An Investigation of a General Rule for the Resolution of Isoperimetrical Problems of all Orders .
By Mr. Thomas Simpson , F. R. S. THE different species of problems comprehended under the name of Isoperimetrical ones , are of much greater extent than the name imports ; since , not only the determination of the greatest areas and solids , under equal Read Jan. 9 , equal perimeters or bounds ( whence the name is derived ) , but whatever relates to the Maxima and Minima of quantities depending on a line , space , or body , whereof the figure is unknown , is , by mathematicians , included under that denomination .
But notwithstanding the usefulness and great extent of this subject , nothing ( that I know of ) had been done thereon farther than the resolution of certain particular cases ( such as finding the line of the swiftest descent , and the solid of the least resistance ) , 'till the celebrated mathematician Mc Laurin , in his treatise of fluxions , gave the investigation of an elegant and very easy method , whereby the principal problems belonging to the first order may be resolved .
The paper I have now the honour to lay before the Society contains farther improvements on this subject : as it is by far more general than any thing yet offered , and is drawn up with a view to obviate the difficulties attending the resolution of a very intricate kind of problems , and thereby to open an easy way to some very interesting inquiries in natural philosophy , I cannot doubt of its meeting with a favourable reception .
Lemma I. Fig. 1 .
At any given points D , G , I , L , in a rightline A L , suppose perpendiculars to be erected ; and from any other given points c , f , h , k , at equal distances ( c D ' , f G ' , h I ' , k L ' , ) from the said perpendiculars , respectively , conceive right-lines c d , f g , h i , k l , to be drawn , to terminate somewhere in the said perpendiculars ; let Q , R , S , T , denote any quantities expressed in terms of A C , c D ' , and D 'd , ( independent of C c ) and Q ' , R ' , S ' , T ' , as many other quantities affected in the very same manner with A F , f G ' , and G ' g ; and let Q ' ' , R ' ' , S ' ' , T ' ' , and Q ' ' ' , R ' ' ' , S ' ' ' , T ' ' ' , be quantities , still , expressed in the same manner , in terms of A H , h I~ , I~ i , and A K , k L ' , L'l , respectively : it is proposed to find an equation expressing the relation of the indeterminate perpendiculars D 'd , G'g , l'i , L'l , so that the quantity Q+Q'+Q''+Q ' ' ' may be a Maximum or Minimum , at the same time that the values of the other quantities R+ R ' + R ' ' + R ' ' ' , S+ S ' + S ' ' + S ' ' ' , and T+ T ' + T ' ' + T ' ' ' , are given , or continue invariable .
~ k L~ i h I~ g ~ G~ d c D~ ACDFGHIKL Put D ' d= ~ , G ' g= ~ , I ' i= ~ , L ' l= ~ ; and let the fluxion of Q ( supposing ~ variable ) be denoted by q ~ , that of R , by ~ ~ , &amp;c. &amp;c. then , since ( by the nature of the proposition ) the fluxion of Q+ Q ' + Q ' ' + Q ' ' ' , as well as those of R+ R ' + R ' ' + R ' ' ' , S+ S ' + S ' ' + S ' ' ' , &amp;c. must be equal to nothing , we therefore q~+ q ' ~+ q ' ' ~+ q ' ' ' ~=~ r~+ r ' ~+ r ' ' ~+ r ' ' ' ~=~ have s~+ s ' ~+ s ' ' ~+ s ' ' ' ~=~ t~+ t ' ~+ t ' ' ~+ t ' ' ' ~=~ In order , now , to exterminate the fluxions ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , let these equations be respectively multiplied by I , e , f , g , ( yet unknown ) , and let all the products thence arising be added together , whence will be had q+er+fs+gt~~+ q ' +e r ' +f s ' +g t ' ~~ + q ' ' + er ' ' +f s ' ' +g t ' ' ~~+ q ' ' ' +e r ' ' ' +f s ' ' ' +g t ' ' ' ~~= ~ .
Make , now , q ' +e r ' +f s ' +g t ' =~ q ' ' +e r ' ' +f s ' ' +g t ' ' =~ q ' ' ' +e r ' ' ' +f s ' ' ' +g t ' ' ' =~ From whence ( there being as many equations as quantities , e , f , g , to be determined ) , the values of these quantities will be always given in terms of q ' , r ' , s ' , &amp;c. that is , e , f , g , will always be represented by quantities depending on q ' , r ' , s ' , &amp;c. ( or on A F , G ' g , &amp;c. ) exclusive of q , r , s , t , ( or of AC and D ' d ) , which have nothing to do in these last equations .
But , because all the terms of the equation q+er+fs+gt~~+ q ' +e r ' +f s ' +g t ' ~ ~ , &amp;c. = o , after the first ( q +er+fs+gt~ ~ ) do vanish ( by their coefficients being made equal to nothing ) , it is evident that q+er+fs+gt must also be = o : which is an equation expressing the general relation of A C , c D ' , and D ' d , with regard to the other proposed quantities A F , f G ' , G ' g , &amp;c. whereon the coefficients e , f , g , depend : and this relation will , evidently , continue the same , at whatever distances from the line A L , the points c , f , h , k , are taken , as these distances have nothing to do in the consideration , all the proposed quantities ( as well the Q 's as R 's , &amp;c. ) being ( by hypothesis ) expressed in terms entirely independent thereof .
