A Physiological Account of the Case of Margaret Cutting , who speaks distinctly , tho ' she has lost the Apex and Body of her Tongue : Addressed to the Royal Society , by James Parsons M. D. F. R. S. Gentlemen , AS several of the Members of this worthy Society were somewhat divided in their Opinions concerning what was reported of Margaret Cutting , when they were first in~ formed of her by Mr. Baker* ; it will be necessary ( in order to render her Case the better understood ) to lay before you the following short Particulars , which Read Dec. 17 .
1747 .
* See these Trans. No. 464 , Artic .
II .
p. 143 , et seq. which are the Result of an Examination made a few Days since by Dr. Milward and myself ; and which , in general , differs not from the Opinion which that learned Gentleman and I mentioned to this Society , upon the Occasion , which the Science of Anatomy necessarily suggested to us at that time .
But James Theobald Esq ; a worthy Member of the Royal Society , having encouraged her to come to London , and having brought her to this Meeting of the Society , has now given us all an Opportunity of coming at the Truth of her Case ; wherefore I shall now , Gentlemen , present you with , first , an Account of her present Condition ; and then , some Considerations on the natural State and Uses of the Tongue ; which will show you how far she makes the Lips and teeth supply the Want of her Tongue in speaking ; and also be a Direction to every Gentleman present to judge of the Case before him .
Of her present Condition .
THE Apex and Body of the Tongue ( being the only Parts that naturally fill the Cavity of the Mouth ) are entirely wanting in this Woman , as closely to the Region of the Os Hyoides , which is the Root of the Tongue , as can well be conceived ; and which is now situated too low in the Throat to be perceived , even when she opens her Mouth at the widest .
But let any one lay the Tops of the Finger and Thumb to the Sides of her Throat , and let her at the same time pronounce the Letter k he will feel the remaining Root of the Tongue rise towards the Roof of her Mouth , in order to perform ; it ; however , she cannot keep it there any longer than the Moment of thrusting it up , for want of the Ligament ( which was destroyed with the Tongue ) that is destined , together with the following Muscles , to keep the whole Tongue forwards in its due Situation .
The Genioglossi are a Pair of Muscles which arise from the fore Part of the Inside of the lower Jaw , and are inserted into the Body of the Tongue by three different Directions ; the anterior Part is carried forward towards the Apex : the posterior runs obliquely backwards towards the Root , sending a narrow Slip on each Side to the Cornua of the Os Hyoides ; and the middle Part ends about the middle of the Tongue .
Now there are certain Inequalities appearing on , and closely adhering to the Floor of the Cavity of the Mouth , one of which being the most considerable , and having a Resemblance in its Substance to that of the Surface of the Tongue , has been , if I am rightly informed , inadvertently mistaken for a Tongue , by a Gentleman professing Surgery in the Country ; and which he thought , for want of a careful Examination , performed the Offices proper to the Apex ; but a little Care and Circumspection would have informed him , that those Appearances are only Fragments of the Genioglossi mentioned before , and that upon the Separation of the sound Parts from those mortified , such Fragments , as had escaped , were retracted , and cicatrized down into their present State ; nor is it difficult to conceive how the Root of the Tongue must of Necessity sink lower down into the Throat , by the Loss of these Muscles and the proper Ligament ; which , as I have observed before , naturally kept it higher than it could remain ever since their Destruction .
If the Mortification had reached the Os Hyoides , it must have reached , and destroyed the Muscles of the Larynx , and then the Voice would have been destroyed ; and also those of the Pharynx , and then Deglutition could never have been performed ; the dreadful Consequences of which need not be enumerated here ; but she swallows well , and her Voice is perfect , and therefore it is not very extraordinary she should command her Voice by the proper Muscles which remain untouched .
The nasal Opening is quite exposed , because the Uvula which covered it was also destroyed ; for one Pair of its Muscles ( the Glosso-Staphilini ) arise from the Tongue ; by which no doubt the Distemper was communicated to this Part also .
She has her Taste perfectly , which is hereafter accounted for .
Some Considerations on the natural State and Uses of the Tongue .
THE Tongue is a fleshy Substance , chiefly made up of Muscles ; and consists of a Basis or Root , a Body , and an Apex ; the Basis is the thickest and most substantial Part , contains the Os Hyoides , and is naturally situated very low in the Throat : From which the Body rises upwards and forwards , and is terminated by the anterior Part or Apex ; proceeding under the Uvula and Roof , and lying upon the Floor ( if I may so call it ) of the Mouth .
As to the more particular Description of all its other Parts , I cannot apprehend it is at all necessary here , since it is not to our Purpose , and would take up too much of your Time .
As to its Uses , it is said to be the Instrument of Speaking and Tasting ; as to the latter , Experience shows us that the very Apex of the Tongue is less capable of discerning Tastes than the next Part to it , and this than the Parts yet farther back , all along the Body to the Root ; so that altho ' the Taste of any thing is first perceived by the Apex , yet the Gust increases , the more the Morsel approaches to Deglutition , until it is quite protruded into the Gula ; because as the Tongue grows more thick backwards it contains more of the nervous Papillae than the smaller Part , and also because there is a Capacity of tasting in the Membranes of the back Part of the Roof to the Root ; as if Nature intended to increase the Gust , that Deglutition may be the better and more eagerly performed for the Service of the Animal : Hence altho ' the Apex and Body of the Tongue be gone , yet there is not a Depravation of Taste , which is the Case of the Person now under your Consideration .
As to Speech , which is only Sound or Voice articulated into Expression , the Tongue is not the sole Organ for such Articulation ; the Lips , Teeth , and Roof of the Mouth are Instruments also for the same Purpose ; the two latter for the necessary Resistance to the Apex of the Tongue , and the Lips for the absolute Articulation and Pronunciation of many Letters ; however the following short Examination of the Letters of the Alphabet , as expressed by these Organs , will demonstrate it .
The Tongue expresses some Letters with its Apex , and some with its Root .
Those absolutely proper to the Apex are only five , d , l , n , r , t. And those to which it only assists are the following Letters , as c , g , s , x , z ; all which can be performed by the Teeth alone , and which this Person does very well .
Now the Lip-Letters , and those expressed by the Root of the Tongue , she also performs as well as any Person ; the former are b , f , m , p ; and the latter are k , q , x ; and as to the Vowels , and the Aspiration h , since they are chiefly sounded by the Exhalation of the Voice , commanded partly by the Lips in widening or straitening the Capacity of the Mouth , these she can also express ; so that there is no Letter she cannot pronounce but the five Apex Letters ; and those she manages so well by bringing the under Lip to her upper Teeth , in the Course of her Conversation , that any one can instantly apprehend every Word she says ; and she further plainly proves the Lips are a better Succedaneum to the Apex , than that could be to the Lips if they were wanting .
Indeed it is natural enough for those who make the Tongue the absolute and sole Instrument of Speech , to imagine it as absurd to say a Woman spoke without a Tongue , as that she saw without an Eye ; but when we consider the provisional assisting Organs ordained by the wise AUTHOR of PROVIDENCE , serving to this necessary and expressive Accomplishment , I hope it will not seem so extremely marvellous , that she speaks without the Body and Apex of her Tongue , as to create any further Doubt of the Matter .
I am , Gentlemen , Your most humble Servant , James Parsons .
AN December 17 .

