in March and April 1751 , the consumption of corn was 19000 measures , called Khilo 's .
On its continuance and decrease it diminished to 17000 , and on its total cessation , it was found not to amount to above 14000 .
A khilo weighs twenty-two okes .
It is grounded to eighteen okes of flower .
The bakers have generally the secret to make out of this last quantity twenty-seven okes of bread .
They add to an oke of flower one of water , besides some salt ; and as their bread is almost dough , few of the watery particles are exhaled ; and it is thought of the best , if it is not doubled in quantity , when taken out of the oven .
The common people , and even most of the middling and easy , live principally on bread ; the former with onion , garlic , fruits , or pulse , according to the seasons ; the latter with very small portions of flesh , or fish .
The more laborious professions , as labouring men , stone-cutters , carpenters , &amp;c. eat from two to two and a half okes a day ; the other , according to the common run of families , composed of men , women , and children , half an oke each ; so that the lowest calculation , on a medium , may be about an oke and a quarter daily , eaten by each person at Constantinople .
But should it be thought too much , an oke , which is two pounds three-quarters English , we may suppose pose nearer truth : the following conclusions then will result : That therefore on the highest number of 19000 ~ 27 , we have 513000 , the quantity of okes of bread consumed , and consequently the number of souls at Constantinople .
That on the decrease of the plague to 17000 , 54000 persons were either dead or mising .
That when the quantity was reduced to 14000 on the cessation , those either fled or dead amounted to 135000 .
It is said by some , that Constantinople contains near three millions of inhabitants ; but on whatever supposition we take the consumption of the quantity of bread , that quantity will be found erroneous .
On a gross calculation made by some of the principal men , and particularly the Chiorbachee 's , or colonels of Janizaries , who had their stations at the most noted and only places where the funerals pass , they reckoned for six weeks , whilst the plague was at its height , and in its crisis , from 900 to 1000 per diem ; and that the whole amount of the dead in that time might be about 40000 : and from the time it was in its increase and decline , they added 15 to 20000 more .
If therefore we admit 60000 in the whole , it will be as that sum to 513000 , or as 1 to 8 11/ 20 .
There is a remarkable coincidence between this proportion , and the number of dead which was carried out of the Adrianople-gate , during twelve days , the same season of the year 1752 ; and of the like number of days in 1751 .
1752 Health .
1751 Plague .
June 14-11 June 12-24 153 13-29 165 14-32 175 15-35 184 16-24 198 20-50 203 25-34 223 22-37 235 23-52 244 July 14-56 255 15-57 263 16-59 59 489 So that the number of dead , at least through that gate , in time of common health , was to those in that of sickness , as 59 to 489 , or as 1 to 8 1/ 3 , nearly .
The Adrianople-gate is reckoned the greatest passage for the dead , on account of its vicinity to the most extensive burial-places .
A great deduction must be made for the vast decrease of the consumption of wheat towards the cessation of the plague , from the considerable numbers , who fled into Asia , the islands of the Archipelago , and Romelia .
A cogent argument with me to demonstrate , that Constantinople is not peopled in proportion to its extent , is the immense care which the late Sultan Mahmud took , not to admit new inhabitants , or strangers ; none could remain a night in the city without commands from the Port ; and those were with great difficulty obtained .
It is extreme difficult , if not impossible , to come at any other computus of the number of inhabitants , much more so of houses , at Constantinople .
The city is divided somewhat in the manner it was under the Graecian empire , that is , into different quarters , called Mahales , and each under the special direction of an Imaum .
As far as it extends to their immediate advantage , they are informed of the number of families in their district ; but whoever would dare to collect from them , might not only risk the censure of the government , but his head .
Besides , if the inquiry is general concerning houses , it is impossible to fix a determined idea ; they confound palace , seraglio , shop , room , and call them indiscriminately houses .
The Jews say , that they have 1 0000 houses at Constantinople : but in what we call a house , there are perhaps ten families , and the distinct number of the latter they dare not mention .
I endeavoured with persuasion , and all my weight , to induce the Greek and Armenian patriarchs , to obtain for me a register of the births and burials of their respective communities ; but at length they acknowleged it impossible .
Their parishes are farmed to curates , by the diocesan bishops ; the income arises from births and burials ; so that to conceal the former , they must likewise the latter ; and they never exhibit a faithful register .
3 .
That there are more women than men born in the east , seems a figment of travellers , rather than sounded in truth ; it is scarce to be known , where polygamy polygamy is lawful .