Lemma II .
Fig. 2 .
Upon a given right-line B L , suppose perpendiculars B b , C c , D d , &amp;c. to be erected at equal distances ; and upon the same line B L , as a base , suppose a polygon BbcdefghiklL to be constituted , having its angular points b , c , d , &amp;c. posited in the said perpendiculars ; let y denote the distance of any of these perpendiculars ( C c , D d , &amp;c. ) from any given point A , in LB produced ; and , supposing b C ' , c D ' , d E ' , &amp;c. to be drawn parallel to A B , let the base of any of the little triangles bC c , c D ' d , &amp;c. be represented by y , and the perpendicular corresponding by x ( y being given , or the same , in every triangle , and x indeterminate ) : then , supposing Q , R , S , T , to denote any quantities expressed in terms of y , y , and x , it is proposed to find an equation exhibiting the general relation of the quantities y , y , and x , so that the sum of all the y Q 's ( resulting from the several triangles ) may be a Maximum or Minimum , at the same time that the sums of all the y R 's , y S 's , &amp; c : are given quantities .
l kL iK hI gH 10 fG9y eF8x dE7n 6v cD5t bC4s 3r 2q 1p ABCDEFGHIKL Because the values of the quantities y Q , y R , y S , y T , depending on the different triangles b C ' c , c D ' d , &amp;c. are supposed to be no-ways affected by the distances ( B b , C c , &amp;c. ) of the bases of those triangles , from the base BL of the polygon , it is evident , that those values may be changed , by atering the species of one , or more , of the said triangles at pleasure , without any-ways affecting the values depending on the other triangles : for another polygon LB1234 5 , &amp;c. may be so described as to have all its sides , respectively , parallel to those of the former , excepting only those ( 23 , 56 , 78 , 910 ) you would have to be different : so that the whole variation in the several sums ( whether of the y Q 's , y R 's , or y S 's , &amp;c. ) will depend entirely upon the difference of the particular triangles 2q 3 , c D ' d ; 5t 6 , f G ' g , &amp;c. assigned .
Since , therefore , the values of the y Q 's , y R 's , y S 's , &amp;c. may be varied , at pleasure , by altering the species of any number of corresponding triangles ( 2 q 3 , c D ' d ; 5t 6 , f G ' g ; 7w 8 , h I ' i ; 9y 10 , k L ' l ) , while the other triangles , and the values depending on them , remain the same , it is manifest , that , when the sum of the y Q 's , answering to all the triangles , is a Maximum or Minimum , the sum of any number of them , taken at pleasure ( other things remaining the same ) , will likewise be a Maximum or Minimum ; and , consequently , that the sum of as many Q 's will , at the same time , be a Maximum or Minimum , because y is every-where the same , or a constant quantity .
Hence , if the construction of the preceding Lemma be retained ( supposing all the Q 's , R 's , S 's , &amp;c. to be here expressed as before , in terms of A C , c D ' , and D ' d , &amp;c. ) it is plain that the sum of all the Q 's , ( or of the y Q 's ) , depending on the said particular triangles ( and consequently of all the y Q 's in general ) , will be a Maximum or Minimum , when the general relation of y , y , x , ( or of A C , c D ' , D ' d , ) is expressed by the same equation q+er+fs+gt= o , there determined : in which q , r , s , t , represent the fluxions of Q , R , S , T , divided by that of ~ ( = ~= D 'd ) , and wherein the coefficients e , f , g , will be constant quantities ; because it is proved that their values depend entirely on the triangles f G ' g , h I ' i , k L ' l , which remain the same , let the perpendicular ( or ordinate ) Cc be taken at what distance you will from the given point A ; that is , let y stand for which you will of the distances A B , A C , A D , &amp;c. Q. E. I. Corollary .
If the sides of the polygon bedefg h , &amp;c. be diminished , and their number increased in infinitum , the sum of all the y Q 's will ( it is well known ) be expressed by the fluent of y Q ; the sum of all the yR s , by the fluent of y R , &amp;c. whence it follows , that , to have the fluent of yQ ( answering to a given value of y ) a Maximum , or Minimum , and the fluents of y R , y S , &amp;c. at the same time , given quantities , the relation of y , y , and x , must be defined by the equation q+er+fs+gt= 0 , above exhibited ; q , r , s , &amp;c. being the respective fluxions of Q , R , S , &amp;c. divided by that of x , ( or x ) ; this quantity x , or x , ( in finding the said fluxions ) being , alone , considered as variable .
Hence we have the following GENERALRUL E. For the resolution of Isoperimetrical Problems , of all orders , take the fluxions of all the given expressions ( as well that respecting the Maximum , or Minimum , as of the others whose fluents are to be given quantities ) , making that quantity ( x ) alone variable , whose fluent ( x ) enters not into the said expressions ; and , having divided everywhere by the second fluxion ( x ) , let the quantities hence arising , joined to general coefficients , 1 , e , f , g , &amp;c. ( whose values will depend on the values given , and may be either positive or negative ) , be united into one sum , and the whole be made equal to nothing ; from which equation the true relation of x and y , and of x and y , will be given , let the number of restrictions be what it will .
For an example of the general Rule here laid down , let the fluxions given be y x3/ y y , and x ; the fluent of the former , corresponding to any given value of y , being to be a Minimum , and that of the latter , at the same time , equal to a given quantity .
Here , taking the fluxions of both expressions ( making x , alone , variable ) , and dividing by x , the quantities resulting will be 3yx x/ y y and 1 ; so that , in this case , we have 3yx x/ y y+e= 0 , and therefore x= a1/ 2 y-1/ 2 y ( supposing a= 1/ 3 e ) .
From whence , by taking the fluents , x=2 a1/ 2 y1/ 2 , or x2 =4a y , an equation answering to the common parabola .
If the abscisse of a curve be denoted by x , and the ordinate by y , it is known , that the several fluxions of the abscisse , curve-line , area , superficies of the generated solid , and of the solid itself , will be represented by x , ~xx+y y , y x , 2py~xx+y y , and p y2 x respectively : if , therefore , the fluxions of these different expressions be taken as before ( making x , alone , variable ) , we shall get 1+e x/ ~ xx+yy + fie +gy x/ ~ xx+yy+~ y2 = 0 , being a general equation for determining the relation of x and y , when any one of the said five quantities ( viz. abscisse , curve-line , area , superficies , or solid ) is a Maximum or Minimum , and all , or any number of the others , at the same time , equal to given quantities ; wherein the coefficients e , f , g , and h , may be either positive or negative , or nothing , as the case proposed may require .
Thus , for example , if the length of the curve , only , be given , and the area corresponding is required to be a Maximum , our equation will then become e x/ ~ xx+yy+fy= 0 , or a2 x2 = y2 x ~x x+yy ( by making a= e/ f ) ; whence x= y y/ ~ aay y ' and consequently x=a~aay y , or 2ax x2 = y2 , answering to a circle ; which figure , therefore , of all others , contains the greatest area , under equal bounds .
If together with the ordinate ( which , here , is always supposed given ) the abscissa , at the end of the fluent , be given likewise , and the superficies generated by the revolution of the curve about its axis be a Minimum ; then , from the same equation , we have 1+gy x/ ~x x+yy= 0 : whence ( making a= -1/ g ) x is found =a y/ ~ yya a ; and , from thence , x= ax hyp .
log .
y+~yya a/ a ; which equation , being impossible when y is less than a , shows that the curve ( which is here the Catanaria ) cannot possibly meet the axis about which the solid is generated ; and , consequently , that the case will not admit of any Minimum , unless the first , or least given value of y exceeds a certain assignable magnitude .
When any , or all of the above-specified quantities are given , and the contempory fluent of some other expression , as ~xx+y y~n x ym x y1 2 n , is required to be a Maximum , or Minimum ; the equation ( by taking the fluxion of this last expression , and joining it to the former ) will then be ~xx+y y~n-1 x2nx ym y1-2 n +d+e x/ ~ xx+yy+ fie +gy x/ ~ xx+yy+h y2 = 0 ; which , when m= 1 , and n= 1 , will be that defining the solid of the least resistance ; and this , when the axis only is supposed to be given ( without farther restrictions ) will be expressed by ~x x+y y~2 x2xy y3 +d= 0 , or 2y y3 x= dx ~x x+y y~2 ; being the case , first , considered by Sir Isaac Newton .
If both the length and the solid content be given , the equation will be 2xy y3 xxx+y y~-2 +d+h y2 = 0 ; but if , besides these , the superficies is given likewise , it will then be 2xy y3 xxx+y y~-2 +d+ey x/ ~ xx+yy +h y2 = 0 .
Thus , in like manner , by assuming m= 1/ 2 , and n= 1/ 2 , we have y-1/ 2 x/ ~ xx+yy+d+e x/ ~ xx+yy+ fie +gy x/ ~ xx+yy+h y2 = 0 , for the general equation of the curve of the swiftest descent : which , when e f , g , and h , are , all of them taken equal to nothing , will become y-1/ 2 x/ ~ xx+yy+ d ; which is the case , considered by so many Others , answering to the cycloid .
When the length of the arch described in the whole descent ( as well as the values of x and y ) is given , the equation will then be y-1/ 2 x/ ~ xx+yy +d+e x/ ~ xx+yy= 0 , or ~e y -1/ 2~2 x x2 = d2 x ~x x+y y. And thus may the relation of x and y be determined , in other cases , and that under any number of restrictions .