The apparent conclusion may seem natural , because many of the Harems of the opulent , especially in the great cities , are numerous : but these are not composed of the natives of those cities , but are brought from countries where the christian rites are observed , in time of peace , from Georgia ; and of war , from Hungary and Russia , ~c .
so that if more women are found in such families than men , they must be looked upon as an extraneous production annually , or daily imported .
I think I can aver , on good foundation , that we have not yet extant , an exact genuine account of the customs , manners , and practices , of these people , nor really of these countries .
Those which I have read are extreme faulty , not to say worse , in many particulars , which have fallen under my own knowlege .
What am I then to conclude , as to those that have not ?
And how can a Tournefort , and many others I could name , in running over vast tracks of countries in two years , or less , sometimes by night , sometimes by day , with hasty caravans , give us a true history ?
Even Ricaut 's , he , who dwelt some years in these countries , is founded on very imperfect memoirs : what he says of the interior of the seraglio is impossible to be known ; and I find by some original letters of his , from Hamburg , to a nephew he had , as secretary to this embassy , that he begged for some notes of one Mr. Coke , formerly in that office , in order to continue his history .
Now , it is evident , that all such notes must have been only the hearsay of the Christians of Pera , who neither have , nor ever , had , knowlege or observation sufficient to be depended on ; nor dare they venture to enter into intimate particulars with such Mahometans as could truly inform them .
Credulity and vulgar errors abound , as a consequence of their faith ; for they are all Greeks or Romanists .
Those are taken traditionally .
To instance in one collected from them , and universally received by travellers ; they tell us , that the Turks make public prayers and processions in time of plague , when 1000 corps a day are carried out of the Adrianoplegate .
This tradition was current in the year 1751 .
I knew it must be false from the very Koran .
However , I had the question put to many , particularly to the Reis Effendi , great chancellor of the empire , who let me know they never numbered them , nor inquired minutely how many died ; that in time of great calamity or sickness , they only ordered a passage of the Koran to be read in their Mosches .
Thus , by a single inquiry , I detected a fable which has passed current , since Mahomet the Second 's time .
This is one example of many .
4 .
I can affirm , with truth , what may seem a paradox , that in general , Mahometans , notwithstanding their law , procreate less than Christians .
The rich , who are the only persons that can maintain concubines , have seldom four or five children .
Few , I have heard of , or known , exceed two or three ; many of the former , and most of the middling and poorer sort , have generally but one wife .
The latter indeed exchange them with facility ; but yet we do not perceive they have a numerous progeny .
I take this to arise from a cause different from that which is commonly assigned , not from their being enervated by variety , but rather from their law .
The frequent ablutions , required by the doctrine of purity and impurity , perhaps may check the libidinous passion ; or when it is at its height , they find themselves prohibited enjoyment .
To enforce this observation might lead me into some singular reflections .
5 .
Inoculation is practised at present among the Greeks , and , notwithstanding religious scruples , among the Romanists : with the few , whom I have known , it generally succeeded ; but the numbers will not admit of comparison .
There are not perhaps twenty in a year inoculated .
The Timoni family pretend , that a daughter had been inoculated at six months old , but afterwards acquired the small-pox in the natural way , and died at twenty-three years .
The evidence is doubtful .
Timoni 's account is incorrect ; his facts are not to be depended on .
Pylarini 's is more exact .
It was neither Circassians , Georgians , nor Asiatics , who introduced the practice .
The first woman was of the Morea ; her successor was a Bosniac ; they brought it from Thessaly , of the Peloponnesus , now Morea .
They properly scarified the patient , commonly on many parts , sometimes on the forehead , under the hair , sometimes on the cheeks , and on the radius of the arm .
A father told me , that the old woman not being able , through age , to make the incision on his daughter , with the razor , he performed that operation .
The needle has also been used .
The Turks never inoculate : they trust to their fatum .
Whence the method had its origin seems here unknown .
A Capuchin friar , whom I often see , was on a mission in Georgia for above sixteen years ; he has returned about two years ; he is a grave sober man , who gives an historical account of the virtues and vices , good and evil , of that country , with plainness and candour .
The usual introduction and security of these missionaries is the pretence to the practice of physic , that in destroying bodies they may save souls : so that this honest man , who is extremely ignorant , was in high reputation both as physician and confessor .
It was therefore impossible , as he himself observes , that either the public or private practice of inoculation could be concealed from him ; but he has most solemnly declared to me repeatedly , that he never heard one word about it at Akalsike , Imirette , or Tifflis ; he is persuaded , that it has never been known among them .
He has often and frequently attended the small-pox , which is almost certain death there ; and generally , if not always , of the confluent kind .
6 .
Printing was introduced by an Hungarian renegado , who called himself Ibrahim Effendi : it had no long continuance .
The copies are not many , and are now very dear and scarce ; few even to be bought .
The maps did not exceed three or four ; one of Persia , one of the Bosphorus , and one of the Euxinus , or Black-sea ; they are not to be found but in private hands .
All our maps of these countries are extremely imperfect and incorrect .
The jealousy and superstition of the people , tho ' the government should permit Christians to raise any printing-house , would be an irresistible impediment ; and they are too ignorant themselves to be ever capable of doing it .
The adoptive son of this Ibrahim Effendi , who bears the same name , is secretary under the interpreter of the port ; he has all the materials for printing , but never could find , since his father 's death , and during Sultan Mahmud 's reign , money to carry it on .
The question is now , whether Sultan Osman is not too strict a mussulman to continue the permission .
7 .
The progress of arts and sciences , and literature , seems travelling on , gradatim , to the westward , from AEgypt to Greece , from Greece to Rome , thence to the west of Europe , and I suppose at last to America .
We find few traces in the east : the Greeks , who should be the depositaries of them , are the same Greeks they ever were , Homines contentionis cupidiores quam veritatis .
They have retained all the vices , imperfections , ill habitudes , of their ancestors ; but have lost all their public spirit , and public virtues .
The clergy , who should support the whole machine of learning , are themselves the source of ignorance ; all their talents and acquisitions consist in bribing amongst the Turks , and soliciting to destroy one patriarch in order to make another ; to raise from a curacy to a bishopric , and to exchange from an indifferent one to a better .
They endeavour to cultivate literal Greek , and some study it , but advance no further .
There are neither grammarians , critics , historians , nor philosophers , among them ; nor have they proper preceptors or masters to instruct .
They have formed a sort of an academy at Mount Athos , for their youth , which will scarce survive the person who has undertaken it : he has himself but the mere elements of science .
However , his desire of knowing may improve him ; and he may perhaps lay the foundations in some youth with success .
The Turks have many books amongst them , tho exceedingly dear ; folios I have seen cost 100 to 2 and 300 dollars each ; i.e. from 15 l. to 45 l. The few printed folios , some of which I picked up some years ago , cost 5 l. to 6 l. sterling .
Their scribes spend many years about a few copies .
Their learning consists principally in abstruse metaphysics : some few touch the surface of science .
I have looked out with great industry for old Arabian manuscripts in the mathematical way : what they brought me were translations of some propositions of Euclid , Theodosius , Archimedes , and Apollonius .
They have some parts of Aristotle ; but their favourite philosophy is the atomical or Epicurean , which with them is called the Democritical , from Democritus .
Many of their speculative men have adopted that system , and conform to it in their secret practice .
The institutes and practice of physic are taken from Galen .
Eben Zyna , or Avicena , is a principal guide : Mathiolus is known .
But with all this , as the sole drift and end of their study is gain , there does not seem the least emulation towards true knowlege : so that the state of letters may be said to remain deplorable , without the least glimmering , or remote prospect of a recovery .
J. P. Constantinople , Feb. 1 , 1755 .
Since the reception of this memoir , Dr. Maty has received another letter from the same gentleman , in which he finds some new facts tending to clear up the accounts relating to the practice of inoculation among the Georgians .
These he hopes will not be unacceptable , as they come from a person equally able , by his universal knowlege and distinguished station , to procure the best informations , and willing , for the good of mankind , to communicate them in the most obliging and candid manner .
Constantinople , May 17 , 1755 .
IAM now to correct the report of the Capuchin concerning inoculation in Georgia .
One of their physicians , a most ignorant fellow , who lives by his profession here , avers that , among those who follow the true Georgian rites , not Romanists , the practice is common .
It has its rise from mere superstition .
He tells us , ` ` That the tradiction and religious belief of that people is , that an Angel presides over that distemper , that therefore , to show their confidence in him , and to invite him to be propitious , they take a pox from the sick person , and , by a scarification , they insert it in one in health , generally between the fore-finger and thumb .
It never misses its effect , and the patient always recovers .
To attract the Angel 's good will more effectually , they hang the patient 's bed with red cloth or stuff , as a colour most agreeable to him .
He has been assistant to this practice , and declares it to be common .
' ' Perhaps the only good effect ever known produced by that monster superstition !
The Capuchin acknowleges , that it might be amongst the Georgians the Doctor mentions , and not have fell under his knowlege .
To vindicate his ignorance , he distinguishes the parts of Georgia , or its divisions .
He has never been at Cackett , and staid but three weeks at once in Tifflis .

